UPSC-CMS 2014 — Dermatology

Question 1: A 40 year old man presented with a flat 1x1cm scaly, itchy black mole on the front of thigh. Examination did not reveal any inguinal lymphodenopathy. The best course of management would be:

• A. FNAC of lesion
• B. Incision biopsy
• C. Wide excision with inguinal lymphadenectomy
• D. Excision biopsy (Correct Answer)

Explanation: ***Excision biopsy*** - A **flat, scaly, itchy, black mole** is highly suspicious for **melanoma**, and an excision biopsy provides the most accurate histopathological diagnosis and depth assessment. - This procedure removes the entire lesion with a narrow margin of normal-appearing skin, allowing for comprehensive evaluation of its nature and determining further management. *FNAC of lesion* - **Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC)** is generally used for evaluating palpable masses or lymph nodes, not primary skin lesions like a suspicious mole. - It provides only cellular samples, making it difficult to assess architectural features, depth of invasion, or determine definitive malignancy in skin lesions. *Incision biopsy* - An **incision biopsy** involves removing only a partial sample of the lesion, which can lead to sampling error and an inaccurate diagnosis if the most aggressive part is missed. - For suspected melanoma, an incomplete biopsy can compromise subsequent staging and definitive treatment planning. *Wide excision with inguinal lymphadenectomy* - This is an **overly aggressive initial approach** before a definitive diagnosis of melanoma and its stage has been established. - **Wide excision** is typically performed after an excision biopsy confirms melanoma and determines its depth, while **lymphadenectomy** is indicated for confirmed lymph node involvement.