Infanticide Practice Questions

Q: In forensic medicine, the hydrostatic test is primarily used to determine which of the following conditions in a deceased infant?

Evidence of infanticide. ### Explanation The **Hydrostatic Test** (also known as the **Raygat’s Test** or **Floatation Test**) is a classic forensic procedure used to determine whether a child was **born alive** or was **stillborn**. This distinction is the cornerstone of investigating suspected **infanticide**. #### Why the Correct Answer is Right: The test is based on the physiological principle that once an infant takes its first breath, the lungs expand and air fills the alveoli. This reduces the specific gravity of the lung tissue (from ~1.050 to ~0.950), making it lighter than water. * **Positive Test (Floating):** Indicates the infant breathed (live birth). * **Negative Test (Sinking):** Indicates the lungs never expanded (stillbirth). In cases of suspected infanticide, proving a "live birth" is the first legal requirement for a homicide charge. #### Why Incorrect Options are Wrong: * **Options A, B, and C (Drowning):** While these involve water, the hydrostatic test is unrelated to the mechanism of drowning. Drowning in adults or children is diagnosed via different findings, such as **Getter’s Test** (chloride levels), **diatom analysis**, or the presence of **fine, leathery froth** at the mouth/nostrils. #### NEET-PG High-Yield Pearls: * **False Positives (Floating despite stillbirth):** Can occur due to **putrefaction** (gas formation) or artificial respiration. * **False Negatives (Sinking despite live birth):** Can occur in cases of **atelectasis**, severe pneumonia, or pulmonary edema. * **Static Test (Fodere’s Test):** Involves weighing the lungs. The **Ploucquet’s Test** compares the lung weight to the total body weight (Ratio is ~1:70 for live birth and ~1:35 for stillbirth). * **Wredin’s Test:** Checks for the presence of air in the middle ear (another sign of live birth).

Q: What does a hydrostatic test help to determine?

Live birth. **Explanation:** The **Hydrostatic Test** (also known as the Raygat’s test or Docimasia pulmonum) is a classic medicolegal procedure used to differentiate between a **live birth** and a **stillbirth**. **Why the correct answer is right:** When a child is born alive and takes its first breath, the lungs expand with air. This air reduces the specific gravity of the lung tissue (from ~1.050 to ~0.950), making it lighter than water. In this test, the lungs (or segments of them) are placed in water; if they **float**, it indicates the child breathed (live birth). If they sink, it suggests the lungs are atelectatic (stillbirth). **Why the incorrect options are wrong:** * **Presence of smegma:** Smegma is a sebaceous secretion found under the prepuce or labia; its presence is used to assess the hygiene or physical maturity of a newborn, not lung aeration. * **Criminal abortion:** Evidence for criminal abortion typically involves looking for local trauma to the cervix/vagina, presence of foreign bodies, or chemical irritants, not lung buoyancy. * **Buccal coitus:** This is a form of sexual assault. Diagnosis relies on the presence of semen, acid phosphatase, or DNA swabs from the oral cavity. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **False Positive (Floating despite stillbirth):** Occurs due to **putrefaction** (gas formation) or artificial respiration. * **False Negative (Sinking despite live birth):** Occurs in cases of pulmonary edema, pneumonia, or extreme atelectasis. * **Static Test (Fodere’s Test):** Involves weighing the lungs. A live-born lung is heavier due to increased pulmonary blood flow (approx. 1/35th of body weight) compared to a stillborn lung (approx. 1/70th). * **Wredin’s Test:** Examination of the middle ear; disappearance of the gelatinous embryonic connective tissue indicates live birth.

Q: What is the IPC section for the punishment of infanticide?

IPC 315. **Explanation:** In Indian law, there is no specific section titled "Infanticide." Instead, cases involving the killing of a newborn are prosecuted under sections related to murder or acts preventing a child from being born alive. **Why Option A is Correct:** **IPC 315** deals with an **"Act done with intent to prevent a child being born alive or to cause it to die after birth."** This section is specifically applied to infanticide when the act is committed either just before birth or immediately after birth to ensure the infant does not survive. It carries a punishment of up to 10 years imprisonment and/or a fine. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **IPC 312:** Relates to **causing miscarriage** (Criminal Abortion) with the consent of the woman. * **IPC 317:** Relates to the **exposure and abandonment** of a child under 12 years of age by a parent or caretaker. While it may lead to death, the primary intent defined here is abandonment. * **IPC 318:** Relates to the **concealment of birth** by secret disposal of the dead body, whether the child died before, during, or after birth. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Hydrostatic Test (Raygat’s Test):** Used to determine if a child was born alive by checking if the lungs float in water (positive in live birth). * **Wredin’s Test:** Detection of air in the middle ear, indicating the child took a breath. * **Breslau’s Second Life Test:** Presence of air in the stomach and intestines (Gastrointestinal tract) as a sign of live birth. * **Precipitate Labor:** A common defense in infanticide cases where the mother claims the birth was so sudden that the infant sustained accidental injuries (e.g., falling on the floor).

Q: Which test involves comparing the weight of the lungs to the body weight?

Ploucquet's Test. **Explanation:** In cases of suspected infanticide, the primary objective is to determine whether the child was born alive or was a stillbirth. **Ploucquet’s Test** is based on the physiological change in pulmonary circulation that occurs at birth. Before birth, only a small fraction of blood flows to the lungs; once respiration begins, the pulmonary vessels dilate, significantly increasing the blood volume and weight of the lungs. * **Ploucquet’s Test (Correct):** It compares the ratio of lung weight to total body weight. * **Stillborn:** Ratio is approximately **1:70**. * **Live born:** Ratio increases to approximately **1:35** due to increased pulmonary vascularization. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **A. Fodere’s Test (Static Test):** This involves observing the physical appearance of the lungs (color, consistency, and volume) and performing the hydrostatic test (Raygat’s) to see if they float in water. * **C. Raygat’s Test (Hydrostatic Test):** The most famous test for live birth. It relies on the presence of air in the alveoli. If the lungs float in water, it suggests the child breathed (live birth), though decomposition can cause false positives. * **D. Wredin’s Test (Ear Test):** This test examines the middle ear. In a stillborn, the middle ear is filled with embryonic gelatinous tissue. In a live-born child who has breathed, this tissue is replaced by air. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Breslau’s Second Life Test:** Involves checking for air in the stomach and intestines (Gastrointestinal Hydrostatic Test). * **Spalding’s Sign:** Overlapping of skull bones on X-ray, indicating intrauterine fetal death (maceration). * **Wredin’s Test** is also known as the **Middle Ear Test**. * **Ploucquet’s Test** is currently considered less reliable than histological examination because pathological conditions (like pneumonia or congestion) can alter lung weight.

Q: A conceptus material is brought by the police. It is 2 cm in length and 10 g in weight. What is the probable age?

6 weeks. **Explanation:** The determination of gestational age in forensic practice is primarily based on the physical dimensions (Crown-Rump Length) and weight of the conceptus. This question tests the knowledge of the **Hase’s Rule** and standard embryological growth charts. **1. Why Option D is Correct:** At **6 weeks** of gestation, the embryo typically measures between **1.5 cm to 2.2 cm** in length and weighs approximately **8 to 12 grams**. The provided measurements (2 cm and 10 g) align perfectly with the developmental milestones of the late 6th week. **2. Why Other Options are Incorrect:** * **A. 2 weeks:** At this stage, the conceptus is a microscopic blastocyst/embryonic disc, not visible to the naked eye as a 2 cm structure. * **B. 4 weeks:** The embryo is approximately 4–5 mm (0.4–0.5 cm) long and weighs less than 1 gram. It resembles a curved "C" shape with early limb buds. * **C. 5 weeks:** The embryo is roughly 8–11 mm (0.8–1.1 cm) long. While larger than at 4 weeks, it has not yet reached the 2 cm mark. **3. High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Hase’s Rule (for length):** * Months 1–5: Age in months² = Length in cm. * Months 6–10: Age in months × 5 = Length in cm. * **Viability:** In India, legal viability is generally considered at **28 weeks** (though medically it is decreasing with advanced NICU care). * **Weight Milestone:** The fetus typically reaches **1 kg at 28 weeks** (7 lunar months). * **Rule of Thumb:** For very early embryos (like in this question), remember that at **8 weeks**, the length is roughly **3 cm** and weight is **15-20 g**. Since the specimen is 2 cm, 6 weeks is the most accurate clinical fit.

Q: What is the cause of death in breech delivery?

Atlanto-axial dislocation. ### Explanation **Correct Option: C. Atlanto-axial dislocation** In forensic medicine and obstetrics, **atlanto-axial dislocation** is considered a classic cause of death specifically associated with **breech delivery**, particularly when excessive traction is applied to the trunk to deliver the after-coming head. The forceful pulling or hyperextension of the neck can lead to the separation of the first and second cervical vertebrae, resulting in fatal compression of the upper spinal cord or medulla oblongata. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **A. Intracranial hemorrhage:** While common in difficult instrumental deliveries (like forceps) or precipitate labor, it is less specific to the mechanical trauma of breech extraction compared to cervical injury. * **B. Aspiration:** Though a fetus may aspirate amniotic fluid or meconium if gasping occurs in utero (due to cord compression), it is rarely the immediate, primary cause of death during the delivery process itself. * **D. Asphyxia:** While asphyxia is a frequent *mode* of death in many neonatal scenarios (e.g., cord prolapse), atlanto-axial dislocation is the specific *mechanical* cause of death linked to the maneuvers used in breech presentations. **High-Yield Facts for NEET-PG:** * **Wredin’s Sign:** Presence of a gelatinous substance in the middle ear of a newborn, indicating the child was born alive (though its reliability is debated). * **Hydrostatic Test (Raygat’s Test):** Used to determine if a child was born alive by checking if the lungs float in water. * **Spalding’s Sign:** Overlapping of skull bones seen on X-ray, indicating intrauterine fetal death (maceration). * **Fracture of the Clavicle:** The most common bone fractured during a difficult labor (shoulder dystocia).

Q: Wreden's test is used to demonstrate which of the following?

Live birth. **Explanation:** **Wreden's Test (also known as the Wendt-Wreden Test)** is a hydrostatic test used in forensic autopsy to determine **live birth**. The underlying medical concept is based on the presence of air in the **middle ear**. In a stillborn fetus, the middle ear is filled with embryonic gelatinous connective tissue or fluid. Once a baby is born alive and begins breathing and swallowing, air travels through the Eustachian tube into the middle ear, displacing the fluid. During the test, the middle ear is opened under water; if air bubbles escape, it indicates the infant breathed after birth. **Analysis of Options:** * **A. Live birth (Correct):** As explained, the presence of air in the middle ear is a sign of respiration and physiological activity post-delivery. * **B. Insanity:** Tests for insanity in forensic psychiatry include the Mc’Naughten rules or clinical evaluations, not anatomical middle ear tests. * **C. Putrefaction:** While decomposition can produce gases that might cause false positives in hydrostatic tests (like the Foderé’s test), Wreden's test is specifically designed to assess viability/live birth. * **D. Assault:** Assault is determined by injury patterns (abrasions, contusions, etc.), not by middle ear air content. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Foderé’s Test (Hydrostatic Test):** The most common test for live birth involving the lungs. Lungs float in water if the infant has breathed. * **Breslau’s Second Life Test:** Involves the stomach and intestines; air swallowed during live birth causes these organs to float. * **Earliest sign of live birth:** The presence of air in the stomach (Breslau's test) can occur even before the lungs fully expand. * **Wreden’s Test Timing:** It is particularly useful when the lungs are putrefied, as the middle ear is relatively protected from early decomposition.

Q: Whiplash injury is commonly seen in which of the following conditions?

Shaken baby syndrome. **Explanation:** **Shaken Baby Syndrome (SBS)**, a severe form of physical child abuse, is the correct answer. It occurs when an infant is violently shaken, causing the heavy head to rotate uncontrollably on the relatively weak neck muscles. This repetitive acceleration-deceleration motion creates a **whiplash effect**, leading to the classic **"Triad of SBS"**: 1. **Subdural Hemorrhage:** Tearing of bridging veins. 2. **Retinal Hemorrhage:** Pathognomonic finding (seen in ~80% of cases). 3. **Encephalopathy:** Brain swelling or diffuse axonal injury. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS):** This is the sudden, unexplained death of an infant under one year of age, usually during sleep. It lacks evidence of trauma or whiplash. * **Munchausen Syndrome by Proxy:** A form of child abuse where a caregiver fabricates or induces illness in a child to gain attention. While it is a psychiatric/forensic entity, it does not specifically involve whiplash mechanics. * **Battered Baby Syndrome:** This is a broad term for repetitive physical abuse. While SBS is a subset of this syndrome, "whiplash injury" is specifically the defining mechanism of the shaking component (SBS) rather than general blunt force trauma (fractures/bruises) seen in typical battered babies. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Caffey’s Triad:** Another name for the clinical presentation of Shaken Baby Syndrome. * **Metaphyseal Bucket-handle fractures:** Highly specific radiological sign of child abuse (avulsion of the periosteum). * **Rib Fractures:** Posterior rib fractures are highly suggestive of non-accidental injury (squeezing the chest while shaking). * **Key Diagnostic Tool:** Non-contrast CT head and Dilated Fundoscopic Examination.

Q: All tests are used to detect live birth, except:

Gettler's test. **Explanation:** The correct answer is **Gettler’s test** because it is used to determine the cause of death in cases of **drowning**, not to establish live birth. It involves comparing the chloride content in the blood of the right and left ventricles of the heart. A significant difference indicates drowning in either fresh or saltwater. **Analysis of other options (Tests for Live Birth):** * **Ploucquet’s Test:** This is based on the ratio of lung weight to total body weight. In a stillborn, the ratio is approximately **1:70**, whereas, in a live-born infant who has breathed, the ratio increases to about **1:35** due to increased pulmonary vascularization. * **Fodere’s Test (Hydrostatic Test):** This is the most famous test for live birth. It relies on the principle that lungs that have breathed will float in water due to the presence of air, while stillborn lungs (atelectatic) will sink. * **Raygat’s Test (Static Test):** This involves the simple observation of the volume and weight of the lungs. Lungs that have breathed are voluminous, spongy, and cover the heart, whereas stillborn lungs are small, firm, and liver-like in consistency. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Wredin’s Test:** Detects the absence of the gelatinous plug in the middle ear (disappears after breathing/swallowing). * **Breslau’s Second Life Test:** Based on the presence of air in the stomach and intestines (Gastrointestinal Hydrostatic Test). * **False Positive Hydrostatic Test:** Can occur due to **putrefaction** (gas formation), which is why the test must be interpreted cautiously if decomposition is present.

Question 1

In forensic medicine, the hydrostatic test is primarily used to determine which of the following conditions in a deceased infant?

Accepted Answer

Evidence of infanticide

Answer

The presence of dry drowning

Answer

The presence of wet drowning

Answer

The circumstances of near drowning

Question 2

Changes in the middle ear after birth are observed in?

Accepted Answer

Werdin's test

Answer

Ploucquet's test

Answer

Fodere's test

Answer

Breslau's test

Question 3

What does a hydrostatic test help to determine?

Accepted Answer

Live birth

Answer

Presence of smegma

Answer

Criminal abortion

Answer

Buccal coitus

Question 4

What is the IPC section for the punishment of infanticide?

Accepted Answer

IPC 315

Answer

IPC 312

Answer

IPC 317

Answer

IPC 318

Question 5

Which test involves comparing the weight of the lungs to the body weight?

Accepted Answer

Ploucquet's Test

Answer

Fodere's Test

Answer

Raygat's Test

Answer

Wredin Test/Cavette test

Question 6

A conceptus material is brought by the police. It is 2 cm in length and 10 g in weight. What is the probable age?

Accepted Answer

6 weeks

Answer

2 weeks

Answer

4 weeks

Answer

5 weeks

Question 7

What is the cause of death in breech delivery?

Accepted Answer

Atlanto-axial dislocation

Answer

Intracranial hemorrhage

Answer

Aspiration

Answer

Asphyxia

Question 8

Wreden's test is used to demonstrate which of the following?

Accepted Answer

Live birth

Answer

Insanity

Answer

Putrefaction

Answer

Assault

Question 9

Whiplash injury is commonly seen in which of the following conditions?

Accepted Answer

Shaken baby syndrome

Answer

Sudden infant death syndrome

Answer

Munchausen syndrome

Answer

Battered baby syndrome

Question 10

All tests are used to detect live birth, except:

Accepted Answer

Gettler's test

Answer

Ploucquet's test

Answer

Fodere's test

Answer

Raygat's test

Infanticide — MCQs

Infanticide — MCQs

On this page

Practice by Chapter

Want unlimited practice?