Bereavement support — MCQs

10 questions

A 30-year-old woman comes to the physician because of difficulty sleeping. She is afraid of falling asleep and gets up earlier than desired. Four months ago, she was the driver in a car accident that resulted in the death of her unborn child. She has vivid nightmares of the event and reports that she frequently re-experiences the accident. She blames herself for the death of her child, has stopped working as an accountant, avoids driving in cars, and has withdrawn from her parents and close friends. Which of the following is the most likely diagnosis?

A 17-year-old boy is being seen by student health for a sports physical. He denies any recent injuries. He reports that he is doing well in his classes. He fractured his left collar bone 3 years ago, which required open reduction and internal fixation. He has not had any other surgeries. He takes no medications. His father and his paternal grandfather have hypertension. When asked about his mother, the patient tears up and he quickly begins talking about how excited he is for baseball tryouts. He has a chance this year to be in the starting lineup if, "I just stay focused." From previous records, the patient's mother died of ovarian cancer 6 months ago. Which of the following defense mechanisms is the patient exhibiting?

A 24-year-old woman visits her psychiatrist a week after she delivered a baby. She is holding her baby and crying as she waits for her appointment. She tells her physician that a day or so after her delivery, she has been finding it difficult to contain her feelings. She is often sad and unable to contain her tears. She is embarrassed and often starts crying without any reason in front of people. She is also anxious that she will not be a good mother and will make mistakes. She hasn’t slept much since the delivery and is often stressed about her baby getting hurt. She makes excessive attempts to keep the baby safe and avoid any mishaps. She does not report any loss of interest in her activities and denies any suicidal tendencies. Which of the following is best course of management for this patient?

A 20-year-old college student comes to the physician because she has been extremely sad for the past 3 weeks and has to cry constantly. Three weeks ago, her boyfriend left her after they were together for 4 years. She has no appetite and has had a 2.3-kg (5.1-lb) weight loss. She has missed several classes because she could not stop crying or get out of bed. She thinks about her ex-boyfriend all the time. She says that she experienced similar symptoms for about 2 months after previous relationships ended. The patient is 158 cm (5 ft 2 in) tall and weighs 45 kg (100 lb); BMI is 18 kg/m2. Her temperature is 36.1°C (97°F), pulse is 65/min, and blood pressure is 110/60 mm Hg. Physical examination shows no abnormalities. On mental status examination she appears sad and cries easily. Which of the following is the most likely diagnosis?

A 5-year-old boy is brought to the physician by his mother because he claims to have spoken to his recently-deceased grandfather. The grandfather, who lived with the family and frequently watched the boy for his parents, died 2 months ago. The boy was taken out of preschool for 3 days after his grandfather's death but has since returned. His teachers report that the boy is currently doing well, completing his assignments, and engaging in play with other children. When asked about how he feels, the boy becomes tearful and says, “I miss my grandpa. I sometimes talk to him when my mom is not around.” Which of the following is the most likely diagnosis?

A 27-year-old woman is brought to the physician by her parents because they are concerned about her mood. They say that she has “not been herself” since the death of her friend, who was killed 3 weeks ago when the fighter jet he piloted was shot down overseas. She says that since the incident, she feels sad and alone. She reports having repeated nightmares about her friend's death. Her appetite has decreased, but she is still eating regularly and is otherwise able to take care of herself. She does not leave her home for any social activities and avoids visits from friends. She went back to work after taking 1 week off after the incident. Her vital signs are within normal limits. Physical examination shows no abnormalities. On mental status examination, she appears sad, has a full range of affect, and is cooperative. In addition to taking measures to evaluate this patient's anxiety, which of the following is the most appropriate statement by the physician at this time?

A 72-year-old man presents to the emergency department with chest pain and shortness of breath. An EKG demonstrates an ST elevation myocardial infarction, and he is managed appropriately. The patient suffers from multiple comorbidities and was recently hospitalized for a myocardial infarction. The patient has a documented living will, which specifies that he does wish to receive resuscitative measures and blood products but refuses intubation in any circumstance. The patient is stabilized and transferred to the medical floor. On day 2, the patient presents with ventricular fibrillation and a resuscitative effort occurs. He is successfully resuscitated, but his pulmonary parameters warrant intervention and are acutely worsening. The patient's wife, son, and daughter are present and state that the patient should be intubated. The patient's prognosis even with intubation is very poor. Which of the following describes the best course of action?

An 85-year-old man with terminal stage colon cancer formally designates his best friend as his medical durable power of attorney. After several courses of chemotherapy and surgical intervention, the patient’s condition does not improve, and he soon develops respiratory failure. He is then placed on a ventilator in a comatose condition. His friend with the medical power of attorney tells the care provider that the patient would not want to be on life support. The patient’s daughter disputes this and says that her father needs to keep receiving care, in case there should be any possibility of recovery. Additionally, there is a copy of the patient’s living will in the medical record which states that, if necessary, he should be placed on life support until full recovery. Which of the following is the most appropriate course of action?

A 67-year-old man presents to the emergency department following an episode of chest pain and a loss of consciousness. The patient is in critical condition and his vital signs are rapidly deteriorating. It is known that the patient is currently undergoing chemotherapy for Hodgkin’s lymphoma. The patient is accompanied by his wife, who wants the medical staff to do everything to resuscitate the patient and bring him back. The patient also has 2 daughters, who are on their way to the hospital. The patient’s written advance directive states that the patient does not wish to be resuscitated or have any sort of life support. Which of the following is the appropriate course of action?

Q10

A 43-year-old male is transferred from an outside hospital to the neurologic intensive care unit for management of a traumatic brain injury after suffering a 30-foot fall from a roof-top. He now lacks decision-making capacity but does not fulfill the criteria for brain-death. The patient does not have a living will and did not name a specific surrogate decision-maker or durable power of attorney. Which of the following would be the most appropriate person to name as a surrogate decision maker for this patient?

Bereavement support US Medical PG Practice Questions and MCQs

Question 1: A 30-year-old woman comes to the physician because of difficulty sleeping. She is afraid of falling asleep and gets up earlier than desired. Four months ago, she was the driver in a car accident that resulted in the death of her unborn child. She has vivid nightmares of the event and reports that she frequently re-experiences the accident. She blames herself for the death of her child, has stopped working as an accountant, avoids driving in cars, and has withdrawn from her parents and close friends. Which of the following is the most likely diagnosis?

A. Acute stress disorder
B. Normal grief
C. Major depressive disorder
D. Adjustment disorder
E. Post-traumatic stress disorder (Correct Answer)

Explanation: ***Post-traumatic stress disorder*** - The patient's symptoms, including **re-experiencing the trauma** (nightmares, flashbacks), avoidance behaviors (avoiding driving, withdrawing from social interactions), and negative alterations in cognition and mood (difficulty sleeping, self-blame), persisting for **four months** after a traumatic event, are characteristic of PTSD. - The severity and chronicity of these symptoms, significantly impacting her daily functioning, align with the diagnostic criteria for PTSD. *Acute stress disorder* - This diagnosis also involves exposure to a traumatic event and similar symptoms (intrusive thoughts, negative mood, avoidance) but is diagnosed only when symptoms last for a minimum of **3 days and a maximum of 1 month** after the trauma. - Since the patient's symptoms have persisted for **four months**, acute stress disorder is ruled out. *Normal grief* - While grief is a natural response to loss, the patient's symptoms extend beyond typical grief, involving specific **trauma-related re-experiencing** and **avoidance behaviors** that are not primarily focused on the deceased, but rather on the traumatic event itself. - Normal grief typically does not involve the severe, persistent avoidance and intrusive symptoms of a traumatic nature seen here. *Major depressive disorder* - Although the patient exhibits symptoms that could overlap with depression (difficulty sleeping, withdrawal, loss of interest), the primary driver of her symptoms is the **traumatic event** and its associated re-experiencing and avoidance. - A diagnosis of MDD would be considered if the depressive symptoms are paramount and not better explained by the trauma response, but in this case, the **trauma-specific symptoms** are central. *Adjustment disorder* - This disorder is characterized by the development of emotional or behavioral symptoms in response to an identifiable stressor, occurring within **3 months of the stressor**. - While a traumatic event could be a stressor, adjustment disorder is diagnosed when the symptoms **do not meet the criteria for another specific mental disorder**, like PTSD, and are generally less severe and pervasive than what is described in this patient.

Question 2: A 17-year-old boy is being seen by student health for a sports physical. He denies any recent injuries. He reports that he is doing well in his classes. He fractured his left collar bone 3 years ago, which required open reduction and internal fixation. He has not had any other surgeries. He takes no medications. His father and his paternal grandfather have hypertension. When asked about his mother, the patient tears up and he quickly begins talking about how excited he is for baseball tryouts. He has a chance this year to be in the starting lineup if, "I just stay focused." From previous records, the patient's mother died of ovarian cancer 6 months ago. Which of the following defense mechanisms is the patient exhibiting?

A. Displacement
B. Denial
C. Rationalization
D. Repression
E. Suppression (Correct Answer)

Explanation: ***Suppression*** - The patient consciously avoids thinking about his mother's death by **deliberately redirecting his thoughts** to baseball tryouts. - He is aware of the grief but chooses to **postpone acknowledging** it openly. *Displacement* - Involves **redirecting emotions** (often anger or frustration) from the original source to a less threatening target. - The patient isn't expressing his grief towards an unrelated object or person; he's avoiding the grief itself. *Denial* - Characterized by a **refusal to accept reality** or a painful fact as if it doesn't exist. - The patient here shows awareness of his mother's death (tearing up) rather than outright denying its occurrence. *Rationalization* - Involves **creating logical-sounding excuses** or justifications for unacceptable thoughts, feelings, or behaviors. - The patient isn't making excuses; he's actively, though consciously, avoiding the painful emotional topic. *Repression* - An **unconscious mechanism** where unacceptable thoughts, feelings, or memories are blocked from conscious awareness. - Repression is an involuntary process, whereas the patient's shift to baseball is a conscious effort to avoid the topic.

Question 3: A 24-year-old woman visits her psychiatrist a week after she delivered a baby. She is holding her baby and crying as she waits for her appointment. She tells her physician that a day or so after her delivery, she has been finding it difficult to contain her feelings. She is often sad and unable to contain her tears. She is embarrassed and often starts crying without any reason in front of people. She is also anxious that she will not be a good mother and will make mistakes. She hasn’t slept much since the delivery and is often stressed about her baby getting hurt. She makes excessive attempts to keep the baby safe and avoid any mishaps. She does not report any loss of interest in her activities and denies any suicidal tendencies. Which of the following is best course of management for this patient?

A. Get admitted immediately
B. Come back for a follow-up in 2 weeks (Correct Answer)
C. Start on a small dose of fluoxetine daily
D. Give her child to child protective services
E. Schedule an appointment for electroconvulsive therapy

Explanation: ***Come back for a follow-up in 2 weeks*** - This patient presents with symptoms highly suggestive of **postpartum blues**, which typically resolve spontaneously within two weeks after delivery. - Reassurance, emotional support, and monitoring her symptoms with a follow-up appointment are the most appropriate initial steps. *Get admitted immediately* - Immediate admission is generally reserved for more severe conditions like **postpartum psychosis**, characterized by delusions, hallucinations, or severe disorganization, which are not described here. - Her symptoms, though distressing, do not indicate a level of impairment or danger requiring urgent inpatient care. *Start on a small dose of fluoxetine daily* - **Antidepressant medication** like fluoxetine is typically considered for **postpartum depression** if symptoms persist beyond two weeks or are severe from the outset. - Given the transient nature of postpartum blues, medication is not the first-line treatment. *Give her child to child protective services* - This action is extreme and entirely unwarranted, as there is no indication of **child abuse, neglect, or harm** from the mother. - Her increased anxiety about the baby's safety indicates concern, not a risk to the child's well-being. *Schedule an appointment for electroconvulsive therapy* - **Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT)** is a highly effective, but usually last-resort, treatment reserved for severe, treatment-refractory depression or psychosis, especially when rapid response is critical. - Her symptoms do not currently warrant such an intensive intervention.

Question 4: A 20-year-old college student comes to the physician because she has been extremely sad for the past 3 weeks and has to cry constantly. Three weeks ago, her boyfriend left her after they were together for 4 years. She has no appetite and has had a 2.3-kg (5.1-lb) weight loss. She has missed several classes because she could not stop crying or get out of bed. She thinks about her ex-boyfriend all the time. She says that she experienced similar symptoms for about 2 months after previous relationships ended. The patient is 158 cm (5 ft 2 in) tall and weighs 45 kg (100 lb); BMI is 18 kg/m2. Her temperature is 36.1°C (97°F), pulse is 65/min, and blood pressure is 110/60 mm Hg. Physical examination shows no abnormalities. On mental status examination she appears sad and cries easily. Which of the following is the most likely diagnosis?

A. Bereavement
B. Anorexia nervosa
C. Major depressive disorder
D. Acute stress disorder
E. Adjustment disorder with depressed mood (Correct Answer)

Explanation: ***Adjustment disorder with depressed mood*** - This diagnosis is most likely as the patient’s symptoms (sadness, crying, loss of appetite, weight loss, difficulty getting out of bed) developed in response to an **identifiable stressor** (breakup with boyfriend) and occurred within **3 months** of its onset. - The patient's history of similar, time-limited reactions to previous relationship endings supports an adjustment disorder pattern, where symptoms are **maladaptive** but resolve once the stressor is removed or a new level of adaptation is achieved, making it distinct from major depression due to its direct and timely link to a stressor. *Bereavement* - Bereavement involves the natural and expected emotional responses to the **death of a loved one**, which is not the case here as her boyfriend left her. - While symptoms can overlap with depression, the precipitating event (death vs. breakup) distinguishes it from adjustment disorder. *Anorexia nervosa* - Anorexia nervosa is characterized by an **intense fear of gaining weight** or becoming fat, a distorted body image, and a persistent restriction of energy intake leading to a significantly low body weight. - The patient's weight loss and poor appetite are attributed to her sadness and crying spells following a breakup, not primarily driven by a desire to be thin or body image preoccupation. *Major depressive disorder* - Major depressive disorder requires symptoms to be present for **at least 2 weeks** and significantly impair functioning, but the key differentiator here is the **clear and recent precipitating stressor** (breakup) and the history of similar, time-limited responses to past relationship endings. - While the symptoms are severe, they are directly and clearly linked to the stressor, and the patient's pattern of response suggests an adjustment disorder rather than an endogenous depressive episode. *Acute stress disorder* - Acute stress disorder occurs in response to exposure to actual or threatened **death, serious injury, or sexual violence**, either directly or indirectly. - The patient's stressor (a breakup) does not meet the criteria for a traumatic event required for acute stress disorder.

Question 5: A 5-year-old boy is brought to the physician by his mother because he claims to have spoken to his recently-deceased grandfather. The grandfather, who lived with the family and frequently watched the boy for his parents, died 2 months ago. The boy was taken out of preschool for 3 days after his grandfather's death but has since returned. His teachers report that the boy is currently doing well, completing his assignments, and engaging in play with other children. When asked about how he feels, the boy becomes tearful and says, “I miss my grandpa. I sometimes talk to him when my mom is not around.” Which of the following is the most likely diagnosis?

A. Normal grief (Correct Answer)
B. Major depressive disorder
C. Brief psychotic disorder
D. Adjustment disorder
E. Schizophreniform disorder

Explanation: ***Normal grief*** - The boy's reaction, including talking to his deceased grandfather and expressing sadness, is a **common and normal part of the grief process in children**, especially given his close relationship with his grandfather and the recent timing of the death. - His continued functioning at school, engaging with peers, and the absence of significant functional impairment indicate that these are likely **age-appropriate coping mechanisms** rather than a pathological condition. *Major depressive disorder* - This diagnosis typically involves **persistent sadness, anhedonia, significant changes in appetite or sleep, fatigue, feelings of worthlessness, or recurrent thoughts of death**, lasting for at least two weeks. - The boy's ability to engage in play and complete schoolwork, along with the episodic nature of his sadness, suggests he does not meet the criteria for **major depressive disorder**. *Brief psychotic disorder* - This disorder is characterized by the sudden onset of **psychotic symptoms** such as delusions, hallucinations, disorganized speech, or grossly disorganized behavior, lasting from one day to one month. - While the boy reports "speaking" to his grandfather, this is more indicative of a **grief-related fantasy or coping mechanism** rather than a true hallucination, especially since he understands his grandfather is deceased and it does not impair his daily functioning. *Adjustment disorder* - This involves **emotional or behavioral symptoms** that develop within three months of an identifiable stressor and cause significant distress or functional impairment. - Although there is a stressor (grandfather's death), the boy's symptoms are part of a **normal grieving process** and do not appear to cause significant impairment in his social or academic functioning. *Schizophreniform disorder* - This is a psychotic disorder with symptoms similar to **schizophrenia** (delusions, hallucinations, disorganized speech, negative symptoms) but lasting between one and six months. - The boy's claims of speaking to his grandfather are more consistent with **grief-induced fantasy** rather than a true psychotic symptom, and he lacks other hallmark features of a psychotic disorder.

Question 6: A 27-year-old woman is brought to the physician by her parents because they are concerned about her mood. They say that she has “not been herself” since the death of her friend, who was killed 3 weeks ago when the fighter jet he piloted was shot down overseas. She says that since the incident, she feels sad and alone. She reports having repeated nightmares about her friend's death. Her appetite has decreased, but she is still eating regularly and is otherwise able to take care of herself. She does not leave her home for any social activities and avoids visits from friends. She went back to work after taking 1 week off after the incident. Her vital signs are within normal limits. Physical examination shows no abnormalities. On mental status examination, she appears sad, has a full range of affect, and is cooperative. In addition to taking measures to evaluate this patient's anxiety, which of the following is the most appropriate statement by the physician at this time?

A. I can see that you have gone through a lot recently, but I think that your reaction is especially severe and has persisted for longer than normal. Would you be open to therapy or medication to help you manage better?
B. I am worried that you may be having an abnormally severe reaction to what is an understandably stressful event. I recommend attending behavioral therapy sessions to help you deal with this challenge.
C. Your grief over the loss of your friend appears to have a negative effect on your social and functional capabilities. I recommend starting antidepressants to help you deal with this challenge.
D. I'm so sorry, but the loss of loved ones is a part of life. Let's try to find better ways for you to deal with this event.
E. I understand that the sudden loss of your friend has affected you deeply. Sometimes in situations like yours, people have thoughts that life is not worth living; have you had such thoughts? (Correct Answer)

Explanation: ***I understand that the sudden loss of your friend has affected you deeply. Sometimes in situations like yours, people have thoughts that life is not worth living; have you had such thoughts?*** - This statement empathetically acknowledges the patient's grief while **directly assessing for suicidal ideation**, which is crucial in any evaluation of a patient experiencing significant emotional distress, especially after a recent loss. - The patient's presentation, including sadness, social withdrawal, decreased appetite, and nightmares, is consistent with **grief**, but the physician must rule out more severe conditions like **major depressive disorder (MDD)**, for which suicidal thoughts are a key diagnostic criterion and safety concern. *I can see that you have gone through a lot recently, but I think that your reaction is especially severe and has persisted for longer than normal. Would you be open to therapy or medication to help you manage better?* - This statement is somewhat judgmental ("especially severe and has persisted for longer than normal") for a patient only three weeks out from a traumatic loss, which could invalidate her feelings. - While therapy or medication might be considered, it's generally too early to classify her normal grief response as an abnormal or prolonged reaction without first screening for immediate safety concerns like suicidal ideation. *I am worried that you may be having an abnormally severe reaction to what is an understandably stressful event. I recommend attending behavioral therapy sessions to help you deal with this challenge.* - Similar to the previous option, labeling her reaction as "abnormally severe" at this early stage (3 weeks post-loss) can be perceived as invalidating and may make the patient less open to further discussion or treatment. - Recommending therapy without first assessing for suicidal ideation or a more comprehensive diagnostic evaluation is premature and misses a critical screening step. *Your grief over the loss of your friend appears to have a negative effect on your social and functional capabilities. I recommend starting antidepressants to help you deal with this challenge.* - While her social and functional capabilities are affected, grief is a normal human response, and recommending antidepressants after only 3 weeks post-loss, without a full psychiatric evaluation or ruling out suicidal ideation, is often premature. - **Antidepressants** are typically considered for **MDD** or **prolonged grief disorder**, usually after a longer period (e.g., 6 months for adults) or if symptoms are markedly severe and debilitating, especially with an immediate safety concern. *I'm so sorry, but the loss of loved ones is a part of life. Let's try to find better ways for you to deal with this event.* - This statement, particularly "the loss of loved ones is a part of life," can come across as dismissive and insensitive to the patient's individual pain and trauma. - It minimizes her experience and does not create an empathetic environment necessary for a patient to open up about potentially sensitive topics, such as suicidal thoughts.

Question 7: A 72-year-old man presents to the emergency department with chest pain and shortness of breath. An EKG demonstrates an ST elevation myocardial infarction, and he is managed appropriately. The patient suffers from multiple comorbidities and was recently hospitalized for a myocardial infarction. The patient has a documented living will, which specifies that he does wish to receive resuscitative measures and blood products but refuses intubation in any circumstance. The patient is stabilized and transferred to the medical floor. On day 2, the patient presents with ventricular fibrillation and a resuscitative effort occurs. He is successfully resuscitated, but his pulmonary parameters warrant intervention and are acutely worsening. The patient's wife, son, and daughter are present and state that the patient should be intubated. The patient's prognosis even with intubation is very poor. Which of the following describes the best course of action?

A. Intubate the patient - the family is representing the patient's most recent and accurate wishes
B. Consult the hospital ethics committee
C. Do not intubate the patient given his living will (Correct Answer)
D. Intubate the patient - a patient's next of kin take precedence over a living will
E. Do not intubate the patient as his prognosis is poor even with intubation

Explanation: ***Do not intubate the patient given his living will*** - A **living will** or **advance directive** is a legally binding document that outlines a patient's wishes regarding medical treatment, including refusal of specific interventions like intubation. - When the patient is **competent**, their stated wishes are paramount; when they are **incapacitated**, their advance directive becomes the primary guide for care decisions. *Intubate the patient - the family is representing the patient's most recent and accurate wishes* - While family input is valuable, a **legally executed living will** takes precedence over family opinions, especially when there's a conflict regarding specific life-sustaining treatments like intubation. - There is no evidence presented that the patient has **revoked or updated** his living will. *Consult the hospital ethics committee* - While an ethics committee can provide guidance in complex cases, the patient's living will provides **clear instructions** that should be followed directly, making an immediate ethics committee consultation less necessary for this specific decision. - The primary role of the ethics committee is to address **ambiguity or conflict** in patient care, which is not present regarding the patient's explicit refusal of intubation. *Intubate the patient - a patient's next of kin take precedence over a living will* - This statement is incorrect; a **valid living will** *takes precedence* over the wishes of the next of kin when the patient is unable to express their current desires. - The next of kin's role is to act as a **surrogate decision-maker** only when a patient lacks capacity and has no advance directive that covers the specific situation. *Do not intubate the patient as his prognosis is poor even with intubation* - While a **poor prognosis** can be a factor in end-of-life discussions, the primary reason for not intubating in this scenario is the patient's explicit refusal documented in his **living will**, not solely the prognosis. - Relying *only* on prognosis without considering the patient's prior stated wishes can undermine **patient autonomy**.

Question 8: An 85-year-old man with terminal stage colon cancer formally designates his best friend as his medical durable power of attorney. After several courses of chemotherapy and surgical intervention, the patient’s condition does not improve, and he soon develops respiratory failure. He is then placed on a ventilator in a comatose condition. His friend with the medical power of attorney tells the care provider that the patient would not want to be on life support. The patient’s daughter disputes this and says that her father needs to keep receiving care, in case there should be any possibility of recovery. Additionally, there is a copy of the patient’s living will in the medical record which states that, if necessary, he should be placed on life support until full recovery. Which of the following is the most appropriate course of action?

A. Withdraw the life support since the patient’s chances of recovery are very low
B. Contact other family members to get their input for the patient
C. Act according to the patient’s living will
D. The durable medical power of attorney’s decision should be followed. (Correct Answer)
E. Follow the daughter’s decision for the patient

Explanation: ***The durable medical power of attorney's decision should be followed*** - The patient designated his friend as his **durable power of attorney for healthcare (DPOA)**, giving him legal authority to make medical decisions when the patient cannot communicate. - While the living will states life support "until full recovery," the patient has **terminal stage colon cancer** - full recovery is **medically impossible**. The living will's condition cannot be fulfilled. - When advance directive language is ambiguous or cannot be applied to actual clinical circumstances, the **DPOA's interpretive authority** is essential. The DPOA is expected to apply the patient's values to the real situation. - The DPOA states the patient would not want to be on life support - this reflects the patient's **values and wishes** as understood by his chosen decision-maker, applied to the actual terminal situation. - This honors both **patient autonomy** (through his chosen proxy) and the reality that advance directives cannot anticipate every clinical scenario. *Act according to the patient's living will* - While a living will expresses patient wishes, it states life support should continue "**until full recovery**" - but the patient has terminal cancer with no possibility of recovery. - Literal adherence to an advance directive whose conditions are **medically impossible** does not serve the patient's true interests or autonomy. - Living wills and DPOAs work **together** - the DPOA interprets and applies the living will to actual circumstances, especially when literal application is impossible or the situation wasn't anticipated. *Withdraw the life support since the patient's chances of recovery are very low* - While this may align with the DPOA's interpretation of the patient's wishes, unilateral physician decision-making without following the proper **decision-making hierarchy** is inappropriate. - The physician should work **with the DPOA** rather than make independent decisions about life support withdrawal. *Contact other family members to get their input for the patient* - The patient **legally designated** his friend as DPOA, indicating his trust in this person's judgment over family members. - While family input can be valuable, seeking additional opinions when there is a **legally appointed decision-maker** undermines the patient's explicit choice. - The daughter has no legal standing to override the DPOA's decisions. *Follow the daughter's decision for the patient* - The daughter was **not designated** as the healthcare decision-maker; the friend was explicitly chosen as DPOA. - Following the daughter's wishes would **violate** the patient's autonomous choice of decision-maker. - Family relationship alone does not override a formal DPOA designation.

Question 9: A 67-year-old man presents to the emergency department following an episode of chest pain and a loss of consciousness. The patient is in critical condition and his vital signs are rapidly deteriorating. It is known that the patient is currently undergoing chemotherapy for Hodgkin’s lymphoma. The patient is accompanied by his wife, who wants the medical staff to do everything to resuscitate the patient and bring him back. The patient also has 2 daughters, who are on their way to the hospital. The patient’s written advance directive states that the patient does not wish to be resuscitated or have any sort of life support. Which of the following is the appropriate course of action?

A. Consult a judge
B. Respect the patient’s advance directive orders (Correct Answer)
C. Contact the patient’s siblings or other first-degree relatives
D. Take into account the best medical decision made by the physician for the patient
E. Respect the wife’s wishes and resuscitate the patient

Explanation: ***Respect the patient’s advance directive orders*** - **Advance directives** legally document a patient's wishes regarding medical treatment, including end-of-life care, and must be honored if the patient is unable to make decisions. - The patient's previously expressed autonomous decision, through a **written advance directive**, carries legal and ethical precedence over the wishes of family members or medical staff. *Consult a judge* - Consulting a judge is typically reserved for situations where there is **ambiguity or dispute** regarding the interpretation of an advance directive, or when no advance directive exists and family members disagree. - In this case, the **written advance directive is clear**, making judicial intervention unnecessary. *Contact the patient’s siblings or other first-degree relatives* - Although family input can be valuable in some medical decisions, it does not **override a legally binding advance directive** made by the patient. - The **patient's own wishes** are paramount, especially when clearly documented. *Take into account the best medical decision made by the physician for the patient* - While physicians provide medical expertise, patient **autonomy and established advance directives** take precedence over a physician's "best medical decision," especially regarding resuscitation. - The physician's role here is to **implement the patient's documented wishes**, not to countermand them. *Respect the wife’s wishes and resuscitate the patient* - The wife's wishes, while important for emotional support, **do not legally or ethically supersede** the patient's explicit, written advance directive regarding resuscitation. - Honoring the wife's request would violate the patient's **right to self-determination** and their previously stated wishes.

Question 10: A 43-year-old male is transferred from an outside hospital to the neurologic intensive care unit for management of a traumatic brain injury after suffering a 30-foot fall from a roof-top. He now lacks decision-making capacity but does not fulfill the criteria for brain-death. The patient does not have a living will and did not name a specific surrogate decision-maker or durable power of attorney. Which of the following would be the most appropriate person to name as a surrogate decision maker for this patient?

A. The patient's 67-year-old mother
B. The patient's 22-year-old daughter (Correct Answer)
C. The patient's girlfriend of 12 years
D. The patient's older brother
E. The patient's younger sister

Explanation: **The patient's 22-year-old daughter** - Most jurisdictions prioritize next of kin in a specific order, typically **spouse**, adult children, parents, and then siblings if no advanced directives exist. - An **adult child** ranks higher in most default surrogate decision-making hierarchies than parents, siblings, or unmarried partners. *The patient's 67-year-old mother* - While a close family member, a **parent** is typically lower on the hierarchy of surrogate decision-makers than an adult child. - The goal is often to find someone who best understands the patient's wishes, and adult children are generally assumed to have this insight more than parents in many legal frameworks. *The patient's girlfriend of 12 years* - An **unmarried partner or girlfriend**, regardless of relationship length, typically holds no legal standing as a surrogate decision-maker unless explicitly named in an advanced directive. - Legal frameworks prioritize **blood relatives** or legally recognized unions (marriage) when no formal documentation exists. *The patient's older brother* - A **sibling** is usually further down the hierarchy of surrogate decision-makers after adult children and parents. - While a family member, they would not be prioritized over a child in the absence of other directives. *The patient's younger sister* - Similar to the brother, a **sibling** is generally lower on the hierarchy than an adult child or parent. - Family relationships are important, but legal protocols follow specific orders of precedence.

Want unlimited practice?

Get full access to all questions, explanations, and performance tracking.

Start For Free