Nonunion and Malunion

On this page

Definitions & Overview - Broken & Bent

  • Nonunion: Fracture fails to unite.

    ⭐ The FDA defines nonunion as a fracture at least 9 months old with no signs of healing for 3 consecutive months.

    • Types:
      • Hypertrophic (elephant foot): Vascular, abundant callus, unstable.
      • Atrophic: Avascular, no callus, gap present.
      • Oligotrophic: Vascular, minimal/no callus; often due to distraction or poor apposition.
      • Septic: Infected nonunion.
      • Aseptic: Non-infected nonunion.
  • Malunion: Fracture heals in a non-anatomical/deformed position (e.g., angulation, rotation, shortening).

Etiology & Risk Factors - Why Bones Balk

CategoryKey Risk Factors
Patient-RelatedSmoking (major!), diabetes mellitus, malnutrition (↓protein, Vit C/D), chronic NSAID/steroid use, systemic infection, advanced age, peripheral vascular disease (PVD).
Fracture-RelatedSignificant instability or gap (e.g., >1mm), compromised blood supply (e.g., scaphoid, talus head), severe soft tissue injury/stripping, substantial bone loss, open fractures (contamination), segmental fractures, intra-articular extension.
Surgeon-RelatedInadequate fracture reduction, improper or insufficient fixation (too loose/too rigid), excessive soft tissue stripping during surgery, distraction at fracture site, iatrogenic infection.

Diagnosis & Classification - Signs & Sorts

  • Clinical Features:
    • Nonunion: Pain, tenderness, abnormal motion, deformity, pseudoarthrosis.
    • Malunion: Deformity, functional limitation, pain, arthritis.
  • Investigations:
    • X-rays (Serial): Sclerosis, resorption, implant failure, no callus (3-6 months).
    • CT Scan: Details anatomy & union.
    • Infection: ↑ESR, ↑CRP; Bone/WBC scan.
  • Classification of Nonunion (Weber-Cech):
    TypeViabilitySubtypeX-ray Feature
    HypertrophicVascularA1: Elephant FootAbundant callus
    A2: Horse HoofLess callus
    A3: OligotrophicMinimal/no callus
    AtrophicAvascularB1: Torsion WedgeIntermediate fragment
    B2: ComminutedNecrotic fragments
    B3: DefectGap, bone loss
    B4: AtrophicResorbed ends
    Weber-Cech classification of nonunion types
    • Paley: For bone defects.

⭐ The 'elephant foot' appearance on X-ray is characteristic of a vascular, hypertrophic nonunion (Weber-Cech Type A1).

Management Principles - Mending Methods

Error: Failed to generate content for this concept group.

High‑Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

  • Nonunion: Fracture unhealed by 6-9 months. Malunion: Healed with deformity.
  • Hypertrophic nonunion ("elephant foot"): good biology, poor stability. Atrophic ("pencil point"): poor biology.
  • Key nonunion causes: Infection, avascularity, instability, gap.
  • Diamond concept (osteogenic cells, scaffold, growth factors, stability) guides nonunion treatment.
  • Common nonunion sites: Scaphoid, tibia (distal), femoral neck.
  • Malunion causes functional loss and arthritis; requires corrective osteotomy.

Practice Questions: Nonunion and Malunion

Test your understanding with these related questions

Nonunion is most common in fracture of the:

1 of 5

Flashcards: Nonunion and Malunion

1/10

_____ formation occurs during fracture healing when the fracture is not fixed rigidly

TAP TO REVEAL ANSWER

_____ formation occurs during fracture healing when the fracture is not fixed rigidly

Callus

browseSpaceflip

Enjoying this lesson?

Get full access to all lessons, practice questions, and more.

Start Your Free Trial