Ethics in Psychiatry — MCQs
Principles of Health education include all except:
In the context of Indian regulations, what is the minimum number of Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) cases a doctor must have performed to be eligible to perform an MTP?
Doctor or nurse disclosing the identity of a rape victim is punishable under the following section of IPC?
A 45-year-old female patient is told about the benefits and complications of a hysterectomy, and she agrees to the procedure. What kind of consent is this?
A doctor is not held guilty of negligence if
Provision of the Mental Health Act 2017, based on WHO guidelines, includes all, except:
In civil negligence, onus of proof lies on -
Who coined the term 'psychiatry'?
Who proposed the concept of 'la belle indifférence'?
Who proposed the concept of the 'id, ego, and superego' structure of the psyche?
Ethics in Psychiatry Indian Medical PG Practice Questions and MCQs
Question 1: Principles of Health education include all except:
- A. Punishment (Correct Answer)
- B. Motivation
- C. Participation
- D. Reinforcement
Explanation: ***Punishment*** - **Punishment** is generally not considered a principle of effective health education because it can lead to **negative feelings**, resistance, and avoidance of health-seeking behaviors rather than genuine behavior change. - Effective health education focuses on **empowerment** and positive reinforcement rather than punitive measures. *Motivation* - **Motivation** is a core principle, as individuals are more likely to adopt healthy behaviors when they are **personally motivated** and understand the benefits. - Health educators aim to **stimulate and sustain interest** in health-promoting actions. *Participation* - **Participation** is crucial for effective learning and retention; active involvement by the learner (e.g., through discussions, practical exercises) fosters a **deeper understanding** and sense of ownership over their health. - It ensures that educational programs are **relevant and tailored** to the needs of the target audience. *Reinforcement* - **Reinforcement** is a key principle that helps to **solidify desired behaviors** through positive feedback and encouragement. - **Positive reinforcement** (e.g., praise, rewards, recognition) is particularly effective in health education as it rewards healthy actions and promotes their continuation without creating fear or resistance.
Question 2: In the context of Indian regulations, what is the minimum number of Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP) cases a doctor must have performed to be eligible to perform an MTP?
- A. 10
- B. 15
- C. 25 (Correct Answer)
- D. 35
Explanation: ***25*** - As per the **MTP Act of India (1971)**, a registered medical practitioner needs to have assisted in or performed a minimum of **25 medical termination of pregnancies** in an approved training center to be certified to perform MTPs independently. - This regulation ensures a certain level of practical experience and competence before a doctor can perform this procedure. *10* - This number is **insufficient** according to Indian MTP regulations for a doctor to be eligible to perform MTPs independently. - The required practical experience is set higher to ensure adequate skill and safety for the procedure. *15* - This number also **falls short** of the minimum requirement stipulated by the Indian MTP Act. - The legislative framework emphasizes a more extensive practical exposure for practitioners. *35* - While performing 35 MTPs would certainly meet the experience requirement, it is **not the minimum specified** by the Indian MTP regulations. - The law requires a lower threshold of practical experience, which is 25 cases.
Question 3: Doctor or nurse disclosing the identity of a rape victim is punishable under the following section of IPC?
- A. Section 224A
- B. Section 226A
- C. Section 222A
- D. Section 228A (Correct Answer)
Explanation: ***Section 228A IPC*** - This section of the Indian Penal Code specifically deals with the **disclosure of the identity of a victim of rape and certain sexual offenses** (Sections 376, 376A, 376AB, 376B, 376C, 376D, 376DA, 376DB, 376E). - Making public the name or any matter that can reveal the identity of a rape victim by **any person, including doctors and nurses**, is a punishable offense. - **Punishment**: Imprisonment up to **2 years** and fine. - **Exception**: Disclosure is permitted only to authorized persons like police officers for investigation purposes. - **Important**: This is now covered under **Section 72 of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) 2023**, which replaced the IPC. *Section 224A* - This is **not a valid or recognized provision** within the Indian Penal Code. - It does not relate to offenses concerning privacy or the identity of sexual assault victims. *Section 226A* - This is **not a valid or recognized provision** within the Indian Penal Code. - It does not pertain to the confidentiality of victims of sexual offenses. *Section 222A* - This is **not a valid or recognized provision** within the Indian Penal Code. - There is no such specific section addressing disclosure of victim identity in the IPC.
Question 4: A 45-year-old female patient is told about the benefits and complications of a hysterectomy, and she agrees to the procedure. What kind of consent is this?
- A. Informed consent (Correct Answer)
- B. Implied consent
- C. Opt-out consent
- D. Passive consent
Explanation: ***Informed consent*** - This type of consent occurs when a patient is fully educated about the proposed treatment, including its **benefits, risks, and alternatives**, and voluntarily agrees to proceed. - It ensures the patient has adequate information to make an **autonomous decision** about their healthcare. *Implied consent* - This consent is inferred from a patient's **actions or conduct**, rather than being explicitly stated or written. - Examples include extending an arm for a blood draw or arriving at an appointment for a specific test. *Opt-out consent* - This model assumes agreement unless the individual explicitly **refuses or declines** participation. - It is commonly used in organ donation systems, where individuals are presumed donors unless they register otherwise. *Passive consent* - This usually refers to situations where explicit consent is not sought but also explicitly not denied, such as when parents are informed about a school health program and are given the opportunity to decline, but if they don't, consent is assumed. - It is less formal than informed consent and typically used for **low-risk interventions** or data collection.
Question 5: A doctor is not held guilty of negligence if
- A. He has not obtained informed consent from patient
- B. He has exercised reasonable care and skill (Correct Answer)
- C. Others suffer disease from his patient
- D. He fails to give proper instructions
Explanation: ***He has exercised reasonable care and skill*** - A doctor is not held guilty of **negligence** if they have acted in accordance with a practice accepted as proper by a responsible body of medical men skilled in that particular art (**Bolam test**). - This implies employing the **degree of care, diligence, and skill** that a reasonably competent practitioner would use under similar circumstances. *He has not obtained informed consent from patient* - Failure to obtain **informed consent** can lead to liability for **battery** (unlawful touching) or negligence, especially if the patient can prove they would not have undergone the procedure had they been properly informed of the risks. - Ethical and legal standards mandate that patients provide **voluntary, informed consent** before medical interventions. *Others suffer disease from his patient* - A doctor's primary responsibility is to their patient; however, there are situations where a **duty to warn** third parties exists, especially in cases of foreseeable harm from a communicable disease or dangerous psychiatric patient. - Failure to warn when such a **duty is established** could lead to negligence claims if specific harm to identifiable third parties occurs. *He fails to give proper instructions* - Providing **clear and adequate post-operative or post-treatment instructions** is a fundamental part of a doctor's duty of care. - Failure to give proper instructions can result in **patient harm** and can be grounds for a negligence claim if it leads to complications or a poor outcome.
Question 6: Provision of the Mental Health Act 2017, based on WHO guidelines, includes all, except:
- A. Social support
- B. Screening family members (Correct Answer)
- C. Human rights
- D. Communication regarding care and treatment
Explanation: ***Screening family members*** - The Mental Health Act 2017 focuses on the **rights, treatment, and support of individuals with mental illness**, not routine screening of their family members. - The Act does not contain provisions mandating **screening of asymptomatic family members**, though family history may be relevant for clinical assessment. - This is **not a provision** outlined in the Act based on WHO guidelines. *Human rights* - The Act is explicitly grounded in the **protection and promotion of human rights** for persons with mental illness (Chapter I). - Ensures care with **dignity, respect, and freedom from discrimination** as core principles. - Aligns with WHO's mental health action plan and human rights framework. *Communication regarding care and treatment* - **Section 4** emphasizes the right to information and **informed consent** for all treatment decisions. - Patients must receive clear communication about their **diagnosis, treatment options, and care plans**. - Includes provisions for **advance directives** and involvement in treatment decisions. *Social support* - **Chapter V** addresses rehabilitation and community-based services, emphasizing the role of **social support systems**. - Promotes **community integration** and access to social resources for recovery. - Recognizes family and community support as essential for long-term mental health management.
Question 7: In civil negligence, onus of proof lies on -
- A. Police not below the level of sub inspector
- B. Judicial first degree magistrate
- C. Patients (Correct Answer)
- D. Doctor
Explanation: ***Patients*** - In civil negligence cases, the **onus of proof** (burden of proof) generally lies with the **plaintiff**, who is the patient (or their legal representatives) alleging negligence. - The patient must demonstrate that the doctor owed a **duty of care**, breached that duty, and this breach directly caused their **injury** or harm. *Police not below the level of sub inspector* - The police are primarily involved in **criminal investigations** and maintaining law and order, not typically in initiating civil negligence claims or bearing the burden of proof in such cases. - Their role in medical matters would usually be restricted to investigating potential **criminal acts**, such as severe assault or malpractice leading to death, rather than civil negligence. *Judicial first degree magistrate* - A magistrate is a **judicial officer** who presides over minor legal proceedings and preliminary matters, primarily in criminal cases. - Magistrates are members of the judiciary and are responsible for **adjudicating** cases, not for initiating or proving negligence claims themselves. *Doctor* - While the doctor is the **defendant** in a medical negligence case, they do not bear the initial **onus of proof** to show they were not negligent. - The doctor may have to present evidence to **rebut** the patient's claims, but the primary burden remains on the patient to establish negligence.
Question 8: Who coined the term 'psychiatry'?
- A. Moral
- B. Bleuler
- C. Pinel
- D. Johann Reil (Correct Answer)
Explanation: ***Johann Reil*** - The term "**psychiatry**" (Psychiatrie) was coined by the German physician **Johann Christian Reil** in **1808**. - Reil introduced the term in his work to advocate for a more **humane and medical approach** to mental illness, moving away from purely custodial care. *Moral* - While Reil's efforts were part of a broader movement towards **moral treatment** of the mentally ill, "moral" itself is not the specific context in which the term was coined. - **Moral treatment** emphasized humane care, occupational therapy, and a therapeutic environment, contributing to the development of psychiatry but not coining the word. *Bleuler* - **Eugen Bleuler** is known for coining the term "**schizophrenia**" in the early 20th century. - He significantly contributed to the understanding of psychotic disorders but did not coin the broader term "psychiatry." *Pinel* - **Philippe Pinel** was a French physician who was an instrumental figure in the **humanitarian reform** of mental asylum care in the late 18th century. - He is famous for **unshackling patients** at Bicêtre and Salpêtrière asylums, but he did not coin the term "psychiatry."
Question 9: Who proposed the concept of 'la belle indifférence'?
- A. Seligman
- B. Lorenz
- C. Freud (Correct Answer)
- D. Bleuler
Explanation: **Explanation:** The correct answer is **Freud**. The term **'la belle indifférence'** (the beautiful indifference) was popularized by **Sigmund Freud** to describe a specific clinical feature of **Conversion Disorder** (Functional Neurological Symptom Disorder). It refers to a paradoxical state where a patient shows a surprising lack of concern or anxiety regarding their severe physical symptoms (e.g., sudden paralysis or blindness), which have no organic cause and are rooted in psychological conflict. **Analysis of Options:** * **A. Seligman:** Martin Seligman is known for the theory of **'Learned Helplessness,'** which is a foundational model for understanding the etiology of Depression. * **B. Lorenz:** Konrad Lorenz was an ethologist famous for his work on **'Imprinting'** and attachment behaviors in animals. * **C. Freud (Correct):** As the father of psychoanalysis, Freud linked 'la belle indifférence' to the "primary gain" of conversion—where the physical symptom reduces the patient's internal anxiety. * **D. Bleuler:** Eugen Bleuler is renowned for naming **Schizophrenia** and defining its core symptoms, known as the **'4 As'** (Ambivalence, Autism, Affective flattening, and Association looseness). **NEET-PG High-Yield Pearls:** * **Conversion Disorder:** Now classified in DSM-5 as Functional Neurological Symptom Disorder. * **Primary Gain:** Internal relief from anxiety by converting psychological conflict into a physical symptom. * **Secondary Gain:** External benefits derived from being sick (e.g., attention, avoiding work). * **Clinical Note:** While classically associated with conversion disorder, 'la belle indifférence' is neither pathognomonic nor present in all cases; it can occasionally be seen in patients with organic brain lesions.
Question 10: Who proposed the concept of the 'id, ego, and superego' structure of the psyche?
- A. Bleuler
- B. Lorenz
- C. Erikson
- D. Freud (Correct Answer)
Explanation: **Explanation:** The correct answer is **Sigmund Freud (Option D)**. Freud, the father of psychoanalysis, proposed the **Structural Model of the Psyche** in 1923. According to this model, the human personality consists of three interacting components: * **Id:** Operates on the **pleasure principle**, representing instinctual drives (libido) and unconscious desires. * **Ego:** Operates on the **reality principle**, acting as a mediator between the id and the external world. * **Superego:** Operates on the **perfection/moral principle**, representing internalized societal values and the conscience. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **A. Eugen Bleuler:** Known for coining the term "Schizophrenia" and describing the "4 As" (Association, Affect, Ambivalence, and Autism). * **B. Konrad Lorenz:** An ethologist famous for the concept of **Imprinting** (the rapid learning process in early life). * **C. Erik Erikson:** Developed the **Psychosocial Theory of Development**, which consists of eight stages (e.g., Trust vs. Mistrust). **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Topographical Model:** Freud also proposed the levels of consciousness: Conscious, Preconscious, and Unconscious. * **Defense Mechanisms:** These are unconscious processes used by the **Ego** to resolve conflicts between the Id and Superego. * **Psychosexual Stages:** Freud’s developmental stages include Oral, Anal, Phallic, Latency, and Genital. * **Oedipus Complex:** Occurs during the Phallic stage (3–6 years).
Want unlimited practice?
Get full access to all questions, explanations, and performance tracking.
Start For Free