Legal and Ethical Aspects of Medicine — MCQs

Legal and Ethical Aspects of Medicine Indian Medical PG Practice Questions and MCQs

Question 181: Who has the authority to commute a death sentence?

A. High Court
B. Supreme Court
C. President (Correct Answer)
D. Any of the above

Explanation: **Explanation:** The authority to commute a death sentence is a **sovereign executive power**, not a judicial one. Under **Article 72** of the Constitution of India, the **President** has the power to grant pardons, reprieves, respites, or remissions of punishment, or to suspend, remit, or **commute** the sentence of any person convicted of any offense where the sentence is a sentence of death. A similar power is vested in the **Governor** of a State under **Article 161**, though the President’s power is broader (including court-martial cases). **Why other options are incorrect:** * **High Court (A) & Supreme Court (B):** These are judicial bodies. While they have the authority to **pass, confirm, or reduce** a sentence during the trial or appeal process (judicial review), "commutation" in the legal context of a final death sentence refers to the **mercy jurisdiction** exercised by the Executive head after all legal remedies/appeals are exhausted. * **Any of the above (D):** Incorrect because the specific constitutional power of commutation (post-final verdict) is reserved for the Executive (President/Governor). **High-Yield Facts for NEET-PG:** * **Commutation:** Changing the nature of the punishment to a lighter form (e.g., death sentence to life imprisonment). * **Remission:** Reducing the amount of sentence without changing its character (e.g., 10 years to 5 years). * **Section 433 of CrPC:** Also empowers the appropriate government (Central or State) to commute sentences. * **Medical Role:** A doctor must certify the fitness of a prisoner before execution. Execution is stayed if the convict is found to be pregnant or insane (until recovery).

Question 182: A person attempts suicide and is subsequently cured by a private doctor. What is the doctor's responsibility?

A. Inform the police
B. No action is required (Correct Answer)
C. Report to the magistrate
D. Refer to a psychiatrist

Explanation: ### Explanation **1. Why "No action is required" is correct:** The legal landscape regarding suicide in India changed significantly with the **Mental Healthcare Act (MHCA), 2017**. According to **Section 115** of the MHCA, any person who attempts suicide is presumed to be under severe stress and shall not be tried or punished under Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC). Since the act is no longer treated as a criminal offense in practice, a doctor (especially in a private setup) is **not legally mandated to inform the police**. The primary responsibility of the doctor is to provide medical treatment and psychiatric care, rather than legal reporting. Furthermore, patient confidentiality must be maintained unless a crime is involved; since the attempt is presumed to be due to mental illness, it is treated as a medical emergency, not a medico-legal case (MLC). **2. Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **A & C (Inform the police/magistrate):** Previously, under Section 309 IPC, suicide was a criminal offense, making it mandatory to report. However, with the MHCA 2017 overriding the IPC, the "criminal" element is removed. Reporting is only mandatory in cases of "homicide" or "suspicious injury," not self-inflicted harm under stress. * **D (Refer to a psychiatrist):** While this is a **clinical** necessity and the "best next step" for the patient's welfare, it is not a **legal responsibility** or a mandatory reporting requirement in the context of the question's focus on legal obligations. **3. High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Section 115 of MHCA 2017:** Effectively decriminalizes suicide by creating a presumption of severe stress. * **Section 309 IPC:** Still exists in the statute book but is rendered redundant by the MHCA. * **Section 306 IPC:** Deals with **Abetment of Suicide**, which remains a serious, cognizable, and non-bailable criminal offense. * **Confidentiality:** In private practice, reporting a non-criminal medical condition violates the Indian Medical Council (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations, 2002.

Question 183: Which of the following constitutes professional misconduct?

A. Selling drugs
B. Dichotomy
C. Issuing a false certificate
D. All of the above (Correct Answer)

Explanation: **Explanation:** Professional misconduct, also known as **Infamous Conduct**, refers to any act by a medical practitioner that falls below the ethical standards expected by the profession. The National Medical Commission (NMC), formerly the Medical Council of India (MCI), defines these under the **Code of Medical Ethics**. * **Selling Drugs (Option A):** While a doctor can dispense medicines to their own patients, running an open chemist shop or engaging in the commercial sale of drugs is prohibited. Furthermore, involvement in the illegal trade of scheduled drugs is a serious ethical and legal violation. * **Dichotomy (Option B):** Also known as **Fee-splitting**, this is the practice of a physician sharing a portion of their fee with another practitioner for referring a patient. This is strictly unethical as it compromises patient care for financial gain. * **Issuing a False Certificate (Option C):** A doctor is legally bound to ensure that any certificate (medical, birth, death, or fitness) issued by them is truthful. Signing a false or misleading certificate is a major ground for disciplinary action. Since all three activities violate the ethical code, **Option D** is the correct answer. **High-Yield Facts for NEET-PG:** * **Punishment:** The State Medical Council can take disciplinary action, ranging from a warning to the **removal of the doctor’s name from the Medical Register** (either temporarily or permanently). This is known as the **"Professional Death Sentence."** * **The 6 'A's of Misconduct:** Adultery (with a patient), Abortion (illegal), Assault, Addiction, Advertising, and Association (with unqualified persons). * **Dichotomy** is specifically mentioned as a violation in the NMC (Professional Conduct, Etiquette and Ethics) Regulations.

Question 184: Which of the following statements is not true regarding a summons?

A. It is a legal document.
B. No conduct money is paid to the doctor in criminal cases. (Correct Answer)
C. Sections 61-69 of the CrPC deal with summons.
D. None of the above.

Explanation: **Explanation:** A **Summons** is a legal document issued by a court compelling the attendance of a witness to give evidence or produce documents. Under the Code of Criminal Procedure (CrPC), specific rules govern its issuance and the compensation provided to witnesses. **Why Option B is the correct answer (The "Not True" statement):** In **criminal cases**, the government is responsible for the prosecution. Therefore, the court or the government pays the witness (doctor) **conduct money** (traveling and subsistence allowance) at the time the summons is served or after the testimony. The statement that "no conduct money is paid" is factually incorrect. In contrast, in **civil cases**, conduct money is paid by the party that has summoned the witness. **Analysis of other options:** * **Option A:** A summons is indeed a **legal document** issued in writing, in duplicate, signed by the presiding officer of the court, and bearing the seal of the court. * **Option C:** **Sections 61 to 69 of the CrPC** specifically outline the processes regarding the form of summons and how they must be served (e.g., personal service, service on corporate bodies, or service when the person cannot be found). **High-Yield Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Priority of Summons:** If a doctor receives summons from two different courts for the same day, the priority is: **Criminal Court > Civil Court** and **Higher Court > Lower Court**. * **Section 174 IPC:** Failure to obey a summons without a valid reason is a punishable offense under Section 174 of the Indian Penal Code. * **Conduct Money:** Also known as "Diet Money," it must be paid to the witness to cover reasonable travel expenses. In criminal cases, it is paid by the State; in civil cases, by the private party.

Question 185: Normal courtesy of one doctor towards another is according to:

A. Medical etiquette (Correct Answer)
B. Medical ethics
C. Both
D. None

Explanation: ### Explanation **Correct Answer: A. Medical etiquette** **Why it is correct:** **Medical etiquette** refers to the conventional code of behavior and "professional courtesy" that medical practitioners observe toward one another. It deals with the **social and professional manners** among doctors, such as how to behave when a colleague is a patient, how to handle referrals, and maintaining mutual respect. It is essentially the "rules of conduct" that ensure smooth professional relationships within the fraternity. **Why the other options are incorrect:** * **B. Medical ethics:** While often confused with etiquette, medical ethics refers to the **moral principles** and values that govern the relationship between a doctor and their patients, the state, and society. It focuses on duties, obligations, and moral judgments (e.g., autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice). * **C & D:** These are incorrect because there is a distinct functional difference between the "manners" (etiquette) and the "morals" (ethics) of the profession. --- ### High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG: * **Medical Etiquette vs. Ethics:** Remember, **Etiquette** = Doctor-to-Doctor relationship (Courtesy); **Ethics** = Doctor-to-Patient/Society relationship (Morality). * **Dichotomy (Fee-splitting):** This is a violation of both medical ethics and etiquette. It involves a doctor sharing a portion of their fee with another doctor for referring a patient. * **Professional Death Sentence:** This term refers to the **Erasure of a doctor's name** from the Medical Register by the State Medical Council (SMC) or National Medical Commission (NMC) due to "Professional Misconduct" (Infamous Conduct). * **Privileged Communication:** A doctor’s duty to disclose confidential information to a third party/authority to protect the interest of the community (e.g., reporting a communicable disease or a crime). This is an ethical exception to patient confidentiality.

Question 186: Jurisdiction of land assessment comes under which authority?

A. Supreme Court
B. Sessions Court
C. District Court
D. None of the above (Correct Answer)

Explanation: ### Explanation **Correct Answer: D. None of the above** In the context of Forensic Medicine and Medical Jurisprudence, it is essential to distinguish between **Judicial Courts** and **Revenue Courts**. **Why "None of the above" is correct:** Jurisdiction over land assessment, land revenue, and land records does not fall under the hierarchy of Criminal or Civil Courts (Supreme, Sessions, or District Courts). Instead, these matters are handled by **Revenue Courts**. The highest authority for land assessment in a state is the **Board of Revenue**, and at the district level, these powers are vested in the **Collector (District Magistrate)** and their subordinates (Tehsildar/Lekhpal). **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **A. Supreme Court:** This is the apex judicial body of India. It deals with constitutional matters, inter-state disputes, and final appeals. It does not handle primary land assessment. * **B. Sessions Court:** This is a criminal court. It has the power to try serious offenses and award sentences, including the death penalty (subject to High Court confirmation). It has no jurisdiction over land revenue. * **C. District Court:** While the District Court is the principal civil court in a district, "land assessment" is a specialized administrative/revenue function excluded from general civil jurisdiction and reserved for Revenue Officers. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Hierarchy of Criminal Courts:** Supreme Court → High Court → Sessions Court → Magistrate Courts. * **Inquest Powers:** While the Police conduct most inquests (Sec 174 CrPC), the **Magistrate** (Executive or Judicial) conducts inquests in cases of dowry deaths (within 7 years of marriage), deaths in custody, or deaths during police firing (Sec 176 CrPC). * **Sentencing Power:** A **First Class Judicial Magistrate** can award imprisonment up to 3 years and a fine up to ₹10,000. A **Second Class Magistrate** can award up to 1 year and a fine up to ₹5,000.

Question 187: A registered medical practitioner protecting an unqualified person in practice is known as what?

A. Uncoverage
B. Covering (Correct Answer)
C. Touting
D. Dichotomy

Explanation: **Explanation:** **Correct Answer: B. Covering** **Covering** is a form of professional misconduct where a registered medical practitioner (RMP) uses their legal qualifications and professional status to enable an unqualified person (quack) to practice medicine or perform surgery. By "covering" the unqualified person, the RMP allows them to issue certificates, treat patients, or prescribe medications under the RMP's name or supervision. This is strictly prohibited under the **National Medical Commission (NMC)** guidelines and can lead to the removal of the doctor's name from the Medical Register (Professional Death Sentence). **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **A. Uncoverage:** This is a distractor term and does not have a specific definition in forensic medicine or medical ethics. * **C. Touting:** This refers to the practice of employing agents or "touts" to procure patients for a medical practitioner in exchange for a commission. It is considered unethical professional misconduct. * **D. Dichotomy:** Also known as **Fee-splitting**, this is the practice where a doctor shares a portion of their fee with another doctor (usually a general practitioner) for referring a patient. It is a form of unethical financial kickback. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Professional Death Sentence:** This refers to the permanent erasure of a doctor's name from the State/National Medical Register due to "Infamous Conduct." * **Infamous Conduct:** Examples include covering, adultery with a patient, performing illegal abortions, and conviction by a court for an offense involving moral turpitude. * **Adultery:** Professional misconduct involving a sexual relationship with a patient is often referred to as the "Professional Untouchable" rule.

Question 188: All of the following sections are related to "Dowry death" except?

A. 113(A) Indian Evidence Act
B. 113(B) Indian Evidence Act
C. 304(A) IPC (Correct Answer)
D. 174(3) Criminal Procedure Code

Explanation: **Explanation:** The question asks to identify the section **not** related to "Dowry Death." The correct answer is **304(A) IPC**, as it pertains to **causing death by negligence** (e.g., medical negligence or road traffic accidents), which is a bailable offense and does not involve the specific legal framework of dowry-related fatalities. **Analysis of Options:** * **304(B) IPC (The missing link):** While not an option, it is essential to know that 304(B) defines "Dowry Death." Option **304(A)** is the distractor here. * **113(B) Indian Evidence Act:** This section creates a **presumption of dowry death**. If a woman dies within 7 years of marriage and it is shown that she was subjected to cruelty for dowry soon before death, the court *shall* presume the husband/relatives caused the death. * **113(A) Indian Evidence Act:** This relates to the **presumption of abetment of suicide** by a married woman. Since many dowry deaths are staged as or result from suicides, this section is legally intertwined with dowry investigations. * **174(3) CrPC:** This mandates a **Magisterial Inquiry** (instead of a Police Inquiry) for any woman who dies within **7 years of marriage** under suspicious circumstances, specifically to investigate potential dowry foul play. **NEET-PG High-Yield Pearls:** 1. **The "Rule of 7":** For Dowry Death (304B IPC), Presumption of Dowry Death (113B IEA), and Magisterial Inquiry (174 CrPC), the death must occur within **7 years of marriage**. 2. **Inquest:** A Magistrate conducts the inquest in cases of dowry death, whereas a Police Officer (Sub-inspector) conducts a standard inquest (174 CrPC). 3. **304(A) IPC:** Always remember this is for **Negligence** (unintentional), whereas Dowry Death involves harassment and cruelty.

Question 189: The statement 'Nothing is an offence which is done by a child under seven years of age' is included under which of the following sections of the Indian Penal Code?

A. Section 82 IPC (Correct Answer)
B. Section 83 IPC
C. Section 84 IPC
D. Section 85 IPC

Explanation: ### Explanation **Section 82 IPC** embodies the legal principle of **"Doli incapax"** (incapable of doing wrong). It states that nothing is an offense if committed by a child under **seven years of age**. This is an absolute immunity based on the presumption that a child of such tender age lacks the "mens rea" (guilty mind) and the cognitive maturity to understand the nature and consequences of their actions. #### Analysis of Options: * **Section 83 IPC:** Refers to a child between **7 and 12 years** of age. Here, criminal responsibility depends on "attained maturity of understanding." This is known as **partial immunity** or "qualified doli incapax." * **Section 84 IPC:** Deals with the **"McNaughten’s Rule"** regarding insanity. It states that an act is not an offense if the person, at the time of doing it, was by reason of unsoundness of mind incapable of knowing the nature of the act. * **Section 85 IPC:** Relates to acts committed by a person who is incapable of judgment due to **involuntary intoxication** (intoxication administered without their knowledge or against their will). #### High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG: * **Doli incapax:** Absolute immunity (< 7 years, Sec 82). * **Doli capax:** Capable of crime (usually > 12 years; or 7–12 if maturity is proven). * **Juvenile Justice Act:** In India, a "juvenile" is defined as a person who has not completed **18 years** of age. * **Age of Consent:** For sexual intercourse, the age of consent under POCSO/IPC is **18 years**. * **McNaughten Rule (Sec 84):** Focuses on **legal insanity** rather than medical insanity.

Question 190: The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act was passed in which year?

A. 1981
B. 1983
C. 1985 (Correct Answer)
D. 1986

Explanation: **Explanation:** The **Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances (NDPS) Act** was enacted by the Parliament of India in **1985**. This landmark legislation was designed to consolidate and amend the laws relating to narcotic drugs, to make stringent provisions for the control and regulation of operations relating to narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances, and to implement the provisions of International Conventions on Narcotic Drugs. **Analysis of Options:** * **1985 (Correct):** The Act was passed in 1985 and came into force on November 14, 1985. It prohibits the manufacture, possession, sale, purchase, transport, and consumption of narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances except for medical or scientific purposes. * **1981 (Incorrect):** This year is associated with the **Air (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act**. * **1983 (Incorrect):** While significant for the National Health Policy (1983), it is not the year for the NDPS Act. * **1986 (Incorrect):** This year marks the enactment of the **Consumer Protection Act (COPRA)** and the **Environment Protection Act**, both of which are high-yield for forensic medicine but distinct from drug legislation. **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Punishment:** The NDPS Act is known for its stringent penalties. Section 27 distinguishes between "small quantity" and "commercial quantity" for sentencing. * **Prescription Requirements:** Doctors must maintain meticulous records of psychotropic substances prescribed. * **Related Acts:** * **Drugs and Cosmetics Act:** 1940 (Regulates import/manufacture/distribution). * **Pharmacy Act:** 1948. * **Mental Healthcare Act:** 2017 (Replaced the 1987 Act). * **Cannabis:** Under the NDPS Act, the use of *Charas* and *Ganja* is prohibited, but the use of *Bhang* (leaves) is often regulated by state-specific excise laws.

Practice by Chapter

Medical Jurisprudence Fundamentals

Practice Questions

Medical Ethics Principles

Practice Questions

Consent in Medical Practice

Practice Questions

Confidentiality and Privacy

Practice Questions

Medical Negligence

Practice Questions

Professional Misconduct

Practice Questions

Rights and Duties of Medical Practitioners

Practice Questions

Consumer Protection Laws

Practice Questions

Medical Documentation

Practice Questions

Expert Witness Testimony

Practice Questions

Ethical Dilemmas in Medicine

Practice Questions

International Medical Ethics Codes

Practice Questions

Want unlimited practice?

Get full access to all questions, explanations, and performance tracking.

Start For Free