Legal and Ethical Aspects of Medicine Practice Questions

Q: A doctor examining a patient without consent in an emergency is protected under which section of the Indian Penal Code (IPC)?

Section 92 IPC. ### Explanation **Section 92 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC)** provides immunity for acts done in good faith for the benefit of a person even without their consent. In medical practice, this is known as the **"Doctrine of Necessity."** It applies to emergency situations where the patient is unconscious or unable to give consent, and no guardian is available to provide it. The law recognizes that saving a life takes precedence over the formal requirement of consent in such critical moments. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **Section 87 IPC:** Pertains to acts done by consent (express or implied) which are not intended to cause death or grievous hurt (e.g., injuries sustained during competitive sports like boxing). * **Section 89 IPC:** Deals with acts done in good faith for the benefit of a **child (under 12 years)** or a person of **unsound mind**, by or with the consent of the guardian. * **Section 90 IPC:** Defines what does **not** constitute valid consent (e.g., consent given under fear of injury, misconception of facts, or by a person of unsound mind/intoxication). **Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG:** * **Emergency Consent:** In a life-threatening emergency, if the patient is unconscious, the doctor has a legal duty to treat. This is an exception to the rule of informed consent. * **Section 88 IPC:** Protects doctors for acts done in good faith with the patient's consent (e.g., a planned surgery). * **Age of Consent:** For physical examination, the age of consent is **12 years** (Section 89/90 IPC). However, for a valid legal contract or major surgical procedure, it is generally **18 years** (Indian Contract Act). * **Informed Refusal:** Even in emergencies, if a competent adult refuses treatment, the doctor cannot force it under Section 92.

Q: According to the Transplantation of Human Organs Act, all of the following specialists are authorized for pronouncing brain death except:

Doctor performing the liver transplant. According to the **Transplantation of Human Organs Act (THOA)**, brain death must be certified by a **Board of Medical Experts** consisting of four members. The primary objective of this composition is to prevent any **conflict of interest**. **Why Option B is correct:** The **Doctor performing the transplant** (the surgeon) is strictly prohibited from being part of the brain death certification board. This is to ensure that the decision to declare death is purely clinical and not influenced by the urgency or need to harvest organs for another patient. **Why the other options are incorrect:** As per the THOA guidelines, the Board must include: * **Option C (Doctor attending the patient):** The physician who was treating the patient before brain death occurred. * **Option D (RMP in charge of the hospital):** The Medical Superintendent or the person in charge of the hospital where the patient is admitted. * **Option A (Neurosurgeon/Neurologist):** An independent specialist (Neurologist, Neurosurgeon, or Intensivist) nominated from a panel approved by the Appropriate Authority. **High-Yield Facts for NEET-PG:** * **The Rule of Two:** Brain death must be certified **twice**, with a minimum interval of **6 hours** between the two examinations. * **Apnea Test:** This is the mandatory clinical test used to confirm brainstem death. * **Form 10:** This is the specific statutory form used for the certification of brainstem death under the THOA. * **Age limit:** If the donor is a minor, consent must be obtained from both parents.

Q: What is the legal age of consent?

18 years. **Explanation:** In the context of Indian law and medical ethics, the **legal age of consent** for medical and surgical procedures is **18 years**. This is governed by the **Indian Contract Act**, which stipulates that a person must be a major (18+ years) to enter into a valid legal contract. Consequently, for any major surgical intervention or clinical procedure, a person below 18 years is considered a minor, and consent must be obtained from a parent or legal guardian (Proxy Consent). **Analysis of Options:** * **18 years (Correct):** This is the age of majority. Under Section 11 of the Indian Contract Act, only those 18 and above can give valid legal consent for all medical procedures. * **12 years (Incorrect):** Under **Section 89 and 90 of the IPC**, a child above 12 years can give consent for a physical examination or non-invasive medical treatment. However, this is not the "legal age of consent" for definitive surgical procedures or legal contracts. * **10 & 14 years (Incorrect):** These ages do not hold specific legal standing regarding the general capacity to consent for medical treatment in India. **High-Yield NEET-PG Pearls:** 1. **Section 92 IPC:** Allows a doctor to treat a patient without consent in an **emergency** (e.g., unconscious patient or minor with no guardian available) if the delay would be fatal. 2. **POCSO Act:** For sexual offenses, the age of consent is strictly **18 years**, regardless of the "consent" given by the minor. 3. **Doctrine of Locum Parentis:** In the absence of parents, a person in temporary charge of a minor (like a school principal) can give consent. 4. **Emancipated Minor:** This concept (minor living independently) is recognized in some Western countries but is **not** legally recognized in India.

Q: In case of death in lock-up, who holds the inquest?

A magistrate. **Explanation:** In India, an inquest is a legal inquiry held to determine the cause of death in suspicious or unnatural circumstances. Under **Section 176 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC)** (now Section 196 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita - BNSS), a **Magisterial Inquest** is mandatory in specific cases where there is a high risk of foul play or custodial violence. **Why the Correct Answer is Right:** A **Magistrate** (Executive or Judicial) must conduct the inquest in cases of **custodial death**, such as death in police lock-up, prison, or psychiatric hospitals. This ensures an impartial investigation, as the police themselves are often the accused party in such scenarios. **Analysis of Incorrect Options:** * **A. Police Officer:** Under Section 174 CrPC, a police officer (usually the Sub-Inspector) conducts a **Police Inquest** for most unnatural deaths (suicide, accidents, etc.). However, they are legally barred from leading the inquest in custodial deaths to avoid bias. * **C. Panchayat Officer:** While "Panchayat Nama" is a term often used for the inquest report signed by witnesses (Panchas), the officer does not hold the legal authority to conduct the inquiry. * **D. District Attorney:** The District Attorney is a legal prosecutor and does not have the statutory power to conduct an inquest. **High-Yield NEET-PG Pearls:** * **Mandatory Magisterial Inquest (Section 176 CrPC):** 1. Death in police custody/lock-up. 2. Death during police firing. 3. Death in a psychiatric hospital. 4. **Dowry Death** (within 7 years of marriage). 5. Exhumation (digging up a body for examination). * In cases of custodial death, the post-mortem must be **video-recorded** and ideally performed by a board of two doctors.

Q: Which of the following acts was NOT passed before 1980?

Mental Health Act. The question tests your knowledge of the chronology of important medico-legal legislations in India, a high-yield area for NEET-PG. ### **Explanation of the Correct Answer** The **Mental Health Act** was passed in **1987** (and came into force in 1993). It replaced the outdated Indian Lunacy Act of 1912 to provide better treatment and care for persons with mental illness. Notably, this act has since been repealed and replaced by the **Mental Healthcare Act, 2017**, which focuses on a rights-based approach and decriminalizes suicide attempts (Section 115). ### **Analysis of Incorrect Options** * **Workmen's Compensation Act (1923):** One of the oldest social security legislations in India, it ensures compensation for workers in case of injury or death during employment. * **Factories Act (1948):** Enacted shortly after independence, it regulates working conditions, health, safety, and welfare of workers in factories. * **Employees' State Insurance (ESI) Act (1948):** This provides medical benefits and cash insurance to employees in case of sickness, maternity, or employment injury. ### **High-Yield Clinical Pearls for NEET-PG** * **Consumer Protection Act (CPA):** Originally passed in **1986**; doctors were brought under its ambit in 1995 (VP Shantha vs. IMA case). * **MTP Act:** Passed in **1971** (amended in 2021). * **PNDT Act:** Passed in **1994** (to prevent female feticide). * **Human Organ Transplantation Act (HOTA):** Passed in **1994**. * **Registration of Births and Deaths Act:** Passed in **1969** (Births must be registered within 21 days).

Question 1

A doctor examining a patient without consent in an emergency is protected under which section of the Indian Penal Code (IPC)?

Accepted Answer

Section 92 IPC

Answer

Section 87 IPC

Answer

Section 89 IPC

Answer

Section 90 IPC

Question 2

Contributory negligence is related with:

Accepted Answer

Avoidable consequence rule

Answer

Eggshell skull rule

Answer

Master-servant rule

Answer

Common knowledge rule

Question 3

According to the Transplantation of Human Organs Act, all of the following specialists are authorized for pronouncing brain death except:

Accepted Answer

Doctor performing the liver transplant

Answer

Neurosurgeon

Answer

Doctor attending the patient

Answer

Registered Medical Practitioner in charge of the hospital

Question 4

What is the legal age of consent?

Accepted Answer

18 years

Answer

10 years

Answer

12 years

Answer

14 years

Question 5

In case of death in lock-up, who holds the inquest?

Accepted Answer

A magistrate

Answer

A police officer

Answer

A panchayat officer

Answer

A District Attorney

Question 6

The Declaration of Geneva is related to which of the following?

Accepted Answer

Hippocratic Oath

Answer

Medical etiquette

Answer

Disciplinary control

Answer

Professional misconduct

Question 7

Infamous conduct comprises of all, except:

Accepted Answer

Examining a patient without consent

Answer

Adultery

Answer

Advertising

Answer

Procuring criminal abortion

Question 8

Which of the following acts was NOT passed before 1980?

Accepted Answer

Mental Health Act

Answer

Factories Act

Answer

Employees' State Insurance Act

Answer

Workmen's Compensation Act

Question 9

Harvard criteria are used for the diagnosis of which condition?

Accepted Answer

Brain death

Answer

Brain stem death

Answer

Small obturator foramen

Answer

None of the above

Question 10

Which of the following actions exceeds the requirements of the federal Patient Self Determination Act for hospitals regarding all admitted patients?

Accepted Answer

Require assignment of donor organs.

Answer

Provide all adults with information about their right to accept or refuse treatment if life-threatening conditions arise.

Answer

State the institution's policy on advance directives.

Answer

Not discriminate in care given on the basis of patients' wishes.

Legal and Ethical Aspects of Medicine — MCQs

Legal and Ethical Aspects of Medicine — MCQs

On this page

Practice by Chapter

Want unlimited practice?