Apportionment and limits on recovery

Apportionment and limits on recovery

Published September 28, 2026

Apportionment and limits on recovery

On this page

One-page cheat sheet for Apportionment and limits on recovery: the key takeaways, must-know facts and quick-reference tables for last-minute revision.

Key Takeaways

  • Classify divisible versus indivisible harm before deciding whether collection is several or joint and several.
  • The thin skull rule covers severe harm caused by the claimant’s condition; mitigation addresses unreasonable post-injury choices.
  • Read fee and cap provisions separately: prevailing does not automatically recover fees, and a cap controls only its stated category and exceptions.

Must-Know One-Liners

  • What is the eggshell-plaintiff rule for damages? - A defendant takes the plaintiff as found and is liable for the full extent of the foreseeable injury caused by the tort, even if the plaintiff’s preexisting condition makes the injury unusually severe. The defendant is not liable for harm that would have occurred without the defendant’s conduct.
  • What is the primary distinction between divisible and indivisible harm in the context of multiple tortfeasors? - Divisible harm can be logically separated and assigned to specific actors based on their causal contribution. Indivisible harm, however, cannot be reasonably apportioned among multiple tortfeasors, even if multiple actors contributed to it.
  • What is the recommended order of analysis for classifying damages? - Start with the function (compensate, recognize, punish). Then, ask: 1. What actual harm is proved (general/special compensatory)? 2. Is there no actual loss despite a rights invasion (nominal)? 3. Is there an independent punitive screen (punitive)?
  • When are nominal damages available in tort? - Nominal damages may be awarded when the defendant commits an actionable intentional tort but the plaintiff cannot prove actual damages. They ordinarily are not available for negligence without legally recognized harm.
  • What proof is required for an award of future damages? - Future damages must be proven with reasonable certainty rather than based on speculation. Future monetary damages generally are discounted to present value.
  • Under the traditional and Restatement majority approach, how is indivisible harm caused by multiple tortfeasors apportioned? - Each joint tortfeasor may be held jointly and severally liable for the entire indivisible injury, allowing the plaintiff to recover the judgment from any responsible tortfeasor. A tortfeasor who pays more than that tortfeasor’s equitable share generally may seek contribution from the others, subject to jurisdictional modifications.
  • How does comparative negligence affect a plaintiff’s damages? - The plaintiff’s recovery is reduced in proportion to the plaintiff’s percentage of fault under a comparative-fault system. In modified comparative negligence jurisdictions, recovery is barred when the plaintiff’s fault reaches the jurisdiction’s threshold, commonly 50% or 51%.
  • What is the collateral-source rule? - Under the majority rule, benefits the plaintiff receives from insurance or another independent source do not reduce the defendant’s damages liability. Many jurisdictions modify this rule by statute.

Quick-Reference Tables

QuestionDivisible harmIndivisible harm with joint and several liabilityIndivisible harm with several-only liability
What must be shown?The injury or loss can be causally assignedEach defendant caused the single injury under the governing ruleEach defendant caused the injury and receives an assigned share
What may claimant collect?Each defendant’s causal portionThe whole permitted judgment from any jointly liable defendantOnly each defendant’s assigned percentage or portion
What happens after payment?Usually no reallocation beyond the assigned portionsA paying defendant may seek contributionEach defendant ordinarily remains responsible only for that defendant’s share
Read the full Apportionment and limits on recovery notesDetailed explanations, diagrams and clinical correlations

Practice Questions: Apportionment and limits on recovery

  1. 1.

    • 2. Using only the supplied file and legal resources, prepare a negotiation memorandum assessing the homeowners' private-nuisance claim and proposing a practical settlement package. Address liability, defenses, available relief, evidentiary weaknesses, and terms that could resolve the dispute without closing the venue.

      • 3. A delivery driver negligently ran a red light and struck a bicyclist, fracturing the bicyclist's leg. Emergency personnel transported the bicyclist to a hospital, where a physician performed surgery on the fracture. During surgery, the physician negligently damaged a nearby nerve, causing permanent weakness in the bicyclist's foot. The bicyclist had acted reasonably in selecting the hospital and following the physician's advice. An expert concludes that the nerve damage would not have occurred without the physician's negligence. The bicyclist brings a negligence action against the delivery driver seeking damages for both the fracture and the nerve damage. Which of the following is the strongest conclusion regarding the driver's liability for the nerve damage?

        • A. The driver is not liable because the physician's negligence is a superseding cause of the additional injury.
        • B. The driver is liable only for the fracture because malpractice liability rests exclusively with the treating physician.
        • C. The driver may be liable for both injuries because negligent medical treatment is a foreseeable consequence of the original injury.
        • D. The driver is liable for both injuries only if the driver personally selected the physician who performed the surgery.
        Show answer

        Answer: C. The driver may be liable for both injuries because negligent medical treatment is a foreseeable consequence of the original injury.

        The driver may be liable for both injuries because negligent medical treatment is a foreseeable consequence of the original injury. - The driver's red-light violation caused the fracture that required surgery, and negligent treatment of that injury ordinarily does not break the chain of proximate causation. - The expert attributes the nerve damage to the physician's negligence, but the bicyclist's reasonable choice of hospital and compliance with medical advice support recovery from the driver for the enhanced injury. The driver is not liable because the physician's negligence is a superseding cause of the additional injury. - A treating physician's ordinary negligence is generally a foreseeable intervening event, not a superseding cause that automatically relieves the driver of liability. - The nerve damage occurred during surgery for the fracture the driver caused, and the bicyclist acted reasonably in obtaining treatment. The driver is liable only for the fracture because malpractice liability rests exclusively with the treating physician. - The physician may be liable for the negligently caused nerve damage, but that liability is not exclusive of the driver's potential liability for the enhanced injury. - The driver caused the need for surgery, making foreseeable negligent treatment part of the potential damages from the collision. The driver is liable for both injuries only if the driver personally selected the physician who performed the surgery. - The driver's potential liability turns on foreseeable consequences of the fracture, not on who selected the treating physician. - The bicyclist reasonably selected the hospital and followed the physician's advice, so that choice does not sever the causal chain.

      • 4. An accountant advises several nonprofit organizations. A local blogger posted publicly that the accountant "stole restricted donations from three charities." The blogger identified the accountant by name and claimed to have reviewed financial records. The accountant denies taking any funds. Two clients suspended new assignments but have not yet terminated their contracts. The accountant asks a lawyer to demand a retraction and assess a possible defamation claim. The accountant is not a public official or public figure, and the accusation concerns professional conduct and criminality. Before advising whether the available evidence supports liability and possible presumed damages, which fact would be most important for the lawyer to investigate?

        • A. Investigate whether the blogger disliked the accountant, because personal hostility is required for liability.
        • B. Investigate whether clients repeated the post, because third-party repetition is required to establish initial publication.
        • C. Investigate whether the accountant lost income, because economic loss is required for every actionable defamatory statement.
        • D. Investigate the records the blogger reviewed, because they bear directly on falsity and the blogger's level of fault.
        Show answer

        Answer: D. Investigate the records the blogger reviewed, because they bear directly on falsity and the blogger's level of fault.

        Investigate the records the blogger reviewed, because they bear directly on falsity and the blogger's level of fault. - The records help determine whether the named accountant stole restricted donations and whether the blogger had a reasonable basis for saying so. - They also bear on the blogger’s fault; if the post addresses a matter of public concern, presumed damages require proof that the blogger knew the accusation was false or recklessly disregarded its truth. Investigate whether the blogger disliked the accountant, because personal hostility is required for liability. - Personal hostility is not an element of defamation, so the accountant need not prove that the blogger disliked them. - Hostility might supply context, but it does not establish whether the accusation was false or what the blogger believed about the records. Investigate whether clients repeated the post, because third-party repetition is required to establish initial publication. - The blogger’s public post already communicated the accusation to third parties, satisfying the publication requirement. - Whether clients repeated it may matter to the accusation’s spread, but repetition is not needed to establish the blogger’s initial publication. Investigate whether the accountant lost income, because economic loss is required for every actionable defamatory statement. - An accusation of theft and serious professional misconduct can be actionable without proof of special economic loss. - The suspended assignments may matter to damages, but the absence of a terminated contract does not make lost income a prerequisite to liability.

      • 5. Using only the supplied file and legal resources, prepare an objective memorandum assessing former Mayor Elena Park's threatened defamation claim arising from City Ledger Media's article. Address the provable meaning and falsity of the challenged statements, public-official status and fault, publication and reputational harm, the principal arguments for both sides, and whether a correction or negotiated resolution should be recommended.

        • 6. Using only the supplied file and legal resources, prepare a confidential settlement-evaluation email recommending a negotiation range and terms for resolving Dana Cole's products-liability claim against BrightHeat.

          • 7.

            • 8.

              Everything you need for Bar Exam prep

              Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

              GET STARTED FOR FREE
              75% OFFLimited time offer
              GET 75% OFF