Nova Diagnostics Corp. is a calendar-year public business entity applying U.S. GAAP. You are preparing Nova's March 31, 20X5 revenue workpaper for a new customer contract and evaluating a modification signed on March 31. Use the exhibits to identify the performance obligations, allocate the initial transaction price, determine revenue and the contract balance, and account for the modification.
Show answer and rationale
Rationale
The original contract has two performance obligations; the installation is a fulfillment activity.
- The Revenue Accounting Memorandum concludes that installation and setup transfer no service, so the $24,000 installation fee is part of the transaction price, not a separate performance obligation.
- Calibration certification is distinct and was recognized when completed on January 15; distinct maintenance is recognized over time as Harbor receives its benefits evenly.
The modification is accounted for prospectively using the consideration for services still to be provided.
- The initial $156,000 transaction price is allocated by relative standalone selling prices: $156,000 × $15,000 ÷ $135,000 = $17,333.33 to calibration, and the remaining $138,666.67 to maintenance.
- Through March 31, revenue is $17,333.33 plus three months of maintenance ($138,666.67 × 3 ÷ 24), or $34,666.67; the $51,000 billed and collected therefore leaves a $16,333.33 contract liability.
Traps in this case
Treating the installation fee as a separate performance obligation
- A separately stated $24,000 fee does not make installation distinct when, as the Revenue Accounting Memorandum concludes, the activity does not transfer a service to Harbor.
Treating the modification as a separate contract
- Although the added maintenance is distinct, its $48,000 price is below its $60,000 standalone selling price, so the modification is treated prospectively as termination of the existing contract and creation of a new contract.
Using only the modification price for future revenue
- The 33 remaining months comprise 21 original months and 12 added months; their consideration is unrounded original maintenance consideration of $138,666.67 less three months’ unrounded revenue, plus $48,000, yielding $169,333.33.

