In 2025, an individual sold depreciable equipment to a corporation owned 60% by the individual. The equipment had a $95,000 adjusted basis, and the corporation paid $170,000. The individual incurred $5,000 of selling expenses. Which amount and character should the individual report?
Answer: C. $70,000 of ordinary income
***$70,000 of ordinary income***
- The $170,000 sale price less $5,000 of selling expenses and the $95,000 adjusted basis produces a **$70,000 gain**.
- Because the individual owns **60%** of the corporation, Section 1239 treats the gain on the sale of depreciable equipment as ordinary income.
*$70,000 of Section 1231 gain*
- This choice correctly subtracts the selling expenses: $170,000 − $5,000 − $95,000 = **$70,000**.
- **Section 1231** character is incorrect because Section 1239 makes the gain ordinary on this sale to a more-than-50%-owned corporation.
*$75,000 of Section 1231 gain*
- **$75,000** results from omitting the $5,000 selling expenses: $170,000 − $95,000 = $75,000.
- Even apart from that amount error, Section 1239 requires **ordinary income**, not Section 1231 gain.
*$75,000 of ordinary income*
- **$75,000** is the gain before selling expenses; subtracting the $5,000 expense reduces it to $70,000.
- The **ordinary-income** character is correct under Section 1239 because the individual owns 60% of the purchasing corporation.
Explanation locked
Q2Medium
In 2025, a sole proprietor sold an office building for $700,000 and paid $20,000 of selling expenses. The building's adjusted basis was $430,000, including the effect of $170,000 of straight-line depreciation. Assuming no additional depreciation and before applying Section 1231 netting or lookback, how should the $250,000 gain be characterized?
Answer: C. $170,000 of unrecaptured Section 1250 gain and $80,000 of other Section 1231 gain
***$170,000 of unrecaptured Section 1250 gain and $80,000 of other Section 1231 gain***
- The amount realized is $700,000 − $20,000 = $680,000, so the gain is $680,000 − $430,000 = **$250,000**.
- With no additional depreciation, the $170,000 attributable to straight-line depreciation is **unrecaptured Section 1250 gain**, leaving $80,000 of other Section 1231 gain before netting or lookback.
*$250,000 of ordinary income*
- The $250,000 gain does not become ordinary income merely because depreciation reduced the building’s adjusted basis.
- With **no additional depreciation**, the facts do not establish Section 1250 ordinary-income recapture.
*$170,000 of ordinary income and $80,000 of Section 1231 gain*
- This choice correctly separates the $170,000 depreciation-related portion from the remaining $80,000.
- It incorrectly treats **straight-line depreciation** as ordinary-income recapture rather than an unrecaptured Section 1250 component.
*$250,000 of Section 1231 gain with no unrecaptured Section 1250 component*
- The building’s sale produces a $250,000 gain before Section 1231 netting or lookback.
- This characterization overlooks the **$170,000** of straight-line depreciation reflected in adjusted basis, which identifies the unrecaptured Section 1250 component.
Explanation locked
Q3Medium
A calendar-year individual sells rental real estate held for six years. The land cost $100,000 and is sold for $150,000. The building cost $500,000, has $140,000 of straight-line depreciation, and is sold for $650,000. No selling expenses apply. How should the $340,000 total gain be characterized before Section 1231 netting?
Answer: C. $140,000 unrecaptured Section 1250 gain and $200,000 Section 1231 gain
***$140,000 unrecaptured Section 1250 gain and $200,000 Section 1231 gain***
- The building’s adjusted basis is $500,000 − $140,000 = $360,000, so its gain is $650,000 − $360,000 = **$290,000**.
- Of that gain, **$140,000** is attributable to straight-line depreciation; the remaining $150,000 building gain plus the $50,000 land gain equals **$200,000**.
*$140,000 ordinary income and $200,000 Section 1231 gain*
- The $140,000 of straight-line building depreciation is **unrecaptured Section 1250 gain**, not ordinary Section 1250 recapture.
- Treating that amount as ordinary income is the slip; the $150,000 remaining building gain and $50,000 land gain still total $200,000.
*$290,000 unrecaptured Section 1250 gain and $50,000 Section 1231 gain*
- **$290,000** is the building’s entire gain, but only $140,000 of it is attributable to depreciation.
- Treating all building gain as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain leaves only the $50,000 land gain in the other category.
*$140,000 unrecaptured Section 1250 gain and $150,000 Section 1231 gain*
- The $150,000 is the building gain remaining after its $140,000 depreciation-related portion.
- This answer **omits the land’s $50,000 gain**: $150,000 + $50,000 = $200,000.
Explanation locked
Q4Medium
In 2025, an individual sells a warehouse used in a trade or business for net proceeds of $540,000. The warehouse cost $600,000, and $160,000 of straight-line depreciation was allowed. The property was held for eight years. Before Section 1231 netting, how should the $100,000 gain be characterized?
Answer: C. A $100,000 Section 1231 gain that is potentially unrecaptured real-property depreciation gain
***A $100,000 Section 1231 gain that is potentially unrecaptured real-property depreciation gain***
- Adjusted basis is $600,000 − $160,000 = **$440,000**, so the $540,000 net proceeds produce a $100,000 gain on business property held eight years.
- Before Section 1231 netting, the gain is **Section 1231 gain**; because it is less than the $160,000 of straight-line depreciation, all $100,000 is potentially unrecaptured real-property depreciation gain.
*A $100,000 ordinary gain from depreciation recapture*
- Ordinary Section 1250 recapture generally requires depreciation **in excess of straight-line depreciation**, but only straight-line depreciation was allowed here.
- The $100,000 gain is therefore not ordinary recapture merely because the warehouse was depreciated.
*A $100,000 long-term capital gain subject only to the regular capital-gain rates*
- The warehouse was business property held eight years, so its gain must first enter **Section 1231 netting** rather than be characterized immediately as a long-term capital gain.
- If it receives long-term capital-gain treatment after netting, the depreciation-related amount may fall in the **unrecaptured Section 1250 gain** rate category, not only the regular capital-gain rates.
*A $60,000 Section 1231 gain and a $40,000 ordinary gain from depreciation recapture*
- The entire **$100,000** gain is Section 1231 gain before netting because the facts show no depreciation in excess of straight-line depreciation.
- The $40,000 difference between $160,000 of depreciation and the $100,000 gain is depreciation **not recovered through the sale**, not ordinary recapture.
Explanation locked
Q5
You are preparing the 2025 federal income tax disposition workpaper for Ridgeway, a calendar-year sole proprietor. Ridgeway transferred a warehouse through a qualified intermediary and acquired a replacement distribution center. Determine the qualification, gain, character-deferral mechanics, and replacement-property basis using the documents provided.
Show answer and rationale
Rationale
Ridgeway’s deferred exchange qualifies, and $90,000 of its $400,000 realized gain is recognized.
Both properties are U.S. business real property, and the Qualified Intermediary Agreement prevented Ridgeway from controlling the proceeds before the January 20, 2026 replacement closing.
The November 25 identification met the 45-day deadline, and the January 20 acquisition met the 180-day deadline, which fell before the extended October 15, 2026 return due date.
The remaining $310,000 gain is deferred, giving Distribution Center A a $380,000 tax basis.
Under the Relinquished Warehouse Closing Statement, adjusted basis is $500,000 + $100,000 − $220,000 = $380,000; realized gain is $800,000 − $20,000 − $380,000 = $400,000.
Boot is $40,000 cash plus $150,000 liability relief minus the $100,000 replacement mortgage, or $90,000; deferred gain is $400,000 − $90,000 = $310,000, and replacement basis is $690,000 − $310,000 = $380,000.
Traps in this case
Treating the buyer’s mortgage assumption as disqualifying
The $150,000 assumption affects boot, not qualification, and must be offset by Ridgeway’s $100,000 replacement mortgage.
Ignoring eligible disposition expenses
Omitting the $20,000 brokerage and legal expenses produces a $420,000 realized gain instead of the correct $400,000.
Treating deferred gain as permanently excluded
Section 1031 defers $310,000 and preserves the applicable section 1231 and section 1250 character rules for the $90,000 recognized gain.
Q6
A CPA is preparing the 2025 federal income tax disposition workpaper for Harbor, an individual calendar-year taxpayer. Harbor sold an entire rental warehouse property to an unrelated buyer on December 15, 2025. Harbor had used the property in the rental activity since 2017 and had depreciated the building using the straight-line method. Use the closing statement, tax-basis schedule, and prior-year Section 1231 workpaper to determine the amount and character of Harbor's 2025 gain.
Show answer and rationale
Rationale
The warehouse sale produces a $234,000 gain after allocating selling expenses between the building and land.
The $26,000 commission and legal and title fees are allocated by sales price: $18,000 to the building ($26,000 × $450,000 ÷ $650,000) and $8,000 to land.
Net amounts realized are $432,000 for the building and $192,000 for land; subtracting their respective adjusted bases of $240,000 and $150,000 yields gains of $192,000 and $42,000.
The Section 1231 lookback changes $40,000 of the gain to ordinary income.
Straight-line building depreciation produces $0 of ordinary income under Section 1250 depreciation recapture; the five-year Section 1231 lookback instead treats $40,000 of the $234,000 gain as ordinary income.
Of the remaining $194,000 long-term capital gain, $120,000 is unrecaptured Section 1250 gain and $74,000 is remaining long-term capital gain.
Traps in this case
Using cash paid to the seller as the amount realized
The $100,000 mortgage payoff reduces closing cash but does not reduce the $624,000 amount realized after selling expenses.
Adding the escrow refund to sale proceeds
The unrelated $3,000 property-tax escrow refund is not part of the warehouse’s amount realized.
Treating all building depreciation as ordinary recapture
The $120,000 straight-line depreciation is unrecaptured Section 1250 gain within the remaining long-term capital gain, not ordinary Section 1250 depreciation recapture.
Q7
You are preparing the 2025 federal income tax disposition workpaper for Avery Cole, a calendar-year individual who operates a sole proprietorship. Avery disposed of three business properties during 2025 and also recognized a casualty loss. Review the fixed-asset register, closing documents, ownership correspondence, and prior-year tax workpaper. Determine the amount realized, recognized tax consequences, character, and the effect of the Section 1231 lookback rule.
Show answer and rationale
Rationale
Selling expenses determine each amount realized; recapture and related-party rules determine which results enter Section 1231 netting.
The Packaging machine realizes $90,000 ($95,000 − $5,000), producing a $40,000 gain ($90,000 − $50,000) that is entirely Section 1245 ordinary income.
The Warehouse realizes $460,000 ($470,000 − $10,000) and has an $80,000 Section 1231 gain ($460,000 − $380,000); after the $20,000 casualty loss, the net Section 1231 gain is $60,000.
The lookback rule makes part of the net Section 1231 gain ordinary income.
The prior workpaper’s $25,000 of nonrecaptured Section 1231 losses recharacterizes that amount of the $60,000 net gain as ordinary income.
The remaining $35,000 is long-term capital gain treated as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain, within the Warehouse’s $120,000 of straight-line depreciation.
Traps in this case
Using the land’s appraised value or deducting its loss
The Vacant business land realizes $96,000 ($100,000 − $4,000), not its $110,000 appraised value, and its $24,000 realized loss ($120,000 − $96,000) is entirely disallowed because Avery owns 60% of the buyer.
Including the machine gain in Section 1231 netting
The Packaging machine’s $40,000 gain does not enter the Section 1231 net because it is fully recaptured as Section 1245 ordinary income.
Treating all warehouse gain as ordinary income
Straight-line depreciation produces no Section 1250 ordinary recapture here; only $25,000 of the net Section 1231 gain becomes ordinary under the lookback rule.
Q8
You are preparing the 2025 federal income tax disposition workpaper for Dana Ruiz, a calendar-year individual who operates a sole proprietorship. Dana disposed of Machine A, a warehouse, and business land during 2025. Use Exhibits 1 through 3 to calculate the disposition results, classify each item before netting, apply the Section 1231 netting rules, and determine the effect of the five-year lookback rule.
Show answer and rationale
Rationale
Selling costs determine each disposition result, and depreciation recapture is applied before Section 1231 netting.
Under the 2025 Fixed-Asset Register and Disposition Closing Documents, Machine A’s gain is $55,000 ($90,000 − $5,000 − $30,000), all ordinary Section 1245 recapture because depreciation was $150,000.
The warehouse has a $70,000 Section 1231 gain ($470,000 − $20,000 − $380,000), while business land has a $35,000 Section 1231 loss ($110,000 − $5,000 − $140,000).
The net Section 1231 gain is split between five-year lookback ordinary gain and long-term capital gain.
Closing the Section 1231 accounts debits warehouse gain $70,000 and credits land loss $35,000, leaving a $35,000 net gain.
The Prior-Year Character Workpaper’s $12,000 2022 Section 1231 ordinary loss makes $12,000 of that gain ordinary under the lookback rule; the remaining $23,000 is long-term capital gain classified as unrecaptured Section 1250 gain.
Traps in this case
Treating Machine A’s $90,000 contract price as its amount realized
Dana owed the $5,000 broker commission, so the settlement’s $85,000 net proceeds—not the buyer’s gross payment—determine gain.
Treating the warehouse gain as ordinary depreciation recapture
The warehouse used straight-line depreciation with no additional depreciation over straight line, so its gain enters Section 1231 netting rather than ordinary Section 1250 recapture.
Counting the 2024 stock loss in the lookback
The $8,000 investment-stock loss was a Schedule D capital loss, not a Section 1231 loss; office furniture also creates no 2025 disposition entry because it was not sold.
Q9
You are preparing the 2025 federal income tax disposition workpaper for Avery Cole, a calendar-year individual taxpayer. Determine the tax consequences of Avery's sale of a property that was initially rented and was later used as Avery's principal residence. Use the closing statement, property-use schedule, and client correspondence to complete the workpaper.
Show answer and rationale
Rationale
The closing costs and rental depreciation determine Avery’s realized gain.
The Property Closing Statement shows $50,000 of selling expenses ($45,000 commission + $5,000 fees), so amount realized is $900,000 − $50,000 = $850,000.
The Property Use and Tax Basis Schedule reduces the $400,000 purchase price by $44,000 of depreciation allowed or allowable, giving a $356,000 adjusted basis and an $850,000 − $356,000 = $494,000 realized gain.
Depreciation, nonqualified use, and the section 121 limit determine the taxable gain.
The $44,000 depreciation-related gain is taxable as unrecaptured section 1250 gain and cannot be excluded under section 121; the remaining $450,000 yields $180,000 of nonqualified-use gain ($450,000 × 40%).
The other $270,000 is eligible for section 121 before the statutory limit, but Avery can exclude only $250,000, leaving $244,000 taxable ($44,000 + $180,000 + $20,000).
Traps in this case
Treating the mortgage payoff as a selling expense
The $180,000 mortgage repayment affects Avery’s cash proceeds, not the $850,000 amount realized.
Applying 40% to the entire realized gain
The nonqualified-use fraction applies to $450,000 after removing depreciation-related gain, not to the full $494,000.
Treating Avery’s travel as an interruption of residence use
The Client Email says the property remained Avery’s principal residence and was not rented during the two-month trip.