You are completing the audit of Summit Medical Devices, Inc., a nonissuer that prepares its December 31, 20X5 financial statements in accordance with U.S. GAAP. The audit is conducted under generally accepted auditing standards. Fieldwork is being completed on March 7, 20X6, the planned auditor's report date. Overall materiality is $300,000, performance materiality is $225,000, and the clearly trivial threshold is $15,000. Management has recorded no adjustments arising from the completion procedures summarized in the exhibits.
Show answer and rationale
Rationale
The 20X5 statements must reflect losses supported by conditions that existed at year-end.
- Exhibit 1’s probable patent loss has no best estimate within its $420,000–$500,000 range, so the required accrual is $420,000, requiring a $170,000 increase over the $250,000 recorded.
- Exhibit 2’s bankruptcy confirms a preexisting $120,000 allowance deficiency, and the settlement establishes a $310,000 liability for a 20X5 defect; both require adjustment.
Completion also requires evaluating uncorrected errors, substantial doubt, and the reporting timeline.
- Exhibit 3’s income-affecting errors total $280,000 ($120,000 + $75,000 + $55,000 + $30,000) and must be accumulated with other uncorrected misstatements.
- Exhibit 4’s unsupported land-sale plan does not alleviate substantial doubt; adequate disclosure calls for a separate going-concern section without modifying the opinion for that matter, while Exhibit 5 requires subsequent-events procedures through the March 7, 20X6 auditor’s report date.
Traps in this case
Adjusting for the warehouse fire
- Exhibit 2 says the warehouse was in normal condition at year-end, so the material January 22 fire requires disclosure, not adjustment of 20X5 amounts.
Treating the covenant waiver as a cure
- Exhibit 4’s 15-month waiver addresses the lender’s repayment demand but not the forecast September 20X6 payroll and supplier shortfall.
Assuming the going-concern disclosure resolves the uncorrected misstatements
- The separate going-concern section does not excuse uncorrected adjustments, including the $170,000 patent-accrual deficiency and $310,000 unrecorded settlement.

