A tax manager is reviewing the January 2, 2025 formation of Atlas Manufacturing, Inc., a calendar-year C corporation. Three unrelated individuals transferred land, equipment, cash, and services in exchange for Atlas stock, and one individual received nonqualified preferred stock. The manager must determine whether the exchanges qualify for nonrecognition, calculate transferor and corporate bases, characterize recognized income, and organize the supporting tax workpaper. Assume all stated fair values are accurate and no transfer was undertaken for tax-avoidance purposes.
Show answer and rationale
Rationale
Section 351 control is measured using stock issued for property, while cash boot and services require separate treatment.
- Under the Formation and Transfer Agreement and Closing Statement and Stock Ledger, Avery and Blake receive all 160 voting common shares issued for property, satisfying the 80% control requirement; Casey’s nonqualified preferred stock is treated as other property under Section 351(g).
- Avery recognizes $10,000 long-term capital gain from the cash boot on investment land held four years; Avery’s stock basis is $80,000 + $10,000 gain − $10,000 cash − $50,000 mortgage = $30,000, and Atlas’s land basis is $90,000.
Property and services transferred by the same person have different tax consequences.
- Blake recognizes $0 gain on the equipment exchange but $20,000 ordinary compensation income for services; Blake’s aggregate stock basis is $45,000 equipment basis + $20,000 basis in service stock = $65,000, and Atlas’s equipment basis is $45,000.
- Casey’s nonqualified preferred stock has a $50,000 basis; although it is treated as other property under Section 351(g), Casey recognizes no gain because the cash transferred has a $50,000 basis and value.
Traps in this case
Counting service stock toward control
- Blake’s 20 shares issued for services do not count as stock received for property, even though the 70 shares issued for equipment do.
Treating the assumed mortgage as additional gain
- Avery’s $50,000 mortgage reduces stock basis, but it does not create additional recognized gain because it does not exceed the land’s $80,000 basis.
Assigning Blake a fair-value equipment basis
- Atlas carries over Blake’s $45,000 tax basis, not the equipment’s $70,000 fair value, because Blake recognizes no gain on that transfer.

