Northbridge Pension Fund maintains a liability-driven fixed-income portfolio intended to stabilize the funded status of a closed defined benefit plan. The plan's liabilities are denominated in USD and consist primarily of long-dated nominal benefit payments. The portfolio committee measures funded-status sensitivity using the present values and effective durations of plan assets and liabilities. It permits active positions provided that the portfolio remains within its overall interest-rate risk budget. The chief investment officer first requests an estimate of the effect of an immediate parallel increase in yields. Exhibit 1 reports the relevant present values and effective durations. For this estimate, the committee instructs the manager to use the first-order duration approximation, treat 50 basis points as 0.005 in decimal yield terms, and ignore convexity. Surplus is defined as the market value of assets minus the present value of liabilities. The committee separately asks the team to consider a larger, 150-basis-point yield increase and to assess whether the convexity measures also reported in Exhibit 1 would make the actual price decline for assets and liabilities more or less severe than the duration-only approximation suggests. The active fixed-income team also expects the government yield curve to flatten because short- and intermediate-maturity yields will increase while long-term yields remain unchanged. The team may implement benchmark-relative key-rate-duration positions, but total portfolio duration must remain approximately unchanged. Exhibit 2 presents the team's forecast. The committee prefers a position that directly reflects the maturity-specific forecast rather than an undifferentiated change in total duration. For its credit allocation, Northbridge uses a combined fundamental and relative-value process. Analysts evaluate leverage, cash-flow resilience, covenant protection, expected recovery, and current spread compensation. Exhibit 3 presents current spreads, expected spread changes over the investment horizon, and the analysts' fundamental views for three market segments. Expected default losses are incorporated into those forecasts. The credit team also identifies a possible discrepancy between the cash bond and credit default swap markets for one issuer. Exhibit 4 presents the matched-maturity bond spread and CDS premium. The team can buy or sell the bond and can buy or sell CDS protection. Purchased protection benefits from deterioration in the issuer's credit and offsets default losses on a long position in the issuer's bond. The proposed trade is intended to capture relative mispricing rather than establish an unhedged directional credit position. Finally, to diversify sources of return, the plan has allocated a modest tranche of assets to EUR-denominated bonds. Exhibit 5 presents the current allocation, spot and forward exchange rates, and the unhedged bond's duration. The committee is evaluating a currency-forward hedge sized to the EUR bond tranche's market value and wants to confirm the hedge's effect on both the currency exposure and the underlying bond's interest-rate risk.
Asset and Liability Interest-Rate Exposures
| Measure | Bond portfolio | Liabilities | |---|---:|---:| | Present value | USD 500 million | USD 450 million | | Effective duration | 7.0 | 8.5 | | Convexity | 65 | 72 | Assume an immediate parallel 50-basis-point increase in yields, unchanged credit spreads, and use duration only.
Yield-Curve Forecast and Proposed Positions
| Maturity | Forecast yield change | |---|---:| | 2-year | +30 bps | | 5-year | +15 bps | | 10-year | 0 bps | | 30-year | 0 bps | The benchmark-neutral portfolio may alter key-rate durations while maintaining approximately unchanged total duration.
Credit Market Views
| Segment | Current spread | Forecast spread change | Fundamental view | |---|---:|---:|---| | Defensive A rated | 95 bps | −5 bps | Stable | | Cyclical BBB rated | 185 bps | +35 bps | Deteriorating | | Secured BB rated | 320 bps | −20 bps | Improving recovery prospects |
Bond–CDS Relative-Value Position
A five-year issuer bond trades at a spread of 180 bps over the relevant government curve. Five-year CDS protection on the same seniority trades at 130 bps. Assume matched notionals, matched maturities, no counterparty concerns, and that financing and delivery-option effects are immaterial.
Foreign-Currency Bond Tranche and Hedge Terms
| Item | Value | |---|---:| | EUR-denominated bond allocation (base currency: USD) | EUR 40 million | | Current spot rate (USD/EUR) | 1.10 | | 6-month forward rate (USD/EUR) | 1.095 | | Unhedged EUR bond duration | 6.0 | The committee is evaluating whether to hedge the currency exposure using a 6-month forward contract sized to the current market value of the EUR bond tranche.
- Q1.1
Based on Exhibit 1, the estimated change in the plan's surplus is closest to:
- ADecrease by USD 1.625 million
- BIncrease by USD 0.250 million
- CIncrease by USD 1.625 million
Show answer and rationale
Answer: C. Increase by USD 1.625 million
Rationale
Increase by USD 1.625 million
- Using Exhibit 1 and a 0.005 yield increase, assets decline by (500 \times 7.0 \times 0.005 =) USD 17.500 million, while liabilities decline by (450 \times 8.5 \times 0.005 =) USD 19.125 million.
- Because surplus equals assets minus liabilities, its change is (-17.500 - (-19.125) =) +USD 1.625 million.
Decrease by USD 1.625 million
- The two value changes have the right magnitudes, but this answer reverses the surplus subtraction: (-19.125 - (-17.500) = -1.625).
- The liability decline improves funded status because it reduces the amount subtracted from assets.
Increase by USD 0.250 million
- This results from applying 0.005 directly to the initial USD 50 million surplus: (50 \times 0.005 =) USD 0.250 million.
- Exhibit 1 requires applying each side’s effective duration to its own present value before calculating the change in surplus.
- Q1.2
Based on Exhibit 2, the most appropriate benchmark-relative position is:
- AUnderweight 2-year key-rate duration and overweight 10-year key-rate duration
- BOverweight 2-year key-rate duration and underweight 10-year key-rate duration
- COverweight both 2-year and 10-year key-rate durations
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. Underweight 2-year key-rate duration and overweight 10-year key-rate duration
Rationale
Underweight 2-year key-rate duration and overweight 10-year key-rate duration
- Exhibit 2 forecasts a 30 bp rise in the 2-year yield but no change in the 10-year yield, so reducing 2-year exposure avoids more forecast price decline.
- Shifting key-rate duration toward the 10-year point expresses that relative view while keeping total duration approximately unchanged.
Overweight 2-year key-rate duration and underweight 10-year key-rate duration
- Overweighting the 2-year point adds exposure where Exhibit 2 forecasts the largest yield increase, and thus the greatest price pressure among the listed maturities.
- Underweighting the unchanged 10-year point reverses the benchmark-relative position implied by the forecast.
Overweight both 2-year and 10-year key-rate durations
- The 2-year overweight adds exposure to the forecast 30 bp yield increase, contrary to the maturity-specific view.
- Overweighting both points also tends to increase total duration unless offset elsewhere, rather than directly shifting duration from the 2-year to the 10-year point.
- Q1.3
Based on Exhibit 3, the most appropriate position in cyclical BBB bonds is:
- AOverweight cyclical BBB bonds
- BUnderweight cyclical BBB bonds
- CMaintain benchmark weight in cyclical BBB bonds
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. Underweight cyclical BBB bonds
Rationale
Underweight cyclical BBB bonds
- Exhibit 3 forecasts 35 bps of spread widening for cyclical BBB bonds, which would reduce their prices relative to bonds with unchanged spreads.
- The deteriorating fundamental view reinforces an underweight despite their current 185 bps spread; expected default losses are already incorporated into the forecast.
Overweight cyclical BBB bonds
- Overweighting would increase exposure to the segment for which Exhibit 3 forecasts spread widening and deteriorating fundamentals.
- The current 185 bps spread does not, by itself, justify more exposure when the forecast already incorporates expected default losses.
Maintain benchmark weight in cyclical BBB bonds
- A benchmark weight would leave the portfolio fully exposed to the forecast 35 bps widening rather than reflect the adverse credit view.
- Exhibit 3’s deteriorating assessment gives a reason to underweight, not remain neutral, even though cyclical BBB bonds offer more spread than defensive A rated bonds.
- Q1.4
Based on Exhibit 4, the most appropriate capital-structure arbitrage position is:
- ASell the bond and buy CDS protection
- BSell the bond and sell CDS protection
- CBuy the bond and buy CDS protection
Show answer and rationale
Answer: C. Buy the bond and buy CDS protection
Rationale
Buy the bond and buy CDS protection
- Exhibit 4 shows a 180 bps bond spread and a 130 bps CDS premium, so the bond offers 50 bps more spread than the cost of protection.
- Buying the bond captures its relatively high spread, while purchased CDS protection offsets issuer default losses on the matched bond position.
Sell the bond and buy CDS protection
- Selling the bond and buying protection both benefit from credit deterioration, creating a directional position rather than the intended hedge.
- Selling the bond also gives up its 180 bps spread instead of capturing the 50 bps excess over the CDS premium.
Sell the bond and sell CDS protection
- A short bond paired with sold protection takes the opposite side of the relative-value trade suggested by Exhibit 4.
- The position gives up the bond’s 180 bps spread while receiving only 130 bps for selling protection, an unfavorable 50 bps difference under the stated assumptions.
- Q1.5
Using Exhibit 1, if yields instead rise by 150 basis points (0.015) and the convexity terms are incorporated into the estimate, the liabilities' convexity-adjusted price decline is smaller in magnitude than the duration-only estimate would indicate.
- ATrue
- BFalse
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. True
Rationale
True
- Exhibit 1 gives liabilities an effective duration of 8.5, so a 0.015 yield increase produces a duration-only decline of 8.5 × 0.015 = 12.75%.
- Their positive convexity of 72 adds ½ × 72 × 0.015² = 0.81%, reducing the estimated decline to 11.94%.
False
- Convexity does not make the liabilities’ decline more severe here: Exhibit 1 reports positive convexity, which offsets part of the duration effect when yields rise.
- A larger 150-basis-point increase makes that offset more consequential, but it does not reverse its sign.
- Q1.6Select all that apply
Based on Exhibit 5, which of the following statements about the proposed forward hedge on the EUR bond tranche are correct? (Select all that apply.)
- AHedging converts the currency risk of the principal amount into a fixed USD cash flow at the forward rate.
- BThe EUR bond's interest-rate risk (duration exposure) is eliminated by the currency hedge.
- CBecause the EUR trades at a forward discount to the spot rate, the hedged USD proceeds are lower than the unhedged proceeds would be if the spot rate is unchanged at settlement.
- DThe hedge ratio must equal the bond's effective duration in order to eliminate the currency risk.
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. Hedging converts the currency risk of the principal amount into a fixed USD cash flow at the forward rate.; C. Because the EUR trades at a forward discount to the spot rate, the hedged USD proceeds are lower than the unhedged proceeds would be if the spot rate is unchanged at settlement.
Rationale
Select
Hedging converts the currency risk of the principal amount into a fixed USD cash flow at the forward rate.
- Selling EUR 40 million forward at USD 1.095/EUR fixes the USD amount received for that EUR amount at settlement.
- Exhibit 5’s forward rate gives USD 43.8 million (EUR 40 million × 1.095), regardless of the settlement-date spot rate.
Because the EUR trades at a forward discount to the spot rate, the hedged USD proceeds are lower than the unhedged proceeds would be if the spot rate is unchanged at settlement.
- Exhibit 5’s forward rate of 1.095 is below its spot rate of 1.10 USD/EUR.
- The hedge yields USD 43.8 million, versus USD 44.0 million (EUR 40 million × 1.10) if the tranche remains unhedged and spot is unchanged.
Do not select
The EUR bond's interest-rate risk (duration exposure) is eliminated by the currency hedge.
- A currency forward hedges the exchange rate on the EUR amount sold, not changes in the bond’s value caused by interest rates.
- The EUR bond’s 6.0 effective duration remains an interest-rate exposure after the currency hedge.
The hedge ratio must equal the bond's effective duration in order to eliminate the currency risk.
- The proposed forward is sized to the tranche’s EUR 40 million market value, not its 6.0 effective duration.
- Duration measures interest-rate sensitivity; it does not determine the EUR amount to sell forward to hedge the current currency exposure.
Show case rationale
Rationale
Northbridge’s funded-status result depends on the difference between asset and liability interest-rate sensitivity.
- In Exhibit 1, a 50 bp yield rise reduces assets by USD 500 million × 7.0 × 0.005 = USD 17.5 million and liabilities by USD 450 million × 8.5 × 0.005 = USD 19.125 million, so surplus increases by USD 1.625 million.
- For a 150 bp rise, liabilities’ positive convexity adds ½ × 72 × 0.015² = 0.81% to the duration-only return, making their estimated price decline smaller in magnitude.
Active positions must match the specific risk each forecast or hedge addresses.
- Exhibit 2 favors underweighting 2-year and overweighting 10-year key-rate duration without materially changing total duration; Exhibit 3 favors underweighting cyclical BBB bonds because their spreads are forecast to widen by 35 bps amid deteriorating fundamentals.
- Exhibit 4 supports buying the 180 bp-spread bond and buying 130 bp CDS protection; in Exhibit 5, selling EUR 40 million forward fixes principal proceeds at USD 43.8 million if that amount is delivered.
Traps in this case
Treating a yield increase as equally favorable across maturities
- Overweighting 2-year duration adds exposure where Exhibit 2 forecasts the largest yield increase, 30 bps, while overweighting both maturities needlessly adds total duration.
Taking an unhedged or reversed credit position
- Exhibit 3’s 185 bp BBB spread does not outweigh its forecast widening, and selling the Exhibit 4 bond or CDS protection fails to capture the 50 bp bond–CDS spread difference with a protected long-bond position.
Confusing a currency hedge with an interest-rate hedge
- Exhibit 5’s forward does not eliminate the EUR bond’s 6.0 duration or require a duration-based hedge ratio; at an unchanged 1.10 spot rate, EUR 40 million would instead be worth USD 44.0 million, USD 0.2 million more than the forward proceeds.