Introduction to Risk Management — MCQs

On this page

8 questions
7 chapters
Q1Easy

An adviser observes a client repeatedly selling appreciated shares while retaining loss positions despite unchanged forecasts. This behavior most likely reflects:

Q2Unfolding case study

Northbridge Asset Management must obtain immediate exposure to a large-cap equity index for a taxable institutional account. The exposure is expected to remain in place for one year. Portfolio manager Sameer Patel is considering either purchasing an ETF or establishing an economically equivalent long index-futures position. The client permits both instruments and has sufficient collateral, operational capacity, and counterparty limits. Dividends are incorporated equivalently in current ETF and futures pricing, so the comparison focuses on stated financing and fund expenses. Patel asks a trader to review the ETF order using the information in Exhibit 1. The quoted spread is calculated as the ask price minus the bid price, divided by the bid-ask midpoint. The ETF's intraday indicative value is an estimate of the contemporaneous value of its underlying basket, not a guaranteed execution price. Patel recognizes that quoted depth may understate an ETF's potential liquidity because authorized participants can assemble or dispose of the underlying basket and create or redeem ETF shares. For order selection, a market order prioritizes immediacy but provides no protection against an adverse execution price. A limit buy order establishes the maximum acceptable purchase price, although it may remain unfilled. The trading desk may also contact liquidity providers for risk quotes or use an algorithm that seeks liquidity without revealing the entire order. Patel prefers an initial approach that controls execution price without causing an unnecessary delay in achieving the strategic exposure. Patel will finance an ETF purchase at the investor's cash financing rate and incur the ETF's annual expense ratio. The futures position embeds the futures market's implied financing rate and has no ETF expense ratio. Commissions, taxes, collateral income differences, changes in futures basis, and roll costs are assumed to be zero for this one-year comparison. All rates in Exhibit 1 are annualized and are directly comparable. The creation unit size does not prevent secondary-market purchases in other quantities, although it may affect how authorized participants manage primary-market activity.

ETF Market and Portfolio Data

| Item | Value | |---|---:| | Best bid | USD 49.94 | | Best ask | USD 50.02 | | Intraday indicative value | USD 49.98 | | Shares to purchase | 80,000 | | Average daily volume | 2,000,000 shares | | Underlying basket bid–ask spread | 12 bps | | Creation unit size | 50,000 shares | | Annual fund expense ratio | 18 bps | | Index futures annualized implied financing rate | 4.60% | | Investor's annual cash financing rate | 5.10% |

Trader Statements

**Statement 1:** A limit buy order at USD 50.00 guarantees execution at USD 50.00 or less. **Statement 2:** Persistent ETF premiums can attract authorized participants to create ETF shares by delivering the underlying basket. **Statement 3:** For a large ETF order, secondary-market volume alone fully measures available liquidity.

  1. Q2.1

    Based on Exhibit 1, the ETF's quoted bid–ask spread relative to the midpoint is closest to:

    1. A4 bps
    2. B8 bps
    3. C16 bps
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. 16 bps

    Rationale

    16 bps

    • Exhibit 1 gives a quoted spread of USD 50.02 − USD 49.94 = USD 0.08.
    • The midpoint is USD 49.98, so USD 0.08 ÷ USD 49.98 × 10,000 = 16.0064 bps, closest to 16 bps.

    4 bps

    • Substituting the trader’s proposed USD 50.00 limit price for the USD 49.94 bid produces a USD 0.02 spread.
    • That mistaken spread divided by its USD 50.01 midpoint is approximately 4 bps; a limit price is not the quoted bid.

    8 bps

    • USD 49.98 − USD 49.94 = USD 0.04, which is the half-spread.
    • Dividing USD 0.04 by the USD 49.98 midpoint gives approximately 8 bps, but the question asks for the full bid–ask spread.
  2. Q2.2

    Which trader statement in Exhibit 2 is most accurate?

    1. AStatement 1
    2. BStatement 2
    3. CStatement 3
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Statement 2

    Rationale

    Statement 2

    • When an ETF trades at a persistent premium to its underlying basket, authorized participants can deliver the basket to create ETF shares.
    • Those new shares increase supply and can help bring the ETF price closer to basket value.

    Statement 1

    • A limit buy order at USD 50.00 prevents execution above that price but does not guarantee a fill.
    • If shares are unavailable at USD 50.00 or less, the order may remain unfilled, delaying the desired exposure.

    Statement 3

    • Secondary-market volume alone does not fully measure liquidity for the proposed 80,000-share ETF purchase.
    • Authorized participants can create or redeem shares using the underlying basket, so available liquidity can exceed what reported ETF volume suggests.
  3. Q2.3

    Given the order size and market data, the most appropriate initial execution approach is to:

    1. ASubmit a market order immediately
    2. BSubmit a limit order near fair value
    3. CSplit the order across several weeks
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Submit a limit order near fair value

    Rationale

    Submit a limit order near fair value

    • A limit buy order near the USD 49.98 indicative value caps the purchase price while seeking prompt execution; the indicative value itself is not a guaranteed execution price.
    • The 80,000-share order is 4% of average daily volume, and authorized participants can provide liquidity beyond displayed ETF depth, so a lengthy delay is not warranted.

    Submit a market order immediately

    • A market order provides immediate access but no price protection for the 80,000-share purchase.
    • The displayed ask of USD 50.02 does not guarantee that the entire order will execute at that price.

    Split the order across several weeks

    • Spreading the order over weeks would unnecessarily delay the immediate index exposure Northbridge needs.
    • At 4% of average daily volume, the order does not, on these facts, require weeks to execute; ETF liquidity can also extend beyond displayed volume.
  4. Q2.4

    Ignoring commissions, taxes, and basis changes, the lower-cost one-year implementation is most likely:

    1. AThe ETF, by 68 bps
    2. BThe futures, by 68 bps
    3. CThe futures, by 50 bps
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. The futures, by 68 bps

    Rationale

    The futures, by 68 bps

    • The ETF costs 5.28% for one year: the investor’s 5.10% cash financing rate plus the 0.18% fund expense ratio in Exhibit 1.
    • Futures cost 4.60% at the implied financing rate, making them cheaper by 5.28% − 4.60% = 0.68%, or 68 bps.

    The ETF, by 68 bps

    • The 68 bp difference is correct, but its direction is reversed: the ETF’s 5.28% cost exceeds the futures’ 4.60% cost.
    • The ETF incurs both the investor’s cash financing rate and the fund expense ratio; the futures position has no ETF expense ratio.

    The futures, by 50 bps

    • The 50 bp figure comes from comparing financing rates alone: 5.10% − 4.60% = 0.50%.
    • Omitting the ETF’s 18 bp expense ratio understates the futures’ one-year cost advantage, which is 50 + 18 = 68 bps.
  5. Q2.5

    True or False: The ETF's creation unit size of 50,000 shares prevents Patel from purchasing 80,000 shares in the secondary market.

    1. ATrue
    2. BFalse
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. False

    Rationale

    False

    • The 50,000-share creation unit governs authorized participants’ primary-market creations and redemptions, not the size of secondary-market purchases.
    • Patel can purchase 80,000 shares in the secondary market, subject to available liquidity and execution price.

    True

    • This confuses the ETF’s primary-market creation unit with a minimum or required multiple for secondary-market trades.
    • The case expressly states that creation unit size does not prevent secondary-market purchases in other quantities.
  6. Q2.6Select all that apply

    Which of the following are advantages of using index futures rather than the ETF for this one-year exposure, based on Exhibit 1? (Select all that apply)

    1. AFutures avoid the ETF's annual expense ratio
    2. BFutures embed a lower implied financing rate than the investor's cash financing rate
    3. CFutures eliminate quoted bid-ask spread entirely
    4. DFutures avoid taxable events entirely regardless of holding period
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Futures avoid the ETF's annual expense ratio; B. Futures embed a lower implied financing rate than the investor's cash financing rate

    Rationale

    Select

    Futures avoid the ETF's annual expense ratio

    • Exhibit 1 lists an 18 bps annual ETF expense ratio, which the futures position does not incur.
    • For the one-year exposure, avoiding that expense contributes to the futures position’s lower stated cost.

    Futures embed a lower implied financing rate than the investor's cash financing rate

    • Exhibit 1 shows 4.60% implied futures financing versus 5.10% cash financing for the ETF purchase.
    • Including the ETF’s 18 bps expense ratio gives a stated annual cost of 5.28% for the ETF versus 4.60% for futures.

    Do not select

    Futures eliminate quoted bid-ask spread entirely

    • Futures can also have bid-ask spreads; using futures does not eliminate trading spreads.
    • Exhibit 1 provides ETF bid and ask quotes but no futures spread that would support a zero-spread claim.

    Futures avoid taxable events entirely regardless of holding period

    • The comparison assumes taxes are zero; it does not establish that futures cannot generate taxable events.
    • Nothing in Exhibit 1 supports a tax exemption for futures regardless of holding period.
Show case rationale

Rationale

ETF execution depends on the quoted spread, price control, and liquidity beyond displayed volume.

  • The ETF Market and Portfolio Data give a midpoint of USD 49.98 and a spread of USD 0.08, so the quoted spread is 0.08 ÷ 49.98 × 10,000 ≈ 16 bps; the indicative value estimates basket value but does not guarantee an execution price.
  • Statement 2 is accurate because an ETF premium can attract authorized participants to deliver the underlying basket and create shares; the 50,000-share creation unit does not prevent an 80,000-share secondary-market purchase.

Futures have the lower stated one-year implementation cost.

  • Financing the ETF costs 5.10% + 0.18% = 5.28%, versus the futures’ 4.60% implied financing rate, making futures cheaper by 68 bps under the stated assumptions.
  • Futures avoid the ETF expense ratio and embed a lower financing rate, but neither advantage means futures have no bid–ask spread or avoid taxable events regardless of holding period.

Traps in this case

Confusing a price limit with guaranteed execution

  • A limit buy order near USD 49.98 controls the maximum price without planning an unnecessary weeks-long delay, but it may remain unfilled; a market order offers immediacy without price protection.

Treating displayed volume as total ETF liquidity

  • Statement 3 is inaccurate because authorized participants can create or redeem shares using the underlying basket, so secondary-market volume alone does not fully measure available liquidity.

Omitting the ETF expense ratio

  • Comparing only the financing rates yields 50 bps (5.10% − 4.60%), but adding the ETF’s 18 bps expense ratio produces the 68-bp futures advantage.
Q3Unfolding case study

Northbridge Advisory manages a taxable equity portfolio and uses exchange-traded funds for tactical exposure and liquidity management. The risk committee asks the portfolio manager to estimate one-day market risk using a parametric normal model. Returns are assumed to have a zero daily mean for this calculation, and the committee defines VaR as a positive amount of potential loss. The required one-tailed normal critical value and the portfolio's estimated daily volatility are provided in Exhibit 1. The manager is also evaluating an ETF that holds a transparent basket of domestic large-cap equities. The fund permits in-kind creations and redemptions through authorized participants. At the observation time, the ETF market price exceeds its per-share NAV. Transaction costs are sufficiently small for the stated price discrepancy to support arbitrage. The manager notes that authorized-participant activity should tend to narrow, rather than mechanically eliminate, premiums and discounts. Separately, a trader received an order to purchase 100,000 shares of an individual equity. The portfolio manager recorded the decision price before transmitting the order. The trader began execution at the arrival price but completed only 80,000 shares by the end of the day. The stock closed above both the decision price and the average execution price. Northbridge evaluates the order using implementation shortfall, incorporating commissions, execution slippage relative to the decision price, and the opportunity cost of unexecuted shares. Management fees are excluded because they are not generated by executing this order. The portfolio's private client is reluctant to rebalance. She resists selling securities that have appreciated because she expects their recent gains to continue, and she refuses to purchase asset classes after price declines because doing so would make the loss feel more immediate. The resulting equity allocation has repeatedly moved outside its investment policy range. Her adviser proposes replacing ad hoc negotiations with objective rebalancing bands and advance authorization to trade whenever those bands are breached. The client's liquidity needs, tax circumstances, and strategic allocation are already reflected in the approved policy ranges, so the proposed rule would not override a newly changed financial constraint.

ETF and Trade Data

| Item | Value | |---|---:| | ETF NAV per share | USD 50.00 | | ETF market price per share | USD 50.40 | | Equity portfolio market value | USD 10.0 million | | Estimated daily portfolio volatility | 1.20% | | One-tailed 95% normal critical value | 1.645 | | Decision price for equity order | USD 25.00 | | Arrival price | USD 25.10 | | Average execution price | USD 25.16 | | Closing price | USD 25.30 | | Shares ordered | 100,000 | | Shares executed | 80,000 | | Commission per executed share | USD 0.02 |

  1. Q3.1

    Based on Exhibit 1, the portfolio's one-day 95% parametric VaR is closest to:

    1. AUSD 120,000
    2. BUSD 164,500
    3. CUSD 197,400
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. USD 197,400

    Rationale

    USD 197,400

    • Exhibit 1 gives a USD 10.0 million portfolio value and 1.20% daily volatility, so one daily standard deviation is USD 120,000.
    • With zero mean, one-day 95% parametric VaR is USD 120,000 × the one-tailed critical value of 1.645 = USD 197,400.

    USD 120,000

    • USD 10.0 million × 1.20% = USD 120,000, which is one daily standard deviation.
    • This omits Exhibit 1’s 1.645 critical value, so it is not the requested 95% VaR.

    USD 164,500

    • Rounding Exhibit 1’s 1.20% volatility to 1.00% gives USD 10.0 million × 1.00% × 1.645 = USD 164,500.
    • The VaR calculation must use the stated 1.20% estimate rather than the rounded rate.
  2. Q3.2Fill in the blank

    Using Exhibit 1, calculate the total explicit trading cost (in USD) incurred on the shares of the equity order that were actually executed.

    Answer:  

    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: USD 1,600

    Rationale

    USD 1,600

    • Exhibit 1 reports 80,000 shares executed at a commission of USD 0.02 per share, so explicit trading cost is 80,000 × USD 0.02 = USD 1,600.
    • Only executed shares incur this commission; execution slippage and the opportunity cost of unexecuted shares are not explicit costs.

    Common wrong answers

    USD 2,000

    • Applying the commission to all 100,000 shares ordered, rather than the 80,000 executed, gives 100,000 × USD 0.02 = USD 2,000.

    USD 4,800

    • Mistaking the USD 0.06 difference between the execution and arrival prices for the per-share explicit cost gives 80,000 × USD 0.06 = USD 4,800.
  3. Q3.3

    To reduce the client's tendency to avoid selling appreciated assets and adding to recently declining assets, the adviser should most appropriately:

    1. APermit discretionary delay after market losses
    2. BEstablish automatic policy-band rebalancing
    3. CIncrease the reference price for losing assets
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Establish automatic policy-band rebalancing

    Rationale

    Establish automatic policy-band rebalancing

    • Preauthorized trades when policy bands are breached replace case-by-case decisions that have allowed the equity allocation to move outside its approved range.
    • The bands already reflect the client’s liquidity needs, taxes, and strategic allocation, so the rule addresses her reluctance without overriding those constraints.

    Permit discretionary delay after market losses

    • A delay would leave the client free to avoid buying declined asset classes when doing so makes the loss feel more immediate.
    • Her ad hoc decisions have already let the equity allocation repeatedly breach its policy range, so more discretion does not correct the problem.

    Increase the reference price for losing assets

    • Changing a mental reference price does not authorize the purchases needed when a declined asset class falls below its policy band.
    • It also does not address her reluctance to sell appreciated securities because she expects their recent gains to continue.
  4. Q3.4Select all that apply

    Now assume instead that the ETF trades at a discount to NAV and that the fund uses cash-based (rather than in-kind) creations and redemptions. Which of the following actions would an authorized participant most likely take to exploit this discrepancy? (Select all that apply.)

    1. ABuy ETF shares in the secondary market
    2. BRedeem ETF shares with the fund for cash equal to NAV
    3. CSell the underlying basket short
    4. DCreate new ETF shares for cash equal to NAV
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Buy ETF shares in the secondary market; B. Redeem ETF shares with the fund for cash equal to NAV

    Rationale

    Select

    Buy ETF shares in the secondary market

    • With the ETF trading at a discount to NAV, the authorized participant can buy shares for less than their redemption value.
    • Those purchased shares are what the participant submits to the fund for cash redemption.

    Redeem ETF shares with the fund for cash equal to NAV

    • Under the assumed cash-based redemption process, the fund pays NAV for the ETF shares.
    • Buying below NAV and redeeming at NAV captures the price difference, less transaction costs.

    Do not select

    Sell the underlying basket short

    • Shorting the basket does not provide the ETF shares needed for the stated cash redemption.
    • It also creates a separate short position rather than directly capturing the discount through redemption.

    Create new ETF shares for cash equal to NAV

    • Creating shares requires paying NAV when existing ETF shares can be bought below NAV.
    • Selling newly created shares at the discounted market price would produce a loss before costs.
  5. Q3.5Fill in the blank

    Using Exhibit 1, calculate the total dollar implementation shortfall for the equity order, including explicit costs, execution slippage on the executed shares, and opportunity cost on the unexecuted shares.

    Answer:  

    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: USD 20,400

    Rationale

    USD 20,400

    • On the 80,000 executed shares, commission is USD 0.02 × 80,000 = USD 1,600, and slippage from the decision price is (USD 25.16 − USD 25.00) × 80,000 = USD 12,800.
    • The 20,000 unexecuted shares add opportunity cost of (USD 25.30 − USD 25.00) × 20,000 = USD 6,000, for a total of USD 1,600 + USD 12,800 + USD 6,000 = USD 20,400.

    Common wrong answers

    USD 14,400

    • Omitting the unexecuted shares’ opportunity cost gives USD 1,600 + USD 12,800 = USD 14,400.

    USD 18,800

    • Omitting commission gives USD 12,800 + USD 6,000 = USD 18,800.

    USD 10,400

    • Using the arrival price instead of the decision price for both price differences gives USD 1,600 + (USD 25.16 − USD 25.10) × 80,000 + (USD 25.30 − USD 25.10) × 20,000 = USD 10,400.
  6. Q3.6Select all that apply

    Which of the following are recognized limitations of the parametric (variance–covariance) approach to VaR used in Exhibit 1? (Select all that apply.)

    1. AAssumes returns follow a normal distribution
    2. BMay understate the likelihood of extreme losses (fat tails)
    3. CDirectly captures nonlinear option payoffs
    4. DRequires estimates of volatility (and correlation for multi-asset portfolios)
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Assumes returns follow a normal distribution; B. May understate the likelihood of extreme losses (fat tails); D. Requires estimates of volatility (and correlation for multi-asset portfolios)

    Rationale

    Select

    Assumes returns follow a normal distribution

    • Exhibit 1 uses a normal critical value of 1.645 to estimate one-day VaR.
    • If actual portfolio returns depart from that distribution, the resulting VaR may misstate potential loss.

    May understate the likelihood of extreme losses (fat tails)

    • A normal model assigns relatively low probabilities to extreme losses.
    • If actual returns have fatter tails, the model can understate the likelihood of losses beyond its VaR estimate.

    Requires estimates of volatility (and correlation for multi-asset portfolios)

    • The calculation depends on Exhibit 1’s estimated 1.20% daily volatility, so an inaccurate estimate affects VaR.
    • A multi-asset calculation also needs estimated correlations to determine portfolio volatility.

    Do not select

    Directly captures nonlinear option payoffs

    • The basic variance–covariance approach models portfolio risk using volatility and a normal critical value; it does not directly capture nonlinear option payoffs.
    • Options’ changing sensitivity to the underlying asset is therefore a limitation of this approach, not a capability.
Show case rationale

Rationale

The case turns on applying the specified risk inputs, ETF redemption mechanism, and trading benchmark.

  • One-day 95% VaR is USD 197,400: USD 10,000,000 × 1.20% × 1.645; the normal model can understate fat-tail losses, requires volatility estimates and, for multi-asset portfolios, correlation estimates, and does not directly capture nonlinear option payoffs.
  • At the stated ETF premium, in-kind creation can increase ETF share supply; under the question’s hypothetical discount with cash redemptions, an authorized participant buys ETF shares and redeems them for cash at NAV.

The order’s decision price and the client’s approved policy bands govern the remaining decisions.

  • Executed-share commissions are USD 1,600 (80,000 × USD 0.02), and implementation shortfall is USD 20,400: 80,000 × (USD 25.16 − USD 25.00) + 20,000 × (USD 25.30 − USD 25.00) + USD 1,600.
  • Automatic policy-band rebalancing addresses the client’s reluctance to sell winners or buy after declines without overriding changed financial constraints; management fees are not costs of executing this order.

Traps in this case

Using an incomplete VaR calculation

  • USD 120,000 omits the 1.645 critical value, while USD 164,500 results from substituting 1.00% for the stated 1.20% volatility.

Applying the wrong ETF arbitrage direction

  • Shorting the underlying basket or creating shares at NAV does not exploit a discount by cash redemption; authorized-participant activity tends to narrow discrepancies, not mechanically eliminate them.

Changing the trading benchmark or delaying rebalancing

  • The arrival price is not the recorded decision price for shortfall, and discretionary delay or a higher reference price for losing assets would not enforce the approved rebalancing bands.
Q4Medium

A portfolio invests 65% in equities with beta 1.15, 25% in bonds with beta 0.20, and 10% in cash with beta zero. The calculated portfolio beta is closest to:

Q5Unfolding case study

Northbridge Pension Plan uses exchange-traded funds to implement tactical asset-allocation views while maintaining low operating costs. The portfolio manager expects a particular equity sector to underperform for approximately three months. The plan permits physical ETF purchases and short sales when borrow is available, but it does not permit futures or swaps. Shares of a highly liquid sector ETF are readily borrowable at a modest cost. The manager is also considering a daily inverse sector ETF but recognizes that its exposure resets at the end of each trading day. During a market review, an analyst observes that an equity ETF is trading at a material premium to the net asset value of its underlying securities. The ETF accepts in-kind creation and redemption orders from authorized participants. Transaction costs are small relative to the observed premium, and the securities in the creation basket are liquid. The analyst is asked to identify the transaction that would place downward pressure on the ETF price and upward pressure on the basket value, thereby helping restore the price relationship. Northbridge separately purchases shares of another equity ETF. Exhibit 1 presents the order and execution data. For purchased shares, execution costs are measured as execution price minus decision price. Commissions and fees are excluded from this exercise. The research group also backtests a rules-based equity strategy from 2012 through 2024. To simplify data collection, the researcher downloads the index's constituents as of year-end 2024 and applies that same constituent list throughout the full historical period. Companies removed from the index because of bankruptcy, acquisition, or sustained deterioration are consequently absent from earlier simulated portfolios. All accounting and price data used for the remaining companies were publicly available on the relevant historical rebalancing dates. The committee evaluates each issue separately. It distinguishes ETF arbitrage from directional investing, recognizes that leveraged and inverse ETFs target daily rather than multi-period returns, notes that in-kind redemption mechanics can affect fund tax efficiency, and requires backtests to use the investable universe that was actually observable at each historical date.

Equity ETF Trade

| Item | Value | |---|---:| | Portfolio-manager decision price | USD 50.00 | | Shares ordered for purchase | 100,000 | | First execution | 60,000 shares at USD 50.10 | | Second execution | 30,000 shares at USD 50.25 | | Unexecuted shares | 10,000 | | Market close | USD 50.40 | | Commissions and fees | Excluded |

  1. Q5.1

    If an ETF trades at a material premium to its net asset value, an authorized participant should most likely:

    1. ABuy the basket, create ETF shares, and sell the ETF shares
    2. BBuy ETF shares, redeem them, and sell the underlying basket
    3. CSell both ETF shares and the underlying basket simultaneously
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Buy the basket, create ETF shares, and sell the ETF shares

    Rationale

    Buy the basket, create ETF shares, and sell the ETF shares

    • With the ETF at a premium to net asset value, the authorized participant can buy the liquid creation basket and exchange it in kind for new ETF shares.
    • Selling those shares at the higher ETF price captures the price difference, while basket purchases put upward pressure on basket value and ETF sales put downward pressure on the ETF price.

    Buy ETF shares, redeem them, and sell the underlying basket

    • Buying ETF shares to redeem them is the arbitrage transaction for an ETF trading at a discount to net asset value.
    • At the stated premium, buying the expensive ETF shares and selling the cheaper underlying basket reverses the profitable trade.

    Sell both ETF shares and the underlying basket simultaneously

    • Selling both sides does not use the ETF’s premium to acquire the cheaper basket in exchange for ETF shares.
    • Basket sales would put downward, not upward, pressure on basket value, contrary to the transaction the analyst seeks.
  2. Q5.2

    For the planned three-month sector underweight, the most appropriate implementation is to:

    1. APurchase a broad-market equity ETF
    2. BPurchase a daily inverse sector ETF
    3. CShort a liquid sector equity ETF
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Short a liquid sector equity ETF

    Rationale

    Short a liquid sector equity ETF

    • Shorting the sector ETF provides direct negative exposure to the sector expected to underperform over the planned three months.
    • Its shares are readily borrowable at modest cost, and the short does not have the daily reset feature of an inverse ETF.

    Purchase a broad-market equity ETF

    • Purchasing a broad-market ETF adds broad equity exposure, rather than directly reducing exposure to the sector expected to underperform.
    • It therefore does not implement the planned sector underweight as directly as shorting the borrowable sector ETF.

    Purchase a daily inverse sector ETF

    • A daily inverse sector ETF provides negative sector exposure for one day at a time, so it may appear to fit the manager’s view.
    • Because exposure resets each trading day, its three-month return can differ from the negative of the sector’s cumulative return.
  3. Q5.3

    Based on Exhibit 1, the weighted-average execution price for the executed shares is closest to:

    1. AUSD 50.15
    2. BUSD 50.18
    3. CUSD 50.20
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. USD 50.15

    Rationale

    USD 50.15

    • Exhibit 1 shows 90,000 executed shares: 60,000 at USD 50.10 and 30,000 at USD 50.25.
    • The share-weighted price is [60,000(USD 50.10) + 30,000(USD 50.25)] / 90,000 = USD 50.15.

    USD 50.18

    • Taking the unweighted average of the two execution prices gives (USD 50.10 + USD 50.25) / 2 = USD 50.175, or USD 50.18 rounded.
    • That treats the 60,000-share and 30,000-share executions as equally sized, contrary to Exhibit 1.

    USD 50.20

    • Reversing the share weights gives [30,000(USD 50.10) + 60,000(USD 50.25)] / 90,000 = USD 50.20.
    • Exhibit 1 assigns 60,000 shares to the lower price, USD 50.10, so the higher price must receive the smaller weight.
  4. Q5.4

    The researcher's use of current index constituents throughout the historical backtest most likely introduces:

    1. ASurvivorship bias
    2. BAppraisal bias
    3. CIncubation bias
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Survivorship bias

    Rationale

    Survivorship bias

    • Using the index’s year-end 2024 constituents for every portfolio from 2012 through 2024 excludes companies that left the index after bankruptcy, acquisition, or deterioration.
    • The backtest therefore retains today’s survivors in earlier periods instead of using the index membership observable at each historical rebalancing date.

    Appraisal bias

    • Appraisal bias arises when infrequently traded assets are valued using appraisals that can smooth reported returns.
    • This backtest uses historical accounting and price data that were publicly available at the relevant dates; the problem is its constituent list, not its valuations.

    Incubation bias

    • Incubation bias arises when only successful funds or strategies are reported after an unreported trial period.
    • The question describes no such selection of successful backtests; it describes one strategy tested with a year-end 2024 constituent list.
  5. Q5.5

    True or False: In-kind creation and redemption of ETF shares can help reduce the fund's realized capital gains distributions to shareholders.

    1. ATrue
    2. BFalse
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. True

    Rationale

    True

    • In an in-kind redemption, the ETF delivers portfolio securities to an authorized participant rather than selling them to raise cash.
    • Delivering low-cost-basis securities can reduce the fund’s realized capital gains and, consequently, capital gains distributions to shareholders.

    False

    • This overlooks the tax effect of delivering securities in kind: the fund can remove appreciated holdings without selling them.
    • In-kind transactions do not guarantee that the ETF will make no capital gains distributions, but they can help reduce them.
  6. Q5.6Select all that apply

    Which of the following statements about daily leveraged and inverse ETFs are correct? (Select all that apply.)

    1. AThey are designed to deliver a stated multiple of the underlying index's return on a single trading day.
    2. BCompounding of daily returns can cause multi-period performance to differ materially from the stated multiple of the index's cumulative return.
    3. CThey are generally well suited for buy-and-hold strategies held over multi-month horizons.
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. They are designed to deliver a stated multiple of the underlying index's return on a single trading day.; B. Compounding of daily returns can cause multi-period performance to differ materially from the stated multiple of the index's cumulative return.

    Rationale

    Select

    They are designed to deliver a stated multiple of the underlying index's return on a single trading day.

    • The daily inverse sector ETF Northbridge is considering resets its exposure at each trading day’s end.
    • Its stated multiple therefore targets the sector index’s daily return, not its return over the manager’s three-month horizon.

    Compounding of daily returns can cause multi-period performance to differ materially from the stated multiple of the index's cumulative return.

    • Each day’s return changes the ETF’s value before the next day’s reset, so returns compound over time.
    • Over Northbridge’s proposed three months, the inverse ETF’s return need not equal its stated multiple times the sector index’s cumulative return.

    Do not select

    They are generally well suited for buy-and-hold strategies held over multi-month horizons.

    • A daily return target does not provide a reliable target multiple over a multi-month holding period.
    • Northbridge’s three-month view makes that distinction important; the readily borrowable sector ETF is a separate way to express a negative view without a daily-reset target.
Show case rationale

Rationale

ETF mechanics determine the arbitrage trade and can improve tax efficiency.

  • When the ETF trades at a premium, an authorized participant buys the liquid basket, creates ETF shares, and sells those shares, putting upward pressure on basket values and downward pressure on the ETF price.
  • In-kind redemptions can transfer securities out of the fund without the fund selling them, helping reduce realized capital gains distributions; buying ETF shares to redeem is instead the trade associated with a discount.

The sector view, trade calculation, and backtest each depend on the relevant time horizon.

  • For a three-month sector underweight, shorting the readily borrowable sector ETF directly targets that sector; a broad-market ETF does not, while a daily inverse ETF resets its exposure each day.
  • Exhibit 1 gives an executed-share average of USD 50.15: [(60,000 × 50.10) + (30,000 × 50.25)] ÷ 90,000; using only year-end 2024 constituents in earlier portfolios introduces survivorship bias.

Traps in this case

Treating a daily target as a three-month target

  • Leveraged and inverse ETFs target a stated multiple of one day’s index return, and daily compounding can make their multi-period return differ materially from that multiple of the index’s cumulative return.

Including the unexecuted order in the execution average

  • Exhibit 1’s 10,000 unexecuted shares have no execution price, so neither the 100,000 shares ordered nor the USD 50.40 close belongs in the weighted-average execution price.

Calling the constituent-list problem a different bias

  • Excluding companies that later left the index is survivorship bias, not appraisal bias or incubation bias, even though the remaining companies’ historical data were publicly available.

Want unlimited practice?

Get full access to all questions, explanations, and performance tracking.

Start For Free
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF