Northbridge Asset Management must obtain immediate exposure to a large-cap equity index for a taxable institutional account. The exposure is expected to remain in place for one year. Portfolio manager Sameer Patel is considering either purchasing an ETF or establishing an economically equivalent long index-futures position. The client permits both instruments and has sufficient collateral, operational capacity, and counterparty limits. Dividends are incorporated equivalently in current ETF and futures pricing, so the comparison focuses on stated financing and fund expenses. Patel asks a trader to review the ETF order using the information in Exhibit 1. The quoted spread is calculated as the ask price minus the bid price, divided by the bid-ask midpoint. The ETF's intraday indicative value is an estimate of the contemporaneous value of its underlying basket, not a guaranteed execution price. Patel recognizes that quoted depth may understate an ETF's potential liquidity because authorized participants can assemble or dispose of the underlying basket and create or redeem ETF shares. For order selection, a market order prioritizes immediacy but provides no protection against an adverse execution price. A limit buy order establishes the maximum acceptable purchase price, although it may remain unfilled. The trading desk may also contact liquidity providers for risk quotes or use an algorithm that seeks liquidity without revealing the entire order. Patel prefers an initial approach that controls execution price without causing an unnecessary delay in achieving the strategic exposure. Patel will finance an ETF purchase at the investor's cash financing rate and incur the ETF's annual expense ratio. The futures position embeds the futures market's implied financing rate and has no ETF expense ratio. Commissions, taxes, collateral income differences, changes in futures basis, and roll costs are assumed to be zero for this one-year comparison. All rates in Exhibit 1 are annualized and are directly comparable. The creation unit size does not prevent secondary-market purchases in other quantities, although it may affect how authorized participants manage primary-market activity.
ETF Market and Portfolio Data
| Item | Value | |---|---:| | Best bid | USD 49.94 | | Best ask | USD 50.02 | | Intraday indicative value | USD 49.98 | | Shares to purchase | 80,000 | | Average daily volume | 2,000,000 shares | | Underlying basket bid–ask spread | 12 bps | | Creation unit size | 50,000 shares | | Annual fund expense ratio | 18 bps | | Index futures annualized implied financing rate | 4.60% | | Investor's annual cash financing rate | 5.10% |
Trader Statements
**Statement 1:** A limit buy order at USD 50.00 guarantees execution at USD 50.00 or less. **Statement 2:** Persistent ETF premiums can attract authorized participants to create ETF shares by delivering the underlying basket. **Statement 3:** For a large ETF order, secondary-market volume alone fully measures available liquidity.
- Q2.1
Based on Exhibit 1, the ETF's quoted bid–ask spread relative to the midpoint is closest to:
- A4 bps
- B8 bps
- C16 bps
Show answer and rationale
Answer: C. 16 bps
Rationale
16 bps
- Exhibit 1 gives a quoted spread of USD 50.02 − USD 49.94 = USD 0.08.
- The midpoint is USD 49.98, so USD 0.08 ÷ USD 49.98 × 10,000 = 16.0064 bps, closest to 16 bps.
4 bps
- Substituting the trader’s proposed USD 50.00 limit price for the USD 49.94 bid produces a USD 0.02 spread.
- That mistaken spread divided by its USD 50.01 midpoint is approximately 4 bps; a limit price is not the quoted bid.
8 bps
- USD 49.98 − USD 49.94 = USD 0.04, which is the half-spread.
- Dividing USD 0.04 by the USD 49.98 midpoint gives approximately 8 bps, but the question asks for the full bid–ask spread.
- Q2.2
Which trader statement in Exhibit 2 is most accurate?
- AStatement 1
- BStatement 2
- CStatement 3
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. Statement 2
Rationale
Statement 2
- When an ETF trades at a persistent premium to its underlying basket, authorized participants can deliver the basket to create ETF shares.
- Those new shares increase supply and can help bring the ETF price closer to basket value.
Statement 1
- A limit buy order at USD 50.00 prevents execution above that price but does not guarantee a fill.
- If shares are unavailable at USD 50.00 or less, the order may remain unfilled, delaying the desired exposure.
Statement 3
- Secondary-market volume alone does not fully measure liquidity for the proposed 80,000-share ETF purchase.
- Authorized participants can create or redeem shares using the underlying basket, so available liquidity can exceed what reported ETF volume suggests.
- Q2.3
Given the order size and market data, the most appropriate initial execution approach is to:
- ASubmit a market order immediately
- BSubmit a limit order near fair value
- CSplit the order across several weeks
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. Submit a limit order near fair value
Rationale
Submit a limit order near fair value
- A limit buy order near the USD 49.98 indicative value caps the purchase price while seeking prompt execution; the indicative value itself is not a guaranteed execution price.
- The 80,000-share order is 4% of average daily volume, and authorized participants can provide liquidity beyond displayed ETF depth, so a lengthy delay is not warranted.
Submit a market order immediately
- A market order provides immediate access but no price protection for the 80,000-share purchase.
- The displayed ask of USD 50.02 does not guarantee that the entire order will execute at that price.
Split the order across several weeks
- Spreading the order over weeks would unnecessarily delay the immediate index exposure Northbridge needs.
- At 4% of average daily volume, the order does not, on these facts, require weeks to execute; ETF liquidity can also extend beyond displayed volume.
- Q2.4
Ignoring commissions, taxes, and basis changes, the lower-cost one-year implementation is most likely:
- AThe ETF, by 68 bps
- BThe futures, by 68 bps
- CThe futures, by 50 bps
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. The futures, by 68 bps
Rationale
The futures, by 68 bps
- The ETF costs 5.28% for one year: the investor’s 5.10% cash financing rate plus the 0.18% fund expense ratio in Exhibit 1.
- Futures cost 4.60% at the implied financing rate, making them cheaper by 5.28% − 4.60% = 0.68%, or 68 bps.
The ETF, by 68 bps
- The 68 bp difference is correct, but its direction is reversed: the ETF’s 5.28% cost exceeds the futures’ 4.60% cost.
- The ETF incurs both the investor’s cash financing rate and the fund expense ratio; the futures position has no ETF expense ratio.
The futures, by 50 bps
- The 50 bp figure comes from comparing financing rates alone: 5.10% − 4.60% = 0.50%.
- Omitting the ETF’s 18 bp expense ratio understates the futures’ one-year cost advantage, which is 50 + 18 = 68 bps.
- Q2.5
True or False: The ETF's creation unit size of 50,000 shares prevents Patel from purchasing 80,000 shares in the secondary market.
- ATrue
- BFalse
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. False
Rationale
False
- The 50,000-share creation unit governs authorized participants’ primary-market creations and redemptions, not the size of secondary-market purchases.
- Patel can purchase 80,000 shares in the secondary market, subject to available liquidity and execution price.
True
- This confuses the ETF’s primary-market creation unit with a minimum or required multiple for secondary-market trades.
- The case expressly states that creation unit size does not prevent secondary-market purchases in other quantities.
- Q2.6Select all that apply
Which of the following are advantages of using index futures rather than the ETF for this one-year exposure, based on Exhibit 1? (Select all that apply)
- AFutures avoid the ETF's annual expense ratio
- BFutures embed a lower implied financing rate than the investor's cash financing rate
- CFutures eliminate quoted bid-ask spread entirely
- DFutures avoid taxable events entirely regardless of holding period
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. Futures avoid the ETF's annual expense ratio; B. Futures embed a lower implied financing rate than the investor's cash financing rate
Rationale
Select
Futures avoid the ETF's annual expense ratio
- Exhibit 1 lists an 18 bps annual ETF expense ratio, which the futures position does not incur.
- For the one-year exposure, avoiding that expense contributes to the futures position’s lower stated cost.
Futures embed a lower implied financing rate than the investor's cash financing rate
- Exhibit 1 shows 4.60% implied futures financing versus 5.10% cash financing for the ETF purchase.
- Including the ETF’s 18 bps expense ratio gives a stated annual cost of 5.28% for the ETF versus 4.60% for futures.
Do not select
Futures eliminate quoted bid-ask spread entirely
- Futures can also have bid-ask spreads; using futures does not eliminate trading spreads.
- Exhibit 1 provides ETF bid and ask quotes but no futures spread that would support a zero-spread claim.
Futures avoid taxable events entirely regardless of holding period
- The comparison assumes taxes are zero; it does not establish that futures cannot generate taxable events.
- Nothing in Exhibit 1 supports a tax exemption for futures regardless of holding period.
Show case rationale
Rationale
ETF execution depends on the quoted spread, price control, and liquidity beyond displayed volume.
- The ETF Market and Portfolio Data give a midpoint of USD 49.98 and a spread of USD 0.08, so the quoted spread is 0.08 ÷ 49.98 × 10,000 ≈ 16 bps; the indicative value estimates basket value but does not guarantee an execution price.
- Statement 2 is accurate because an ETF premium can attract authorized participants to deliver the underlying basket and create shares; the 50,000-share creation unit does not prevent an 80,000-share secondary-market purchase.
Futures have the lower stated one-year implementation cost.
- Financing the ETF costs 5.10% + 0.18% = 5.28%, versus the futures’ 4.60% implied financing rate, making futures cheaper by 68 bps under the stated assumptions.
- Futures avoid the ETF expense ratio and embed a lower financing rate, but neither advantage means futures have no bid–ask spread or avoid taxable events regardless of holding period.
Traps in this case
Confusing a price limit with guaranteed execution
- A limit buy order near USD 49.98 controls the maximum price without planning an unnecessary weeks-long delay, but it may remain unfilled; a market order offers immediacy without price protection.
Treating displayed volume as total ETF liquidity
- Statement 3 is inaccurate because authorized participants can create or redeem shares using the underlying basket, so secondary-market volume alone does not fully measure available liquidity.
Omitting the ETF expense ratio
- Comparing only the financing rates yields 50 bps (5.10% − 4.60%), but adding the ETF’s 18 bps expense ratio produces the 68-bp futures advantage.