Code of Ethics and Standards of Professional Conduct — MCQs

On this page

9 questions
2 chapters
Q1Easy

With no legal retention requirement, a firm's policy preserves research records for five years. An analyst accurately describes the policy to clients. Which action is most appropriate?

Q2Easy

Local law permits conduct prohibited by the CFA Institute Standards. The investment manager should most likely:

Q3Easy

An adviser receives a fixed fee from a tax firm for each referred prospect who becomes a client. The adviser should most likely:

Q4Unfolding case study

Ravi Patel is a portfolio manager at Halcyon Wealth Management. Halcyon's personal-trading policy permits employee participation in public offerings only after all client expressions of interest have been satisfied. Patel and several clients request shares in an oversubscribed offering. Before entering the client orders, Patel adds his own smaller order to the allocation list. All participants receive the same execution price, but including Patel's order reduces each client's allocation. Patel manages a charitable foundation under a standard fee schedule. During the holiday season, the foundation's chair gives Patel tickets to a sporting event worth USD 150 and, at a separate meeting, treats him to a business dinner valued at USD 200; both gestures are customary and reasonably related to Halcyon's business. Halcyon's gift policy requires employees to disclose to the firm any gift or entertainment received from a client that has an aggregate value exceeding USD 250 in a calendar year. Patel does not disclose either item to Halcyon because he believes that, since neither item individually exceeded the threshold, no disclosure is required. Patel is also considering establishing an independent advisory firm. Before resigning, he leases office space, registers a business name, and purchases computer equipment on his own time. He has not solicited any Halcyon clients. He is considering copying contact information and portfolio histories from Halcyon's files because he originally introduced many of the clients to the firm. Halcyon's employment agreement identifies client records as firm property but contains no post-employment non-compete provision. One client, a financially sophisticated entrepreneur, has a written investment policy statement limiting aggregate exposure to early-stage technology companies to 20% of portfolio value. Existing holdings in that sector represent 18%. Patel proposes purchasing an additional position equal to 6% of portfolio value after concluding that the individual security is attractive and liquid. The client has not requested a change to the policy and has not approved an exception. Patel reasons that the transaction is suitable because the new security itself represents less than 20% of the portfolio and the client understands the associated risks.

  1. Q4.1

    Patel's allocation of the oversubscribed offering most likely:

    1. AAcceptable because the personal order was smaller than the client orders
    2. BA violation because client transactions must receive priority
    3. CAcceptable because the allocation price was identical for all accounts
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. A violation because client transactions must receive priority

    Rationale

    A violation because client transactions must receive priority

    • Halcyon permits employees to participate in public offerings only after all client expressions of interest have been satisfied.
    • Patel added his personal order before entering client orders, and its inclusion reduced each client’s allocation in the oversubscribed offering.

    Acceptable because the personal order was smaller than the client orders

    • The size of Patel’s order does not override the requirement to satisfy client interest first.
    • Even a smaller personal order reduced the shares allocated to clients.

    Acceptable because the allocation price was identical for all accounts

    • An identical execution price does not make the allocation compliant when clients receive fewer shares.
    • The violation concerns Patel’s priority in an oversubscribed offering, not the price paid by each account.
  2. Q4.2

    Patel's decision not to disclose the tickets and the dinner to Halcyon most likely:

    1. AA violation because the aggregate value of the gifts exceeded Halcyon's disclosure threshold
    2. BAcceptable because each individual gift was below the disclosure threshold
    3. CAcceptable because gifts and entertainment from clients are never subject to firm disclosure policies
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. A violation because the aggregate value of the gifts exceeded Halcyon's disclosure threshold

    Rationale

    A violation because the aggregate value of the gifts exceeded Halcyon's disclosure threshold

    • The tickets and dinner total USD 350 (USD 150 + USD 200), exceeding Halcyon’s USD 250 calendar-year disclosure threshold.
    • Patel therefore had to disclose the client’s gifts and entertainment even though both gestures were customary and business-related.

    Acceptable because each individual gift was below the disclosure threshold

    • The USD 150 tickets and USD 200 dinner were each below USD 250, but Halcyon’s policy applies to their aggregate value.
    • Treating the items separately overlooks their USD 350 combined value in the calendar year.

    Acceptable because gifts and entertainment from clients are never subject to firm disclosure policies

    • Halcyon’s policy expressly covers gifts and entertainment from clients, including these tickets and dinner from the foundation’s chair.
    • Their customary, business-related nature does not exempt Patel from the firm’s disclosure requirement.
  3. Q4.3

    While still employed by Halcyon, Patel may most appropriately:

    1. ACopy Halcyon's client files before resigning because Patel developed the relationships
    2. BSolicit Halcyon clients before resigning if he avoids using written records
    3. CPrepare to compete without taking records or soliciting clients before departure
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Prepare to compete without taking records or soliciting clients before departure

    Rationale

    Prepare to compete without taking records or soliciting clients before departure

    • Under the CFA Institute duty of loyalty to an employer, Patel may prepare to compete by leasing office space, registering a business name, and buying equipment on his own time.
    • He must not take Halcyon’s records or solicit its clients while still employed.

    Copy Halcyon's client files before resigning because Patel developed the relationships

    • Halcyon’s employment agreement identifies client records as firm property, even for clients Patel originally introduced.
    • The absence of a post-employment non-compete provision does not give Patel permission to copy contact information or portfolio histories.

    Solicit Halcyon clients before resigning if he avoids using written records

    • Soliciting clients before departure breaches Patel’s duty of loyalty even if he uses no written records.
    • Patel may prepare his independent firm now, but must wait until after leaving Halcyon to solicit its clients.
  4. Q4.4

    Patel's proposed additional purchase for the entrepreneur is most likely:

    1. AAppropriate because the client is financially sophisticated
    2. BInappropriate because the total position exceeds the portfolio constraint
    3. CAppropriate because each purchase is individually below the limit
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Inappropriate because the total position exceeds the portfolio constraint

    Rationale

    Inappropriate because the total position exceeds the portfolio constraint

    • The existing 18% early-stage technology exposure plus the proposed 6% position would bring aggregate exposure to 24%, above the written 20% limit.
    • The client has neither changed the investment policy statement nor approved an exception, so Patel should not make the purchase as proposed.

    Appropriate because the client is financially sophisticated

    • The entrepreneur’s sophistication does not override the written 20% aggregate exposure limit.
    • Understanding the risks of the new security does not amount to approving an exception to that limit.

    Appropriate because each purchase is individually below the limit

    • The 20% limit applies to the portfolio’s total early-stage technology exposure, not to each purchase separately.
    • Although the proposed position is only 6%, it would raise the existing 18% exposure to 24%.
  5. Q4.5Select all that apply

    Which of the following actions by Patel most likely represent violations of the CFA Institute Standards of Professional Conduct? (Select all that apply.)

    1. APatel's inclusion of his personal order in the offering allocation
    2. BPatel's failure to disclose the aggregate value of the foundation chair's gifts to Halcyon
    3. CPatel's plan to purchase additional shares for the entrepreneur without obtaining approval for an exception to the policy
    4. DPatel's leasing office space and purchasing equipment on his own time before resigning
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Patel's inclusion of his personal order in the offering allocation; B. Patel's failure to disclose the aggregate value of the foundation chair's gifts to Halcyon; C. Patel's plan to purchase additional shares for the entrepreneur without obtaining approval for an exception to the policy

    Rationale

    Select

    Patel's inclusion of his personal order in the offering allocation

    • Halcyon permits employee participation only after all client expressions of interest have been satisfied, but Patel added his order before entering the client orders.
    • His order reduced each client's allocation in the oversubscribed offering; the same execution price does not cure that disadvantage.

    Patel's failure to disclose the aggregate value of the foundation chair's gifts to Halcyon

    • The tickets and dinner totaled USD 350 (USD 150 + USD 200), exceeding Halcyon's USD 250 calendar-year disclosure threshold.
    • The policy applies to the aggregate value, so neither item's being below USD 250 individually excuses Patel's nondisclosure.

    Patel's plan to purchase additional shares for the entrepreneur without obtaining approval for an exception to the policy

    • The proposed 6% position would raise early-stage technology exposure from 18% to 24%, above the written 20% limit.
    • The client's sophistication and the security's liquidity do not replace approval for an exception to the investment policy.

    Do not select

    Patel's leasing office space and purchasing equipment on his own time before resigning

    • Leasing space and buying equipment on his own time are permissible preparatory steps for a future business, and Patel has not solicited Halcyon clients.
    • Copying Halcyon's client records would raise a separate concern because the employment agreement identifies them as firm property, but Patel has only considered doing so.
  6. Q4.6

    True or False: Because Patel originally introduced many of the clients to Halcyon, copying their contact information and portfolio histories before resigning would comply with his duty of loyalty under Standard IV(A).

    1. ATrue
    2. BFalse
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. False

    Rationale

    False

    • Under Standard IV(A), copying Halcyon’s client contact information and portfolio histories before resigning would breach Patel’s duty of loyalty because the employment agreement identifies those records as firm property.
    • Patel may prepare to establish his own firm on his own time, but he may not take Halcyon’s records without authorization.

    True

    • Patel’s having introduced many clients to Halcyon does not give him ownership of their records in Halcyon’s files.
    • The absence of a post-employment non-compete provision does not permit him to copy firm property before leaving.
Show case rationale

Rationale

Client priority and Halcyon’s aggregate gift threshold determine the offering and disclosure issues.

  • Patel violated client priority by adding his personal order to an oversubscribed offering before satisfying client interest, reducing client allocations despite the identical execution price.
  • The foundation chair’s USD 150 tickets and USD 200 dinner total USD 350 in the calendar year, exceeding Halcyon’s USD 250 disclosure threshold even though each item is individually below it.

Preparing to leave is permitted; taking firm records or disregarding a client mandate is not.

  • Patel may lease space and buy equipment on his own time without soliciting clients, but Halcyon’s client files remain firm property even for relationships he introduced.
  • The proposed purchase would raise early-stage technology exposure from 18% to 24%, exceeding the investment policy statement’s 20% aggregate limit without an approved exception.

Traps in this case

Equal price makes the personal allocation acceptable

  • The harm is the smaller client allocations, not a difference in execution price.

Each gift falls below the disclosure threshold

  • Halcyon’s policy tests aggregate calendar-year value, not each occasion separately.

Client sophistication or an attractive security overrides the policy

  • Neither changes the 20% portfolio-level limit or supplies the client’s approval for an exception.
Q5Medium

An issuer offers an analyst a flat fee to produce independent research, regardless of the recommendation. Before accepting, the analyst should most likely:

Q6Unfolding case study

Amara Okafor is a portfolio manager at Northbridge Advisory. She manages institutional accounts and is paid a salary plus a bonus based on Northbridge's overall profitability. One pension-fund client offers to pay Okafor a separate year-end bonus if its account outperforms its policy benchmark by at least 150 basis points. The proposed payment could encourage Okafor to allocate more time and attractive investment opportunities to that client than to Northbridge's other clients. The pension fund sends Okafor a written offer, but neither Okafor nor the client has informed Northbridge. Okafor plans to accept the payment after mentioning it informally to her supervisor. Northbridge is preparing to recommend shares of Lumina Health to suitable discretionary accounts. The recommendation is based entirely on public information and has been approved for release the following morning. Okafor wishes to purchase Lumina shares for her personal account, in which she has a beneficial interest. Northbridge's procedures permit employee purchases after all client orders generated by a new recommendation have been entered and given a reasonable opportunity for execution. Okafor considers submitting her personal order at the same time as the aggregated client order because all orders would receive the same average price. Okafor also wants to expand her private-client business. She agrees to pay an independent solicitor USD 750 for every prospective client who signs an advisory agreement with Northbridge. Northbridge permits referral arrangements, provided they comply with the CFA Institute Standards. The solicitor will not provide investment advice, and referred clients will pay Northbridge's standard fee. Okafor believes disclosure is unnecessary because the referral payment comes from her business-development budget rather than directly from the client's account. Two years ago, Okafor passed the Level I CFA examination and registered for Level II. She subsequently withdrew from the Level II examination and is not currently enrolled in the CFA Program. Her professional biography states, “Amara Okafor, CFA Level II, has completed the first stage of the CFA designation.” She has not earned the CFA charter and is not representing herself as a CFA charterholder elsewhere. A compliance officer asks Okafor to review the biography before it is used in a proposal to a prospective pension client.

  1. Q6.1

    Given that the pension fund's proposed bonus rewards outperformance of the benchmark by a specific margin, this arrangement most likely creates an additional concern under which CFA Institute Standard, separate from the consent required for accepting outside compensation?

    1. AStandard I(B), Independence and Objectivity, because the bonus could pressure her to take excessive risk to trigger the payout
    2. BStandard III(C), Suitability, because the arrangement requires immediate revision of the pension fund's investment policy statement
    3. CStandard V(B), Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients, because new performance reports must be issued solely for this account
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Standard I(B), Independence and Objectivity, because the bonus could pressure her to take excessive risk to trigger the payout

    Rationale

    Standard I(B), Independence and Objectivity, because the bonus could pressure her to take excessive risk to trigger the payout

    • A bonus triggered by exceeding the pension fund’s benchmark by 150 basis points could pressure Okafor to take inappropriate risk or favor that account over other clients.
    • This threat to objectivity is separate from Standard IV(B)’s requirement for written consent before she accepts compensation from the pension fund.

    Standard III(C), Suitability, because the arrangement requires immediate revision of the pension fund's investment policy statement

    • Okafor must continue to manage the account suitably, but the bonus offer alone does not require an immediate revision of its investment policy statement.
    • The additional concern is that the payout threshold could influence her decisions, not that the pension fund’s investment objectives have changed.

    Standard V(B), Communication with Clients and Prospective Clients, because new performance reports must be issued solely for this account

    • The proposed bonus does not, by itself, require new performance reports solely for the pension fund’s account.
    • Its benchmark-linked payout instead raises the possibility that Okafor’s investment decisions will be influenced by her personal compensation.
  2. Q6.2

    Regarding the proposed Lumina transactions, Okafor should most likely:

    1. AEnter both orders simultaneously
    2. BEnter the client orders before her personal order
    3. CEnter her personal order before announcing the recommendation
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Enter the client orders before her personal order

    Rationale

    Enter the client orders before her personal order

    • Under the CFA Institute Standard on Priority of Transactions, orders for Northbridge’s clients take precedence over Okafor’s order for an account in which she has a beneficial interest.
    • Northbridge permits her purchase only after client orders arising from the Lumina recommendation have been entered and given a reasonable opportunity for execution.

    Enter both orders simultaneously

    • Simultaneous entry would let Okafor’s personal order compete with client orders, even if all orders received the same average price.
    • A shared price does not satisfy Northbridge’s requirement to give client orders a reasonable opportunity for execution before an employee purchase.

    Enter her personal order before announcing the recommendation

    • Buying before the Lumina recommendation is released would put Okafor’s personal transaction ahead of the client orders it is expected to generate.
    • The recommendation’s reliance on public information does not remove her obligation to give client transactions priority.
  3. Q6.3

    Okafor's most appropriate treatment of the solicitor arrangement is to:

    1. ADisclose the referral arrangement to prospective clients
    2. BDisclose the arrangement only if a referred client asks
    3. CMake no disclosure because clients pay no separate referral fee
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Disclose the referral arrangement to prospective clients

    Rationale

    Disclose the referral arrangement to prospective clients

    • Under the CFA Institute’s referral-fee standard, Okafor must disclose the USD 750 payment for each prospective client who signs an advisory agreement with Northbridge.
    • Disclosure lets prospective clients assess the solicitor’s incentive to refer them before they decide whether to engage Northbridge.

    Disclose the arrangement only if a referred client asks

    • The referral-fee standard requires proactive disclosure; Okafor cannot wait for a prospective client to ask.
    • The solicitor’s payment depends on a signed advisory agreement, so the incentive matters while the client is considering Northbridge.

    Make no disclosure because clients pay no separate referral fee

    • The duty to disclose applies even though Okafor pays the solicitor from her business-development budget and referred clients pay Northbridge’s standard fee.
    • What matters is the referral incentive, not whether a separate charge appears on the client’s account.
  4. Q6.4

    Okafor should most appropriately revise her biography to:

    1. ARetain the description because she passed one examination
    2. BReplace it with “CFA, Level II” after paying annual dues
    3. CState that she passed Level I and is not currently a candidate
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. State that she passed Level I and is not currently a candidate

    Rationale

    State that she passed Level I and is not currently a candidate

    • Okafor may accurately state that she passed Level I of the CFA examination two years ago.
    • Because she withdrew from Level II and is not currently enrolled, she must not imply that she is a current candidate or holds a CFA designation.

    Retain the description because she passed one examination

    • Passing Level I does not make “CFA Level II” an acceptable designation; no CFA designation is awarded by level.
    • Saying she “completed the first stage of the CFA designation” also misleadingly suggests that she has earned part of a designation.

    Replace it with “CFA, Level II” after paying annual dues

    • “CFA, Level II” still implies a designation Okafor has not earned.
    • Paying annual dues cannot confer the CFA charter or change the fact that she is not currently a candidate.
  5. Q6.5Ordered response

    Place in the correct order (first to last) the steps Northbridge's procedures require before Okafor may enter her personal order for Lumina shares.

    • Enter and fully aggregate the client orders generated by the recommendation
    • Approve and release the Lumina recommendation
    • Enter Okafor's personal order
    • Allow the client orders a reasonable opportunity for execution
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: 1. Approve and release the Lumina recommendation; 2. Enter and fully aggregate the client orders generated by the recommendation; 3. Allow the client orders a reasonable opportunity for execution; 4. Enter Okafor's personal order

    Rationale

    Approve and release the Lumina recommendation → Enter and fully aggregate the client orders generated by the recommendation → Allow the client orders a reasonable opportunity for execution → Enter Okafor's personal order

    • Northbridge’s procedures give client trades arising from a new recommendation priority over an employee’s trade in the same shares.
    • Under Standard VI(B), Priority of Transactions, Okafor must not place her personal interest ahead of clients’ interests.

    1. Approve and release the Lumina recommendation

    • Although Lumina has been approved for release the following morning, the recommendation must be released before orders generated by it can be processed.

    2. Enter and fully aggregate the client orders generated by the recommendation

    • Northbridge requires all client orders generated by the recommendation to be entered before an employee purchase.

    3. Allow the client orders a reasonable opportunity for execution

    • Entering the client orders alone is insufficient; they must have a reasonable opportunity for execution first.

    4. Enter Okafor's personal order

    • Okafor may enter her Lumina order only after those client-order conditions have been met.

    Common wrong orders

    Enter the personal order alongside client orders

    • Receiving the same average price does not replace Northbridge’s requirement that client orders have a reasonable opportunity for execution first.

    Enter client orders before releasing the recommendation

    • The required sequence begins with release of the Lumina recommendation, not with orders generated by an unreleased recommendation.
  6. Q6.6Matrix

    Match each situation in the vignette to the CFA Institute Standard it most directly implicates.

    FindingStandard IV(B) Additional Compensation ArrangementsStandard VI(B) Priority of TransactionsStandard VI(C) Referral FeesStandard VII(B) Reference to CFA Institute, the CFA Designation, and the CFA Program
    Pension fund performance bonus○○○○
    Lumina personal purchase○○○○
    Solicitor referral fee○○○○
    CFA Level II biography○○○○
    Show answer and rationale
    • Pension fund performance bonus: Standard IV(B) Additional Compensation Arrangements
    • Lumina personal purchase: Standard VI(B) Priority of Transactions
    • Solicitor referral fee: Standard VI(C) Referral Fees
    • CFA Level II biography: Standard VII(B) Reference to CFA Institute, the CFA Designation, and the CFA Program

    Rationale

    Pension fund performance bonus

    Standard IV(B) Additional Compensation Arrangements

    • The pension fund’s separate bonus could influence how Okafor allocates time and investment opportunities among Northbridge’s clients.
    • Standard IV(B) requires written consent from Northbridge before she accepts the arrangement; an informal mention to her supervisor is insufficient.

    Standard VI(B) Priority of Transactions

    • The issue is the pension fund’s proposed payment, not the timing of Okafor’s personal trades relative to client trades.

    Standard VI(C) Referral Fees

    • The pension fund is offering a performance bonus, not compensation for referring a client.

    Standard VII(B) Reference to CFA Institute, the CFA Designation, and the CFA Program

    • The bonus does not involve a claim about Okafor’s CFA Program status or designation.

    Lumina personal purchase

    Standard VI(B) Priority of Transactions

    • Okafor has a beneficial interest in her personal Lumina purchase, so client transactions must take priority.
    • The same average price does not justify submitting her order alongside client orders; Northbridge’s procedures require client orders to have a reasonable opportunity for execution first.

    Standard IV(B) Additional Compensation Arrangements

    • A purchase for Okafor’s own account is not additional compensation offered by a client or other outside party.

    Standard VI(C) Referral Fees

    • The Lumina order involves no payment for introducing a prospective client.

    Standard VII(B) Reference to CFA Institute, the CFA Designation, and the CFA Program

    • The timing of a personal securities purchase does not concern how Okafor describes her CFA Program status.

    Solicitor referral fee

    Standard VI(C) Referral Fees

    • Okafor’s agreement to pay USD 750 for each prospective client who signs an advisory agreement is a referral-fee arrangement.
    • She must disclose its nature and amount to Northbridge and affected prospective clients as appropriate, even though she pays it from her business-development budget.

    Standard IV(B) Additional Compensation Arrangements

    • Okafor is paying the solicitor for referrals, not receiving outside compensation that could conflict with her employer’s interests.

    Standard VI(B) Priority of Transactions

    • The referral arrangement does not concern whether Okafor’s personal trades precede client trades.

    Standard VII(B) Reference to CFA Institute, the CFA Designation, and the CFA Program

    • Whether the solicitor provides investment advice does not make this a question about CFA Program references.

    CFA Level II biography

    Standard VII(B) Reference to CFA Institute, the CFA Designation, and the CFA Program

    • “CFA Level II” and “completed the first stage of the CFA designation” improperly suggest a partial designation or current Program status.
    • Okafor may accurately state that she passed the Level I CFA examination, but she cannot imply she is currently a Level II candidate after withdrawing.

    Standard IV(B) Additional Compensation Arrangements

    • The biography describes Okafor’s credentials; it does not propose compensation from a source outside Northbridge.

    Standard VI(B) Priority of Transactions

    • No personal or client securities transaction is at issue in the proposed biography.

    Standard VI(C) Referral Fees

    • Using the biography in a proposal is not a payment for referring a prospective client.
Show case rationale

Rationale

The pension bonus creates a compensation conflict, and the Lumina trade must give clients priority.

  • The benchmark-linked bonus raises an independence and objectivity concern under Standard I(B) because it could encourage excessive risk; accepting it also requires written employer consent under Standard IV(B), not an informal mention to a supervisor.
  • Under Standard VI(B) and Northbridge’s procedures, the Lumina recommendation must be approved and released, client orders entered and aggregated, and those orders given a reasonable opportunity for execution before Okafor enters her personal order.

The referral payment requires disclosure, and the biography must describe Okafor’s actual CFA Program status.

  • Standard VI(C) requires disclosure of the USD 750 referral fee to prospective clients, even though referred clients pay Northbridge’s standard fee.
  • Under Standard VII(B), Okafor may say she passed Level I and is not currently a candidate; “CFA Level II” implies a status or designation she does not hold.

Traps in this case

Same average price for Lumina orders

  • A shared average price does not replace the required client-first sequence for a manager’s personal purchase.

No separate charge to referred clients

  • Disclosure concerns the solicitor’s referral consideration, not whether the client pays an additional fee.

Passing Level I creates a partial CFA designation

  • Passing one examination does not confer a CFA designation, and withdrawing from Level II means Okafor is not currently a candidate.
Q7Unfolding case study

Leena Patel is an equity analyst at Northbridge Securities. She follows Veridian Components, a listed manufacturer. Veridian has not issued updated earnings guidance, and no analyst at Northbridge has received advance financial results. During an industry conference, Patel speaks with the sales director of a small supplier to Veridian. The director privately comments that Veridian recently requested faster delivery of one minor component. Patel determines that purchases from this supplier represent less than 1% of Veridian's cost of goods sold and that the comment, standing alone, would not influence a reasonable investor. Publicly available customs records, employment advertisements, and distributor surveys indicate a broader increase in Veridian's production. Patel combines these public sources with the supplier's observation and develops an earnings estimate above consensus. Separately, Veridian's investor-relations officer telephones Patel and offers her a personal $2,000 honorarium, paid directly to Patel rather than to Northbridge, for participating in a private call with Veridian's chief financial officer before Patel's report is released. Northbridge's compliance manual requires that any compensation offered by a covered issuer be disclosed to and approved by the compliance department, and it prohibits analysts from accepting personal payments from issuers they cover. Patel considers accepting the honorarium and noting it only in her own expense log. While drafting the report, Patel's supervisor reviews her valuation and asks her to raise the price target so that it matches the expectations of a large investment-banking client, even though Patel's model does not support a higher figure. Patel's draft report describes historical revenue taken from Veridian's audited statements. It also states, without qualification, that Veridian will gain exactly two percentage points of market share next year. The market-share figure is Patel's model estimate, supported by documented assumptions and current industry data. Northbridge requires analysts to identify forecasts as opinions and retain the supporting research. Patel has accepted a position at another investment firm. Before leaving, she reviews several items she could take with her: a valuation template she built personally using Northbridge's systems and firm data feeds; a private diary in which she recorded her own career reflections and lessons learned, without client or firm data; copies of firm-wide industry reports authored by other Northbridge analysts; and a personal contact list of industry sources she cultivated over her career, some of whom she met before joining Northbridge. Northbridge's policy states that research records produced within the scope of employment belong to the firm, but it does not restrict an employee's general knowledge, skills, or personal, non-firm-specific materials.

  1. Q7.1

    Regarding Patel's use of the supplier's comment, her most appropriate action is to:

    1. ARefrain from publishing because the supplier's comment was nonpublic
    2. BUse the comment with public data in the earnings analysis
    3. CPublish only after obtaining the issuer's confirmation
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Use the comment with public data in the earnings analysis

    Rationale

    Use the comment with public data in the earnings analysis

    • The supplier’s private comment is nonpublic but immaterial: the component accounts for less than 1% of Veridian’s cost of goods sold, and the comment alone would not influence a reasonable investor.
    • Under mosaic theory, Patel may combine that observation with public customs records, employment advertisements, and distributor surveys to support an above-consensus earnings estimate.

    Refrain from publishing because the supplier's comment was nonpublic

    • The restriction concerns material nonpublic information, not every privately obtained observation.
    • The supplier’s request for faster delivery of one minor component is immaterial on its own, so it does not prevent Patel from using it in her analysis.

    Publish only after obtaining the issuer's confirmation

    • Issuer confirmation is not required to use an immaterial supplier observation alongside public information.
    • Patel can publish an estimate supported by her research without asking Veridian to validate the supplier’s comment or her earnings conclusion.
  2. Q7.2

    Patel's most appropriate response to Veridian's honorarium offer is to:

    1. AAccept the honorarium and note it only in her personal expense log
    2. BDecline the honorarium and report Veridian's offer to Northbridge compliance
    3. CAccept a reduced honorarium amount to lessen the conflict of interest
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Decline the honorarium and report Veridian's offer to Northbridge compliance

    Rationale

    Decline the honorarium and report Veridian's offer to Northbridge compliance

    • A personal $2,000 payment from Veridian, an issuer Patel covers, threatens her independence and objectivity before she releases her report.
    • Northbridge’s compliance manual prohibits personal payments from covered issuers and requires offers of compensation to be disclosed to compliance.

    Accept the honorarium and note it only in her personal expense log

    • An expense-log entry is not disclosure to Northbridge compliance, as the manual requires.
    • Keeping a private record does not cure the conflict created by accepting Veridian’s personal payment.

    Accept a reduced honorarium amount to lessen the conflict of interest

    • Northbridge prohibits personal payments from covered issuers regardless of their amount.
    • A smaller payment would still create a conflict concerning Patel’s coverage of Veridian and must be declined.
  3. Q7.3

    When her supervisor asks her to raise the price target to match the banking client's expectations, Patel should most appropriately:

    1. ARaise the price target and note in the file that it was requested by her supervisor
    2. BMaintain the price target supported by her own analysis and document the supervisor's request
    3. CAsk the banking client to justify why a higher price target is warranted
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Maintain the price target supported by her own analysis and document the supervisor's request

    Rationale

    Maintain the price target supported by her own analysis and document the supervisor's request

    • Patel’s valuation model does not support a higher target, so independence and objectivity require her to retain the target supported by her analysis.
    • Documenting the supervisor’s request preserves a record of the pressure to match the investment-banking client’s expectations.

    Raise the price target and note in the file that it was requested by her supervisor

    • Raising the target despite an unsupported valuation would let business pressure determine Patel’s research conclusion.
    • A note in the file does not make an unsupported price target appropriate.

    Ask the banking client to justify why a higher price target is warranted

    • The banking client’s expectations are not valuation evidence supporting a higher price target.
    • Asking the client for a justification does not resolve the supervisor’s request to depart from Patel’s own analysis.
  4. Q7.4

    Regarding the market-share estimate, Patel should most appropriately:

    1. ARemove the market-share estimate until audited data are available
    2. BIdentify the estimate as an opinion and retain its supporting analysis
    3. CPresent the estimate as a fact because the model is documented
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Identify the estimate as an opinion and retain its supporting analysis

    Rationale

    Identify the estimate as an opinion and retain its supporting analysis

    • The two-percentage-point market-share gain is a forecast, unlike the historical revenue taken from Veridian’s audited statements.
    • Patel should label it as an opinion and retain the documented assumptions and current industry data that support it.

    Remove the market-share estimate until audited data are available

    • Audited data are not required for a forecast that has a reasonable basis and is identified as an opinion.
    • Patel already has documented assumptions and current industry data supporting the estimate, so removing it is unnecessary.

    Present the estimate as a fact because the model is documented

    • A documented model supports Patel’s analysis but does not make a prediction about next year’s market share a fact.
    • Stating that Veridian will gain exactly two percentage points without qualification fails to distinguish the estimate from historical revenue.
  5. Q7.5

    Which of the following groups of items may Patel appropriately take with her to her new employer?

    1. AThe valuation template she built using Northbridge's systems and data feeds, along with copies of firm-wide industry reports authored by other Northbridge analysts
    2. BHer private diary containing personal career reflections and lessons learned, along with her personal contact list of industry sources cultivated over her career
    3. CCopies of firm-wide industry reports authored by other Northbridge analysts, along with the valuation template built using Northbridge's systems
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Her private diary containing personal career reflections and lessons learned, along with her personal contact list of industry sources cultivated over her career

    Rationale

    Her private diary containing personal career reflections and lessons learned, along with her personal contact list of industry sources cultivated over her career

    • Patel’s diary contains no client or firm data, so it is personal, non-firm-specific material rather than a Northbridge research record.
    • Her personal contact list reflects relationships cultivated over her career, and Northbridge’s policy does not restrict employees from taking personal materials or using their general knowledge and skills.

    The valuation template she built using Northbridge's systems and data feeds, along with copies of firm-wide industry reports authored by other Northbridge analysts

    • Building the template herself does not make it personal property: she created it using Northbridge’s systems and data feeds within the scope of her work.
    • The firm-wide reports are other analysts’ research records, not Patel’s personal materials, and she may not take copies to her new employer.

    Copies of firm-wide industry reports authored by other Northbridge analysts, along with the valuation template built using Northbridge's systems

    • Reversing the order changes nothing: the industry reports remain Northbridge research records authored by its analysts.
    • The template also remains firm work product despite Patel’s authorship because it was built using Northbridge’s systems and data feeds.
  6. Q7.6

    Which of the following correctly orders the actions Patel should complete when preparing her research report on Veridian, from first to last?

    1. AVerify materiality of the supplier's comment; incorporate the verified data into the earnings estimate; label the market-share estimate as an opinion; submit the report for compliance review
    2. BIncorporate the supplier's comment into the earnings estimate; verify materiality afterward; submit the report for compliance review; label the market-share estimate as an opinion
    3. CLabel the market-share estimate as an opinion; submit the report for compliance review; verify materiality of the supplier's comment; incorporate the verified data into the earnings estimate
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Verify materiality of the supplier's comment; incorporate the verified data into the earnings estimate; label the market-share estimate as an opinion; submit the report for compliance review

    Rationale

    Verify materiality of the supplier's comment; incorporate the verified data into the earnings estimate; label the market-share estimate as an opinion; submit the report for compliance review

    • Patel must first establish that the supplier’s comment is not material on its own; she can then combine it with the public customs records, employment advertisements, and distributor surveys in her earnings estimate.
    • Before compliance review, she must identify the projected two-percentage-point market-share gain as an opinion, rather than present it as a fact.

    Incorporate the supplier's comment into the earnings estimate; verify materiality afterward; submit the report for compliance review; label the market-share estimate as an opinion

    • Using the private supplier comment before assessing materiality risks incorporating material nonpublic information into Patel’s estimate.
    • Submitting the report for compliance review before labeling the market-share forecast leaves a model estimate stated as an unqualified fact.

    Label the market-share estimate as an opinion; submit the report for compliance review; verify materiality of the supplier's comment; incorporate the verified data into the earnings estimate

    • Labeling the forecast is necessary, but it does not replace the initial materiality assessment of the private supplier comment.
    • Compliance review should follow incorporation of the verified information, not precede the resulting earnings estimate.
Show case rationale

Rationale

Patel may use the supplier’s immaterial observation in a research mosaic, but must distinguish supported forecasts from facts.

  • The supplier’s faster-delivery comment concerns less than 1% of cost of goods sold and would not alone influence a reasonable investor, so Patel may combine it with public customs records, job advertisements, and distributor surveys.
  • She should assess the comment’s materiality, incorporate the usable evidence into her earnings estimate, label the two-percentage-point market-share forecast as an opinion, retain its support, and then submit the report for compliance review.

Patel must preserve independent analysis and distinguish personal materials from Northbridge’s research records.

  • She must decline and report Veridian’s personal $2,000 honorarium, and maintain her model-supported price target while documenting her supervisor’s unsupported request.
  • She may take her private career diary and personal industry-source contact list, but not the valuation template built with Northbridge’s systems and data feeds or other analysts’ firm-wide reports.

Traps in this case

Treating all nonpublic information as prohibited

  • The supplier’s privately shared observation is immaterial on its own, unlike material nonpublic information that Patel could not use in a report.

Treating a documented forecast as an established fact

  • Documented assumptions support Patel’s market-share estimate, but they do not turn a prediction about next year into audited historical data.

Treating work created personally as personal property

  • Patel built the valuation template herself, but its use of Northbridge’s systems and data feeds makes it a firm research record under Northbridge’s policy.
Q8Unfolding case study

Lydian Asset Management manages equity, fixed-income, and multi-asset mandates. Its compliance committee proposes stating in all marketing materials that Lydian complies with the Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct. The equity division has implemented all applicable provisions, including policies for client communication, trading, risk management, and performance reporting. The fixed-income division has not yet adopted the required business-continuity procedures, and the multi-asset division does not provide clients with the prescribed disclosures concerning soft-dollar arrangements. The committee proposes limiting the claim to the equity division or, alternatively, making a firmwide claim accompanied by a list of provisions not yet implemented. During a separate review, compliance officer Daniel Foster discovers an error in an institutional equity composite. An account that fell below the composite's minimum asset threshold during the second half of 2023 was nevertheless retained in the composite for that period, and its outsized gains modestly inflated the composite's reported 2023 return. Lydian's marketing team has already provided the inflated composite presentation to three prospective clients. No existing client invested based on the presentation. Foster proposes correcting the historical composite and sending the revised presentation to the prospects together with an explanation of the error. Lydian also has discretionary authority to vote proxies for several frontier-market accounts. Its disclosed proxy policy states that voting decisions will seek to maximize client value and that Lydian may refrain from voting when administrative or custodial costs are expected to exceed the economic benefit. For an upcoming routine vote, local custodians would charge USD 18,000 in aggregate processing fees. The portfolio team reasonably estimates that voting could add no more than USD 4,000 in expected client value. The governing investment management agreements do not require voting on every proposal. Foster has passed Level II of the CFA Program and is registered for the next Level III examination. He has not earned the CFA charter. The marketing director asks him to select a biography statement for a request for proposal. Foster considers stating either that he passed Level II and is registered for the next examination, that he is virtually certain to earn the charter once he sits for the Level III examination, or that his CFA candidacy demonstrates an ability to outperform benchmarks. Lydian's compliance manual requires biographies to describe professional credentials accurately and prohibits performance guarantees.

  1. Q8.1

    Regarding Lydian's proposed Asset Manager Code claim, compliance should most likely:

    1. ARefrain from claiming compliance until the Code is implemented firmwide
    2. BClaim compliance for the equity division that follows the relevant provisions
    3. CClaim compliance if the omitted provisions are disclosed to prospective clients
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Refrain from claiming compliance until the Code is implemented firmwide

    Rationale

    Refrain from claiming compliance until the Code is implemented firmwide

    • An Asset Manager Code compliance claim requires Lydian to implement all applicable provisions throughout the firm.
    • The fixed-income division lacks required business-continuity procedures, and the multi-asset division omits prescribed soft-dollar disclosures, so a firmwide claim is premature.

    Claim compliance for the equity division that follows the relevant provisions

    • The equity division has implemented its applicable provisions, but the proposed claim would cover only one division of Lydian.
    • The Asset Manager Code does not permit Lydian to claim partial compliance while its other divisions have not implemented applicable provisions.

    Claim compliance if the omitted provisions are disclosed to prospective clients

    • Listing the missing business-continuity procedures and soft-dollar disclosures would identify Lydian’s unimplemented provisions, not satisfy them.
    • Disclosure to prospective clients cannot make a firmwide Asset Manager Code compliance claim valid before those provisions are implemented.
  2. Q8.2

    After discovering the composite error, Lydian should most appropriately:

    1. AContinue using the presentation because the outsized gains were legitimate performance
    2. BCorrect the composite history and provide the revised presentation to affected prospects
    3. CRemove every account that ever fell below the minimum threshold from all prior and future composite returns
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Correct the composite history and provide the revised presentation to affected prospects

    Rationale

    Correct the composite history and provide the revised presentation to affected prospects

    • The account fell below the composite’s minimum asset threshold in the second half of 2023, so retaining it for that period inflated the reported return.
    • Lydian should correct the history and send the revised presentation, with an explanation of the error, to the three prospects who received the inaccurate version.

    Continue using the presentation because the outsized gains were legitimate performance

    • The gains may have been genuine, but the account’s eligibility, not the legitimacy of its gains, determines whether it belongs in the composite.
    • Continuing to use a presentation with an inflated 2023 return would leave prospective clients with inaccurate performance information.

    Remove every account that ever fell below the minimum threshold from all prior and future composite returns

    • Falling below the threshold in the second half of 2023 does not erase periods when an account met the composite criteria.
    • Blanket removal from all prior and future returns would distort the record rather than correct the periods affected by the error.
  3. Q8.3

    Under Lydian's disclosed proxy policy, the frontier-market proxies should most likely be:

    1. AVote every proxy because voting rights are assets belonging to clients
    2. BAbstain only after obtaining consent from each affected client
    3. CAbstain when expected client benefits do not justify the voting costs
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Abstain when expected client benefits do not justify the voting costs

    Rationale

    Abstain when expected client benefits do not justify the voting costs

    • Lydian’s disclosed proxy policy permits abstention when voting costs exceed expected client benefits, and the USD 18,000 in fees exceeds the estimated maximum USD 4,000 benefit.
    • The vote is routine, and the investment management agreements do not require Lydian to vote on every proposal.

    Vote every proxy because voting rights are assets belonging to clients

    • Voting rights belong to clients, but exercising them on every proposal is not required when the expected costs outweigh the benefits.
    • Here, voting would incur USD 18,000 in fees for no more than USD 4,000 in expected client value.

    Abstain only after obtaining consent from each affected client

    • Individual consent is not required for abstention under Lydian’s disclosed proxy policy when abstaining serves clients’ interests.
    • The investment management agreements do not require voting on every proposal, so the unfavorable cost–benefit assessment supports abstention without seeking separate consent.
  4. Q8.4

    Which statement by Foster is least likely to violate the Standards?

    1. A“I passed Level II and am registered for the next Level III examination.”
    2. B“I am virtually certain to earn my CFA charter after sitting for the Level III examination.”
    3. C“My CFA candidacy demonstrates that my portfolios should outperform their benchmarks.”
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. “I passed Level II and am registered for the next Level III examination.”

    Rationale

    “I passed Level II and am registered for the next Level III examination.”

    • Foster has passed Level II and is registered for the next Level III examination, so both claims accurately describe his CFA Program status.
    • The statement does not imply that he has earned the charter or guarantee a future result.

    “I am virtually certain to earn my CFA charter after sitting for the Level III examination.”

    • Sitting for Level III does not establish that Foster will pass it or earn the charter.
    • Claiming near-certainty misrepresents an uncertain future qualification, contrary to the requirement to describe credentials accurately.

    “My CFA candidacy demonstrates that my portfolios should outperform their benchmarks.”

    • CFA candidacy does not establish that Foster’s portfolios will outperform their benchmarks.
    • The claimed performance implication misrepresents the significance of candidacy and conflicts with Lydian’s prohibition on performance guarantees.
  5. Q8.5Select all that apply

    Which of the following steps must Lydian complete before it can accurately claim full firmwide compliance with the Asset Manager Code? (Select all that apply.)

    1. AAdopt the required business-continuity procedures in the fixed-income division
    2. BProvide clients with the prescribed soft-dollar disclosures in the multi-asset division
    3. CDiscontinue offering multi-asset mandates entirely
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Adopt the required business-continuity procedures in the fixed-income division; B. Provide clients with the prescribed soft-dollar disclosures in the multi-asset division

    Rationale

    Select

    Adopt the required business-continuity procedures in the fixed-income division

    • Lydian cannot claim firmwide compliance while its fixed-income division lacks required business-continuity procedures.
    • The equity division’s compliance does not cure a missing provision in another division.

    Provide clients with the prescribed soft-dollar disclosures in the multi-asset division

    • The multi-asset division must provide the required soft-dollar disclosures before Lydian makes a firmwide compliance claim.
    • Listing unimplemented provisions alongside that claim does not make the claim accurate.

    Do not select

    Discontinue offering multi-asset mandates entirely

    • The Asset Manager Code requires Lydian to address the multi-asset division’s missing disclosures, not discontinue its mandates.
    • Lydian can retain those mandates and claim firmwide compliance once every division implements its applicable provisions.
  6. Q8.6

    True or False: Because the governing investment management agreements do not obligate Lydian to vote on every proposal, Lydian's decision to abstain from the frontier-market proxy vote due to cost considerations is consistent with its fiduciary duties under the disclosed proxy voting policy.

    1. ATrue
    2. BFalse
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. True

    Rationale

    True

    • Lydian’s disclosed policy permits abstaining when voting costs exceed the expected benefit to clients, and the USD 18,000 processing fees exceed the vote’s maximum estimated value of USD 4,000.
    • Because the governing agreements do not require a vote on every proposal, abstaining from this routine vote is consistent with the disclosed, client-focused policy.

    False

    • Fiduciary duty does not require Lydian to vote every proxy regardless of cost, particularly when the governing agreements impose no universal voting obligation.
    • This choice overlooks the disclosed cost-benefit exception: the expected voting benefit is at most USD 4,000, well below the USD 18,000 fees.
Show case rationale

Rationale

Asset Manager Code compliance requires implementation across Lydian, not just its equity division.

  • The fixed-income division must adopt the required business-continuity procedures, and the multi-asset division must provide the prescribed soft-dollar disclosures, before Lydian claims firmwide compliance.
  • Neither an equity-only claim nor a firmwide claim listing omitted provisions cures incomplete implementation; Lydian need not discontinue multi-asset mandates.

Accurate performance reporting and client-focused voting decisions govern the remaining conduct.

  • Lydian must correct the 2023 composite after the below-threshold account inflated its return, then send the revised presentation and an explanation to the three affected prospects.
  • Under its disclosed policy, Lydian may abstain from the routine proxy vote: expected client value is at most USD 4,000, versus USD 18,000 in fees, and the agreements do not require every vote.

Traps in this case

Legitimate gains make the inflated composite acceptable

  • The gains were real, but retaining the account after it fell below the minimum threshold made the reported composite return inaccurate; the absence of reliance by existing clients does not excuse the presentation sent to prospects.

Voting rights require a vote or individual consent to abstain

  • Client interests govern the decision, and Lydian’s disclosed policy permits abstention when voting costs exceed expected benefits without requiring consent from each client.

CFA candidacy predicts a charter or benchmark outperformance

  • Foster may accurately state that he passed Level II and is registered for Level III, but he has neither earned the charter nor established that his candidacy predicts investment results.
Q9Unfolding case study

Sofia Ramos is head of research at Apex Capital and supervises analyst Noah Ellis. Apex requires employees to preclear personal trades and prohibits trading in securities on an analyst's restricted list. Ramos delegated daily review of preclearance requests to an operations employee but did not periodically test whether the reviews were completed. She learns that the employee was absent for three weeks and that the electronic system automatically approved requests during that period. Ellis executed several personal trades while covering the same issuers, although Ramos has not yet determined whether the transactions conflicted with client activity or restricted-list rules. Ellis has passed Level II of the CFA Program and is registered for the next Level III examination. His résumé states, “Passed Level II of the CFA Program,” and his professional profile describes him as a “2026 Level III CFA candidate.” His new business card, however, displays “Noah Ellis, CFA, Level II.” Ellis believes the wording is acceptable because it communicates his progress and does not expressly state that he is a charterholder. Ellis is preparing to change his recommendation on Veridian Industries from hold to buy. Apex offers premium clients detailed reports and basic-service clients shorter research summaries; these service differences are disclosed in advance and reflected in client fees. Both versions contain the same recommendation and are scheduled for release at 10:00 a.m. Ellis proposes telephoning Apex's ten largest clients at 9:30 a.m. so that they can ask questions before the electronic release. He would then release both report versions through the firm's approved distribution channels at 10:00 a.m. For separate research, a mining issuer invites Ellis to inspect a remote operating site. No commercial airline, train, or road service reaches the site. The issuer offers a seat on a modest charter aircraft carrying engineers and other analysts. It also offers two nights at a luxury resort after the one-day inspection, including entertainment unrelated to the visit. Apex's policy permits necessary issuer-provided transportation to remote sites if a supervisor approves it and the arrangement is disclosed in the analyst's research. Unnecessary entertainment and lavish benefits are prohibited. Ellis can complete the inspection without attending the resort weekend.

  1. Q9.1

    After discovering Ellis's unreviewed trades, Ramos should most appropriately:

    1. ARemind Ellis of the policy and take no further action
    2. BReport Ellis immediately without reviewing the transactions
    3. CInvestigate the trades and strengthen the deficient controls
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Investigate the trades and strengthen the deficient controls

    Rationale

    Investigate the trades and strengthen the deficient controls

    • Under CFA Standard IV(C), Responsibilities of Supervisors, Ramos must determine whether Ellis’s trades violated the restricted-list or other applicable rules before deciding on corrective action.
    • Because preclearance requests were automatically approved during the reviewer’s three-week absence, she must also repair and test the review process to prevent recurrence.

    Remind Ellis of the policy and take no further action

    • A reminder leaves unresolved whether Ellis’s trades conflicted with client activity or restricted-list rules.
    • It also leaves the failed preclearance control in place, despite Ramos’s supervisory responsibility.

    Report Ellis immediately without reviewing the transactions

    • Reporting a violation as established is premature when Ramos has not determined whether the trades breached any rule.
    • An immediate report alone would not address the automatic approvals or Ramos’s failure to test whether delegated reviews were completed.
  2. Q9.2

    Which description used by Ellis most likely violates the Standards?

    1. A“CFA, Level II” after Ellis's name
    2. B“Passed Level II of the CFA Program”
    3. C“2026 Level III CFA candidate”
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. “CFA, Level II” after Ellis's name

    Rationale

    “CFA, Level II” after Ellis's name

    • CFA after Ellis’s name implies that he holds the charter, but passing Level II does not confer it.
    • “Level II” cannot qualify the designation because the CFA Program has no partial charterholder designation.

    “Passed Level II of the CFA Program”

    • This accurately states the examination level Ellis has passed without claiming the CFA charter.
    • The Standards permit a factual description of progress through the CFA Program.

    “2026 Level III CFA candidate”

    • Ellis is registered for the next Level III examination, so describing himself as a candidate is permissible.
    • Unlike “CFA” after his name, this wording does not present Ellis as a charterholder.
  3. Q9.3

    Ellis should most appropriately distribute the Veridian recommendation by:

    1. ASend the recommendation first to accounts paying performance fees
    2. BRelease the recommendation simultaneously through approved channels
    3. CTelephone the firm's largest accounts before electronic publication
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Release the recommendation simultaneously through approved channels

    Rationale

    Release the recommendation simultaneously through approved channels

    • CFA Standard III(B), Fair Dealing, requires a fair opportunity for clients to act on Ellis’s change from hold to buy.
    • Apex may provide different report lengths at different disclosed service levels because both versions contain the same recommendation and are scheduled for release at 10:00 a.m.

    Send the recommendation first to accounts paying performance fees

    • Paying performance fees would not justify giving those accounts advance access to the buy recommendation.
    • Apex’s disclosed differences in report detail and client fees permit different service levels, not preferential timing for actionable research.

    Telephone the firm's largest accounts before electronic publication

    • Calling the ten largest clients at 9:30 a.m. would disclose the buy recommendation before the scheduled 10:00 a.m. release.
    • Releasing both report versions later through approved channels would not undo those clients’ earlier opportunity to act.
  4. Q9.4

    Regarding the issuer-sponsored site visit, Ellis should most appropriately:

    1. AAccept the necessary charter after employer approval and disclosure
    2. BDecline the visit unless Apex pays for a private aircraft
    3. CAccept the charter and the issuer's luxury weekend package
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Accept the necessary charter after employer approval and disclosure

    Rationale

    Accept the necessary charter after employer approval and disclosure

    • With no commercial transport to the remote site, the issuer’s modest charter is necessary for Ellis to conduct the inspection.
    • Apex permits this transportation with supervisor approval and disclosure in Ellis’s research, while prohibiting unnecessary benefits.

    Decline the visit unless Apex pays for a private aircraft

    • A private aircraft paid for by Apex is not required when Ellis can take the modest charter carrying engineers and other analysts.
    • The charter addresses the site’s lack of commercial access, provided Ellis obtains approval and discloses the arrangement.

    Accept the charter and the issuer's luxury weekend package

    • Ellis can complete the one-day inspection without the resort weekend, so the lodging and entertainment are unnecessary.
    • Accepting those lavish benefits would threaten his independence and objectivity and violate Apex’s policy.
Show case rationale

Rationale

The case turns on investigating possible misconduct while maintaining effective supervision and accurate CFA Program references.

  • Under Standard IV(C), Ramos should investigate Ellis’s unreviewed trades and repair the approval process; the trades’ compliance with client-activity and restricted-list rules remains undetermined.
  • Under Standard VII(B), Ellis may state that he passed Level II and is a registered Level III candidate, but “CFA, Level II” improperly uses CFA after his name.

The case also turns on fair access to recommendations and independence during issuer-sponsored research.

  • Under Standard III(B), Apex may provide disclosed, fee-based differences in report detail, but both client groups must receive the buy recommendation simultaneously through approved channels.
  • Under Standard I(B), Ellis may use the necessary modest charter with supervisor approval and research disclosure, but should decline the unrelated luxury resort and entertainment.

Traps in this case

Treating unreviewed trades as either harmless or proven violations

  • A reminder alone leaves the failed controls unresolved, while an immediate report without reviewing the transactions assumes facts Ramos has not established.

Giving favored clients an early recommendation

  • Neither performance fees nor account size justifies sending or discussing the actionable Veridian upgrade before the 10:00 a.m. release.

Confusing necessary travel with issuer hospitality

  • Apex need not pay for a private aircraft when its policy permits the necessary charter, and the inspection does not require the luxury weekend.

Want unlimited practice?

Get full access to all questions, explanations, and performance tracking.

Start For Free
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF