Horizon Asset Partners manages separate accounts for individual and institutional clients. The firm has adopted several policies based on the CFA Institute Code and Standards and is considering adopting the Asset Manager Code of Professional Conduct. Its compliance officer reviews proposed marketing materials, employee biographies, referral arrangements, and research disclosures before publication. Horizon has entered into an agreement with an independent insurance agent who is not himself a Horizon client. The agent receives 20% of the first year's advisory fee for each referred prospect who opens an account with Horizon. This percentage-based fee does not increase the total advisory fee charged to the referred client, but Horizon's business-development director proposes disclosing the arrangement to referred clients only after they open an account, reasoning that earlier disclosure could discourage the referral. Neither referred prospects nor existing clients have been informed about the arrangement before account opening. Elena Marsh is a portfolio manager at Horizon who has held the CFA charter for five years. She has not paid her annual CFA Institute membership dues for the past two years, though CFA Institute has not yet formally revoked her right to use the marks. In a proposed biography, she writes, "Elena Marsh, CFA." Marsh argues that because she legitimately earned the charter and merely fell behind on dues, continuing to use the credential is harmless. Horizon follows most provisions of the Asset Manager Code but has not implemented the Code's performance-reporting provision. Management nevertheless proposes claiming compliance while expressly identifying that exception in client materials. The compliance officer notes that the firm voluntarily chose to adopt the Code and that local law does not require it to make any compliance claim. Management would provide clients with a copy of the complete Code upon request. A Horizon analyst is preparing a favorable recommendation on Kestrel Mining. She beneficially owns Kestrel shares in a personal brokerage account, but the position represents less than 1% of her net worth and does not give her control over the issuer. The shares were purchased six months before she began researching the company. She has complied with Horizon's preclearance and transaction-reporting procedures but has not disclosed the holding in the research report. Horizon permits analysts to own covered securities if ownership is disclosed and personal transactions do not precede pending client trades. Exhibit 1 presents the statements under review.
Proposed Marketing and Research Statements
1. **Referral statement:** Horizon pays an independent insurance agent, who is not himself a Horizon client, 20% of the first year's advisory fee for each referred prospect who opens an account. Horizon's business-development director proposes disclosing the arrangement to referred clients only after they open an account. 2. **Credential statement:** Elena Marsh, a CFA charterholder who has not paid her CFA Institute membership dues for the past two years, writes, "Elena Marsh, CFA." 3. **Compliance statement:** Horizon writes, "Horizon complies with the Asset Manager Code except for the performance-reporting provision." 4. **Research statement:** Before recommending Kestrel Mining, an analyst does not disclose that she beneficially owns Kestrel shares.
- Q4.1
Horizon should most appropriately address the referral arrangement with the insurance agent by:
- ADisclose the arrangement only after the referred prospect opens an account
- BDisclose the nature and percentage-based amount of the fee before the prospect opens an account
- CDisclose the arrangement only if the referred prospect requests fee information
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. Disclose the nature and percentage-based amount of the fee before the prospect opens an account
Rationale
Disclose the nature and percentage-based amount of the fee before the prospect opens an account
- CFA Institute Standard VI(C) requires Horizon to disclose the referral arrangement before a referred prospect enters an advisory relationship.
- The disclosure should explain that the independent insurance agent receives 20% of the first year’s advisory fee, even though the referral does not increase the client’s total fee.
Disclose the arrangement only after the referred prospect opens an account
- Disclosure after account opening comes too late for the prospect to consider the agent’s financial incentive when deciding whether to hire Horizon.
- The fact that the referral does not increase the client’s fee does not remove Horizon’s disclosure obligation.
Disclose the arrangement only if the referred prospect requests fee information
- Standard VI(C) requires proactive disclosure of referral compensation, not disclosure only upon request.
- A prospect cannot be expected to ask about the agent’s compensation when Horizon has not revealed that the arrangement exists.
- Q4.2
Marsh should most appropriately address her use of the CFA designation by:
- AContinue using "CFA" because she legitimately earned the charter
- BSuspend use of "CFA" until her CFA Institute dues are current and she is in good standing
- CUse "CFA (inactive)" to indicate that her dues are unpaid
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. Suspend use of "CFA" until her CFA Institute dues are current and she is in good standing
Rationale
Suspend use of "CFA" until her CFA Institute dues are current and she is in good standing
- Use of the CFA designation requires current membership in good standing, and Marsh has not paid her annual dues for two years.
- She should remove “CFA” from her proposed biography until she restores her eligibility to use the designation.
Continue using "CFA" because she legitimately earned the charter
- Earning the charter five years ago does not eliminate the ongoing membership requirement for using the designation.
- The fact that CFA Institute has not formally revoked her right to use the marks does not make her unpaid dues irrelevant.
Use "CFA (inactive)" to indicate that her dues are unpaid
- “CFA (inactive)” is not an authorized form of the designation.
- Marsh must stop using the marks while she is not in good standing, rather than qualify them with a parenthetical.
- Q4.3
Horizon's proposed Asset Manager Code compliance statement is best described as:
- APermissible if the omitted provision is identified prominently
- BImpermissible because compliance may be claimed only in full
- CPermissible if clients receive the complete Code on request
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. Impermissible because compliance may be claimed only in full
Rationale
Impermissible because compliance may be claimed only in full
- Horizon has not implemented the Asset Manager Code’s performance-reporting provision, so it cannot claim compliance with the Code.
- Adoption is voluntary, but once Horizon makes a compliance claim, it must satisfy all applicable provisions.
Permissible if the omitted provision is identified prominently
- Horizon’s proposed statement identifies the performance-reporting exception, but disclosure of an exception does not make partial compliance a valid compliance claim.
- The firm can describe the policies it follows without claiming that it complies with the Asset Manager Code.
Permissible if clients receive the complete Code on request
- Providing the complete Code would tell clients what its provisions are, but it would not implement the missing performance-reporting provision.
- Horizon must meet that provision before claiming compliance, regardless of whether clients can request a copy of the Code.
- Q4.4Select all that apply
Which of the following actions should the analyst take regarding her Kestrel Mining recommendation and personal holding? (Select all that apply.)
- ADisclose her beneficial ownership of Kestrel shares before issuing the recommendation
- BDivest her entire position immediately, regardless of firm disclosure policies
- CConfirm that her personal transactions have not preceded pending client trades
- DTake no action because the holding is immaterial to her net worth
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. Disclose her beneficial ownership of Kestrel shares before issuing the recommendation; C. Confirm that her personal transactions have not preceded pending client trades
Rationale
Select
Disclose her beneficial ownership of Kestrel shares before issuing the recommendation
- Her Kestrel shares create a potential conflict with a favorable recommendation, even though they represent less than 1% of her net worth.
- Horizon permits ownership of covered securities if disclosed, but her holding is absent from the research report.
Confirm that her personal transactions have not preceded pending client trades
- Horizon requires client trades to take priority over an analyst’s personal transactions.
- Buying the shares six months before starting her research does not replace checking that her transactions did not precede pending client trades.
Do not select
Divest her entire position immediately, regardless of firm disclosure policies
- Horizon expressly permits analysts to own covered securities when they disclose ownership and do not trade ahead of clients.
- Divestiture is not required solely because she holds Kestrel shares; she must follow the firm’s disclosure and trading controls.
Take no action because the holding is immaterial to her net worth
- The position’s size does not remove the potential conflict between her ownership and her recommendation.
- She still must disclose the holding and confirm compliance with Horizon’s rule against personal transactions preceding pending client trades.
- Q4.5
True or False: Horizon may claim compliance with the Asset Manager Code if it clearly discloses in its marketing materials that it does not follow the performance-reporting provision.
- ATrue
- BFalse
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. False
Rationale
False
- Horizon has not implemented the Asset Manager Code’s performance-reporting provision, so it cannot claim compliance with the Code.
- A firm may claim compliance only when it follows all applicable provisions; disclosing an exception does not satisfy that requirement.
True
- The proposed statement, “Horizon complies with the Asset Manager Code except for the performance-reporting provision,” remains a compliance claim despite naming the exception.
- Providing the complete Code on request does not cure Horizon’s failure to follow the performance-reporting provision.
- Q4.6Select all that apply
Which of the following statements about Horizon's referral arrangement with the insurance agent are accurate? (Select all that apply.)
- AThe arrangement creates a conflict of interest that must be disclosed regardless of whether the referred client's fee increases
- BWaiting until after account opening to disclose the fee satisfies Horizon's disclosure obligation
- CThe percentage-based structure of the fee does not exempt Horizon from disclosure requirements
- DDisclosure is unnecessary because the insurance agent is not a Horizon client
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. The arrangement creates a conflict of interest that must be disclosed regardless of whether the referred client's fee increases; C. The percentage-based structure of the fee does not exempt Horizon from disclosure requirements
Rationale
Select
The arrangement creates a conflict of interest that must be disclosed regardless of whether the referred client's fee increases
- Horizon pays the insurance agent 20% of the first year’s advisory fee for each prospect who opens an account, creating an incentive to refer clients.
- Under the CFA Institute referral-fee standard, that compensation must be disclosed even though the referred client’s total advisory fee does not increase.
The percentage-based structure of the fee does not exempt Horizon from disclosure requirements
- The payment is referral compensation whether it is calculated as a percentage of the advisory fee or as a fixed amount.
- Horizon must disclose the arrangement to referred prospects before they enter into an advisory relationship.
Do not select
Waiting until after account opening to disclose the fee satisfies Horizon's disclosure obligation
- Disclosure after account opening is too late because the prospect has already decided to enter the advisory relationship.
- The director’s concern that earlier disclosure could discourage referrals does not change Horizon’s obligation to disclose the arrangement beforehand.
Disclosure is unnecessary because the insurance agent is not a Horizon client
- The agent’s status as a nonclient does not eliminate the conflict created by Horizon’s payment for referrals.
- The relevant disclosure is to the referred prospects, who should know about the agent’s compensation before opening an account.
Show case rationale
Rationale
The case turns on making required disclosures before clients act and using the CFA designation only while in good standing.
- Under the CFA Institute referral-fee standard, Horizon must disclose the agent’s 20% of first-year advisory fees arrangement before a referred prospect opens an account, even though the prospect’s fee does not increase and the agent is not a client.
- Marsh must stop using “CFA” until her dues are current and she is in good standing; earning the charter five years ago and not yet having the marks formally revoked do not make “CFA” or “CFA (inactive)” appropriate.
Code compliance claims and research conflicts require separate checks.
- Horizon cannot claim Asset Manager Code compliance while omitting its performance-reporting provision, even if it identifies the omission or supplies the complete Code on request.
- Before recommending Kestrel Mining, the analyst must disclose her beneficial ownership and confirm that her personal transactions have not preceded pending client trades; Horizon’s policy does not require automatic divestment.
Traps in this case
Disclosure after account opening
- Waiting until the prospect opens an account—or asks about fees—does not provide timely disclosure of the referral incentive.
Qualified compliance claim
- Voluntary adoption of the Asset Manager Code does not permit a claim of compliance with an exception for performance reporting.
Small personal holding
- Owning less than 1% of net worth, buying before beginning research, and following preclearance procedures do not replace disclosure in the Kestrel recommendation.