Ethical decision-making frameworks — MCQs

8 questions
Read Study Notes
Q1Unfolding case study

Daniel Okafor is a research analyst and CFA Program Level III candidate employed by Harbor Peak Asset Management. He plans to resign in two months and establish an independent advisory firm. Harbor Peak's employment and compliance provisions are summarized in Exhibit 1. Outside working hours and using his personal funds, Okafor forms a limited liability company for the future firm and secures a professional liability insurance policy. He does not use Harbor Peak personnel or equipment for these arrangements. Before resigning, however, he telephones three Harbor Peak clients from his personal cell phone. He tells them he is forming a competing firm and asks whether they would consider moving their accounts to the new firm once it is operational; he provides no fee information. Two clients express interest but make no commitment. Okafor also copies onto a personal drive a proprietary portfolio-risk scoring model, along with its supporting documentation. Okafor personally wrote the model's underlying code, but he developed, tested, and refined it entirely on Harbor Peak's servers, using the firm's licensed software and client portfolio data supplied by Harbor Peak. He intends to use the model only after leaving Harbor Peak and believes retaining it is acceptable because he is its original author. Amina Njeri, CFA, supervises Okafor. Harbor Peak's compliance system is generally adequate and includes written personal-trading rules, restricted-list notices, preclearance, and monthly review of employee brokerage confirmations. Njeri receives a same-day alert indicating that Okafor purchased shares in a restricted security without preclearance. Okafor tells her the purchase was accidental and asks her to wait for the normal monthly review. Njeri has authority to suspend Okafor's trading access and refer the matter to compliance. Separately, Harbor Peak's marketing department prepares the biography in Exhibit 1. Okafor reviews the text before publication but does not request any revisions. He has passed Levels I and II and is properly registered for the upcoming Level III examination. He understands that passing the examination alone would not result in the charter unless all CFA Institute membership, experience, and other requirements are also satisfied. Finally, Njeri owns a small interest in a technology company being considered for client portfolios. She informs Harbor Peak and affected clients of the ownership, its approximate value, and the potential effect on her judgment before participating in the recommendation.

Employment and Compliance Facts

**Employment agreement:** Research records, valuation models, and client lists prepared or maintained for Harbor Peak are firm property. Employees may make reasonable preparations for future employment but may not solicit Harbor Peak clients before resignation. **Personal-trading procedure:** Employees must receive preclearance before trading securities on the restricted list. Compliance reviews brokerage confirmations each month. **Marketing biography:** “Daniel Okafor, CFA Level III, is expected to receive the CFA charter this year.” Okafor is registered for the Level III examination but has not passed it and has not been awarded the charter.

  1. Q1.1

    Before resigning, Okafor may most appropriately undertake:

    1. ABoth forming the LLC and contacting clients about moving accounts
    2. BNeither forming the LLC nor contacting clients about moving accounts
    3. CForming the LLC but not contacting clients about moving accounts
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Forming the LLC but not contacting clients about moving accounts

    Rationale

    Forming the LLC but not contacting clients about moving accounts

    • Forming the LLC with personal funds outside working hours is a permissible preparation for future employment under the Employment and Compliance Facts.
    • Asking Harbor Peak clients to consider moving their accounts before resignation is solicitation, which the employment agreement prohibits.

    Both forming the LLC and contacting clients about moving accounts

    • Using a personal phone does not make the calls permissible: Okafor asked existing Harbor Peak clients about moving accounts to his competing firm.
    • The clients’ lack of commitment and Okafor’s omission of fee information do not change the soliciting purpose of the calls.

    Neither forming the LLC nor contacting clients about moving accounts

    • The Employment and Compliance Facts expressly permit reasonable preparations for future employment, and Okafor formed the LLC without Harbor Peak resources.
    • The prohibition applies to soliciting clients before resignation, not to every step toward establishing an independent firm.
  2. Q1.2

    Regarding the risk-scoring model copied from Harbor Peak, Okafor should most appropriately:

    1. ARetain the copied model until his final employment date
    2. BReturn or delete the model and rebuild it from permissible sources
    3. CUse the model only for clients who independently contact his new firm
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Return or delete the model and rebuild it from permissible sources

    Rationale

    Return or delete the model and rebuild it from permissible sources

    • Exhibit 1 identifies valuation models prepared for Harbor Peak as firm property, and Okafor developed this model using Harbor Peak’s servers, licensed software, and client data.
    • His authorship does not entitle him to keep the copy; he may build a new model using his experience and permissible sources.

    Retain the copied model until his final employment date

    • The employment agreement does not permit Okafor to retain firm property on a personal drive for his future business.
    • Waiting until resignation does not make the copied model his property or authorize its later use.

    Use the model only for clients who independently contact his new firm

    • A client’s independent contact does not grant Okafor rights to Harbor Peak’s proprietary model.
    • Even without soliciting that client, using the copied model would still misuse firm property.
  3. Q1.3

    After learning of the restricted-list purchase, Njeri should most appropriately:

    1. AInvestigate promptly and increase monitoring while the matter is resolved
    2. BWait for the monthly brokerage report before taking further action
    3. CAccept Okafor's explanation because the violation was unintentional
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Investigate promptly and increase monitoring while the matter is resolved

    Rationale

    Investigate promptly and increase monitoring while the matter is resolved

    • The same-day alert identifies a restricted-list purchase without required preclearance, so Njeri must promptly investigate the possible violation under her supervisory responsibilities.
    • She should take steps reasonably designed to prevent further misconduct, such as suspending trading access or referring the matter to compliance while increasing monitoring.

    Wait for the monthly brokerage report before taking further action

    • Harbor Peak’s monthly review is a routine control, but Njeri already has a same-day alert identifying a specific possible breach.
    • Waiting for that report would leave the purchase uninvestigated despite her authority to suspend trading access and refer the matter to compliance.

    Accept Okafor's explanation because the violation was unintentional

    • Okafor’s claim that the purchase was accidental does not establish whether he complied with the preclearance requirement.
    • Njeri must investigate and respond to the apparent breach even if Okafor did not intend to violate the personal-trading procedure.
  4. Q1.4

    The marketing biography in Exhibit 1 is best described as:

    1. AAcceptable because Okafor is registered for Level III
    2. BAcceptable if Harbor Peak identifies the examination date
    3. CMisleading because candidacy does not assure receipt of the charter
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Misleading because candidacy does not assure receipt of the charter

    Rationale

    Misleading because candidacy does not assure receipt of the charter

    • Exhibit 1 calls Okafor “CFA Level III,” implying a designation he has not earned; he may accurately say he is a Level III candidate.
    • Its prediction that he will receive the charter this year is misleading because passing Level III would not, by itself, satisfy the membership, experience, and other requirements.

    Acceptable because Okafor is registered for Level III

    • Registration permits Okafor to describe himself as a Level III candidate, not to use “CFA Level III” as a designation.
    • He has not passed Level III or received the charter, so registration does not support Exhibit 1’s prediction.

    Acceptable if Harbor Peak identifies the examination date

    • Adding the examination date would not correct the misleading “CFA Level III” description in Exhibit 1.
    • It also would not justify predicting receipt of the charter, which depends on requirements beyond the examination.
  5. Q1.5Select all that apply

    Which of Njeri's actions regarding her ownership interest in the technology company are required under the Code and Standards? (Select all that apply.)

    1. ADisclosing the ownership interest to Harbor Peak
    2. BDisclosing the ownership interest to affected clients
    3. CDisclosing the approximate dollar value of the interest
    4. DDivesting the interest before participating in the recommendation
    5. EDisclosing the interest's potential effect on her judgment
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Disclosing the ownership interest to Harbor Peak; B. Disclosing the ownership interest to affected clients; E. Disclosing the interest's potential effect on her judgment

    Rationale

    Select

    Disclosing the ownership interest to Harbor Peak

    • Njeri’s stake in a company under consideration for client portfolios creates a potential conflict that she must disclose to Harbor Peak under Standard VI(A).
    • Disclosure allows Harbor Peak to assess whether her interest could affect the recommendation.

    Disclosing the ownership interest to affected clients

    • Affected clients must know about Njeri’s ownership interest before relying on a recommendation involving the technology company.
    • Telling Harbor Peak alone would not disclose the conflict to those clients.

    Disclosing the interest's potential effect on her judgment

    • Standard VI(A) requires disclosure that is sufficiently clear for affected parties to understand how the interest could impair objectivity.
    • Njeri’s explanation of the potential effect on her judgment makes the conflict more meaningful than a bare statement of ownership.

    Do not select

    Disclosing the approximate dollar value of the interest

    • Njeri disclosed the approximate value, but Standard VI(A) does not specifically require a dollar amount.
    • The required disclosure concerns the ownership conflict and its potential effect on her judgment, not a prescribed valuation figure.

    Divesting the interest before participating in the recommendation

    • Standard VI(A) requires disclosure of this potential conflict, not automatic divestiture before Njeri participates.
    • Her ownership can be evaluated by Harbor Peak and affected clients once she has disclosed it and its potential effect on her judgment.
  6. Q1.6

    Complete the statement: Under the Standards, disclosing Njeri's ownership interest and its potential effect on her judgment to affected clients is ____________, whereas disclosing the exact dollar value of that interest is ____________.

    1. Amandatory / mandatory
    2. Bmandatory / not mandatory but may be a useful practice
    3. Cnot mandatory / mandatory
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. mandatory / not mandatory but may be a useful practice

    Rationale

    mandatory / not mandatory but may be a useful practice

    • Under Standard VI(A), Njeri must disclose her ownership interest in the technology company and its potential effect on her judgment to affected clients before participating in the recommendation.
    • The Standards do not require an exact dollar value; her disclosure of the interest and its approximate value gives clients context for assessing the conflict.

    mandatory / mandatory

    • Disclosure of the ownership interest and its potential effect is mandatory because the company is being considered for client portfolios.
    • The second “mandatory” is wrong: Standard VI(A) requires disclosure of the conflict, not the exact dollar value of Njeri’s holding.

    not mandatory / mandatory

    • The first “not mandatory” is wrong because Njeri’s financial interest could affect her objectivity in recommending the company.
    • The exact dollar value is not mandatory, although providing an approximate value, as Njeri did, may help affected clients assess the conflict.
Show case rationale

Rationale

Preparing to leave Harbor Peak does not permit soliciting its clients or taking its property.

  • Okafor may form the LLC and buy insurance outside working hours with personal funds, but his calls asking Harbor Peak clients to consider moving their accounts are solicitation before resignation, which the employment agreement prohibits.
  • He must return or delete the copied risk-scoring model and rebuild it from permissible sources: he wrote the code, but developed it using Harbor Peak’s servers, software, and client data, and the agreement makes its models firm property.

Supervision, CFA candidacy, and conflicts require action and accurate disclosure.

  • Njeri should investigate promptly and increase monitoring after the restricted-list alert, rather than await the monthly review or accept Okafor’s claim that the trade was accidental.
  • Okafor should seek correction of the biography: Level III registration does not make “CFA Level III” an appropriate designation or assure receipt of the charter, which has additional requirements.

Traps in this case

Using a personal phone or withholding fee details makes the client calls permissible

  • The calls still asked existing Harbor Peak clients to consider moving their accounts before Okafor resigned.

Waiting for the routine compliance review is enough

  • Njeri has a same-day alert and authority to suspend trading access and refer the purchase to compliance.

Conflict disclosure requires an exact value or divestment

  • Njeri must disclose her ownership and its potential effect on her judgment to Harbor Peak and affected clients; an exact dollar value and divestment are not required.
Q2Unfolding case study

Harland Securities is reviewing several matters before releasing its quarterly research package. Junior analyst Sophie Lee proposes a sell recommendation on Talon Energy after reading an anonymous social-media post claiming that a major customer will terminate its supply agreement. Lee has not contacted the issuer, reviewed customer filings, examined industry data, or attempted to corroborate the post. She argues that the report can be released if it identifies the post as its source and clearly labels the recommendation as her opinion. The alleged contract termination would be material if true, but Harland has no evidence that the anonymous author possesses reliable information. Senior analyst David Morgan is preparing a buy recommendation on Portwell Systems. Morgan beneficially owns Portwell shares worth approximately four months of his salary, making the holding material to him. He reported the position to Harland's compliance department when he joined the firm, but his draft report contains no disclosure to clients. Harland permits analysts to cover securities they own if personal trades are precleared and material conflicts are prominently disclosed in research distributed to clients. Morgan is also negotiating an arrangement with an independent tax adviser. The adviser would pay Morgan USD 500 for every Harland client who retains the adviser's services, regardless of the amount of work performed. Morgan intends to describe the adviser as an external specialist when making introductions but does not plan to mention the payment. Harland has not yet approved the arrangement, and no clients or prospects have received a referral. Lee is registered for the Level III CFA examination. She has passed Levels I and II, remains enrolled in the CFA Program, and has complied with all candidate conduct requirements. Her proposed website biography states: “Sophie Lee earned the CFA Level II designation and expects to become a CFA charterholder next year.” She has not completed the work-experience and membership requirements for the charter. Harland's compliance manager asks Lee to revise the statement so that it accurately describes her progress without implying that passing Level II confers a designation or that obtaining the charter is assured. Harland's compliance manual incorporates the CFA Institute Code and Standards. It requires research personnel to document the basis for recommendations, disclose conflicts to report recipients, and obtain approval before entering compensated referral arrangements.

  1. Q2.1

    Before distributing Lee's issuer recommendation, Harland should most appropriately:

    1. ADelay publication until a diligent investigation supports the recommendation
    2. BPublish while identifying the social-media source in the report
    3. CPublish because the recommendation is labelled as an opinion
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Delay publication until a diligent investigation supports the recommendation

    Rationale

    Delay publication until a diligent investigation supports the recommendation

    • The CFA Institute Standard on Diligence and Reasonable Basis requires Lee to investigate sufficiently before recommending that clients sell Talon Energy.
    • An anonymous post alleging a material contract termination, without corroboration from the issuer, customer filings, or industry data, does not support publication.

    Publish while identifying the social-media source in the report

    • Identifying the anonymous post tells readers where the claim originated but does not establish that the alleged termination is reliable.
    • Lee must corroborate the claim and develop a reasonable basis before Harland distributes the recommendation.

    Publish because the recommendation is labelled as an opinion

    • Calling the sell recommendation an opinion does not remove the requirement for a diligent, reasonable basis.
    • Lee has made no attempt to verify the post or examine other relevant information, so the label cannot justify publication.
  2. Q2.2

    Regarding Morgan's personal holding, the most appropriate action is to:

    1. ADisclose the holding only to Harland's compliance department
    2. BDisclose the holding prominently to recipients of the report
    3. CSell the holding immediately before publishing the report
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Disclose the holding prominently to recipients of the report

    Rationale

    Disclose the holding prominently to recipients of the report

    • Morgan’s Portwell shares are worth about four months of his salary, making his ownership a material conflict for a buy recommendation.
    • CFA Standard VI(A) and Harland’s policy require prominent disclosure to report recipients so they can assess its potential effect on his objectivity.

    Disclose the holding only to Harland's compliance department

    • Morgan already reported the position to compliance when he joined Harland, but his draft report contains no disclosure to clients.
    • Internal reporting does not tell recipients about the conflict in the recommendation they are being asked to consider.

    Sell the holding immediately before publishing the report

    • Harland permits analysts to cover securities they own when personal trades are precleared and material conflicts are prominently disclosed.
    • Divestiture is therefore not required to publish Morgan’s report, while selling would itself be subject to Harland’s preclearance policy.
  3. Q2.3

    Morgan's proposed referral arrangement is most appropriately addressed by choosing which action?

    1. ADisclose the arrangement only if a referred prospect becomes a client
    2. BDisclose the arrangement only to Harland before making referrals
    3. CDisclose the arrangement's nature and consideration to relevant parties
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Disclose the arrangement's nature and consideration to relevant parties

    Rationale

    Disclose the arrangement's nature and consideration to relevant parties

    • Under the CFA Institute referral-fee standard, Morgan must disclose the arrangement and the USD 500 per referral to Harland and relevant clients or prospects before making referrals.
    • The payment gives Morgan an incentive to recommend the tax adviser, so calling the adviser an “external specialist” does not adequately disclose the conflict.

    Disclose the arrangement only if a referred prospect becomes a client

    • Waiting until a prospect becomes a client is too late: the prospect needs to know about Morgan’s payment before deciding whether to retain the adviser.
    • The disclosure obligation is not limited to people who ultimately engage the adviser.

    Disclose the arrangement only to Harland before making referrals

    • Harland must be informed, and its manual requires approval before Morgan enters a compensated referral arrangement.
    • Employer disclosure alone leaves clients and prospects unaware that Morgan would receive USD 500 if they retain the adviser.
  4. Q2.4

    Which biography statement by Lee is most appropriate under the Standards?

    1. APassed Level II of the CFA Program
    2. BEarned the CFA Level II designation
    3. CExpected to become a CFA charterholder next year
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Passed Level II of the CFA Program

    Rationale

    Passed Level II of the CFA Program

    • Lee has passed Levels I and II, so “Passed Level II” accurately states her progress.
    • The statement does not imply that passing Level II awards a designation or that Lee will receive the CFA charter.

    Earned the CFA Level II designation

    • Passing Level II does not confer a partial CFA designation.
    • Lee may describe the examination level she passed, but she cannot claim a designation she has not earned.

    Expected to become a CFA charterholder next year

    • “Expected” implies a future outcome that Lee cannot assure merely by registering for Level III.
    • She has not yet passed Level III or completed the work-experience and membership requirements for the charter.
  5. Q2.5Select all that apply

    Which of the following statements about the case are accurate? (Select all that apply.)

    1. ALee's recommendation lacks a reasonable and adequate basis for publication
    2. BMorgan's Portwell holding must be disclosed to report recipients
    3. CMorgan's referral arrangement requires disclosure of the compensation to relevant parties
    4. DHarland's compliance manual policies conflict with the CFA Institute Standards
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Lee's recommendation lacks a reasonable and adequate basis for publication; B. Morgan's Portwell holding must be disclosed to report recipients; C. Morgan's referral arrangement requires disclosure of the compensation to relevant parties

    Rationale

    Select

    Lee's recommendation lacks a reasonable and adequate basis for publication

    • Lee relies solely on an anonymous social-media post and has not corroborated the alleged Talon Energy contract termination.
    • Naming the post and labeling the sell recommendation as opinion do not replace the diligence required for a reasonable and adequate basis.

    Morgan's Portwell holding must be disclosed to report recipients

    • Portwell shares worth approximately four months of Morgan's salary are a material conflict in his buy recommendation.
    • Reporting the holding to Harland's compliance department does not replace prominent disclosure to clients receiving the research.

    Morgan's referral arrangement requires disclosure of the compensation to relevant parties

    • The proposed USD 500 per-client payment gives Morgan a financial incentive to recommend the tax adviser.
    • Calling the adviser an external specialist would not disclose that incentive to Harland and affected clients or prospects.

    Do not select

    Harland's compliance manual policies conflict with the CFA Institute Standards

    • Harland's requirements to document research, disclose conflicts, and obtain approval for compensated referrals are consistent with the Standards.
    • The potential violations arise from Lee's unsupported recommendation and Morgan's planned omissions, not from the manual.
  6. Q2.6Matrix

    Match each scenario to the CFA Institute Standard it most directly implicates. (A. Standard V(A) Diligence and Reasonable Basis; B. Standard VI(A) Disclosure of Conflicts; C. Standard VI(C) Referral Fees; D. Standard VII(B) Reference to CFA Institute, the CFA Designation, and the CFA Program)

    FindingABCD
    1. Lee's use of an unverified social-media post as the basis for a sell recommendation○○○○
    2. Morgan's failure to disclose his Portwell holding to report recipients○○○○
    3. Morgan's referral arrangement with the tax adviser○○○○
    4. Lee's proposed biography statement about her CFA Program status○○○○
    Show answer and rationale
    • 1. Lee's use of an unverified social-media post as the basis for a sell recommendation: A
    • 2. Morgan's failure to disclose his Portwell holding to report recipients: B
    • 3. Morgan's referral arrangement with the tax adviser: C
    • 4. Lee's proposed biography statement about her CFA Program status: D

    Rationale

    1. Lee's use of an unverified social-media post as the basis for a sell recommendation

    A

    • Standard V(A), Diligence and Reasonable Basis, requires a substantiated basis for Lee’s sell recommendation.
    • Identifying the anonymous post as the source and labeling the recommendation an opinion do not replace corroboration.

    B

    • Standard VI(A) concerns conflicts of interest, not whether Lee has adequately investigated the alleged contract termination.

    C

    • Standard VI(C) concerns referral compensation, and Lee’s proposed recommendation involves no referral arrangement.

    D

    • Standard VII(B) governs references to the CFA Program, not the evidentiary basis for Lee’s research.

    2. Morgan's failure to disclose his Portwell holding to report recipients

    B

    • Standard VI(A), Disclosure of Conflicts, applies because Morgan’s Portwell holding is material to him and could affect how clients assess his buy recommendation.
    • Reporting the holding to Harland’s compliance department does not replace disclosure to report recipients.

    A

    • Standard V(A) addresses the diligence supporting the buy recommendation, not disclosure of Morgan’s personal holding.

    C

    • Standard VI(C) addresses compensated referrals; Morgan’s ownership of Portwell shares is not a referral fee.

    D

    • Standard VII(B) addresses CFA Institute and CFA Program references, neither of which appears in Morgan’s Portwell report.

    3. Morgan's referral arrangement with the tax adviser

    C

    • Standard VI(C), Referral Fees, requires disclosure of the proposed USD 500 payment for each Harland client who retains the adviser.
    • Calling the adviser an external specialist would not disclose Morgan’s financial incentive; Harland also requires approval before he enters the arrangement.

    A

    • Standard V(A) concerns the basis for investment recommendations, not compensation for introducing clients to a tax adviser.

    B

    • Standard VI(A) addresses conflicts generally, but VI(C) most directly governs this payment for referrals.

    D

    • Standard VII(B) concerns CFA Program references, which are unrelated to Morgan’s proposed introductions.

    4. Lee's proposed biography statement about her CFA Program status

    D

    • Standard VII(B), Reference to CFA Institute, the CFA Designation, and the CFA Program, governs Lee’s description of her progress.
    • Passing Level II does not confer a “CFA Level II designation,” and her expected charterholder status is not assured without the remaining requirements.

    A

    • Standard V(A) concerns the basis for Lee’s investment recommendation, not wording in her biography.

    B

    • Standard VI(A) concerns disclosure of conflicts, not whether Lee accurately describes her CFA Program status.

    C

    • Standard VI(C) concerns referral fees, and Lee’s biography describes no compensated referral.
Show case rationale

Rationale

The research and conflict questions turn on evidence and disclosure to report recipients.

  • Under Standard V(A), Lee must delay the sell recommendation until a diligent investigation provides a reasonable and adequate basis; an unverified anonymous post does not do so.
  • Under Standard VI(A), Morgan must prominently disclose his Portwell holding to report recipients because shares worth roughly four months of his salary present a material conflict; Harland permits him to cover the stock with that disclosure.

The referral arrangement and biography require accurate disclosure of what Morgan receives and what Lee has achieved.

  • Under Standard VI(C), Morgan must disclose the referral arrangement’s nature and USD 500 per client consideration to relevant parties, and obtain Harland’s approval before entering the arrangement.
  • Under Standard VII(B), Lee may say she “Passed Level II of the CFA Program”; passing an exam confers no Level II designation or assurance of a future charter.

Traps in this case

Identifying the post or calling the recommendation an opinion

  • Neither step corroborates the alleged contract termination or supplies the reasonable basis required for publication.

Treating internal reporting as sufficient

  • Morgan’s notice to compliance does not replace disclosure of his holding to report recipients, and employer approval alone would not replace referral-fee disclosure to relevant parties.

Claiming a partial designation or a guaranteed charter

  • Lee remains a Level III candidate but has not met the charter’s work-experience and membership requirements, so neither claim accurately describes her status.
Q3Unfolding case study

Rina Shah is an investment adviser at Meridian Advisory. Her client, Thomas Cole, has a written investment policy statement specifying capital preservation, moderate income, and a maximum allocation of 15% to below-investment-grade bonds. Cole currently has a 14% allocation to such bonds. He instructs Shah to use 10% of the portfolio to purchase an additional speculative-grade issue after hearing its chief executive interviewed on television. Cole initiated the instruction without a recommendation from Shah. Shah determines that the purchase would raise the allocation well above the limit and materially increase expected portfolio volatility. Meridian's procedures permit execution of unsolicited instructions after the adviser explains any inconsistency with the client's objectives and documents the client's acknowledgment. Shah later changes her recommendation on a widely held technology company from hold to sell. Meridian's approved client portal can release the recommendation to all entitled clients at the same time, although clients will access the message at different times. A colleague proposes first telephoning Meridian's ten largest clients because they generate the most commission revenue. Shah notes that smaller clients and clients with discretionary accounts also own the security. No client's mandate requires differentiated treatment of this recommendation. Shah also participates in Meridian's block trades. A family trust established by Shah's parents owns shares in a thinly traded company that Meridian plans to sell for several client accounts and for an account beneficially owned by Meridian itself. Shah is a current beneficiary of the family trust and has authority to direct its trades, although the account is registered in her father's name. Shah wants to include the trust's sale in the same trading program. Meridian's allocation policy gives client transactions first priority, employer transactions second priority, and employees' beneficially owned accounts last priority. Finally, a regional investment association asks Shah to teach a six-week evening course. The association offers a cash fee based on enrollment and confirms the arrangement in writing. The course would use general educational material, but two sessions would address securities covered by Meridian. Meridian has no prohibition against outside teaching, although the employment agreement requires disclosure of outside compensation arrangements. Shah expects to prepare some course material using knowledge and analytical methods developed during her employment. She has not yet informed Meridian or accepted the association's offer.

  1. Q3.1

    Regarding Cole's unsolicited bond instruction, Shah should most likely:

    1. AReject the instruction because advisers may not execute unsuitable investments
    2. BExecute immediately because unsolicited instructions are exempt from suitability review
    3. CExplain the inconsistency and obtain acknowledgment before executing the instruction
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Explain the inconsistency and obtain acknowledgment before executing the instruction

    Rationale

    Explain the inconsistency and obtain acknowledgment before executing the instruction

    • Cole’s requested purchase would raise his speculative-grade bond allocation from 14% to 24%, exceeding the 15% limit in his investment policy statement.
    • Because Cole initiated the trade, Shah should explain its conflict with his objectives and document his acknowledgment before executing it, as Meridian’s procedures require.

    Reject the instruction because advisers may not execute unsuitable investments

    • The purchase conflicts with Cole’s capital-preservation objective and bond limit, but Meridian permits unsolicited instructions after the adviser explains the inconsistency and documents acknowledgment.
    • Shah need not reject the instruction solely because it would increase expected portfolio volatility.

    Execute immediately because unsolicited instructions are exempt from suitability review

    • Cole’s unsolicited instruction does not excuse Shah from considering its effect on his portfolio and explaining the conflict with his 15% limit.
    • Immediate execution would skip the acknowledgment and documentation required by Meridian’s procedures.
  2. Q3.2

    The most appropriate initial dissemination of Shah's revised recommendation is to:

    1. ARelease the recommendation through the firm's approved client portal
    2. BTelephone the firm's largest clients before posting the recommendation
    3. CDelay release until every client confirms availability to review it
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Release the recommendation through the firm's approved client portal

    Rationale

    Release the recommendation through the firm's approved client portal

    • Meridian’s approved portal releases Shah’s revised sell recommendation to all entitled clients at the same time, giving them a fair opportunity to act.
    • Clients need not read the message simultaneously for the initial dissemination to be fair.

    Telephone the firm's largest clients before posting the recommendation

    • Calling the ten largest clients first would give them advance access to the sell recommendation because they generate more commission revenue.
    • Smaller clients and discretionary accounts also hold the security, and no client mandate justifies giving the largest clients priority.

    Delay release until every client confirms availability to review it

    • Fair dealing requires a fair opportunity to receive the recommendation, not confirmation that every client is ready to review it.
    • The approved portal can release the recommendation to all entitled clients simultaneously even though they will access it at different times.
  3. Q3.3

    The family trust's proposed trade should most appropriately be executed:

    1. ATrade the family account with client accounts because it is not registered in Shah's name
    2. BTrade the family account after client and employer transactions have received priority
    3. CTrade the family account first because the existing position creates market risk
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Trade the family account after client and employer transactions have received priority

    Rationale

    Trade the family account after client and employer transactions have received priority

    • Shah is a beneficiary of the trust and can direct its trades, so its sale is treated as a personal transaction despite the account’s registration.
    • Meridian’s allocation policy places client transactions first, its own account second, and employees’ beneficially owned accounts last, a priority that matters in this thinly traded stock.

    Trade the family account with client accounts because it is not registered in Shah's name

    • Registration in her father’s name does not negate Shah’s beneficial interest or her authority to direct the trust’s trades.
    • Including the trust on equal terms with client accounts would bypass Meridian’s required priority for clients and its own account.

    Trade the family account first because the existing position creates market risk

    • The trust’s exposure to market risk does not give Shah’s personal transaction priority over client sales.
    • Selling the trust’s shares first in a thinly traded stock could disadvantage the client and employer accounts that Meridian’s policy places ahead of it.
  4. Q3.4

    Before accepting the association's compensation, Shah should most likely:

    1. AAccept the payment after orally notifying Meridian
    2. BAccept the payment after obtaining the association's written approval
    3. CAccept the payment after obtaining written consent from both parties
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Accept the payment after obtaining written consent from both parties

    Rationale

    Accept the payment after obtaining written consent from both parties

    • Under CFA Standard IV(B), Shah must obtain written consent from both Meridian and the association before accepting compensation that could conflict with Meridian’s interests.
    • The enrollment-based fee, sessions covering securities followed by Meridian, and planned use of methods developed at work make the outside arrangement a potential conflict despite Meridian’s lack of a teaching ban.

    Accept the payment after orally notifying Meridian

    • Oral notification does not satisfy Standard IV(B)’s written-consent requirement.
    • Telling Meridian about the course also does not establish the association’s written consent to the arrangement.

    Accept the payment after obtaining the association's written approval

    • The association’s written offer does not replace Meridian’s written consent under Standard IV(B).
    • Shah’s employment agreement requires disclosure of outside compensation, and the possible conflict requires consent before she accepts the fee.
  5. Q3.5

    Which of the following statements correctly describes Shah's obligations regarding the course material and outside compensation?

    1. AUse general knowledge and skills gained through experience without restriction
    2. BUse Meridian's confidential records or proprietary analytical models without consent
    3. CDisclose the outside compensation arrangement to Meridian in writing before accepting
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Disclose the outside compensation arrangement to Meridian in writing before accepting

    Rationale

    Disclose the outside compensation arrangement to Meridian in writing before accepting

    • The association’s enrollment-based cash fee is outside compensation, and Shah’s employment agreement requires her to disclose the arrangement to Meridian before accepting it.
    • Because she has not yet informed Meridian or accepted the offer, she must address that obligation even though Meridian does not prohibit outside teaching.

    Use general knowledge and skills gained through experience without restriction

    • Shah may draw on general knowledge and skills developed during her employment when preparing educational material.
    • “Without restriction” is too broad: she must protect Meridian’s confidential or proprietary information, and using general knowledge does not remove her outside-compensation obligation.

    Use Meridian's confidential records or proprietary analytical models without consent

    • Shah’s plan to use knowledge and analytical methods does not give her permission to use confidential records or proprietary models in the course.
    • Using such employer property without consent would breach her duty to Meridian, regardless of whether the association pays her a fee.
  6. Q3.6

    Because Meridian's employment agreement contains no prohibition on outside teaching, Shah may accept the association's fee without disclosing it to Meridian. Which statement best evaluates this claim?

    1. ATrue, because the absence of a prohibition on outside teaching implies no disclosure is required
    2. BFalse, because the employment agreement requires written disclosure of outside compensation regardless of any teaching prohibition
    3. CFalse, because Meridian's approval, not disclosure, is what determines whether Shah may accept the fee
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. False, because the employment agreement requires written disclosure of outside compensation regardless of any teaching prohibition

    Rationale

    False, because the employment agreement requires written disclosure of outside compensation regardless of any teaching prohibition

    • Meridian’s employment agreement requires disclosure of outside compensation arrangements, and the association has offered Shah an enrollment-based cash fee.
    • The absence of a ban on outside teaching does not remove that obligation; Shah has not yet informed Meridian.

    True, because the absence of a prohibition on outside teaching implies no disclosure is required

    • Permission to teach and the duty to disclose outside compensation are separate matters under Shah’s agreement.
    • The association’s written confirmation of its offer does not disclose the arrangement to Meridian.

    False, because Meridian's approval, not disclosure, is what determines whether Shah may accept the fee

    • This claim overlooks the agreement’s express disclosure requirement for outside compensation.
    • Whether further consent is needed does not make disclosure unnecessary, particularly when two sessions will cover securities followed by Meridian.
Show case rationale

Rationale

Shah must address Cole’s unsuitable instruction and distribute her revised recommendation fairly.

  • Cole’s unsolicited purchase would push speculative-grade bonds above his 15% limit; Shah should explain the inconsistency and obtain his documented acknowledgment before executing, rather than reject it automatically or execute immediately.
  • Shah should release the sell recommendation through Meridian’s approved client portal to all entitled clients at once; different access times do not justify calling high-commission clients first or waiting for every client to be available.

Beneficial ownership governs trade priority, while outside compensation requires written authorization.

  • Because Shah benefits from and directs the family trust, its sale has last priority, after client and employer transactions, despite registration in her father’s name or the position’s market risk.
  • Before accepting the course fee, Shah must disclose the arrangement to Meridian in writing and obtain written consent from both parties; the association’s written offer alone is insufficient.

Traps in this case

No ban on teaching means no disclosure is needed

  • Meridian permits outside teaching, but its employment agreement still requires disclosure of outside compensation before Shah accepts it.

General experience and proprietary material are interchangeable

  • Shah may draw on general knowledge and skills, but may not use Meridian’s confidential records or proprietary analytical models without consent.

Employer approval alone settles the fee arrangement

  • Disclosure to Meridian is required, but Shah must obtain written consent from both Meridian and the association before accepting the compensation.
Q4Medium

An adviser has a reciprocal referral arrangement with an accountant: the adviser refers tax-preparation clients to the accountant, and in exchange, the accountant refers advisory prospects to the adviser. No cash payment is involved. Before making or accepting a referral under this arrangement, the adviser should most appropriately:

Q5Unfolding case study

Elena Morgan is a portfolio manager at Northbridge Advisory. She manages a USD 40 million portfolio for the Hartwell Foundation. The foundation's investment policy statement specifies a seven-year investment horizon, moderate risk tolerance, and a maximum allocation of 10% to illiquid investments. The foundation must distribute USD 12 million in two years to finance construction of a medical facility. Its remaining assets are invested in publicly traded equities and investment-grade bonds. Morgan is considering a private equity fund with a ten-year contractual life, no expected distributions during its first four years, and no established secondary market. She proposes allocating 35% of the foundation portfolio to the fund because its expected return exceeds the foundation's required return. The foundation's chair says the board understands that private equity is illiquid but has not approved any amendment to the investment policy statement. Morgan also identifies Arcadia Robotics as an attractive investment for several suitable client accounts. Arcadia's shares trade infrequently, and Morgan expects the aggregated client order to represent a substantial portion of normal daily volume. Before placing the client order, she considers purchasing shares for her personal account. She developed the investment thesis without using confidential client information and has disclosed her personal brokerage account to Northbridge. The foundation offers Morgan a personal bonus equal to 10% of any annual portfolio return above its policy benchmark. This payment would be separate from Northbridge's advisory fee and would be made directly to Morgan. Northbridge's employment agreement requires employees to obtain approval for outside compensation. Morgan plans to tell the compliance officer verbally after the foundation signs the arrangement, reasoning that the bonus aligns her interests with the client's interests. Finally, a local accountant refers prospective clients to Morgan. For each prospect who becomes a Northbridge client, Morgan pays the accountant USD 1,000. The payment does not increase the advisory fee charged to the client. Morgan currently tells prospects that she has “professional relationships with local advisers,” but she does not identify the payment amount or explain that the accountant is compensated only when a referral results in a new client. Northbridge permits referral arrangements when the required disclosures are made.

  1. Q5.1

    Regarding the proposed private equity allocation, Morgan should most appropriately:

    1. AReject the proposed allocation as inconsistent with the mandate
    2. BRecommend the allocation because its expected return is attractive
    3. CRecommend the allocation if the client acknowledges its illiquidity
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Reject the proposed allocation as inconsistent with the mandate

    Rationale

    Reject the proposed allocation as inconsistent with the mandate

    • The proposed 35% allocation exceeds the Hartwell Foundation’s investment policy limit of 10% in illiquid investments.
    • The fund’s ten-year life and lack of expected distributions for four years also conflict with the foundation’s USD 12 million distribution in two years.

    Recommend the allocation because its expected return is attractive

    • An expected return above the foundation’s required return does not override the investment policy’s 10% illiquid-investment limit.
    • The fund cannot be expected to provide cash during its first four years, when the foundation must fund its two-year distribution.

    Recommend the allocation if the client acknowledges its illiquidity

    • The chair’s acknowledgment does not amend the investment policy statement, and the board has approved no amendment.
    • Understanding illiquidity does not make a 35% allocation consistent with the 10% limit or the foundation’s near-term cash need.
  2. Q5.2

    Morgan's personal purchase of Arcadia shares should most appropriately occur:

    1. APurchase shares before clients because the idea is personally generated
    2. BPurchase shares concurrently with the aggregated client order
    3. CPurchase shares after suitable client accounts receive priority
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Purchase shares after suitable client accounts receive priority

    Rationale

    Purchase shares after suitable client accounts receive priority

    • Under CFA Standard VI(B), client transactions take priority over transactions for Morgan’s personal account.
    • Because Arcadia trades infrequently and the aggregated client order is substantial relative to daily volume, Morgan should wait until suitable client accounts have had priority.

    Purchase shares before clients because the idea is personally generated

    • Developing the Arcadia thesis herself does not give Morgan priority over suitable client accounts.
    • Buying first could raise the price clients pay for the infrequently traded shares; disclosing her brokerage account to Northbridge does not change the required order.

    Purchase shares concurrently with the aggregated client order

    • Concurrent personal trading could compete with clients for Arcadia’s limited liquidity.
    • With the client order expected to represent a substantial portion of normal daily volume, Morgan must give suitable client accounts priority rather than participate alongside them.
  3. Q5.3

    Morgan may accept the foundation's performance bonus most appropriately by:

    1. AAccept after verbally notifying Northbridge's compliance officer
    2. BAccept only after obtaining written consent from all involved parties
    3. CAccept because the payment is made directly by the client
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Accept only after obtaining written consent from all involved parties

    Rationale

    Accept only after obtaining written consent from all involved parties

    • The foundation’s proposed 10% performance bonus is compensation separate from Northbridge’s advisory fee and could affect Morgan’s duties to her employer.
    • CFA Standard IV(B) requires written consent from all involved parties before Morgan accepts the arrangement.

    Accept after verbally notifying Northbridge's compliance officer

    • Verbal notification does not meet Standard IV(B)’s written-consent requirement.
    • Telling the compliance officer after the foundation signs the arrangement also fails to obtain the required consent before acceptance.

    Accept because the payment is made directly by the client

    • Direct payment by the foundation does not remove a potential conflict with Northbridge’s interests.
    • The bonus is outside Morgan’s Northbridge compensation arrangement, so its source does not eliminate the need for prior written consent.
  4. Q5.4

    Morgan should most appropriately disclose the accountant's referral arrangement by:

    1. ADisclose only that an external referral arrangement exists
    2. BDisclose the payment after the prospect becomes a client
    3. CDisclose the nature and estimated value before engagement
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Disclose the nature and estimated value before engagement

    Rationale

    Disclose the nature and estimated value before engagement

    • Under the CFA Institute referral-fee standard, Morgan must tell prospects that the accountant receives USD 1,000 when a referral becomes a Northbridge client.
    • Disclosure before engagement lets prospects evaluate the accountant’s financial incentive before deciding whether to hire Morgan.

    Disclose only that an external referral arrangement exists

    • Saying only that Morgan has “professional relationships with local advisers” does not reveal that the accountant is paid for successful referrals.
    • Prospects also need the payment’s estimated value, even though it does not increase their advisory fee.

    Disclose the payment after the prospect becomes a client

    • Waiting until a prospect becomes a client prevents the prospect from considering the referral incentive when choosing an adviser.
    • Morgan must disclose the arrangement before engagement, not after the USD 1,000 payment is triggered.
Show case rationale

Rationale

The foundation’s mandate and client priority govern Morgan’s investment decisions.

  • The proposed 35% private equity allocation exceeds the IPS’s 10% illiquid-investment limit and conflicts with the USD 12 million distribution due in two years; attractive expected returns and the chair’s acknowledgment of illiquidity do not amend the mandate.
  • Morgan must give suitable client accounts priority in Arcadia shares: her independently developed thesis and disclosed brokerage account do not justify buying first, and a concurrent personal purchase could compete with clients for thinly traded shares.

Separate payments require consent or disclosure before Morgan proceeds.

  • Morgan may accept the foundation’s bonus only after obtaining written consent from all involved parties; verbal notice after signing and payment directly by the client are insufficient.
  • Before a prospect engages Northbridge, Morgan must disclose the referral payment’s nature and estimated value, including the USD 1,000 paid when a referral becomes a client.

Traps in this case

Expected return or client acknowledgment overrides the IPS

  • Neither makes a ten-year fund with no expected distributions for four years suitable for the proposed allocation.

Personal research permits an early or concurrent trade

  • The substantial client order in infrequently traded Arcadia shares makes client transaction priority decisive.

Informal notice satisfies payment obligations

  • The bonus requires prior written consent, while saying only “professional relationships” or disclosing the referral fee after engagement fails to inform the prospect in time.
Q6Unfolding case study

Elena Marik is an equity analyst at Northbridge Securities. She is preparing a recommendation on Solara Components, a publicly traded manufacturer. Northbridge requires analysts to preserve financial models, interview notes, source documents, and material correspondence for seven years. Marik has retained only her completed reports, explaining that most underlying data can be downloaded again from public databases. Marik gathers the information summarized in Exhibit 1. The chief financial officer asks her not to mention their private conversation until the issuer announces the contract in three weeks. Marik believes she can use the information because the public export data and consultant's comments independently support a positive outlook. The contract is large relative to Solara's existing operations, and Northbridge has not established an information barrier restricting Marik from covering the issuer. Solara later invites Marik and every other analyst covering the company to attend a three-day product demonstration at a resort. Solara will pay for business-class travel, accommodation, meals, and recreational activities. The product can also be examined at Solara's headquarters, which Marik can reach by train at modest cost. Marik tells her supervisor that issuer-paid travel is acceptable because all covering analysts received the same invitation. Northbridge's policy requires employees to obtain approval before accepting benefits that could reasonably threaten their independence, but Marik has not requested approval. For her valuation, Marik licenses a proprietary forecasting model from an independent industry consultant. The license permits Northbridge to use the model in client research but does not transfer authorship. Marik tests the formulas, changes several assumptions, and concludes that the model has a reasonable basis. She plans to describe the model as one she developed because she independently verified it and Northbridge paid the licensing fee. Her report clearly separates historical facts from her own forecasts and discloses that Northbridge provides market-making services in Solara shares. After finishing her analysis, Marik sends the report to her three largest institutional clients twenty minutes before releasing it to Northbridge's remaining 400 retail and institutional clients, believing the largest clients deserve first access given their trading volume. Marik also prepares a summary of her three-year track record for a prospective client, stating that her recommendations have generated a 22% average annual return, based only on the eight stocks that performed best among the fifteen she covered during that period.

Research Inputs Recorded by Elena Marik

| Source | Information obtained | |---|---| | Public customs database | Monthly export volumes for the issuer's principal product increased 18%. | | Industry consultant | Competitors have extended delivery times because of sector-wide capacity constraints. | | Issuer's chief financial officer | During a private call, stated that an unannounced contract will increase next quarter's revenue by approximately 12%. |

  1. Q6.1

    Based on Exhibit 1, Marik should most appropriately:

    1. AExclude the CFO's information and rely only on the other inputs
    2. BUse all three inputs after confirming the public data independently
    3. CUse all three inputs after informing the issuer's investor-relations department
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Exclude the CFO's information and rely only on the other inputs

    Rationale

    Exclude the CFO's information and rely only on the other inputs

    • The CFO privately disclosed an unannounced contract expected to increase next quarter’s revenue by approximately 12%, making the information material and nonpublic.
    • Marik may base her recommendation on the public customs data showing an 18% export-volume increase and the consultant’s sector-wide observations, but must not use the CFO’s disclosure.

    Use all three inputs after confirming the public data independently

    • Independently confirming the customs data does not make the CFO’s private contract disclosure public.
    • The mosaic approach permits analysis of public and nonmaterial nonpublic information; it does not permit use of this material nonpublic disclosure.

    Use all three inputs after informing the issuer's investor-relations department

    • Telling investor relations about the CFO’s statement does not constitute a public announcement of the contract.
    • Until the contract information becomes public, Marik must exclude it from her recommendation rather than use it after notifying the issuer.
  2. Q6.2

    Regarding the issuer-paid resort trip, Marik should most appropriately:

    1. AAccept the trip because the issuer invited all covering analysts
    2. BAccept the trip after disclosing its value in the research report
    3. CDecline the trip unless Northbridge determines it will not compromise objectivity
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: C. Decline the trip unless Northbridge determines it will not compromise objectivity

    Rationale

    Decline the trip unless Northbridge determines it will not compromise objectivity

    • Solara’s offer of business-class travel, resort accommodation, meals, and recreation could reasonably threaten Marik’s independence when she is preparing a recommendation on Solara.
    • Northbridge requires approval before accepting such benefits, and Marik has not requested it; the product can instead be examined at headquarters after a modest-cost train trip.

    Accept the trip because the issuer invited all covering analysts

    • Inviting every covering analyst does not remove the potential influence of issuer-paid hospitality on Marik’s recommendation.
    • The equal invitation also does not satisfy Northbridge’s requirement to obtain approval before accepting a benefit that could reasonably threaten independence.

    Accept the trip after disclosing its value in the research report

    • Disclosure would tell readers about the benefit but would not establish that the resort trip leaves Marik’s judgment uncompromised.
    • Marik must address Northbridge’s approval requirement before accepting the trip, rather than treat disclosure in the report as a substitute.
  3. Q6.3

    Marik should most appropriately treat her research records by:

    1. ARetain only the final report because the supporting data are publicly available
    2. BPreserve the supporting records because they substantiate the recommendation
    3. CDelete the working files after compliance approves the published report
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: B. Preserve the supporting records because they substantiate the recommendation

    Rationale

    Preserve the supporting records because they substantiate the recommendation

    • Marik must retain the models, interview notes, source documents, and material correspondence that support her Solara recommendation.
    • Northbridge requires those records to be preserved for seven years; keeping only completed reports does not satisfy that requirement.

    Retain only the final report because the supporting data are publicly available

    • A final report does not preserve the analysis and source material used to reach Marik’s recommendation.
    • The ability to download some data again does not replace retaining the supporting records, including her models and interview notes.

    Delete the working files after compliance approves the published report

    • Compliance approval of a published report does not remove Northbridge’s seven-year record-retention requirement.
    • Deleting working files would discard the models, notes, and other materials needed to substantiate Marik’s recommendation.
  4. Q6.4

    When using the consultant's valuation model, Marik should most appropriately:

    1. AIdentify the consultant's model as third-party work
    2. BPresent the model without attribution because Northbridge purchased it
    3. CPresent the model without attribution if Marik verifies its assumptions
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Identify the consultant's model as third-party work

    Rationale

    Identify the consultant's model as third-party work

    • The independent industry consultant created the proprietary forecasting model, so Marik must identify it as third-party work rather than present it as her own.
    • Testing its formulas and changing assumptions may support her valuation’s reasonable basis, but neither makes her the model’s author.

    Present the model without attribution because Northbridge purchased it

    • Northbridge’s license permits use of the model in client research but does not transfer authorship.
    • Paying the licensing fee therefore does not justify Marik’s plan to describe the model as one she developed.

    Present the model without attribution if Marik verifies its assumptions

    • Marik’s review of the formulas and assumptions addresses whether the model has a reasonable basis, not who created it.
    • Even after independently verifying and modifying the model, she must identify the consultant’s work as third-party work.
  5. Q6.5Select all that apply

    Based on Marik's distribution of her report, which of the following statements are accurate regarding Northbridge's fair-dealing obligations? (Select all that apply)

    1. ASending the report to the three largest clients before other clients violates fair dealing
    2. BClients with larger trading volumes may permissibly receive research ahead of other clients
    3. CNorthbridge should have policies to ensure simultaneous or randomized dissemination of research
    4. DFair dealing requires that every client receive identical investment recommendations regardless of objectives
    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: A. Sending the report to the three largest clients before other clients violates fair dealing; C. Northbridge should have policies to ensure simultaneous or randomized dissemination of research

    Rationale

    Select

    Sending the report to the three largest clients before other clients violates fair dealing

    • Marik gave her three largest institutional clients the Solara report 20 minutes before Northbridge’s other 400 clients.
    • Under Standard III(B), Fair Dealing, trading volume does not justify preferential early access to an investment recommendation.

    Northbridge should have policies to ensure simultaneous or randomized dissemination of research

    • Simultaneous or randomized dissemination would help Northbridge avoid consistently favoring particular clients when distributing research.
    • Such a policy would address the unequal access created when Marik released the Solara report to her largest clients first.

    Do not select

    Clients with larger trading volumes may permissibly receive research ahead of other clients

    • Marik’s belief that her largest clients deserved first access because of their trading volume does not excuse the 20-minute head start.
    • Fair dealing permits differences in service but not preferential early dissemination of this recommendation on that basis.

    Fair dealing requires that every client receive identical investment recommendations regardless of objectives

    • Standard III(B) requires fair treatment, not identical recommendations for clients with different investment objectives.
    • The problem here is the timing of Marik’s distribution, not a requirement that every Northbridge client receive the same advice.
  6. Q6.6Fill in the blank

    Marik advertised a 22% average annual return based on only 8 of the 15 stocks she covered over the three-year period. To comply with the Standard on Performance Presentation, what is the minimum number of stocks she must include when calculating and presenting her track record? (Enter a whole number.)

    Answer:  

    Show answer and rationale

    Answer: 15

    Rationale

    15

    • Standard III(D), Performance Presentation, requires Marik’s track record to fairly represent her recommendations rather than selectively highlight successful stocks.
    • She covered 15 stocks during the three-year period, so the calculation must include all 15, not just the eight best performers.

    Common wrong answers

    8

    • Counting only the eight best-performing stocks repeats the selective presentation that makes the advertised 22% average misleading.

    7

    • Subtracting the eight selected stocks from the 15 covered gives 7 excluded stocks, not the number that must be included.
Show case rationale

Rationale

The unannounced contract is material nonpublic information, not part of a permissible mosaic.

  • The CFO privately disclosed a contract expected to increase next quarter’s revenue by approximately 12%, and the issuer will not announce it for three weeks.
  • Marik must exclude that disclosure from her recommendation; independently confirming the public export data or informing investor relations would not make the CFO’s information public.

Marik must preserve the basis for her research, credit its source, deal fairly with clients, and present a complete track record.

  • Northbridge requires seven years of models, notes, source documents, and material correspondence; downloadable public data and a retained final report do not replace those records.
  • The licensed model remains the consultant’s work, the three largest clients should not receive the report ahead of the other 400 because of trading volume, and the advertised return must include all 15 stocks, not just the best eight.

Traps in this case

An invitation to every analyst makes the resort trip acceptable

  • Equal invitations do not remove the threat to independence from issuer-paid business-class travel and recreation; Marik needs Northbridge’s approval, particularly when a modest-cost train trip to headquarters is available.

Verifying or licensing a model transfers authorship

  • Testing formulas, changing assumptions, and paying the licensing fee do not permit Marik to present the consultant’s model as one she developed.

Fair dealing means identical recommendations for every client

  • Northbridge should use simultaneous or randomized research dissemination, but recommendations may differ according to clients’ objectives.
Q7Easy

An asset manager discloses that it votes proxies only when the expected client benefit exceeds the voting cost. Not voting an immaterial proxy is most likely:

Q8Medium

An issuer offers an analyst first-class travel and a resort stay before a ratings review; the analyst's employer can fund ordinary travel. The analyst should most likely:

Want unlimited practice?

Get full access to all questions, explanations, and performance tracking.

Start For Free
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF