Northstar Investments is assessing trade opportunities involving Ardin and Belvar. Both countries can produce wine and cloth using labor as the only input, and labor is mobile between industries within each country but not between countries. Transportation costs are zero, product quality is identical across countries, and the unit labor requirements in Exhibit 1 are constant over the relevant production range. Northstar's economist emphasizes that the direction of trade should be based on relative opportunity costs rather than on which country uses fewer labor hours in absolute terms. Ardin also imports steel at the world price. Because Ardin is a small country in the global steel market, changes in its imports do not affect the world price. Domestic steel producers have requested protection, arguing that either a tariff or a quota would raise domestic production and reduce imports. The government is comparing the LCU10-per-tonne tariff with an import quota calibrated to generate the same domestic price and quantity effects. The two measures differ in who receives the associated government revenue or scarcity rents. The proposed allocation of quota licenses is described in Exhibit 2. Northstar initially classified Ardin as a stable destination for foreign direct investment. New developments have changed that assessment. Ardin's government has announced that strategic mineral assets may be transferred to state ownership without a specified compensation process. It is also considering restrictions on converting local-currency proceeds into foreign currency. At the same time, a state-linked group has conducted cyberattacks against logistics companies in neighboring countries. No armed conflict has begun, but several multinational companies have delayed planned investments while reviewing the enforceability of contracts and their ability to repatriate cash flows. A Northstar analyst argues that the absence of military conflict means the developments should not affect valuation discount rates. The senior economist responds that geopolitical risk includes political, economic, and technological instruments as well as conventional military action. Investors may therefore demand compensation for a greater probability of expropriation, interruption, or capital immobility. Northstar is instructed to evaluate the likely direction of required returns and foreign direct investment without assuming that the adverse developments are already reflected in asset prices. Each question should be answered using the stated small-country assumptions, the license-allocation procedure, the labor data, and the described geopolitical developments. No retaliatory trade measures or offsetting investment guarantees are expected.
Unit Labor Requirements
| Country | One unit of wine | One unit of cloth | |---|---:|---:| | Ardin | 2 labor hours | 6 labor hours | | Belvar | 4 labor hours | 8 labor hours |
Proposed Trade Measures
Ardin is a small importing country that cannot affect the world price. The world price of imported steel is LCU100 per tonne. The government is considering either a tariff of LCU10 per tonne or an import quota producing the same domestic price and import quantity. Under the quota, licenses would be allocated without charge by the exporting country's government to its exporters.
- Q2.1
If Ardin adopts the tariff in Exhibit 2, the domestic welfare effects most likely include:
- AConsumer surplus rises and government revenue falls
- BConsumer surplus rises and government revenue rises
- CConsumer surplus falls and government revenue rises
Show answer and rationale
Answer: C. Consumer surplus falls and government revenue rises
Rationale
Consumer surplus falls and government revenue rises
- The LCU10 tariff raises Ardin’s domestic steel price from LCU100 to LCU110 per tonne, reducing consumer surplus.
- As a small country, Ardin cannot change the world price, so its government collects LCU10 per imported tonne while imports continue.
Consumer surplus rises and government revenue falls
- Consumers pay LCU110 rather than LCU100 per tonne, so their surplus falls rather than rises.
- Revenue does not fall: the tariff pays Ardin’s government, whereas the proposed quota would give licenses without charge to foreign exporters.
Consumer surplus rises and government revenue rises
- The revenue effect is right because Ardin’s government collects LCU10 per imported tonne.
- The consumer effect is reversed: a higher domestic price reduces, rather than increases, consumer surplus.
- Q2.2
Under the quota-license arrangement in Exhibit 2, the quota rents will most likely accrue to:
- AArdin's steel consumers
- BForeign steel exporters
- CArdin's government
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. Foreign steel exporters
Rationale
Foreign steel exporters
- Exhibit 2 says the exporting country’s government gives quota licenses without charge to its exporters, so those exporters receive the quota rents.
- The quota has the same price effect as the LCU10 tariff: Ardin’s steel price rises from LCU100 to LCU110 per tonne, creating a LCU10-per-tonne rent on licensed imports.
Ardin's steel consumers
- Ardin’s consumers pay the higher LCU110-per-tonne domestic price; they do not hold the import licenses that capture the rent.
- The quota therefore raises their steel costs rather than giving them the LCU10-per-tonne difference between domestic and world prices.
Ardin's government
- Ardin’s government would collect revenue under the LCU10-per-tonne tariff, but Exhibit 2 specifies a quota instead.
- It does not auction the quota licenses or receive the scarcity rents because the licenses are given to foreign exporters without charge.
- Q2.3
Comparing the tariff and the quota described in Exhibit 2, which statement is most accurate?
- AThe tariff generates revenue for Ardin's government, while the quota's rents accrue to foreign exporters
- BThe quota generates revenue for Ardin's government, while the tariff's rents accrue to foreign exporters
- CBoth measures generate revenue that accrues to Ardin's government
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. The tariff generates revenue for Ardin's government, while the quota's rents accrue to foreign exporters
Rationale
The tariff generates revenue for Ardin's government, while the quota's rents accrue to foreign exporters
- Exhibit 2’s LCU10-per-tonne tariff raises Ardin’s domestic steel price from LCU100 to LCU110 and gives Ardin’s government LCU10 for each tonne imported.
- The quota has the same price and quantity effects, but its licenses are allocated without charge to foreign exporters, who receive the LCU10-per-tonne scarcity rent.
The quota generates revenue for Ardin's government, while the tariff's rents accrue to foreign exporters
- Ardin’s government does not collect quota revenue because Exhibit 2 assigns the licenses without charge to foreign exporters.
- The tariff payment goes to Ardin’s government, not to foreign exporters.
Both measures generate revenue that accrues to Ardin's government
- The tariff generates government revenue of LCU10 per imported tonne.
- The quota generates scarcity rents instead, and Exhibit 2’s license allocation gives those rents to foreign exporters, not Ardin’s government.
- Q2.4
Northstar's revised geopolitical assessment most likely implies which response by foreign investors?
- ALower required returns and greater direct investment
- BUnchanged required returns and unchanged direct investment
- CHigher required returns and reduced direct investment
Show answer and rationale
Answer: C. Higher required returns and reduced direct investment
Rationale
Higher required returns and reduced direct investment
- Ardin’s possible uncompensated transfer of mineral assets to state ownership and restrictions on currency conversion increase expropriation and repatriation risk, so foreign investors are likely to require higher returns.
- State-linked cyberattacks add disruption risk, and several multinational companies have already delayed planned investments while reviewing contracts and cash repatriation.
Lower required returns and greater direct investment
- These developments weaken, rather than strengthen, investors’ confidence in recovering their assets and converting local-currency proceeds.
- With no offsetting investment guarantees expected, greater geopolitical risk does not support lower required returns or more direct investment.
Unchanged required returns and unchanged direct investment
- Geopolitical risk is not limited to armed conflict; Ardin’s proposed ownership and currency measures can affect investors even though no armed conflict has begun.
- The reported investment delays and the instruction not to assume the risks are already priced undermine a prediction of no change in required returns or investment.
Show case rationale
Rationale
The steel tariff and quota have the same domestic price and import quantity effects, but their proceeds go to different recipients.
- As a small importer, Ardin faces an unchanged world steel price of LCU100; the LCU10 tariff raises its domestic price to LCU110, reducing consumer surplus and generating government revenue on imports.
- The equivalent quota creates scarcity rents, but the exporting country gives licenses to its exporters without charge, so those rents accrue to foreign exporters rather than Ardin’s government.
Ardin’s geopolitical developments increase investment risk even without armed conflict.
- Possible uncompensated state ownership transfers, currency-conversion restrictions, and state-linked cyberattacks raise the risk of lost assets, immobile cash flows, or disruption.
- Without assuming these risks are already priced in, foreign investors would likely require higher returns and reduce direct investment.
Traps in this case
Treating protection as a gain for steel consumers
- Both measures raise Ardin’s domestic steel price above LCU100, so consumer surplus falls, not rises.
Treating quota rents as tariff revenue
- A tariff pays Ardin’s government LCU10 per imported tonne, whereas the specified free quota licenses give the associated rents to foreign exporters.
Treating the absence of war as the absence of geopolitical risk
- The threatened asset transfers and conversion restrictions can affect required returns and investment even though no armed conflict has begun.