Armitage Alternatives is reviewing several non-traditional strategies for a diversified institutional portfolio. The investment committee is concerned that strategy labels can conceal materially different market exposures, fee outcomes, and operational risks. Fund Alpha buys equities that its manager considers undervalued and sells short equities considered overvalued. The manager does not seek to eliminate all market exposure and may vary the portfolio's net long position as market opportunities change. Exhibit 1 reports long exposure as a percentage of NAV and short exposure as the absolute magnitude of short positions. Gross exposure is therefore the sum of long and short exposure, while net exposure is long exposure minus short exposure. Fund Beta, by contrast, purchases shares of announced acquisition targets and may short the acquirer's shares when consideration includes stock. Its primary risks include deal failure, delays, financing problems, and changes in the anticipated consideration. Armitage also reviews Fund Alpha's annual fee calculation. The management fee is charged at year-end using beginning NAV. The incentive fee is then applied only to value remaining above the high-water mark after deducting the management fee. There is no hurdle rate, fee crystallisation occurs on the stated year-end date, and no subscriptions, redemptions, taxes, or other expenses occur during the year. The high-water mark is not adjusted for inflation. For its commodity allocation, the institution maintains long exposure by holding crude oil futures and replacing each contract shortly before expiration. At the current date, futures prices increase with contract maturity. Assume the shape of the curve and the spot price remain unchanged during the roll and ignore collateral income and transaction costs. The committee wants to identify the roll component of return separately from changes in the commodity's spot price. The institution is also considering a digital payment token designed to maintain a value of USD 1. The token is a liability of a private issuer that reports holding short-term securities and bank deposits as reserves. Redemption is subject to the issuer's procedures and available liquidity; no government deposit insurance applies to token holders. The institution would not hold its private keys directly but would use an external custodian. The custodian states that it uses offline storage and approval controls but does not guarantee against all cyber, fraud, legal, or operational losses. Armitage's analyst must evaluate each exposure using its actual economic structure rather than treating hedge funds, commodity futures, and digital tokens as conventional long-only securities.
Hedge Fund Strategy and Fee Information
| Item | Fund Alpha | Fund Beta | |---|---:|---:| | Long equity exposure | 130% | 105% | | Short equity exposure | 90% | 100% | | Primary activity | Fundamental stock selection | Pricing announced acquisitions | | Beginning NAV | USD 100 million | — | | Gross ending value before fees | USD 112 million | — | | Management fee | 1% of beginning NAV | — | | Incentive fee | 20% | — | | High-water mark | USD 108 million | — |
Commodity and Digital Asset Observations
| Market | Observation | |---|---| | Crude oil futures | Successively longer-dated contracts trade at higher prices | | Commodity position | Long investor rolls an expiring contract into the next contract | | Payment token | Issuer promises redemption at USD 1 and holds short-term reserve assets | | Token custody | Private keys are held by an external custodian |
- Q1.1
Fund Alpha's strategy is best classified as:
- ALong–short equity
- BEquity market neutral
- CMerger arbitrage
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. Long–short equity
Rationale
Long–short equity
- Fund Alpha buys undervalued stocks and shorts overvalued stocks, using fundamental stock selection on both sides.
- Its 130% long exposure less 90% short exposure leaves a 40% net long position, which the manager may vary.
Equity market neutral
- Equity market-neutral strategies seek to minimise systematic equity exposure, whereas Fund Alpha retains a 40% net long position.
- Fund Alpha’s manager explicitly does not seek to eliminate all market exposure.
Merger arbitrage
- Merger arbitrage focuses on announced acquisitions and the risks that their terms or completion may change.
- That activity describes Fund Beta, which buys acquisition targets and may short acquirers, not Fund Alpha’s fundamental stock selection.
- Q1.2
Based on Exhibit 1, Fund Alpha's net return after management and incentive fees is closest to:
- A8.8%
- B10.4%
- C10.8%
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. 10.4%
Rationale
10.4%
- The management fee is 1% × USD 100 million = USD 1 million, leaving USD 111 million before the incentive fee.
- The incentive fee is 20% × (USD 111 million − USD 108 million) = USD 0.6 million, so ending NAV is USD 110.4 million and the net return is 10.4%.
8.8%
- Charging the incentive fee on all USD 11 million remaining profit, rather than only the amount above the high-water mark, produces 20% × USD 11 million = USD 2.2 million.
- That leaves USD 108.8 million after fees, or an 8.8% return, but ignores the USD 108 million high-water mark.
10.8%
- This results from incorrectly using the USD 1 million management fee as the incentive-fee base: 20% × USD 1 million = USD 0.2 million.
- Deducting USD 1 million and USD 0.2 million from USD 112 million leaves USD 110.8 million, but the incentive-fee base is the USD 3 million above the high-water mark.
- Q1.3
Based on Exhibit 2, the crude oil position will most likely experience:
- AZero roll return
- BPositive roll return
- CNegative roll return
Show answer and rationale
Answer: C. Negative roll return
Rationale
Negative roll return
- Exhibit 2 shows contango: successively longer-dated crude oil futures trade at higher prices.
- The long investor replaces the cheaper expiring contract with a more expensive next contract, producing a negative roll return when the curve and spot price remain unchanged.
Zero roll return
- Exhibit 2 shows different prices for the expiring and next contracts, so the roll component is not zero.
- An unchanged spot price rules out a spot-price gain or loss; it does not eliminate the effect of maintaining long futures exposure across maturities.
Positive roll return
- A positive roll return for a long position is associated with backwardation, when the next contract is cheaper than the expiring one.
- Exhibit 2 states the opposite price relationship: longer-dated crude oil contracts are more expensive.
- Q1.4
The payment token in Exhibit 2 most likely exposes its holder to:
- ADependence on issuer reserves and custodian controls
- BElimination of reserve-asset credit risk
- CGuaranteed purchasing-power stability
Show answer and rationale
Answer: A. Dependence on issuer reserves and custodian controls
Rationale
Dependence on issuer reserves and custodian controls
- The token’s promised USD 1 redemption depends on the private issuer’s reserves, procedures, and available liquidity.
- Because an external custodian holds the private keys, access also depends on its controls, which do not guarantee protection against cyber, fraud, legal, or operational losses.
Elimination of reserve-asset credit risk
- The issuer reports holding short-term securities and bank deposits, but those reserve assets are not stated to be free of credit risk.
- Token holders have no government deposit insurance, and redemption remains subject to the issuer’s available liquidity.
Guaranteed purchasing-power stability
- A promise to redeem for USD 1 concerns the token’s nominal value, not what that dollar can buy.
- The issuer’s redemption conditions also mean the promised dollar value is not an unconditional guarantee to holders.
- Q1.5
Based on Exhibit 1, Fund Alpha's net exposure equals 220% of NAV. True or False?
- ATrue
- BFalse
Show answer and rationale
Answer: B. False
Rationale
False
- Exhibit 1 gives Fund Alpha 130% long exposure and 90% short exposure, so net exposure is 130% − 90% = 40% of NAV.
- The stated 220% is therefore not Fund Alpha’s net exposure.
True
- Adding the exposures, 130% + 90% = 220% of NAV, calculates gross exposure because Exhibit 1 reports short exposure as an absolute magnitude.
- Net exposure instead subtracts the short position from the long position: 130% − 90% = 40% of NAV.
- Q1.6Select all that apply
Which of the following statements about the digital payment token in Exhibit 2 are accurate? (Select all that apply)
- AThe token's redemption value is guaranteed by government deposit insurance.
- BThe custodian's offline storage and approval controls eliminate all risk of loss to the token holder.
- CThe token holder bears credit and liquidity risk tied to the issuer's reserve assets.
- DThe token holder bears custodial risk related to the safekeeping of private keys by the external custodian.
Show answer and rationale
Answer: C. The token holder bears credit and liquidity risk tied to the issuer's reserve assets.; D. The token holder bears custodial risk related to the safekeeping of private keys by the external custodian.
Rationale
Select
The token holder bears credit and liquidity risk tied to the issuer's reserve assets.
- The token is a private issuer’s liability backed by reported short-term securities and bank deposits, so reserve losses or issuer failure could impair redemption.
- Redemption at USD 1 also depends on the issuer’s procedures and available liquidity, rather than an unconditional ability to convert the token into cash.
The token holder bears custodial risk related to the safekeeping of private keys by the external custodian.
- The institution relies on an external custodian to safeguard the private keys needed to access its tokens.
- Offline storage and approval controls reduce some risks, but the custodian does not guarantee against all cyber, fraud, legal, or operational losses.
Do not select
The token's redemption value is guaranteed by government deposit insurance.
- The case expressly states that no government deposit insurance applies to token holders.
- The issuer’s USD 1 redemption promise is subject to its procedures and available liquidity, so it is not a government guarantee.
The custodian's offline storage and approval controls eliminate all risk of loss to the token holder.
- The custodian’s controls do not eliminate cyber, fraud, legal, or operational risk; it explicitly declines to guarantee against all such losses.
- Even effective private-key safeguards would not remove credit and liquidity risk associated with the private issuer’s reserves.
Show case rationale
Rationale
Fund Alpha’s exposures, fee base, and high-water mark determine its classification and net return.
- Fund Alpha is long–short equity: it selects stocks to buy and short, while its 130% long and 90% short positions leave 40% net long exposure, not the near-zero exposure sought by equity market neutral strategies.
- From USD 112 million, deduct the USD 1 million management fee, then a 20% incentive fee on the USD 3 million above the USD 108 million high-water mark; ending NAV is USD 110.4 million, a 10.4% return.
The futures curve and the token’s obligations determine risks that their labels do not remove.
- Rolling a long crude oil position into a higher-priced later contract produces negative roll return when the curve and spot price remain unchanged—not zero or positive roll return.
- The USD 1 redemption promise depends on the issuer’s reserves and liquidity; it neither eliminates reserve-asset credit risk nor guarantees purchasing-power stability, and token holders have no government deposit insurance.
Traps in this case
Confusing gross exposure with net exposure
- Fund Alpha’s 220% gross exposure is 130% plus 90%, whereas its net exposure is 130% minus 90%, or 40%; Fund Beta, not Alpha, prices announced acquisitions in a merger-arbitrage strategy.
Charging the incentive fee on the wrong amount
- The incentive fee applies only to the USD 3 million remaining above the high-water mark after the management fee, not to the full annual gain or ending value.
Treating custody controls as a guarantee
- The external custodian’s offline storage and approval controls do not eliminate custodial risk from cyber, fraud, legal, or operational losses involving the private keys.