Principles of screening

On this page

Principles of Screening - The Health Radar

  • Goal: Detect potential disease in asymptomatic individuals for early intervention.
  • Core Principles (Wilson-Jungner Criteria):
    • Disease: Important health problem with a known natural history.
    • Test: Suitable, acceptable, reliable, and cost-effective.
    • Treatment: Effective and available treatment for the condition.
    • System: Benefits of early detection must outweigh harms like over-diagnosis.

⭐ Screening is susceptible to lead-time bias (survival appears longer due to earlier diagnosis) and length-time bias (detecting more slow-growing, less aggressive cases).

Screening Program Criteria - The Wilson-Jungner Checklist

This checklist outlines prerequisites for a viable screening program, addressing both the disease and the test.

Criteria Related to the DiseaseCriteria Related to the Test & Program
* Important Health Problem: High prevalence/morbidity.* Suitable & Acceptable Test: Must be accurate, safe, and well-tolerated by the population.
* Known Natural History: The progression from preclinical to clinical disease must be understood.* Effective Treatment: An accepted treatment must be available that improves outcomes when started early.
* Detectable Preclinical Phase: A long latent period or early symptomatic stage must exist.* Cost-Effective: The overall benefits must outweigh the costs of screening, diagnosis, and treatment.
* Continuous Process: Screening must be ongoing, not a one-time campaign.

Screening Metrics & Biases - De-biasing the Numbers

  • Screening Metrics: Evaluates test accuracy against a gold standard.
    • Sensitivity: $TP / (TP + FN)$
      • Ability to correctly identify those with the disease.
      • 📌 SNOUT: High Sensitivity test, when Negative, rules OUT disease.
    • Specificity: $TN / (TN + FP)$
      • Ability to correctly identify those without the disease.
      • 📌 SPIN: High Specificity test, when Positive, rules IN disease.
    • PPV (Positive Predictive Value): $TP / (TP + FP)$
    • NPV (Negative Predictive Value): $TN / (TN + FN)$

2x2 Contingency Table for Screening Test Metrics

⭐ ↑ Prevalence → ↑ PPV & ↓ NPV. Sensitivity and specificity are intrinsic test characteristics and do not change with prevalence.

  • Screening Biases:
    • Lead-Time Bias: Early detection artificially inflates survival time, but the course of the disease and time of death are unchanged.
    • Length-Time Bias: Screening is more likely to detect slow-growing, indolent cases, which naturally have a better prognosis.
    • Selection (Volunteer) Bias: Participants in screening studies are often healthier than the general population, skewing results toward better outcomes.

High‑Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

  • Screening is for asymptomatic individuals; it is not diagnostic.
  • The condition should be an important health problem with a long preclinical phase.
  • An effective and acceptable treatment must be available.
  • The screening test must be sensitive, specific, safe, and affordable.
  • Beware of lead-time bias (earlier detection artificially inflates survival) and length-time bias (detecting more slow-growing, benign cases).

Practice Questions: Principles of screening

Test your understanding with these related questions

A 36-year-old female presents to clinic inquiring about the meaning of a previous negative test result from a new HIV screening test. The efficacy of this new screening test for HIV has been assessed by comparison against existing gold standard detection of HIV RNA via PCR. The study includes 1000 patients, with 850 HIV-negative patients (by PCR) receiving a negative test result, 30 HIV-negative patients receiving a positive test result, 100 HIV positive patients receiving a positive test result, and 20 HIV positive patients receiving a negative test result. Which of the following is most likely to increase the negative predictive value for this test?

1 of 5

Flashcards: Principles of screening

1/10

Latent tuberculosis infections result in a positive _____ skin test

TAP TO REVEAL ANSWER

Latent tuberculosis infections result in a positive _____ skin test

purified protein derivative (PPD+)

browseSpaceflip

Enjoying this lesson?

Get full access to all lessons, practice questions, and more.

Start Your Free Trial