Avoiding unnecessary testing

Avoiding unnecessary testing

Avoiding unnecessary testing

On this page

Why Test Wisely? - The Core Principles

Cost of Low-Value Care: Harms of Over-testing & Solutions

  • Patient Safety First: Every test carries potential risks.
    • False positives → patient anxiety, unnecessary invasive follow-up procedures.
    • False negatives → false reassurance, delayed crucial diagnosis.
    • Direct harm: radiation (CT), contrast nephropathy, procedural complications (biopsy).
  • Resource Stewardship: Reduces costs for the patient and healthcare system, ensuring resources are available for those who genuinely need them.
  • Improved Diagnostic Accuracy: Testing without clear indication (low pre-test probability) increases the chance of misleading false-positive results.

⭐ Diagnostic errors affect ~1 in 20 adults, with over half having potential for severe harm. Many stem from inappropriate test ordering or misinterpretation.

Common Pitfalls - Test Traps & Triumphs

Based on 'Choosing Wisely India' principles to curb unnecessary testing.

Commonly Ordered TestWhen It's Actually Indicated (Choosing Wisely)
Routine pre-op labs (CBC, KFT, CXR, ECG)Symptomatic patients; specific risk based on history/exam for the planned surgery.
Vit D, B12, Ferritin screeningHigh-risk groups or clear clinical suspicion (e.g., malabsorption, unexplained anemia). Not for general screening.
Thyroid Function Tests (TFTs)Symptoms/signs of thyroid dysfunction (goitre, arrhythmia). Avoid in asymptomatic, non-pregnant adults.
Urine culture (asymptomatic catheterized pt)Signs of systemic infection (fever, ↑WBC). Treating asymptomatic bacteriuria ↑ resistance.
Tumour markers (CEA, CA-125)Monitoring diagnosed cancer. Not for screening asymptomatic individuals due to low specificity.

Clinical Decision Rules - Your Diagnostic Compass

Validated clinical decision rules (CDRs) are evidence-based tools to guide diagnostic testing, reducing patient harm and costs. They help identify low-risk patients where imaging or further tests can be safely avoided.

  • Wells Score: Stratifies risk for DVT & PE.
    • DVT score >2 = DVT likely.
    • PE score >4 = PE likely.
  • Ottawa Ankle & Knee Rules: For ankle/knee injuries.
    • 📌 Mnemonic (Ankle): "Bony Tenderness at Malleolar or Midfoot Zones" - check posterior edge/tip of lateral/medial malleolus, navicular, or base of 5th metatarsal.
    • Inability to bear weight for 4 steps is key.
  • NEXUS Criteria: Clears low-risk patients from C-spine imaging post-trauma.
  • PERC Rule: Rules out PE if all 8 criteria are negative (e.g., Age <50, HR <100, SaO2 >94%).

High-Yield: CDRs like PERC and Ottawa rules have very high sensitivity (>95%), making them excellent for ruling out disease. Their specificity is variable.

High‑Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

  • Pre-test probability is paramount; avoid tests for low-probability diseases.
  • Never use a "shotgun approach"; investigations must be hypothesis-driven.
  • Utilize clinical prediction rules (e.g., Wells score) to guide testing.
  • Always consider cost-effectiveness and the risk of iatrogenic harm from over-investigation.
  • Minimize radiation exposure (CT scans), especially in the young and pregnant.
  • Embrace the Choosing Wisely campaign principles to avoid unnecessary procedures.

Practice Questions: Avoiding unnecessary testing

Test your understanding with these related questions

A mother presents to the family physician with her 16-year-old son. She explains, "There's something wrong with him doc. His grades are getting worse, he's cutting class, he's gaining weight, and his eyes are often bloodshot." Upon interviewing the patient apart from his mother, he seems withdrawn and angry at times when probed about his social history. The patient denies abuse and sexual history. What initial test should be sent to rule out the most likely culprit of this patient's behavior?

1 of 5

Enjoying this lesson?

Get full access to all lessons, practice questions, and more.

Start Your Free Trial