Pilot and feasibility studies

Pilot and feasibility studies

Pilot and feasibility studies

On this page

Pilot Studies - Testing the Waters

  • Small-scale, preliminary studies conducted before a large-scale trial to assess feasibility.
  • Key Objectives:
    • Test recruitment strategies & consent processes.
    • Evaluate and refine study protocols & interventions.
    • Assess data collection methods & instruments.
    • Estimate sample size parameters (e.g., standard deviation).
    • Identify potential logistical problems.

⭐ Pilot studies are primarily for assessing feasibility and are not powered for formal hypothesis testing. Their results should be interpreted with caution.

Core Objectives - The Pre-Flight Checklist

  • Assess Feasibility: Evaluates recruitment potential, participant retention rates, and overall willingness to participate. Can the study actually be done?
  • Refine Protocol: Tests and improves study instruments, intervention acceptability, and data collection methods before the main investment.
  • Estimate Key Parameters: Provides preliminary estimates of effect size and standard deviation to inform the definitive sample size calculation ($n$) for the main trial.
  • Logistical Dry-Run: Tests the project's budget, resource allocation, and proposed timelines to identify potential operational issues early.

⭐ Pilot studies are not designed for hypothesis testing. Being underpowered, a non-significant result doesn't rule out a true effect. Their primary goal is to inform the design of the main trial.

Design & Analysis - Sizing It Up

  • Core Objective: To assess feasibility and estimate parameters for a future, larger study, not for hypothesis testing.
  • Sample Size:
    • Not based on formal power calculations.
    • Aims to reliably estimate key variables like standard deviation or recruitment/dropout rates.
    • General guideline: 10-12 participants per group.
  • Statistical Analysis:
    • Emphasizes descriptive statistics and confidence intervals over p-values.
    • Focus is on precision of estimates, not statistical significance.
    • Uses pre-defined progression criteria (e.g., meet 80% of recruitment goal) to determine if the main study is viable.

⭐ A key pilot study outcome is estimating the outcome's standard deviation, which is essential for performing an accurate power calculation for the main trial.

  • Pilot studies are small-scale versions of a main study, testing the entire research process (e.g., recruitment, randomization, data collection).
  • Feasibility studies ask if a future study can be done, questioning its overall practicality and viability.
  • The primary goal is to identify problems before committing to a large, expensive trial, allowing for protocol refinement.
  • Data can inform the sample size calculation for the main study.
  • They are not for hypothesis testing due to being statistically underpowered.

Practice Questions: Pilot and feasibility studies

Test your understanding with these related questions

A 21-year-old man presents to the office for a follow-up visit. He was recently diagnosed with type 1 diabetes mellitus after being hospitalized for diabetic ketoacidosis following a respiratory infection. He is here today to discuss treatment options available for his condition. The doctor mentions a recent study in which researchers have developed a new version of the insulin pump that appears efficacious in type 1 diabetics. They are currently comparing it to insulin injection therapy. This new pump is not yet available, but it looks very promising. At what stage of clinical trials is this current treatment most likely at?

1 of 5

Flashcards: Pilot and feasibility studies

1/10

_____ studies are observational studies that compare a group of people with disease to a group without disease

TAP TO REVEAL ANSWER

_____ studies are observational studies that compare a group of people with disease to a group without disease

Case-control

browseSpaceflip

Enjoying this lesson?

Get full access to all lessons, practice questions, and more.

Start Your Free Trial