What does a Weaken stem literally ask you to find? A fact that, if true, makes the conclusion less likely to follow from the stated premises.
Unlike Must Be True, the credited answer here will usually introduce new information the stimulus never mentioned - that new fact is the mechanism, not a flaw.
Ask yourself: If every premise remains true, how could the conclusion become less likely? Accept the premises as true. Then locate the inferential link, using argument structure, conditional logic, quantifiers, and the causal assumption you already know.
Run this procedure:
The answer may be abstract. “The evidence is not representative of the relevant population” feels less concrete than a story about named people. Translate it: Which group was actually observed, and which group does the conclusion discuss?
Why does a causal conclusion feel stronger than it is? The stimulus often gives a correlation and quietly treats one direction of explanation as settled. Keep the observed facts, then ask what else could produce them.
An alternate cause says, “B may be present because C produced it.” If stores near a new train station have more customers, nearby offices may explain the increase better than the station itself. Reversed causation says, “B may have caused A.” Perhaps prosperous neighborhoods demanded train service, rather than train service making them prosperous. A broken effect says, “Even if A caused B in some cases, the expected result is blocked here”: a new training program may improve skill, but employees’ performance may remain unchanged because their equipment is obsolete.
A causal answer need not prove the proposed cause false. It only needs to make another explanation or a failed effect plausible. This is why the hold-premises-fixed rule matters: do not object that the reported increase never happened. Ask what the increase means.
When an argument generalizes from a survey or sample, ask four questions:
A sample can be large and still be biased. A thousand self-selected respondents do not automatically represent a city. A survey about “satisfaction with public transit” may measure opinions of morning commuters while concluding something about all riders.
Notice the abstract answer choice: “The respondents were not representative of the target population.” Translate it into a concrete comparison. If the sample is weekday commuters and the target is all riders, the choice attacks the generalization directly.
Why do EXCEPT questions cause avoidable reversals? The ordinary Weaken task asks you to select a damaging fact; EXCEPT asks you to select the one choice that fails to damage the argument. LEAST functions essentially the same way as EXCEPT.
Use the same link attack, but reverse the final selection:
A choice can sound hostile without weakening the argument. “The program costs more than expected” does not weaken “the program reduced accidents” unless cost is part of that conclusion or its support.
Here is the case. The conclusion concerns what all users believe, but the survey covers only a narrow slice of users.
A city surveyed 600 people entering its new protected bike lane on weekday mornings.
Of those surveyed, 78 percent said that the lane made their commute safer.
The city concluded that most people who use the lane believe it makes their commute safer and decided to retain the lane permanently.
Practice
Which one of the following, if true, most seriously weakens the city’s conclusion?
A library extended its evening hours, and evening attendance rose 30 percent. The director concludes that the extended hours caused the increase. During the same month, a large employer nearby shifted many employees to evening schedules.
Which one of the following most weakens the director’s conclusion?
For timing, spend about 1 minute 25 seconds. Use the first portion to isolate the conclusion and link, then test choices against a predicted attack. After each miss, record the conclusion, the gap in its support, and why your chosen answer failed to attack that gap. Drill especially with causal arguments and surveys: state the target population, the observed sample, and the exact property measured before reading the choices.
Hold the premises fixed: weaken the link that supposedly carries them to the conclusion. For causal arguments, test an alternate cause, reversed direction, or a failure of the predicted effect. For surveys, compare who was counted and what was measured with the population and property named in the conclusion. On EXCEPT or LEAST questions, select the one choice that does not genuinely reduce the argument’s support.
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more
1. Delivery manager: Six weeks after our company adopted a new protocol for stacking parcels in trucks, the proportion of delivered parcels generating damage claims was 35 percent lower than during the preceding six weeks. Thus, the new stacking protocol reduced damage to parcels. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the delivery manager's argument?
Answer: B. At the same time the new protocol was adopted, the company began requiring customers to submit photographic evidence before a damage claim would be processed.
At the same time the new protocol was adopted, the company began requiring customers to submit photographic evidence before a damage claim would be processed. - The manager treats a 35 percent drop in the proportion of parcels generating damage claims as evidence that fewer parcels were damaged. - The new photographic-evidence requirement could reduce processed claims even if the rate of actual damage stayed the same, providing an alternative explanation for the drop. The company handled slightly fewer parcels during the six weeks after adopting the protocol. - The manager compares the proportion of delivered parcels generating claims, not the total number of claims. - A slightly smaller delivery volume does not explain why a smaller share of parcels generated damage claims. Some drivers considered the former stacking protocol easier to follow than the new protocol. - Driver preference does not establish that the new protocol caused more damage or failed to prevent it. - The statement gives no evidence about whether drivers followed the new protocol or how parcels fared under it. Damage claims had varied moderately from week to week before the protocol was changed. - Moderate weekly variation shows that the claim rate was not perfectly steady before the change. - It does not account for the 35 percent decline across the six weeks after the protocol was adopted. The company provided written instructions when it introduced the new stacking protocol. - Written instructions could help drivers follow the new protocol, rather than explain the decline through an unrelated change. - This fact gives no reason to think actual parcel damage stayed the same while damage claims fell.
2. Product manager: After our company rewrote the planting instructions included with its seed packets, customer complaints about unsuccessful germination declined sharply. Therefore, the decline occurred because the revised instructions were clearer and helped customers avoid planting errors. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the product manager's argument?
Answer: D. Gardeners randomly given the revised instructions made fewer planting errors than those given the former instructions.
Gardeners randomly given the revised instructions made fewer planting errors than those given the former instructions. - Random assignment makes the groups comparable, so the difference in planting errors supports the claim that the revised instructions caused it. - Fewer errors directly support the manager’s proposed explanation for the decline in complaints about unsuccessful germination. Sales of the seed packets increased after the revised instructions were introduced. - Higher sales do not show that customers understood the revised instructions better or made fewer planting errors. - The argument concerns why complaints declined, not how many packets were sold. Complaints about the durability of the seed packets also declined during the same period. - Packet durability is separate from planting errors and unsuccessful germination. - A decline in another kind of complaint does not establish that clearer instructions caused the decline in germination complaints. Several experienced gardeners praised the illustrations included with the revised instructions. - Praise from experienced gardeners does not show that typical customers found the planting directions clearer. - It also does not show that the illustrations reduced planting errors. The company's customer helpline was open for fewer hours after the instructions were revised. - Fewer helpline hours could mean customers had fewer opportunities to complain, even if germination did not improve. - That alternative explanation weakens the inference that clearer instructions caused the decline in complaints.
3. Research director: Our institute began offering monthly public webinars summarizing its working papers. During the following six months, downloads of those papers increased substantially. Thus, offering the webinars caused the increase in downloads. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the research director's argument?
Answer: C. A major academic search engine began indexing the institute's working papers during the same period.
A major academic search engine began indexing the institute's working papers during the same period. - Search-engine indexing could have made the papers easier to find, providing an alternative cause of the increased downloads. - Because indexing began during the same six months as the webinars, the timing alone does not establish that the webinars caused the increase. Most webinar attendees watched only portions of the presentations. - Even a partial presentation could prompt an attendee to download a working paper. - This does not explain the increase in downloads independently of the webinars. Several working papers discussed subjects not covered in the webinars. - The webinars could still have increased downloads of the papers they covered. - The director claims an increase in downloads overall, not that every paper received a webinar. Researchers who downloaded the papers could access them without attending a webinar. - Access without attendance does not show that the webinars failed to draw attention to the papers. - Someone could learn about a paper through a webinar and download it afterward. Attendance at the webinars declined somewhat during the six-month period. - A somewhat declining attendance trend does not rule out the webinars as a source of new readers. - Unlike search-engine indexing, this fact supplies no separate cause for the substantial rise in downloads.
4. Product researcher: Participants received identical snack portions in either newly designed containers or the company's older containers. Those receiving the new containers rated the snacks as fresher. Thus, the new container design caused participants to perceive the snacks as fresher. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the researcher's argument?
Answer: B. The new containers were stored on a warmer shelf than the older containers during the study.
The new containers were stored on a warmer shelf than the older containers during the study. - The groups differed in storage temperature as well as container design, so the freshness ratings do not isolate the effect of design. - If warmer storage affected how fresh the snacks seemed, it could explain the higher ratings even though the portions were identical. Some participants assigned to the new containers preferred the appearance of the older containers. - A preference for the older containers’ appearance does not explain why the new-container group rated its snacks as fresher. - The claim concerns perceived freshness, not whether every participant liked the new design. Several participants in each group had previously purchased the product used in the study. - Prior purchases occurred in both groups, so this fact identifies no difference that explains their different ratings. - Nothing states that previous purchasers were distributed in a way that favored the new-container group. Participants were not told how much either type of container cost to manufacture. - Manufacturing cost has no stated connection to how fresh the snacks seemed. - Because neither group was told the costs, that information cannot explain the difference in ratings. The new containers can hold slightly more product than the older containers can hold. - Greater capacity does not mean participants received more snack: the portions were identical. - The capacity difference therefore provides no reason, on these facts, for the new-container group’s higher freshness ratings.
5. Bakery owner: Three months ago, we began giving customers a discount for ordering pastries one day in advance. Since then, the proportion of pastries left unsold each evening has declined substantially. Thus, the preorder discount reduced the proportion of pastries left unsold by enabling us to forecast demand more accurately. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the bakery owner's argument?
Answer: A. At the same time, the bakery stopped producing several varieties that had historically sold poorly.
At the same time, the bakery stopped producing several varieties that had historically sold poorly. - Discontinuing pastries that often went unsold could itself reduce the proportion left unsold each evening. - Because this change occurred when the discount began, the decline does not establish that preorders improved demand forecasts. Customers using the discount generally collected their orders before the bakery's busiest afternoon period. - Collection time does not explain why a smaller proportion of pastries remained unsold. - Picking up an order before the busiest period does not show that forecasting failed to improve. The bakery advertised the preorder discount primarily through messages sent to its existing customers. - Advertising to existing customers identifies who heard about the discount, not why fewer pastries went unsold. - Those customers’ advance orders could still have helped the bakery forecast demand. Some customers who preordered pastries also purchased beverages when collecting their orders. - Beverage purchases do not account for the decline in unsold pastries. - They also provide no reason to doubt that advance pastry orders improved forecasts. Competing bakeries nearby did not offer discounts to customers who ordered pastries in advance. - Competitors’ discount policies do not explain the bakery’s lower proportion of unsold pastries. - This fact does not challenge the owner’s proposed link between preorders and more accurate forecasts.
6. A cinema sold more tickets this month than in any previous month. Yet the percentage of available seats occupied at its showings was lower this month than during any previous month. Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy?
Answer: A. The cinema opened several additional auditoriums, increasing the number of seats available at each showing.
The cinema opened several additional auditoriums, increasing the number of seats available at each showing. - The occupancy percentage compares tickets sold with seats available, so record ticket sales can coincide with a record-low percentage if capacity rises even faster. - Additional auditoriums supply the missing change in available seats that reconciles the two facts. The cinema sold fewer tickets for weekday showings but more tickets for weekend showings. - This shifts sales between weekdays and weekends but does not establish an increase in available seats. - Without such an increase, the shift does not explain how record total sales produced the lowest overall occupancy percentage. Some customers bought tickets online rather than at the cinema's ticket counter. - Buying online changes the purchase method, not the number of tickets sold. - It also leaves the number of available seats unchanged, so it cannot explain the lower occupancy percentage. The cinema showed more films that had already been screened at other local cinemas. - Where the films were previously screened does not establish a change in the cinema’s seating capacity. - It therefore does not reconcile record ticket sales with a record-low occupancy percentage. Customers who attended the cinema purchased fewer refreshments per visit than before. - Refreshment purchases do not enter the occupancy percentage, which concerns tickets and available seats. - Buying fewer refreshments therefore explains neither the record ticket sales nor their coexistence with lower occupancy.
7. Public-records director: After our office introduced an online request portal, the total number of requests completed each month increased, and the number of requests pending for more than 30 days decreased. Yet the average employee time spent on each request handled by employees increased. Which one of the following, if true, most helps to resolve the apparent discrepancy?
Answer: A. A new portal automatically completed routine requests, freeing employees to clear old cases while leaving them unusually complex new cases.
A new portal automatically completed routine requests, freeing employees to clear old cases while leaving them unusually complex new cases. - Automatic completion increased total monthly completions and freed employees to reduce the number of requests pending more than 30 days. - Because employees handled a greater share of complex requests, their average time per employee-handled request could rise even as the office completed more requests overall. Employees began recording preparation time that had previously been excluded from the calculation of time spent per request. - Counting previously excluded preparation time could raise the reported average without any change in how long requests actually took. - It does not explain why monthly completions increased or why fewer requests remained pending more than 30 days. Most people submitting requests through the new portal had never submitted a public-records request before. - The requesters’ prior experience does not establish how much employee time their requests required. - It also does not explain the increase in completions or the decrease in requests pending more than 30 days. Several employees who processed requests also began answering questions from people considering submitting requests. - Answering prospective requesters’ questions adds a duty but does not show that employees spent more time on each request they handled. - The added duty does not explain how the office completed more requests and reduced its older backlog. The office received more requests concerning recent records than concerning records created many years earlier. - Record age alone does not show whether a request is routine, complex, or time-consuming for employees. - This comparison does not account for both the improved completion and backlog figures and the higher average employee time per handled request.
1. In a Weaken-EXCEPT task, what distinguishes the correct answer from the other choices?
The correct answer does not make the conclusion less likely; it may be irrelevant, neutral, or strengthening. Every other choice weakens the argument’s reasoning.
2. When weakening an argument, should you dispute a stated premise or attack the reasoning from the premises to the conclusion?
Accept the premises as given and attack the link to the conclusion. Show that the premises can be true while the conclusion is less likely to follow.
3. An argument concludes that X causes Y because X and Y occur together. What kind of new fact would weaken this conclusion by offering an alternate cause?
A fact that some third factor Z causes both X and Y weakens the causal link. It suggests the correlation does not show that X causes Y.
4. In the street trees and crime rate example, what role does 'wealth' play in weakening the conclusion?
Wealth acts as an alternate cause. It explains both the presence of street trees (wealthier neighborhoods can afford them) and lower crime rates (wealthier neighborhoods spend more on security), thus making the conclusion that trees reduce crime less necessary.
5. What are the three biggest takeaways for Weaken-EXCEPT questions?
1. Mark four genuine attacks and choose the single answer that leaves the exact conclusion intact. 2. Judge every choice against the conclusion’s precise scope. 3. A consequence consistent with the conclusion is not weakening.
6. When should you attack the 'scope' of a survey argument?
Attack the scope when the survey measures one specific property or condition, but the conclusion of the argument asserts a claim about a different, broader, or unrelated property or condition.
7. Before evaluating a potential weaken answer, what is the crucial first step to prevent misidentifying the target?
Mentally or physically label the exact conclusion (e.g., 'Causal claim: X caused Y,' 'Recommendation: We should do X') to ensure the answer attacks that specific claim and not an unstated one.
8. A survey concludes that most residents support a policy. How could the wording of the survey weaken that conclusion?
Show that the question was leading, ambiguous, or omitted an important cost of the policy. The responses may then reflect the wording rather than genuine support.
9. An argument infers that a new procedure caused improvement because results were better after its adoption. What comparison would most strongly weaken that inference?
Show that a similar group that did not adopt the procedure improved by the same amount. This points to a broader factor rather than the procedure as the cause.
Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.
Scan to download app
Enter your email to get your 75% OFF code and unlock the full LSAT question bank on the app.