Strengthening a cause by eliminating alternatives

Strengthening a cause by eliminating alternatives

Published September 28, 2026

Strengthening a cause by eliminating alternatives

On this page

The Causal Gap: Which Alternative Must Disappear?

When an argument says that X caused Y, ask: What else could have produced Y? If a rival explanation remains, the conclusion is not secure. The best strengthener makes that rival unavailable.

Run this procedure:

  1. Mark the proposed cause and effect. Write the argument’s causal claim as “X → Y.”
  2. Name the strongest alternative. Ask what could have produced Y even if X had no effect. Look for a preexisting difference, a simultaneous change, selection into groups, or coincidence.
  3. Predict the needed evidence. The best strengthener will show that the alternative was absent, equal across groups, or unable to account for the result.
  4. Test every choice against that alternative. Do not ask merely whether a choice makes X sound beneficial. Ask whether it removes a specific competing cause of Y.

The goal is to reduce credible routes to Y, not collect favorable facts about X. If people who received X also differed from everyone else in another relevant way, evidence about X’s general reputation will not eliminate that difference. Evidence that groups were alike before X directly attacks the rival.

Define “eliminating” precisely. The answer need not prove that no other explanation is imaginable. It must remove the serious alternative that the argument leaves open. A choice can therefore suffice without establishing the causal conclusion with certainty.

The Rival-Cause Test: Evidence That Closes the Escape Route

Consider a common pattern:

  • Group 1 received X and later had more Y.
  • Group 2 did not receive X and had less Y.
  • Therefore, X caused Y.

The obvious alternative is that Group 1 already had some feature that made Y more likely. For example, motivated people may have been more likely both to choose X and to achieve Y. It strengthens the conclusion to show motivation was comparable before the groups diverged.

Other alternatives require different repairs:

  • Different starting conditions: Show the groups were equivalent before X.
  • Self-selection: Show assignment to X did not depend on traits related to Y.
  • A simultaneous intervention: Show no other relevant change occurred only for the X group.
  • A time-based coincidence: Show Y increased after X, not before it or independently of it.

Do not overreach. If the argument concerns whether X caused Y in one population, evidence that X causes a different outcome elsewhere may not remove the local rival. Likewise, a choice showing that X was implemented correctly may confirm that X occurred without showing that nothing else caused Y.

A useful internal sentence is:

“If this choice is true, the strongest remaining explanation for Y would be ______.”

If you cannot fill that blank with the original rival, the choice probably does not perform the needed causal work.

One Case, One Rival: Find the Choice That Removes It

A city compared two neighborhoods. Residents of Northside received free air-purifying plants, while residents of Southside did not. Six months later, Northside reported fewer respiratory complaints than Southside. The city concluded that the plants reduced respiratory complaints.

Practice

Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the city’s conclusion?

The forced-choice discipline matters here. (C) is not merely a favorable fact about plants. It changes the comparison: if the neighborhoods began alike on the outcome and its obvious environmental cause, the strongest escape route for the causal conclusion is closed.

High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

Identify the strongest rival cause of the observed effect. Prefer evidence showing the groups began alike or were assigned independently of the outcome. Reject facts that praise the cause without removing the rival explanation.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Strengthening a cause by eliminating alternatives

  1. 1. Transportation official: After Lark installed textured crosswalks at its busiest intersections, pedestrian collisions at those intersections declined by 30 percent. During the same period, pedestrian collisions did not decline at comparable intersections in a neighboring town. Therefore, the textured crosswalks reduced pedestrian collisions in Lark. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the official's argument?

    • A. Traffic volume, pedestrian volume, weather, and collision-reporting practices changed similarly in both towns, and only Lark installed the textured crosswalks.
    • B. Most pedestrian collisions in Lark before the installation occurred at intersections that did not receive textured crosswalks.
    • C. Many Lark residents support installing additional traffic-safety devices at intersections throughout the town.
    • D. Textured crosswalk material costs more to maintain than the paint used for ordinary crosswalks.
    • E. Some crosswalks in the neighboring town use paint that is brighter than the paint previously used in Lark.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Traffic volume, pedestrian volume, weather, and collision-reporting practices changed similarly in both towns, and only Lark installed the textured crosswalks.

    Traffic volume, pedestrian volume, weather, and collision-reporting practices changed similarly in both towns, and only Lark installed the textured crosswalks. - Similar changes in traffic, pedestrians, weather, and reporting make the neighboring town a stronger comparison for Lark’s 30 percent decline. - If installing textured crosswalks was the relevant difference, the unchanged collision rate at comparable intersections next door strengthens the claim that the crosswalks caused Lark’s decline. Most pedestrian collisions in Lark before the installation occurred at intersections that did not receive textured crosswalks. - This concerns where collisions occurred before installation, not why they later declined at the treated intersections. - It gives no comparison that rules out another cause of the reported 30 percent decline. Many Lark residents support installing additional traffic-safety devices at intersections throughout the town. - Residents’ support says nothing about whether textured crosswalks prevented collisions. - It neither explains Lark’s decline nor strengthens the comparison with the neighboring town. Textured crosswalk material costs more to maintain than the paint used for ordinary crosswalks. - Maintenance cost is separate from whether the crosswalks reduce pedestrian collisions. - A higher cost does not explain the differing collision trends at the two towns’ intersections. Some crosswalks in the neighboring town use paint that is brighter than the paint previously used in Lark. - A difference in paint brightness does not show what caused Lark’s collision rate to fall after installation. - This fact does not establish that other relevant conditions changed similarly in the two towns.

  2. 2. Distributor: In a three-month trial, products shipped in rigid reusable containers generated fewer damage claims per shipment than products shipped during the preceding three months in disposable cartons. Thus, replacing the cartons with reusable containers will reduce damage during shipping. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the distributor's argument?

    • A. The reusable containers require more storage space when they are returned empty.
    • B. Some customers prefer recyclable packaging even when it does not reduce product damage.
    • C. The reusable containers cost more per unit than the disposable cartons they replaced.
    • D. Shipments made in reusable containers and disposable cartons traveled comparable routes and carried similarly fragile products.
    • E. Damage claims for products shipped by other distributors also declined during the same quarter.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Shipments made in reusable containers and disposable cartons traveled comparable routes and carried similarly fragile products.

    Shipments made in reusable containers and disposable cartons traveled comparable routes and carried similarly fragile products. - Comparable routes and product fragility make the shipments more alike in two ways that could affect damage. - That makes the switch to reusable containers a more plausible explanation for the trial’s fewer damage claims per shipment. The reusable containers require more storage space when they are returned empty. - Empty-container storage space is a drawback, but it does not indicate whether products suffer less damage during shipping. - It therefore does not strengthen the inference from fewer claims in the trial to less shipping damage. Some customers prefer recyclable packaging even when it does not reduce product damage. - Customer preference for recyclable packaging says nothing about the damage-prevention performance of these reusable containers. - The argument concerns shipping damage, not whether customers like a packaging choice. The reusable containers cost more per unit than the disposable cartons they replaced. - Higher unit cost might matter to a purchasing decision, but the conclusion is only that reusable containers will reduce damage. - Cost does not explain why damage claims per shipment were lower in the trial. Damage claims for products shipped by other distributors also declined during the same quarter. - A decline among other distributors suggests that a broader change, rather than these containers, may explain the lower claim rate. - This provides an alternative explanation for the trial result and thus weakens, rather than strengthens, the argument.

  3. 3. Magazine editor: Readers who use our new audio-summary feature subsequently read more full-length articles per month than readers who do not use the feature. Hence, offering audio summaries causes readers to read more full-length articles. The answer to which one of the following questions would be most useful in evaluating the editor's argument?

    • A. Before audio summaries became available, were eventual users already more likely than nonusers to read full articles?
    • B. Does producing an audio summary cost the magazine less than producing the corresponding written article?
    • C. Do users generally prefer audio summaries narrated by professional speakers rather than by staff members?
    • D. Are articles with audio summaries approximately the same length as articles without such summaries?
    • E. Do advertisers pay higher rates for placement beside articles accompanied by audio summaries?
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Before audio summaries became available, were eventual users already more likely than nonusers to read full articles?

    Before audio summaries became available, were eventual users already more likely than nonusers to read full articles? - The editor observes a difference after the feature became available but concludes that the feature caused it. - If eventual users already read more full articles, self-selection could explain the difference; if they did not, the causal claim would be stronger. Does producing an audio summary cost the magazine less than producing the corresponding written article? - Production cost could affect the magazine’s decision to offer summaries. - It does not show whether using summaries changes how many full-length articles readers read. Do users generally prefer audio summaries narrated by professional speakers rather than by staff members? - Narrator preference concerns the presentation of the summaries. - It does not establish whether users would have read fewer full-length articles without the feature. Are articles with audio summaries approximately the same length as articles without such summaries? - Article length might affect which full articles readers choose. - Comparing article lengths does not determine whether summary users were already more avid readers than nonusers. Do advertisers pay higher rates for placement beside articles accompanied by audio summaries? - Advertising rates concern the feature’s potential revenue. - They do not help distinguish an effect of audio summaries from preexisting differences between users and nonusers.

  4. 4. Hiring director: Applicants for several positions were randomly assigned either a structured interview with standardized questions or a traditional interview chosen by each interviewer. Comparable proportions were hired from each group, but after six months, hires from the structured-interview group received higher supervisor ratings. Therefore, structured interviews identify employees who perform better. Which one of the following would be most useful to know in evaluating the director's argument?

    • A. Did applicants generally prefer structured interviews to traditional interviews?
    • B. Did the supervisors providing the six-month ratings know which interview method each employee had received?
    • C. Did structured interviews require more preparation time from interviewers than traditional interviews?
    • D. Did any applicants interviewed during the pilot decline offers of employment?
    • E. Did the organization use traditional interviews for positions not included in the pilot?
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Did the supervisors providing the six-month ratings know which interview method each employee had received?

    Did the supervisors providing the six-month ratings know which interview method each employee had received? - The director treats higher supervisor ratings as evidence that structured interviews identify better performers, so it matters whether the ratings could have been influenced by knowledge of interview method. - If supervisors knew the method, expectations might have affected their ratings; if they did not, that particular alternative explanation would be less plausible. Did applicants generally prefer structured interviews to traditional interviews? - Applicant preference does not establish whether hires from the structured-interview group performed better after six months. - Even a strong preference would not explain why that group received higher supervisor ratings. Did structured interviews require more preparation time from interviewers than traditional interviews? - Preparation time bears on the method’s cost or convenience, not on whether its hires performed better. - The director’s inference depends on what the six-month ratings show, rather than how long interviewers prepared. Did any applicants interviewed during the pilot decline offers of employment? - Declined offers could affect which applicants became hires, but knowing only whether any offers were declined would not reveal whether the two groups were affected differently. - This question therefore tests the performance comparison less directly than whether knowledge of interview method could have influenced the ratings themselves. Did the organization use traditional interviews for positions not included in the pilot? - Interviews for positions outside the pilot do not explain the rating difference between hires in the two randomly assigned groups. - The director’s conclusion rests on the pilot’s six-month ratings, not on how other positions were filled.

  5. 5. Café owner: After our café replaced its plastic-lined cups with compostable cups, the number of discarded cups found on the surrounding block fell by half over eight weeks. Since no other aspect of the café's waste policy changed, introducing the compostable cups caused the reduction in cup litter. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the owner's argument?

    • A. The compostable cups cost the café less per unit than the plastic-lined cups had cost.
    • B. The city began cleaning the café's block daily, rather than weekly, when the new cups were introduced.
    • C. Several nearby cafés continued using plastic-lined cups throughout the eight-week period.
    • D. Pedestrian traffic on the café's block remained approximately constant during the eight-week period.
    • E. The cup manufacturer describes the new cups as suitable for commercial composting facilities.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The city began cleaning the café's block daily, rather than weekly, when the new cups were introduced.

    The city began cleaning the café's block daily, rather than weekly, when the new cups were introduced. - Daily street cleaning could have removed discarded cups before they were counted, explaining why the number found fell by half. - The café’s unchanged waste policy does not rule out this simultaneous change by the city. The compostable cups cost the café less per unit than the plastic-lined cups had cost. - Unit cost does not show whether customers discarded fewer cups or whether fewer discarded cups were found. - Nothing in the argument links the café’s spending to the litter count on the surrounding block. Several nearby cafés continued using plastic-lined cups throughout the eight-week period. - Their continued use of plastic-lined cups does not show what happened to litter near those cafés. - Without a litter comparison, this fact does not challenge the claimed cause of the decline on the café’s block. Pedestrian traffic on the café's block remained approximately constant during the eight-week period. - Constant pedestrian traffic makes a drop in passersby less plausible as an alternative explanation. - It therefore does not weaken the claim that the cup change caused the decline. The cup manufacturer describes the new cups as suitable for commercial composting facilities. - Commercial compostability says nothing about how many cups customers discarded on the block. - It also does not explain whether discarded cups were removed before they were counted.

  6. 6. Shop owner: Norton's repair shop will begin guaranteeing every repair for one year. Because customers will therefore become more confident in the quality of Norton's work, the guarantee will increase the number of customers choosing the shop. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the shop owner's argument?

    • A. Most repairs covered by the guarantee can be completed in less than one day.
    • B. Some customers select repair shops chiefly on the basis of geographic convenience.
    • C. The guarantee will apply only to repairs performed using parts supplied by the shop.
    • D. Customers who doubt repair quality often avoid shops that do not guarantee their work.
    • E. Competing repair shops charge approximately the same prices as Norton's shop.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Customers who doubt repair quality often avoid shops that do not guarantee their work.

    Customers who doubt repair quality often avoid shops that do not guarantee their work. - The owner predicts that a one-year guarantee will bring in more customers, not merely make existing customers feel better about Norton's work. - This choice links confidence in quality to shop selection: customers deterred by a lack of guarantees may choose Norton's once it offers one. Most repairs covered by the guarantee can be completed in less than one day. - Quick completion might appeal to customers, but the owner's argument concerns the effect of a guarantee. - Repair speed does not show that offering the guarantee will cause more customers to choose Norton's. Some customers select repair shops chiefly on the basis of geographic convenience. - Geographic convenience explains why some customers choose a shop regardless of its guarantee. - It does not establish that the guarantee will attract other customers to Norton's. The guarantee will apply only to repairs performed using parts supplied by the shop. - This condition limits coverage of the guarantee, despite the owner's description of a guarantee for every repair. - It gives no reason to expect that customers will become more confident or choose Norton's more often. Competing repair shops charge approximately the same prices as Norton's shop. - Similar prices may make price less important when customers compare shops. - But price similarity does not show that Norton's one-year guarantee will change customers' choices.

  7. 7. Operations director: One division of our appliance-repair company introduced a barcode system that allows technicians to locate replacement parts quickly. During the six-month pilot, that division's average repair time decreased by 14 percent. Therefore, introducing the barcode system in our other divisions will probably reduce their average repair times. Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the operations director's argument?

    • A. Technicians generally preferred scanning barcode labels to entering part numbers manually.
    • B. A similar division that retained the old system showed no comparable decrease in repair times.
    • C. Several repairs completed during the pilot required parts that the company rarely kept in stock.
    • D. Managers had expected the barcode system to reduce inventory-recording errors as well as repair times.
    • E. The company purchased the barcode equipment from a vendor used by several other repair businesses.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A similar division that retained the old system showed no comparable decrease in repair times.

    A similar division that retained the old system showed no comparable decrease in repair times. - A similar division provides a comparison for the six-month pilot: without the barcode system, it did not show a comparable decrease. - That makes a shared cause of the pilot division’s 14 percent decrease less likely, strengthening the prediction that the system could reduce repair times elsewhere. Technicians generally preferred scanning barcode labels to entering part numbers manually. - A preference for scanning does not establish that technicians completed repairs faster. - It also does not show that the barcode system caused the pilot division’s decrease in average repair time. Several repairs completed during the pilot required parts that the company rarely kept in stock. - Rarely stocked parts may be difficult to obtain even if technicians can locate them quickly. - This fact about several repairs does not explain the division-wide decrease or support a similar decrease in other divisions. Managers had expected the barcode system to reduce inventory-recording errors as well as repair times. - Managers’ expectations are not evidence that the system caused the observed decrease. - Fewer inventory-recording errors, even if achieved, would not by itself establish shorter average repair times. The company purchased the barcode equipment from a vendor used by several other repair businesses. - Other businesses’ use of the vendor says nothing about whether their repair times decreased. - The vendor’s customer list does not help attribute the pilot division’s improvement to the barcode system.

  8. 8. Online retailer: Product pages containing brief, conversational descriptions had higher purchase rates last month than pages containing only photographs and specifications. Adding such descriptions to the remaining pages will therefore increase their purchase rates. Which one of the following would be most useful to determine in evaluating the retailer's argument?

    • A. Whether customers who purchased products generally read every part of the corresponding product page
    • B. Whether the descriptions were written by employees who had previously worked in advertising
    • C. Whether products with descriptions generated more revenue per sale than products without descriptions
    • D. Whether customers preferred concise descriptions to equally informative descriptions written in a longer style
    • E. Whether descriptions were added mainly to products already expected to sell better than the other products
    Show answer

    Answer: E. Whether descriptions were added mainly to products already expected to sell better than the other products

    Whether descriptions were added mainly to products already expected to sell better than the other products - The retailer treats last month’s higher purchase rates as evidence that descriptions caused more purchases. - If descriptions were added mainly to products already expected to sell better, those products’ appeal could explain the difference; if not, the comparison better supports the retailer’s plan. Whether customers who purchased products generally read every part of the corresponding product page - Customers need not read every part of a page for a description to affect their decision. - This does not establish whether the products with descriptions were otherwise comparable to those without them. Whether the descriptions were written by employees who had previously worked in advertising - The writers’ advertising experience does not show whether descriptions caused the higher purchase rates. - Even professionally written descriptions could have been added mainly to products already expected to sell better. Whether products with descriptions generated more revenue per sale than products without descriptions - The argument concerns purchase rates, not revenue earned from each sale. - A difference in revenue per sale would not explain whether adding descriptions makes visitors more likely to buy. Whether customers preferred concise descriptions to equally informative descriptions written in a longer style - This compares two description styles, while the retailer compares pages with descriptions to pages without them. - A preference for concise wording would not rule out preexisting differences between the two product groups.

Flashcards: Strengthening a cause by eliminating alternatives

  1. 1. An argument says a city added bike lanes and then traffic congestion fell, so the bike lanes caused the decline. What kind of fact would strengthen this causal conclusion?

    Show answer

    A fact ruling out another likely cause, such as evidence that public-transit use, population, and commuting patterns remained stable.

  2. 2. An objection says a new tutoring program only appears effective because its students were stronger beforehand. What evidence would specifically rule out that objection?

    Show answer

    Evidence that tutored and untutored students had equivalent academic performance before the program would weaken the objection and strengthen the conclusion.

  3. 3. A study finds that employees with standing desks report less back pain, concluding that standing desks reduce back pain. What selection-based alternative should a strengthener address?

    Show answer

    Employees who already had less back pain may have been more likely to choose standing desks. Random assignment to desk type would help eliminate this alternative.

  4. 4. In the 'Inspection Report' argument, why do answers that confirm accurate reporting (like option A or D) fail to strengthen the conclusion?

    Show answer

    They only make the premise (that voluntarily inspected factories have fewer reported injuries) more credible, but they don't show that requiring inspections will cause a reduction in injuries. The conclusion's inferential gap (from voluntary association to mandatory causation) remains unaddressed.

  5. 5. What three elements should you compare between the evidence and the conclusion to identify a gap?

    Show answer

    You should compare the evidence's population, measure, and conditions with the conclusion's population, measure, and conditions.

  6. 6. What is the 'displacement objection' in the context of an apparent benefit?

    Show answer

    The objection that an observed benefit (e.g., a problem decreasing in one area) is merely a relocation of the original problem to another area, rather than a true reduction.

  7. 7. According to the lesson, how should you state an objection to an argument's conclusion?

    Show answer

    State it as: 'The conclusion could still be false because .' Then, turn that objection into a prediction and seek evidence that contradicts the prediction.

  8. 8. When does evidence supporting a premise strengthen an argument?

    Show answer

    Only when the premise itself is uncertain and making it more credible increases support for the conclusion. If the premise is already granted, merely repeating or verifying it may not address the reasoning gap.

  9. 9. An argument assumes that if a policy reduces waste, it should be adopted. What additional principle would strengthen the recommendation?

    Show answer

    A principle stating that policies producing substantial waste reduction should be adopted when their costs and side effects are acceptable would connect the factual benefit to the recommendation.

Everything you need for LSAT prep

Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

GET STARTED FOR FREE
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF