The Filter: Does This Help the Conclusion or Just Its Evidence?
How can you tell whether a tempting Strengthen answer actually helps the argument-or merely makes one of its premises look more reliable?
Run this test before comparing answer choices:
-
State the conclusion in your own words.
-
Point to the premise the argument uses to support it.
-
For each answer, ask: “If this is true, is the conclusion more likely, or do I merely feel better about the premise?”
An answer that props up a premise may establish that the evidence is accurate, representative, honestly reported, or relevant. That can be useful in some arguments, but it does not necessarily move the conclusion. The missing work is the argument’s final step: what the premises are supposed to show.
A quick deletion test helps. Temporarily treat the premise as completely true and trustworthy. Then add the answer choice. If the conclusion still does not become more likely, reject the choice. You are not being asked whether the answer is relevant to the subject. You are asking whether it changes the argument’s inferential position.
Micro-Item: The Inspection Report That Is Not Enough
Factories that voluntarily undergo safety inspections have fewer reported injuries than factories that do not. Therefore, requiring all factories to undergo safety inspections will reduce the number of workplace injuries.
Practice
Which one of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?
Notice the contrast between A, D, and B. A and D improve confidence in the reported evidence. B changes what the evidence supports by introducing the exact feature in the conclusion-mandatory inspection-and tracking the predicted result.
The Final Pass: Erase the Premise and Watch the Answer Fail
When an answer seems attractive, name its job in a short phrase:
- “It confirms the reports.”
- “It makes the sample more trustworthy.”
- “It shows the observers were competent.”
- “It supplies the conclusion’s missing connection.”
The first three jobs prop up premises. The last job strengthens the argument. This classification is especially useful when several choices concern the same facts and all sound “helpful.”
Use one final counterfactual: suppose the relevant premise were already perfectly established. Would the answer still give you a reason to believe the conclusion? If yes, keep it in contention. If no, eliminate it.
Do not rescue a premise-supporting choice by saying that stronger premises generally help arguments. The test is comparative and targeted: which answer most increases support for this conclusion? An answer can improve the foundation without extending the argument across its actual gap.
High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways
Treat every premise as already credible; keep only answers that further support the conclusion. “Accurate,” “reliable,” or “representative” evidence may still leave the conclusion unsupported. Ask what job each choice performs: premise repair or conclusion support.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more