What does a Role of a Statement question literally ask? It asks what a marked statement is doing in the argument: supplying support, stating a conclusion, setting the scene, granting an opposing point, or linking claims. Typical stems include “The statement that X plays which one of the following roles in the argument?” and “The function served by the statement that X is to….” The choices supply descriptions of the marked statement’s function.
Before deciding whether a sentence matters most, tag it neutrally. Ask: is it background, premise, conclusion, or concession? Background identifies the setting, subject, or circumstances. A premise is offered as support. A conclusion is asserted as something to accept. A concession is a point the author grants, often one favorable to the opposing view, while continuing toward a different conclusion.
Run this quick procedure:
Tag the sentence first; only then decide what role it plays in the argument.
Why does a sentence that looks like a premise sometimes count as a conclusion? Because a claim can be supported by one sentence and then support another. The relevant question is not “Does this sentence sound factual?” but “What does the argument use this sentence to establish?”
Suppose the stimulus says: “The survey found that buses arrive late. Therefore, riders cannot reliably reach work by bus. The city should increase bus frequency.” The middle claim is an intermediate conclusion. The survey supports it; it supports the recommendation.
Loading diagram…
Ask yourself: if the marked claim disappeared, would a later claim lose a reason? If yes, it may be an intermediate conclusion even if it is also supported. If it has no outgoing support, it may be a direct premise or an endpoint. Do not confuse “intermediate” with “unimportant”; it is often the hinge of the entire argument.
How can you tell whether a sentence is merely background or a concession? Ask whether it locates the topic, provides history, defines a term, or identifies circumstances. If so, it is likely background. If it acknowledges a point that an opponent or a reader might use against the author while preserving a larger claim, it is likely a concession.
Consider: “The committee met during a year of unusually heavy rain.” That tells you the setting. “Although the rain damaged several roads, the proposed bridge is still unnecessary because the existing bridge handled all traffic safely.” The damage is conceded, but the author uses the rest of the argument to resist the proposal.
What changes when the stimulus reports another person’s position? You must track that position separately from the author’s. Write down the opposing proposition, its stated reason, and the author’s response: grants, qualifies, challenges, or replaces it.
Ask: is the marked sentence something the author wants you to accept, or something the author is describing in order to attack? The answer comes from its speaker and its place in the support chain. A sentence can accurately summarize an opponent without becoming the author’s conclusion.
For an EXCEPT stem, four choices perform the role described and one does not; LEAST functions essentially the same way here. Read the stem as a sorting instruction, then select the single mismatch rather than trying to rank imperfect descriptions.
Here is a layered argument. Read the target sentence as a node in the chain, not as an isolated assertion.
Some residents contend that the city should fund community gardens on vacant lots because gardens increase neighborhood interaction.
The council need not dispute that gardens can give neighbors a place to meet.
However, the only survey of the proposed lots found that residents used them mainly as walking routes and rarely gathered there.
Therefore, converting these lots into gardens would not, by itself, increase neighborhood interaction.
The city’s grant program should fund projects only when evidence indicates that they will achieve their stated primary goal.
Thus, the council should reject the garden proposal.
Practice
The statement that converting these lots into gardens would not, by itself, increase neighborhood interaction plays which one of the following roles in the argument?
Two finalists micro-drill. Critics argue that extending library hours is wasteful because few patrons arrive after 8 p.m. Although the extension would add staffing costs, the proposal could still be worthwhile because earlier closing forces students to leave group projects unfinished.
The statement that the extension would add staffing costs primarily:
On the clock, spend about 1:25: tag the marked sentence, map one support link before and after it, identify any opposing speaker, then select the one role established by the text. After each miss, record the conclusion, the gap in the support chain, and why your chosen answer failed.
A statement can be both supported and supporting; that two-way position usually marks an intermediate conclusion. Background sets the scene, while a concession grants an opposing point without giving up the author’s position. Track who owns each proposition before deciding whether the marked sentence is a premise, conclusion, concession, or target under attack.
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more
1. Policy analyst: Every municipal program that receives emergency funding must undergo an independent review. Any program that undergoes such a review must publish the review's findings. The river-cleanup program has just received emergency funding. Therefore, . Which one of the following most logically completes the analyst's argument?
Answer: E. the river-cleanup program must publish the findings of an independent review
> Key point: Apply each rule in sequence: emergency funding requires review, and review requires publication of findings. Why the river-cleanup program must publish the findings of an independent review is correct - The program received emergency funding, so it must undergo an independent review. - Every program that undergoes that review must publish its findings. Decision path mermaid flowchart TD A[" Emergency funding received "]:::input --> B[" Must undergo review? "]:::decision B -->|Yes| C[" Independent review "]:::rule C --> D[" Must publish findings "]:::outcome Why the other options are wrong - Funding only if findings are favorable: The rules require review and publication, not favorable findings. - Every publisher received funding: This reverses the stated implication; publication does not prove funding. - Work must finish before review: The rules specify no timing for the review relative to the cleanup work. - Denied programs are exempt from all review: The rules say nothing about programs denied funding or other review requirements.
1. What question helps distinguish a premise from a conclusion?
Ask whether the statement is offered as support or is being supported. A premise supports another claim, while a conclusion is presented as following from other claims.
2. An author says, “Critics maintain that the policy will raise costs,” and then argues that costs will fall. What role does the critics’ claim play?
It states the opposing position that the author intends to challenge. It is not the author’s own conclusion.
3. An author admits that a proposal is expensive but argues that its benefits justify the cost. What role does “the proposal is expensive” play?
It is a concession. The author accepts a drawback while maintaining the proposal should be adopted.
4. A statement is supported by one premise and is then used to support another claim. What is its role?
It is an intermediate conclusion. It functions as both a conclusion and a premise within the argument.
5. What are the three biggest takeaways for recognizing background and concessions?
1. Ask whether deletion removes context (background) or an admitted objection (concession). 2. 'Critics are right that' usually marks the author’s granted ground. 3. Do not expand a concession beyond the exact proposition the author accepts.
6. An author states, 'Critics are right that the new policy will increase administrative overhead.' What exactly does the author concede?
The author concedes that the new policy will increase administrative overhead. The author does not necessarily concede that the policy is bad or should not be implemented, only the specific fact mentioned.
7. What is the key difference between background information and a concession in an argument?
Background information provides context or setting for the argument, orienting the reader to the situation. A concession, however, is a point that the author grants as true, even though it could potentially weaken their argument or support an opposing view.
8. What is the role of a premise in an argument?
A premise provides support for a conclusion. It is offered as a reason to believe another claim.
9. What role does a concession play in an argument?
A concession acknowledges a point that may favor the other side or limit the author’s position. The author accepts it without abandoning the main conclusion.
Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.
Scan to download app
Enter your email to get your 75% OFF code and unlock the full LSAT question bank on the app.