Two Roles, One Main Conclusion: Track What Each Claim Does
When a statement is itself supported, but then used to support another statement, is it the main conclusion or only an intermediate one?
Run this procedure:
-
Mark every substantive claim. Ignore examples, background details, and repeated wording for the moment.
-
For each claim, record its support direction. Ask: “What claim does this support?” and “What claim supports it?” A claim can have support coming into it and support going out of it.
-
Separate the two kinds of conclusion. An intermediate conclusion is supported by something earlier or later, then serves as a reason for a further claim. The main conclusion is the argument’s final position-the claim for which the other argumentative claims ultimately provide support.
-
Check the whole structure, not one sentence. If removing a claim would weaken a later claim but not the argument’s ultimate position directly, that claim is probably intermediate. If the other claims are being assembled to establish it, it is probably the main conclusion.
A useful representation is:
- Premise → intermediate conclusion → main conclusion
The intermediate conclusion is not “wrong.” It is a conclusion in the argument, but it is functioning as evidence for something more important.
For example:
- The new policy would reduce processing time.
- Reducing processing time would lower administrative costs.
- Therefore, the agency should adopt the new policy.
The second sentence is an intermediate conclusion: the first sentence supports it, and it supports the recommendation. The recommendation is the main conclusion.
The distinction depends on argumentative role. A sentence’s location, confidence, or importance does not settle the issue.
First, Last, or Middle: Read the Argument’s Architecture
A main conclusion can appear at any point in the stimulus.
If it appears first, do not automatically treat it as the author’s starting point or as background. The author may announce the position and then defend it:
- The town should preserve the wetland.
- The wetland prevents flooding.
- It also supports several declining species.
The later statements are reasons for the first statement, so the first sentence is the main conclusion.
If it appears last, the structure may be more familiar:
- The wetland prevents flooding.
- It supports several declining species.
- Therefore, the town should preserve it.
Here the final recommendation is the main conclusion.
If it appears in the middle, later sentences may provide additional support, or an intermediate conclusion may follow it. For instance:
- The shuttle carries many students after dark.
- The university should retain the late-night shuttle.
- Its operating cost is lower than the cost of the alternatives.
- It also reduces students’ need to walk across campus at night.
The recommendation in sentence two is still the main conclusion. Sentences three and four support it, even though they come afterward.
Use a positional-neutral check:
- Can the other claims be organized as reasons for this claim?
- Is another conclusion merely being used to strengthen it?
- Would treating a later claim as the main conclusion leave the recommendation unexplained?
Do not promote an intermediate conclusion just because it is phrased assertively. In a chain, the middle claim often sounds especially persuasive because it has its own support. Its additional job, however, is to support the main conclusion.
Worked Item: The Recommendation in the Middle
During winter, the campus shuttle carried many students between the residence halls and the library after dark. The transportation committee should retain the late-night shuttle. The shuttle costs less to operate than the security escort that would otherwise be needed, and students who use it are less likely to walk alone across campus. These facts make retaining the shuttle a sensible use of university funds.
Practice
The argument most strongly supports which one of the following?
Before choosing, translate the argument into roles rather than order: factual support, supporting conclusion, and main conclusion. That translation makes a middle-position conclusion visible.
High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways
A conclusion used to support another conclusion is intermediate, not main. Test each claim’s role; position alone cannot identify the main conclusion. A main conclusion may appear first, last, or between its supporting reasons.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more