Naming the flaw and matching it

On this page

The Pre-Choice Diagnosis: Put the Error on Paper First

The question to answer is: How can I recognize the matching argument before an attractive answer choice tells me what to notice?

Run the stimulus through a fixed sequence before looking at the choices:

  1. Separate support from claim. Write what the premises establish and what the conclusion adds.
  2. Translate the controlling relationship. For a conditional, use a plain arrow: A → B.
  3. Compare the premise actually given with the premise required. If the argument needs A but supplies B, record that mismatch.
  4. State the flaw in one sentence. Do not name the subject matter; name the unsupported move.

For example:

  • Rule: grant funding → published results.
  • Given: published results.
  • Claimed: grant funding.
  • Error: treating the consequence as proof of the condition.

That diagnosis is your prediction. Only then should you inspect the choices. Your task is no longer “Which argument feels similar?” It is “Which argument makes the same unsupported move?”

This matters especially in Prove questions. The credited choice must be forced by the stimulus’s structure, not merely resemble its conclusion, vocabulary, or confidence.

The Micro-Item: Match the Missing Direction

If a grant funds a research project, the project will publish its results. This project published its results. Therefore, the grant funded it.

Practice

Which one of the following arguments contains flawed reasoning most similar to that in the argument above?

Notice what made the answer forced: not “projects,” “grants,” or the similar conclusion. The match survives after replacing every topic word with letters.

The Matching Routine: Recheck the Arrow, Then the Claim

Use this routine on every Parallel Flaw question:

  1. Cover the choices. State the stimulus flaw in a compact form, such as “A → B; B; therefore A.”
  2. Identify the conclusion’s added commitment. Ask what the argument wants you to believe that the premises do not guarantee.
  3. Translate each candidate only far enough to test its move. You usually need the direction of one conditional, not a full formal diagram.
  4. Reject topic matches immediately. A choice about grants can be wrong; a choice about permits can be right.
  5. Check validity before similarity. A choice may use the same words and still reason correctly.
  6. Return to the predicted signature. The winner must reproduce the unsupported step, not merely another kind of bad reasoning.

The most common trap is reading an answer choice for its conclusion first: “This also concludes that something caused an observed result.” That description is too loose. The required match is more exact: the argument must use the observed result as if it established its possible cause.

A second trap is treating every conditional reversal as identical without checking the wording. “If A, then B” differs from “A only if B.” Translate “only if” before judging. In the micro-item, that translation changes (D) from a tempting look-alike into a valid argument.

Before selecting, say the flaw aloud in both arguments:

  • Stimulus: “The project published, so the grant funded it.”
  • (E): “The project published, so the grant funded it.”

If you cannot state the same error without mentioning the subject matter, you have not yet matched the reasoning.

High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

Name the unsupported move before reading choices. Match conditional direction and inference, not vocabulary or conclusion. Reject a choice if its similar-looking reasoning is actually valid.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Naming the flaw and matching it

  1. 1. Commentator: Everyone who received the city's civic medal was nominated by a neighborhood council. Inez was nominated by a neighborhood council. Therefore, Inez received the city's civic medal. The flawed reasoning in the commentator's argument is most closely paralleled by which one of the following?

    • A. Every violinist in the orchestra is a trained musician. Sela is a violinist in the orchestra. Therefore, Sela is a trained musician.
    • B. No vendor receives a market permit without passing inspection. This vendor did not pass inspection. Therefore, this vendor did not receive a market permit.
    • C. Every certified playground was inspected by the city. North Park was inspected by the city. Therefore, North Park is a certified playground.
    • D. Some editors are poets, and some poets are teachers. Therefore, at least some editors are teachers.
    • E. Most applicants for the fellowship receive interviews. Ravi applied for the fellowship. Therefore, Ravi received an interview.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Every certified playground was inspected by the city. North Park was inspected by the city. Therefore, North Park is a certified playground.

    > Key point: If A is required for B, knowing A occurred does not prove that B occurred. Why the certified-playground argument is correct - The commentator’s argument says nomination is required to receive the medal, then treats nomination as sufficient to prove receipt. - The playground argument makes the same error: inspection is required for certification, but inspection alone does not prove certification. How they compare | Argument | Reasoning pattern | Result | |---|---|---| | Certified playground | Certified → inspected; inspected | Reverses the conditional | | Orchestra violinist | Violinist → trained; violinist | Validly applies the rule | | Market permit | Permit → passed; did not pass | Validly denies a necessary condition | | Editors and poets | Editors overlap poets; poets overlap teachers | The groups need not overlap | | Fellowship | Most applicants interviewed; Ravi applied | A majority claim need not apply to Ravi | Why the other options are wrong - Every violinist in the orchestra is a trained musician...: Sela meets the stated condition, so the conclusion follows. - No vendor receives a market permit without passing inspection...: Failing a required inspection rules out receiving the permit. - Some editors are poets, and some poets are teachers...: The two groups of poets might not be the same people. - Most applicants for the fellowship receive interviews...: Ravi could be among the applicants who do not receive an interview.

  2. 2. Editor: Our article accurately quoted a researcher as saying that a proposed conservation program would be costly. We have since learned that the researcher immediately added that the program's long-term savings would exceed its costs, but our article omitted that qualification. Although the quotation itself was accurate, it created a materially misleading impression, so we should promptly publish a clarification. Which one of the following principles most closely conforms to the editor's reasoning?

    • A. A publisher that discovers reliable evidence that its accurate words created a materially misleading impression should promptly clarify that impression.
    • B. A publisher should correct a statement only when the statement was false at the time it was originally published.
    • C. A publisher should provide clarification whenever a person discussed in an article claims that the article caused reputational harm.
    • D. A publisher that quotes part of an interview should ordinarily release the complete interview along with the published quotation.
    • E. A publisher need not clarify an accurate statement unless the misleading impression it created was deliberately produced.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A publisher that discovers reliable evidence that its accurate words created a materially misleading impression should promptly clarify that impression.

    > Key point: An accurate quotation can still require prompt clarification if reliable evidence shows it created a materially misleading impression. Why the publisher should promptly clarify is correct - The quotation was accurate, but omitting the researcher’s qualification made the article’s impression materially misleading. - The editor’s reasoning makes discovery of that misleading impression—not falsity or intent—the reason to clarify. How they compare | Principle | What it requires | Fit with the reasoning | |---|---|---| | Prompt clarification | Reliable evidence of a materially misleading impression | Matches the editor’s reasoning | | Correct only false statements | The original statement must be false | Too restrictive | | Clarify on a harm claim | A person claims reputational harm | Not the editor’s basis | | Release full interview | Publish the complete interview | Goes beyond clarification | | Clarify only deliberate deception | Intent to mislead | Adds a condition absent from the reasoning | Why the other options are wrong - Correct only when the statement was false: The quotation was accurate, yet its misleading impression still warrants clarification. - Clarify whenever someone claims reputational harm: The reasoning depends on the omitted qualification and resulting impression, not a claim of harm. - Release the complete interview: The editor calls for a clarification, not publication of the full interview. - Clarify only if the impression was deliberately produced: The editor’s reasoning does not require deliberate deception.

  3. 3. If a shipment was packed by the automated line, its label is perfectly aligned. The label on this shipment is perfectly aligned. Therefore, the shipment was packed by the automated line. The flawed reasoning in the argument above is most similar to that in which one of the following?

    • A. If a manuscript was professionally edited, it contains no typographical errors. This manuscript contains none, so it was professionally edited.
    • B. If the alarm was activated, the indicator flashed. The alarm was not activated, so the indicator did not flash.
    • C. Only registered vehicles may enter the loading area. This vehicle entered the area, so it was registered.
    • D. If a reservation was confirmed, a notice was sent. This reservation was confirmed, so a notice was sent.
    • E. The notice was delivered either electronically or on paper. It was not delivered on paper, so it was delivered electronically.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. If a manuscript was professionally edited, it contains no typographical errors. This manuscript contains none, so it was professionally edited.

    > Key point: Affirming the consequent mistakes a stated result for proof of the condition that would produce it. Why the manuscript argument is correct - Both arguments have the same form: if P, then Q; Q; therefore P. - Professional editing may prevent typographical errors, but an error-free manuscript does not prove it was professionally edited. How they compare | Reasoning pattern | Status | Why | |---|---|---| | No errors, so professionally edited | Flawed | Affirms the consequent | | No activation, so no flash | Flawed | Denies the antecedent | | Entered, so registered | Valid | Registration is required for entry | | Confirmed, so notice sent | Valid | Applies the stated conditional | | Not on paper, so electronic | Valid | Eliminates one of two alternatives | Why the other options are wrong - The alarm was not activated, so the indicator did not flash: denies the antecedent; the indicator could flash for another reason. - The vehicle entered, so it was registered: validly infers a necessary condition from entry. - The reservation was confirmed, so a notice was sent: validly applies the conditional from its stated condition. - The notice was not delivered on paper, so it was delivered electronically: validly eliminates paper delivery from the two stated alternatives.

  4. 4. Archivist: If a manuscript was translated by our staff, its catalog record includes a translator code. This manuscript's catalog record includes a translator code. Therefore, the manuscript was translated by our staff. Which one of the following arguments exhibits reasoning that is flawed in the same way as the archivist's reasoning?

    • A. If the greenhouse is heated, its vents open automatically. The vents did not open, so the greenhouse was not heated.
    • B. Every shelf made from cedar is durable. This shelf is made from cedar, so it must be durable.
    • C. If the alarm malfunctions, its warning light flashes. The alarm did not malfunction, so the warning light did not flash.
    • D. If a package is sent by express service, it receives an orange label. This package has an orange label, so it was sent express.
    • E. Some poets are editors, and every editor is an attentive reader. Therefore, some poets are attentive readers.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. If a package is sent by express service, it receives an orange label. This package has an orange label, so it was sent express.

    > Key point: Inferring a condition from its guaranteed result affirms the consequent and does not establish that condition. Why the express-package argument is correct - Both arguments have the form: if P, then Q; Q; therefore P. - An orange label, like a translator code, could be present without the stated cause. How they compare | Argument | Form | Assessment | |---|---|---| | Express package | If P, then Q; Q; so P | Affirms the consequent | | Heated greenhouse | If P, then Q; not Q; so not P | Valid contraposition | | Cedar shelf | P; if P, then Q; so Q | Valid application | | Malfunctioning alarm | If P, then Q; not P; so not Q | Denies the antecedent | | Poets and editors | Some P are Q; all Q are R; so some P are R | Valid inference | Why the other options are wrong - Heated greenhouse: It validly rules out heating because the guaranteed result did not occur. - Cedar shelf: It applies the rule to a shelf known to meet its condition. - Malfunctioning alarm: It denies the antecedent; the light could flash for another reason. - Poets and editors: The poets who are editors must be attentive readers, so the conclusion follows.

  5. 5. Principle: An organization may use a general indicator as a substitute for directly assessing a relevant qualification only when direct assessment is impracticable and the indicator reliably tracks that qualification. Even then, if reliable direct evidence about a particular person conflicts with the indicator, the organization should use the direct evidence. Which one of the following actions most closely conforms to the principle?

    • A. A theater uses applicants’ drama-school attendance as an indicator of acting ability, although brief individual auditions are practical and school attendance reliably tracks ability.
    • B. A publisher uses years of employment as an indicator of editing skill because direct assessment is impracticable, although it has no evidence that the indicator tracks skill.
    • C. A clinic uses punctuality as an indicator of reliability because direct assessment is impracticable and punctuality reliably tracks reliability, rejecting an applicant despite conflicting reliable direct evidence.
    • D. A foundation uses completion of long projects as an indicator of persistence because direct assessment is impracticable, the indicator reliably tracks persistence, and no reliable direct evidence conflicts.
    • E. A cooperative uses prior management experience as an indicator of leadership because direct assessment is impracticable and the indicator reliably tracks leadership, despite conflicting reliable direct evidence.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A foundation uses completion of long projects as an indicator of persistence because direct assessment is impracticable, the indicator reliably tracks persistence, and no reliable direct evidence conflicts.

    > Key point: Use an indicator only when direct assessment is impracticable and it reliably tracks the qualification; conflicting reliable direct evidence takes precedence. Why the foundation’s action is correct - Direct assessment is impracticable, and completion of long projects reliably tracks persistence. - No reliable direct evidence conflicts, so using the indicator conforms to the principle. Why the other options are wrong - Theater uses drama-school attendance: Auditions are practical, so the indicator cannot substitute for direct assessment. - Publisher uses years of employment: There is no evidence that the indicator reliably tracks editing skill. - Clinic uses punctuality: Conflicting reliable direct evidence should take precedence over the indicator. - Cooperative uses management experience: Conflicting reliable direct evidence should take precedence over the indicator.

  6. 6. Every warehouse selected for overnight dispatch has an automated inventory check. No warehouse lacking continuous power monitoring has an automated inventory check. Therefore, every warehouse selected for overnight dispatch has continuous power monitoring. Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its reasoning to the argument above?

    • A. Every newsletter chosen for daily publication receives copyediting. No newsletter without a designated editor receives copyediting. Therefore, every newsletter chosen for daily publication has a designated editor.
    • B. Every scholarship finalist receives an interview. Every scholarship recipient receives an interview. Therefore, every scholarship finalist is a scholarship recipient.
    • C. No café without a patio permit offers outdoor service. This café does not offer outdoor service. Therefore, this café does not have a patio permit.
    • D. Every toll route receives a safety inspection. No route without a barrier receives such an inspection. Some route has a barrier. Therefore, that route charges a toll.
    • E. Every authenticated artifact is cataloged. No replica is authenticated. Therefore, every cataloged artifact is not a replica.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Every newsletter chosen for daily publication receives copyediting. No newsletter without a designated editor receives copyediting. Therefore, every newsletter chosen for daily publication has a designated editor.

    > Key point: The argument chains two conditional rules: dispatch selection implies an inventory check, which implies continuous power monitoring. Why the newsletter argument is correct - Daily publication implies copyediting, and copyediting implies a designated editor. - Like the stimulus, it chains two implications to reach the conclusion. How they compare | Argument | Structure | Why it matches or fails | |---|---|---| | Newsletter | A → B; B → C; therefore A → C | Same conditional chain | | Scholarship | A → C; B → C; therefore A → B | Shared result does not link A to B | | Café | ¬P → ¬S; ¬S; therefore ¬P | Affirms the consequent | | Toll route | A → B; B → C; some C; therefore that route is A | The premises do not identify the barrier route as a toll route | | Artifact | A → C; B → ¬A; therefore C → ¬B | Reverses the cataloging implication | Why the other options are wrong - Scholarship finalists and recipients: Both groups receiving interviews does not show that finalists are recipients. - Café without a patio permit: The café’s lack of outdoor service does not establish that it lacks a permit. - Toll route: The premises show that toll routes have barriers, not that every route with a barrier charges a toll. - Authenticated artifact: Being cataloged does not establish that an artifact is authenticated, so cataloged replicas are not ruled out.

  7. 7. Consumer advocate: A file-storage company publicly promised to notify customers before materially changing how long their deleted files would remain recoverable. Many customers relied on that promise when choosing the service. The company later shortened the recovery period without advance notice. Even if the change violated no regulation, the company should restore the former period until customers receive the promised notice. Which one of the following principles most helps to justify the consumer advocate's reasoning?

    • A. An organization that voluntarily makes a clear commitment should honor it when others reasonably rely on that commitment.
    • B. An organization should reverse a policy change whenever that change causes inconvenience to some of its customers.
    • C. An organization may alter a service without notice only when every affected customer benefits from the alteration.
    • D. An organization that complies with applicable rules has no further obligations concerning its representations to customers.
    • E. An organization should retain its original policies whenever customers could not easily obtain similar services elsewhere.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. An organization that voluntarily makes a clear commitment should honor it when others reasonably rely on that commitment.

    > Key point: A clear voluntary commitment should be honored when others reasonably rely on it. Why the reliance principle is correct - The company promised advance notice before materially changing file recovery, and customers relied on that promise when choosing the service. - Restoring the former period until notice is given honors the commitment, regardless of whether the change violated a regulation. Why the other options are wrong - Reverse a change whenever it inconveniences some customers: The argument rests on the broken promise, not inconvenience alone. - Change without notice only if every affected customer benefits: The argument does not establish whether customers benefit; it objects to failing to give promised notice. - Compliance means no further obligations about representations: The advocate says the promise should be honored even if no regulation was violated. - Retain policies when similar services are hard to obtain: The argument gives no information about alternatives; it ties restoration to the promised notice.

  8. 8. No ceramic vessel in the collection is both glazed and unsealed. Every vessel displayed in Case R is glazed. Therefore, no unsealed vessel is displayed in Case R. Which one of the following arguments is most similar in its reasoning to the argument above?

    • A. No manuscript in the archive is both anonymous and dated. Every manuscript in Drawer K is anonymous. Therefore, no manuscript in Drawer K is dated.
    • B. No instrument in the storeroom is both brass and damaged. Some instruments on the upper shelf are brass. Therefore, no instrument on that shelf is damaged.
    • C. Every ticket scanned at the entrance is valid. No counterfeit ticket is valid. Therefore, every valid ticket was scanned at the entrance.
    • D. Some trees in the courtyard are evergreen. No evergreen tree loses all its leaves in winter. Therefore, no courtyard tree loses all its leaves in winter.
    • E. Every report in the blue folder is confidential. Some confidential reports are unsigned. Therefore, some reports in the blue folder are unsigned.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. No manuscript in the archive is both anonymous and dated. Every manuscript in Drawer K is anonymous. Therefore, no manuscript in Drawer K is dated.

    > Key point: The matching argument applies a universal restriction to a group whose every member has the restricted property. Why the manuscript argument is correct - Both arguments say no member of a broader group can have two properties together. - Every member of the narrower group has one of those properties, so none can have the other. How they compare | Argument | Key difference | |---|---| | Manuscripts | Every Drawer K manuscript is anonymous; none can also be dated. | | Instruments | Only some upper-shelf instruments are brass. | | Tickets | Reverses the direction of the conditional. | | Trees | Only some courtyard trees are evergreen. | | Reports | Assumes an overlap not established by the premises. | Why the other options are wrong - Instruments: “Some” brass instruments does not establish that every instrument on the shelf is brass. - Tickets: Scanned tickets being valid does not mean every valid ticket was scanned. - Trees: The premise covers only some courtyard trees, not all of them. - Reports: The unsigned confidential reports need not be in the blue folder.

  9. 9. Editor: Readership increased shortly after the newspaper switched to a new front-page layout. Therefore, the new layout caused the increase in readership. Which one of the following arguments exhibits reasoning most similar in its flaw to the editor's argument?

    • A. Traffic accidents decreased shortly after the city installed new streetlights. Therefore, the new streetlights caused the decrease in accidents.
    • B. Every certified guide has completed safety training. Niko is a certified guide. Therefore, Niko has completed safety training.
    • C. If severe weather closes the pier, the ferry is delayed. The ferry was not delayed. Therefore, severe weather did not close the pier.
    • D. Attendance at the museum rose shortly after ticket prices were lowered. Therefore, the lower ticket prices caused the rise in attendance.
    • E. Every ceramic bowl in the collection is fragile. Some fragile objects in the collection are imported. Therefore, some ceramic bowls are imported.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Attendance at the museum rose shortly after ticket prices were lowered. Therefore, the lower ticket prices caused the rise in attendance.

    Attendance at the museum rose shortly after ticket prices were lowered. Therefore, the lower ticket prices caused the rise in attendance. - Like the editor, this argument treats an increase in audience after a change affecting that audience as proof that the change caused the increase. - Neither argument rules out other reasons for the rise in readership or attendance. Traffic accidents decreased shortly after the city installed new streetlights. Therefore, the new streetlights caused the decrease in accidents. - This argument also infers causation from timing, so it shares the editor’s flaw. - The museum argument is the closer match because both it and the editor’s argument concern a rise in the number of people using a service after a change to that service. Every certified guide has completed safety training. Niko is a certified guide. Therefore, Niko has completed safety training. - The stated rule applies to every certified guide, and Niko is a certified guide. - The conclusion follows from that rule rather than inferring a cause from an event’s timing. If severe weather closes the pier, the ferry is delayed. The ferry was not delayed. Therefore, severe weather did not close the pier. - This is valid contraposition: if closing the pier would delay the ferry, no delay means severe weather did not close the pier. - It makes no claim that one event caused another merely because it happened first. Every ceramic bowl in the collection is fragile. Some fragile objects in the collection are imported. Therefore, some ceramic bowls are imported. - The imported fragile objects need not include any ceramic bowls. - Its flaw is an unsupported inference about overlapping groups, not an inference of causation from timing.

Flashcards: Naming the flaw and matching it

  1. 1. Why can a logically valid answer choice be eliminated in a parallel-flaw problem?

    Show answer

    A valid argument cannot parallel a flawed argument because it commits no reasoning error. Similar subject matter or wording cannot overcome that difference.

  2. 2. Before examining answer choices in a parallel-flaw problem, what should you identify?

    Show answer

    Identify the stimulus’s conclusion, supporting evidence, and exact inferential error. State the flaw in an abstract form that can apply to other topics.

  3. 3. What must two arguments share for one to be a true parallel-flaw match?

    Show answer

    They must make the same type of logical error in the same structural role. Their topics, wording, and conclusions may differ.

  4. 4. Identify the flaw in this argument: 'Every shipment that clears customs receives a tracking number. The Vega shipment received a tracking number. Therefore, the Vega shipment cleared customs.'

    Show answer

    This argument commits the fallacy of affirming the consequent. It assumes that because the consequent (receiving a tracking number) occurred, the antecedent (clearing customs) must also have occurred, when other reasons for receiving a tracking number might exist.

  5. 5. What flaw occurs when an argument reasons, “If P, then Q; Q; therefore P”?

    Show answer

    It confuses a sufficient condition with a necessary condition by affirming the consequent. A parallel answer must make that same mistaken reversal.

  6. 6. What flaw occurs when an argument reasons, “If P, then Q; not P; therefore not Q”?

    Show answer

    It denies the antecedent, wrongly treating P as necessary for Q. A parallel match must likewise infer the absence of an outcome from the absence of one sufficient condition.

  7. 7. If two choices contain the same named flaw, what additional feature helps identify the closer parallel?

    Show answer

    Match how the flawed step connects the premises to the conclusion, including conditional direction, quantifiers, and causal or group relationships. The same broad label can cover structurally different mistakes.

  8. 8. How do you distinguish a part-to-whole flaw from a whole-to-part flaw when matching arguments?

    Show answer

    Part-to-whole reasoning transfers a trait from members or components to the group; whole-to-part reasoning transfers a group trait to each member. The answer must preserve the direction of the mistaken transfer.

  9. 9. What must match when the stimulus attacks a person instead of addressing that person’s evidence?

    Show answer

    The answer must also reject a claim because of an irrelevant fact about its source rather than evaluate the claim’s support. A generally skeptical tone is not enough.

Everything you need for LSAT prep

Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

GET STARTED FOR FREE
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF