Why one increase does not imply another

Why one increase does not imply another

Published September 28, 2026

Why one increase does not imply another

On this page

More X can feel like evidence of more Y. When is that inference valid?

Run this procedure:

  1. Name the two quantities. State exactly what increased and what the argument says increased.

  2. Underline the claimed connection. Is the argument saying X guarantees, causes, or merely accompanies Y?

  3. Look for a rule, not a sequence. A premise reporting “X increased” gives you one change. It does not supply an arrow from X to Y. You need an explicit rule such as X → Y, or a definition that makes Y depend on X.

  4. Build a counterexample. Keep the stated increase in X, but imagine Y staying the same or decreasing. If that is consistent with the stimulus, the conclusion about Y is not forced.

For example, more museum visitors could include free visitors, repeat visitors using existing passes, or people who enter without buying a new ticket. The point is to show that the first increase can occur while the second does not.

One Increase, Two Possible Outcomes: Test the Inference

Last year, the museum recorded 20,000 visitors and sold 18,000 admission tickets. This year, it recorded 22,000 visitors. Therefore, it sold more admission tickets this year.

Practice

The argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it:

Make the Counterexample Fast: Freeze the Target Quantity

When you see “X increased, so Y increased,” ask: Can X rise while Y remains unchanged?

If yes, the argument fails unless another premise rules that possibility out. You need only describe a coherent situation: more visitors but the same ticket sales; more applicants but the same number hired; more rainfall but the same reservoir level.

If the stimulus states that every X produces one Y, or that Y is defined by X, then the connection may be forced. Otherwise, treat the two movements as independent and demand the missing link.

High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

Treat an increase as local evidence unless a stated rule links it to the target quantity. Test the inference by holding the first increase fixed while leaving the second unchanged or lower. Accept the conclusion only when the stimulus supplies the missing link, not when the quantities merely sound related.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Why one increase does not imply another

  1. 1. Ensemble manager: For years, rehearsals began at 7:00 P.M. During a two-month trial in which rehearsals instead began at 6:00 P.M., the average number of late arrivals per rehearsal declined substantially. Thus, beginning rehearsals earlier caused ensemble members to arrive more punctually. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the ensemble manager's argument?

    • A. Several ensemble members preferred the earlier rehearsal time even before the trial began.
    • B. More frequent train service to the rehearsal venue began when the new schedule was introduced.
    • C. The ensemble continued imposing the same consequences for lateness throughout the entire trial.
    • D. Some rehearsals under both schedules began several minutes after their announced starting times.
    • E. The ensemble rehearsed the same compositions before and after the schedule was changed.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. More frequent train service to the rehearsal venue began when the new schedule was introduced.

    More frequent train service to the rehearsal venue began when the new schedule was introduced. - More frequent train service could have made it easier for members to reach rehearsals on time. - Because that change coincided with the two-month trial, the decline in late arrivals does not establish that the 6:00 P.M. start caused it. Several ensemble members preferred the earlier rehearsal time even before the trial began. - A preference for 6:00 P.M. does not show that those members arrived earlier or explain the decline in late arrivals. - It supplies no competing cause for the change observed during the trial. The ensemble continued imposing the same consequences for lateness throughout the entire trial. - Unchanged consequences do not explain why late arrivals declined during the trial. - Keeping this policy constant leaves the manager’s proposed explanation largely untouched. Some rehearsals under both schedules began several minutes after their announced starting times. - Delayed starts occurred under both schedules, so this fact does not explain why late arrivals declined during the trial. - The choice identifies no systematic difference that would undermine the comparison between the 7:00 P.M. and 6:00 P.M. periods. The ensemble rehearsed the same compositions before and after the schedule was changed. - The same compositions give no apparent reason for members to arrive more punctually during the trial. - This similarity does not offer an alternative cause for the decline in late arrivals.

  2. 2. Cafeteria manager: Last month, we moved desserts from a prominent counter beside the cash registers to a less noticeable shelf. The average number of grams of sugar contained in each purchased lunch then declined. Therefore, moving the desserts caused customers to choose lunches containing less sugar. Which one of the following would be most useful to know in evaluating the manager’s argument?

    • A. Whether some customers purchased desserts without buying lunch
    • B. Whether the cafeteria’s lunch prices changed during the same period
    • C. Whether the sugar content of the foods offered at lunch changed
    • D. Whether customers considered the new dessert shelf less attractive
    • E. Whether average lunchtime attendance increased after the shelf was moved
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Whether the sugar content of the foods offered at lunch changed

    Whether the sugar content of the foods offered at lunch changed - The decline in average sugar per purchased lunch could result from lower-sugar foods being offered, even if customers made the same kinds of choices as before. - Knowing whether the offerings changed directly tests the manager’s claim that moving the desserts, rather than a change in the food available, caused the decline. Whether some customers purchased desserts without buying lunch - Dessert-only purchases are not purchased lunches, so they do not enter the average the manager cites. - Knowing whether they occurred would not explain why the measured sugar content per purchased lunch declined. Whether the cafeteria’s lunch prices changed during the same period - A price change could matter if it changed which foods customers bought, but this question alone does not establish that connection. - A change in the sugar content of foods offered provides a more direct alternative explanation for the measured decline. Whether customers considered the new dessert shelf less attractive - Finding the shelf less attractive might help explain how the move affected choices. - It would not distinguish that explanation from a decline caused by changes in the sugar content of the foods offered. Whether average lunchtime attendance increased after the shelf was moved - Attendance counts how many people came, while the manager’s evidence concerns average sugar per purchased lunch. - An increase alone would not show whether the decline came from the shelf move, different foods, or different purchasing choices.

  3. 3. Production analyst: At the North plant, the number of defective units fell from 600 last year to 450 this year. At the South plant, it fell from 300 to 240. Each plant produced the same total number of units this year as it did last year. Therefore, the defect rate declined by more percentage points at North than at South. Which one of the following, if assumed, enables the production analyst's conclusion to be properly drawn?

    • A. The North plant produced more units than the South plant in each of the two years.
    • B. The North and South plants produced the same total number of units in each of the two years.
    • C. The number of nondefective units produced by each plant increased from last year to this year.
    • D. Defective units from the two plants imposed approximately the same average replacement cost.
    • E. Defective units from each plant were equally likely to be identified during the final inspection.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The North and South plants produced the same total number of units in each of the two years.

    The North and South plants produced the same total number of units in each of the two years. - Because each plant’s output was unchanged across years, this assumption gives both plants the same denominator for comparing changes in defect rates. - North’s defective-unit count fell by 150, versus 60 at South, so North’s defect rate fell by more percentage points. The North plant produced more units than the South plant in each of the two years. - Producing more units does not establish how the plants’ rate changes compare. - For example, with unchanged outputs of 10,000 at North and 1,000 at South, their declines would be 1.5 and 6 percentage points, respectively. The number of nondefective units produced by each plant increased from last year to this year. - This already follows because each plant’s total output stayed constant while its defective-unit count fell. - It does not establish a common denominator for comparing the plants’ defect-rate declines. Defective units from the two plants imposed approximately the same average replacement cost. - Replacement cost does not enter the calculation of a defect rate. - Equal costs therefore cannot show whether North’s decline of 150 defective units represents more percentage points than South’s decline of 60. Defective units from each plant were equally likely to be identified during the final inspection. - Equal identification likelihood does not specify either plant’s total output. - Without those denominators, the larger drop in defective units at North need not be the larger percentage-point drop.

  4. 4. Principle: An organization should publicly correct one of its factual statements if and only if the statement is materially inaccurate and issuing the correction would not reveal confidential information. Which one of the following actions most closely conforms to this principle?

    • A. An agency corrects a materially inaccurate statement even though doing so reveals confidential information.
    • B. An agency declines to correct a materially inaccurate statement whose correction would reveal no confidential information.
    • C. An agency corrects an immaterial inaccuracy whose correction would reveal no confidential information.
    • D. An agency corrects a materially inaccurate statement whose correction would reveal no confidential information.
    • E. An agency corrects an accurate statement after several members of the public criticize it.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. An agency corrects a materially inaccurate statement whose correction would reveal no confidential information.

    An agency corrects a materially inaccurate statement whose correction would reveal no confidential information. - The statement is materially inaccurate, and correcting it would reveal no confidential information. - Because both conditions hold, the principle requires a public correction, which is exactly what the agency does. An agency corrects a materially inaccurate statement even though doing so reveals confidential information. - The statement is materially inaccurate, but correcting it reveals confidential information. - The principle permits correction only when it would not reveal confidential information, so this correction violates it. An agency declines to correct a materially inaccurate statement whose correction would reveal no confidential information. - Both conditions for correction hold: the statement is materially inaccurate, and correction would reveal no confidential information. - The principle therefore requires correction, so declining to correct violates it. An agency corrects an immaterial inaccuracy whose correction would reveal no confidential information. - The inaccuracy is immaterial, even though correcting it would reveal no confidential information. - Without material inaccuracy, the principle does not permit the agency to issue a public correction. An agency corrects an accurate statement after several members of the public criticize it. - An accurate statement does not meet the principle’s material-inaccuracy condition. - Public criticism does not substitute for material inaccuracy, so correcting the statement violates the principle.

  5. 5. Operations manager: A help desk's northern team began holding mandatory ten-minute briefings before each shift. Over the next two months, the number of that team's tickets remaining unresolved for more than 48 hours decreased by 40 percent. The corresponding number for the southern team, which held no such briefings, remained unchanged. Therefore, the briefings improved the speed with which the northern team resolved tickets. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the operations manager's argument?

    • A. The northern team also transferred its oldest unresolved tickets to a separate unit during the two-month period.
    • B. Most members of the northern team reported that the briefings made their daily responsibilities clearer.
    • C. Both teams continued using the same ticket-management software throughout the two-month period.
    • D. The northern team received more new tickets during the two-month period than it had previously received.
    • E. The decrease for the northern team was larger for routine tickets than for unusually complex tickets.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The northern team also transferred its oldest unresolved tickets to a separate unit during the two-month period.

    The northern team also transferred its oldest unresolved tickets to a separate unit during the two-month period. - Transferring the oldest unresolved tickets could reduce the northern team’s count of tickets open for more than 48 hours without resolving those tickets any faster. - The transfers therefore offer an alternative explanation for the 40 percent decrease that the southern team’s unchanged count does not rule out. Most members of the northern team reported that the briefings made their daily responsibilities clearer. - Clearer responsibilities are consistent with the briefings helping the northern team work faster. - The reports do not explain how the count of overdue tickets could fall without an improvement in resolution speed. Both teams continued using the same ticket-management software throughout the two-month period. - Unchanged software makes a software change less likely to explain the difference between the teams. - It does not identify another cause of the northern team’s 40 percent decrease. The northern team received more new tickets during the two-month period than it had previously received. - A larger incoming workload could make it harder, not easier, to reduce the count of tickets open for more than 48 hours. - The decrease despite more new tickets therefore does not provide an alternative explanation for the result. The decrease for the northern team was larger for routine tickets than for unusually complex tickets. - Briefings could improve resolution speed more for routine tickets while still improving speed overall. - A smaller decrease among complex tickets does not show that the northern team’s overdue-ticket count fell for a reason other than faster resolution.

  6. 6. Help-desk manager: Two years ago, password-reset requests constituted 18 percent of all requests received by our help desk. Last year, they constituted only 12 percent of all requests. Therefore, the number of password-reset requests received by the help desk decreased. The reasoning in the manager's argument is flawed because the argument

    • A. It bases a conclusion about requests on data that do not identify how many users submitted them.
    • B. It overlooks the possibility that total requests increased enough for password-reset requests to increase in number.
    • C. It presumes without justification that each request was assigned to only one service category.
    • D. It treats a proportional decline as establishing that service improvements caused the decline.
    • E. It projects a pattern observed over two years indefinitely into the future.
    Show answer

    Answer: B. It overlooks the possibility that total requests increased enough for password-reset requests to increase in number.

    It overlooks the possibility that total requests increased enough for password-reset requests to increase in number. - The manager infers a decrease in the number of password-reset requests from a decrease in their share of all requests, from 18 percent to 12 percent. - If total requests rose from 1,000 to 2,000, password-reset requests would have risen from 180 to 240 despite the lower percentage. It bases a conclusion about requests on data that do not identify how many users submitted them. - The conclusion concerns the number of requests, not the number of distinct users who submitted them. - A user’s ability to submit multiple requests therefore does not explain the gap between the percentages and the conclusion. It presumes without justification that each request was assigned to only one service category. - The argument does not need to assume that service categories are mutually exclusive. - Even if requests could belong to multiple categories, the stated percentages alone would still not establish a decrease in password-reset requests. It treats a proportional decline as establishing that service improvements caused the decline. - The manager draws a conclusion about the number of password-reset requests, not the cause of any change. - No service improvement is mentioned or offered as an explanation for the drop from 18 percent to 12 percent. It projects a pattern observed over two years indefinitely into the future. - The conclusion compares two years ago with last year; it makes no prediction about later years. - The flaw is in converting percentages for those two years into a claim about the number of requests, not in extending a trend.

  7. 7. Café manager: Eight weeks after our café replaced disposable cups with reusable cups requiring a refundable deposit, the amount of litter collected each morning on the surrounding block had fallen by half. Thus, our new cup policy caused the reduction in litter on the block. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the café manager's argument?

    • A. Most customers returned their reusable cups and collected the deposits they had paid.
    • B. The café spent more administering the deposit program than it previously spent purchasing disposable cups.
    • C. A nearby construction project that had produced most of the area's litter ended when the policy began.
    • D. Several other cafés continued providing disposable cups without requiring customers to pay deposits.
    • E. The café's total number of beverage sales remained approximately constant during the eight-week period.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A nearby construction project that had produced most of the area's litter ended when the policy began.

    A nearby construction project that had produced most of the area's litter ended when the policy began. - The project’s end provides an alternative cause for the decline in litter collected on the block. - Because it ended when the cup policy began, the manager cannot attribute the decline to the policy merely from their timing. Most customers returned their reusable cups and collected the deposits they had paid. - Returning cups is consistent with fewer café cups being discarded, so this could support the manager’s explanation. - It does not identify another cause of the block’s reduced litter. The café spent more administering the deposit program than it previously spent purchasing disposable cups. - The program’s cost does not bear on whether it reduced litter. - A policy can cost more than its predecessor and still cause the observed decline. Several other cafés continued providing disposable cups without requiring customers to pay deposits. - Those cafés’ continued practices do not identify a change that explains why litter on this block fell. - Disposable cups could still be used elsewhere while this café’s policy reduced litter nearby. The café's total number of beverage sales remained approximately constant during the eight-week period. - Stable sales make a drop in this café’s beverage activity a less plausible explanation for the litter decline. - They do not rule out the cup policy as a cause, so they do not weaken the manager’s argument.

  8. 8. Principle: A manager is justified in attributing an improved outcome to a workplace change only if a comparable workplace that did not adopt the change showed no similar improvement and no other relevant change occurred only at the workplace being evaluated. Which one of the following situations most closely conforms to the principle?

    • A. A branch changed its displays, and sales rose there and at an unchanged comparison branch.
    • B. A branch changed its displays, and sales rose, but no comparison branch was examined.
    • C. A branch changed its displays, sales rose only there, and it also hired additional sales staff.
    • D. A warehouse adopted a checklist, errors fell only there, and comparable operations otherwise remained unchanged.
    • E. A branch changed employee schedules, sales rose only there, and it also replaced its outdated equipment.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A warehouse adopted a checklist, errors fell only there, and comparable operations otherwise remained unchanged.

    A warehouse adopted a checklist, errors fell only there, and comparable operations otherwise remained unchanged. - Errors fell only at the warehouse that adopted the checklist, not at comparable operations. - Because other relevant conditions remained unchanged, the checklist meets both conditions for attributing the improvement to it. A branch changed its displays, and sales rose there and at an unchanged comparison branch. - Sales also rose at the unchanged comparison branch, so the required comparison showed a similar improvement. - The display change therefore cannot be credited under the principle, even though sales rose at the branch that made it. A branch changed its displays, and sales rose, but no comparison branch was examined. - Without a comparison branch, the manager cannot establish that a workplace without new displays showed no similar sales increase. - The branch’s higher sales alone do not satisfy the principle’s conditions for attribution. A branch changed its displays, sales rose only there, and it also hired additional sales staff. - Sales rising only there satisfies the comparison condition. - Hiring additional sales staff is another relevant change at the improving branch, so the manager cannot isolate the displays as the cause. A branch changed employee schedules, sales rose only there, and it also replaced its outdated equipment. - Sales rising only there satisfies the comparison condition. - Replacing outdated equipment is another relevant change at that branch, so the manager is not justified in attributing the increase to the schedules alone.

Flashcards: Why one increase does not imply another

  1. 1. A report states that 'X increased, therefore Y increased.' What is the fastest way to test this inference?

    Show answer

    Ask: Can X rise while Y remains unchanged or even decreases? If yes, the inference fails unless a rule explicitly links X to Y.

  2. 2. The percentage of defective items fell from 10% to 8%. Must the number of defective items have fallen?

    Show answer

    No. If total production increased enough, 8% of the new total could exceed 10% of the old total.

  3. 3. A report claims that more people bought electric cars because electric cars' share of all car sales rose. What fact would most weaken that inference?

    Show answer

    Total car sales fell enough that the higher percentage represents fewer electric cars. A rising share does not guarantee a rising number when the base shrinks.

  4. 4. If exactly 30% of a group voted 'yes', what must be true about the number of 'yes' votes?

    Show answer

    The number of 'yes' votes must be a multiple of 3. (30% = 3/10, so the count must be a multiple of the numerator, 3.)

  5. 5. A survey says 60% of Group A and 40% of Group B support a proposal. Can you conclude that more supporters are in Group A?

    Show answer

    No. The sizes of Groups A and B are needed to compare their numbers of supporters.

  6. 6. A city reports that 30% of its residents commute by train. What additional information is needed to determine the number of train commuters?

    Show answer

    The city's total number of residents—the base—is needed. Multiply that total by 30%.

  7. 7. Department A's budget increased by $10,000, while Department B's increased by 10%. Can the larger increase be identified?

    Show answer

    Not without Department B's original budget. Its 10% increase could be less than, equal to, or greater than $10,000.

  8. 8. A company employs 80 engineers, who make up 20% of all employees. How many total employees does the company have?

    Show answer

    The company has 400 employees: 80 ÷ 0.20 = 400.

Everything you need for LSAT prep

Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

GET STARTED FOR FREE
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF