The Missing Link: Separate What Rose from What Must Follow
More X can feel like evidence of more Y. When is that inference valid?
Run this procedure:
-
Name the two quantities. State exactly what increased and what the argument says increased.
-
Underline the claimed connection. Is the argument saying X guarantees, causes, or merely accompanies Y?
-
Look for a rule, not a sequence. A premise reporting “X increased” gives you one change. It does not supply an arrow from X to Y. You need an explicit rule such as X → Y, or a definition that makes Y depend on X.
-
Build a counterexample. Keep the stated increase in X, but imagine Y staying the same or decreasing. If that is consistent with the stimulus, the conclusion about Y is not forced.
For example, more museum visitors could include free visitors, repeat visitors using existing passes, or people who enter without buying a new ticket. The point is to show that the first increase can occur while the second does not.
One Increase, Two Possible Outcomes: Test the Inference
Last year, the museum recorded 20,000 visitors and sold 18,000 admission tickets. This year, it recorded 22,000 visitors. Therefore, it sold more admission tickets this year.
Practice
The argument is most vulnerable to criticism on the grounds that it:
Make the Counterexample Fast: Freeze the Target Quantity
When you see “X increased, so Y increased,” ask: Can X rise while Y remains unchanged?
If yes, the argument fails unless another premise rules that possibility out. You need only describe a coherent situation: more visitors but the same ticket sales; more applicants but the same number hired; more rainfall but the same reservoir level.
If the stimulus states that every X produces one Y, or that Y is defined by X, then the connection may be forced. Otherwise, treat the two movements as independent and demand the missing link.
High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways
Treat an increase as local evidence unless a stated rule links it to the target quantity. Test the inference by holding the first increase fixed while leaving the second unchanged or lower. Accept the conclusion only when the stimulus supplies the missing link, not when the quantities merely sound related.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more