The Stem Decides the Job: Read the Number Trap Through the Question Type
First, identify what the stem asks you to prove.
-
Flaw: Find the unsupported move. The numerical error is often not bad arithmetic but an unearned comparison: a rate is treated like a count, a sample is treated like a population, or an association is treated like a cause. State precisely what the evidence establishes and what the conclusion adds.
-
Weaken: Damage that unsupported move. Look for information that changes the relevant comparison, reveals a different group composition, or shows that the numerical pattern does not support the conclusion. A merely surprising number is not enough; it must interfere with the argument’s bridge.
-
Must Be True: Treat every figure as a restriction. Translate the statements into groups, apply only what is stated, and choose the answer that follows without importing causation, representativeness, or an unstated comparison. “Could be true” is not the task.
One Item, Three Kinds of Discipline: Keep “Must” Narrow
A survey of 1,000 employees found that 40 percent used the company’s new scheduling app. Of app users, 60 percent said they had avoided at least one scheduling conflict that month. Of nonusers, 30 percent said they had avoided at least one scheduling conflict.
Practice
Which one of the following must be true?
The same discipline transfers directly to the other stems. In a Flaw question, answer the choice describing the unsupported leap, not a choice merely saying that more data would help. In a Weaken question, choose information that attacks the leap while respecting the stated groups. In a Must Be True question, reject any answer that changes “more people” into “higher rate,” “associated with” into “caused,” or “reported” into “actually experienced.”
A Thirty-Second Run: Force the Right Comparison
-
Name the stem’s burden: flaw, weaken, or must be true.
-
Mark each number’s group: who is in the numerator, and which larger group supplies its denominator?
-
Identify the claim being tested: count, rate, causal effect, or certainty.
-
Ask what would reverse or support that claim: a different group size, an omitted comparison, or an alternative explanation.
-
Reject excess: if an answer says “causes,” “all,” “most,” or “exactly,” demand explicit support for that stronger wording.
High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways
Match your numerical attack to the stem: unsupported leap, damaging information, or forced consequence. Compare counts and rates only after identifying the groups behind them. In Must Be True questions, reject every causal, exact, or stronger claim not compelled by the numbers.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more