Attacking the source and the straw man

Attacking the source and the straw man

Published September 28, 2026

Attacking the source and the straw man

On this page

Find the Target: Is the Attack Aimed at the Claim or Its Source?

When an argument attacks a person, publication, motive, or origin, how do you tell whether it has answered the claim?

Run this procedure:

  1. State the target claim neutrally. Ask what proposition is supposed to be true.
  2. Locate the support offered against it. Is the support about the claim’s evidence, or about where the claim came from?
  3. Name the object attacked.
    • If the argument attacks the source as a source, it uses a source argument.
    • If it attacks the source’s character, motives, intelligence, or status, it is an ad hominem.
    • If it attacks the origin or history of the belief, it is a genetic fallacy.
    • If it attacks only the quality of an argument and then concludes that the argument’s conclusion is false, it commits the fallacy fallacy.
  4. Ask whether the source information actually bears on the claim. A source’s reliability can matter when the source is the only basis for the claim. But “this came from a bad person” or “this began in a disreputable place” does not by itself refute the content.

These labels can overlap. A genetic fallacy is often a source attack, and an ad hominem is often a source attack. Use the narrowest label that matches what the argument attacks.

Do not confuse “the source is unreliable” with “the claim is false.” The first may show only that this support is weak.

Separate the Person, the Origin, and the Reason: Three Fast Tests

For a source argument, replace the source temporarily with a neutral description:

“The claim is false because its advocate has a financial interest.”

The argument has not examined the claim. It has tried to disqualify the source. The same structure can be reasonable if the conclusion is specifically about the source-for example, “This witness is unreliable because she could not see the event.” The flaw appears when source information substitutes for evaluating the claim.

For an ad hominem, ask whether the attack would work only by making the audience dislike or distrust the person:

“Do not accept the proposal; its author is arrogant.”

Arrogance does not show that the proposal is mistaken. Motive attacks work the same way: a person may have a bad motive and still make a true statement.

For the genetic fallacy, track the claim’s birthplace rather than the current speaker:

“That medical practice originated in an ancient superstition, so it cannot be effective.”

Its origin may be irrelevant to whether it works now. The claim must be tested on present evidence, not merely on how it began.

For the fallacy fallacy, use a different test:

“That argument relies on an ad hominem, so its conclusion is false.”

The criticism may correctly show that the argument fails to establish its conclusion. It does not show that the conclusion itself is false. A bad argument can accidentally support a true conclusion.

One Source, One Claim: Classify the Attack

A study reports that a particular fertilizer increases crop yields. The study first appeared in a newsletter published by a company that sells that fertilizer. Dana says, “The study’s conclusion is worthless because it came from that newsletter.”

Practice

Which one of the following most accurately describes Dana’s reasoning?

On a question stem, identify the conclusion first, then circle the noun receiving the attack: argument, person, or origin. If the conclusion is rejected merely because the argument was defective, select the fallacy fallacy instead.

High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

Identify whether the attack targets the claim, its source, a person, or the claim’s origin. An ad hominem attacks the person; a genetic fallacy attacks where the belief came from. A bad argument does not make its conclusion false: that mistake is the fallacy fallacy.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Attacking the source and the straw man

  1. 1. Editor: Every manuscript accepted for the anthology undergoes copyediting. Lio's manuscript underwent copyediting. Therefore, Lio's manuscript was accepted for the anthology. Which one of the following arguments exhibits reasoning most similar in its flaw to that exhibited by the editor's argument?

    • A. Every reserved auditorium seat has a number. This seat has no number, so it is not reserved.
    • B. Any employee authorized to approve invoices has completed compliance training. Mara is authorized, so she completed the training.
    • C. Some trained tour guides speak several languages. Elena is a trained guide, so she speaks several languages.
    • D. Every recipient of the research grant was interviewed. Nia was interviewed, so she received the research grant.
    • E. Every application submitted late is reviewed separately. Omar's application was not late, so it was not reviewed separately.
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Every recipient of the research grant was interviewed. Nia was interviewed, so she received the research grant.

    Every recipient of the research grant was interviewed. Nia was interviewed, so she received the research grant. - The editor treats copyediting, a requirement for acceptance, as proof that Lio’s manuscript was accepted. - Likewise, this argument treats being interviewed, a requirement for receiving the grant, as proof that Nia received it. Every reserved auditorium seat has a number. This seat has no number, so it is not reserved. - This argument validly uses the contrapositive: if every reserved seat has a number, an unnumbered seat cannot be reserved. - The editor instead starts with the required feature, copyediting, and wrongly infers acceptance. Any employee authorized to approve invoices has completed compliance training. Mara is authorized, so she completed the training. - Authorization guarantees compliance training under the stated rule, so the conclusion about Mara follows. - Copyediting does not similarly guarantee that Lio’s manuscript was accepted. Some trained tour guides speak several languages. Elena is a trained guide, so she speaks several languages. - Some trained guides being multilingual does not establish that Elena is one of them. - The editor’s flaw instead reverses an every statement: acceptance requires copyediting, but copyediting need not mean acceptance. Every application submitted late is reviewed separately. Omar's application was not late, so it was not reviewed separately. - This argument denies the antecedent: an application submitted on time might still be reviewed separately. - The editor instead affirms the consequent, inferring acceptance from copyediting.

  2. 2. Archivist: Every report meeting the archive’s permanent-retention standard contains either original field observations or analysis that cannot be reproduced from retained data. Report R contains neither: its observations duplicate archived records, and its analysis can be reproduced from retained data. Therefore, Report R does not meet the standard. Since the archive restores a report only if that report meets the standard, Report R should not be restored. The claim that Report R does not meet the permanent-retention standard plays which one of the following roles in the archivist’s argument?

    • A. It is the argument’s main conclusion about what action the archive should take.
    • B. It is a premise offered to establish that the report contains no original observations.
    • C. It is a subsidiary conclusion that supports the argument’s final recommendation.
    • D. It is an objection that the argument acknowledges before rejecting the archive’s policy.
    • E. It is a general principle inferred from the particular features of Report R.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It is a subsidiary conclusion that supports the argument’s final recommendation.

    It is a subsidiary conclusion that supports the argument’s final recommendation. - The general standard and Report R’s lack of original observations or irreproducible analysis support the conclusion that R does not meet the permanent-retention standard. - That conclusion then supports the final recommendation: because the archive restores a report only if it meets the standard, R should not be restored. It is the argument’s main conclusion about what action the archive should take. - The main conclusion about action is that Report R should not be restored. - The claim that R does not meet the standard is an intermediate step toward that recommendation, not the recommendation itself. It is a premise offered to establish that the report contains no original observations. - The archivist establishes the absence of original observations by saying R’s observations duplicate archived records. - That fact helps establish that R does not meet the standard; the proposed premise-and-conclusion relationship runs in the opposite direction. It is an objection that the argument acknowledges before rejecting the archive’s policy. - The archivist endorses the claim that R does not meet the standard rather than raising it as an objection. - The argument applies the archive’s restoration policy; it does not reject that policy. It is a general principle inferred from the particular features of Report R. - The claim concerns Report R specifically, not reports in general. - The archivist applies a general retention requirement to R’s features rather than inferring a general principle from them.

  3. 3. Production analyst: At the Arlen facility, defective items declined from 4 percent of output last quarter to 3 percent this quarter. At the Bex facility, defective items declined from 2 percent of output to 1 percent over the same period. Since each defect rate declined by one percentage point, each facility produced the same number of fewer defective items this quarter. The reasoning in the analyst’s argument is flawed because the argument

    • A. It treats a reduction in defects as sufficient to show that total production increased.
    • B. It assumes without evidence that both facilities’ defect rates will continue to decline.
    • C. It infers equal numerical reductions from equal percentage-point declines without considering output levels.
    • D. It compares defect rates from periods that may differ in length rather than from identical periods.
    • E. It presumes that a facility with a lower defect rate must use a better inspection process.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It infers equal numerical reductions from equal percentage-point declines without considering output levels.

    It infers equal numerical reductions from equal percentage-point declines without considering output levels. - A one-percentage-point decline describes a change in the share of output that is defective, not necessarily the number of defective items. - The numerical change depends on each facility’s output in both quarters, which the analyst does not provide. It treats a reduction in defects as sufficient to show that total production increased. - The analyst concludes that the facilities produced the same number of fewer defective items, not that either produced more items overall. - Total production matters here because it affects the conversion from defect rates to defect counts, not because the analyst claims it increased. It assumes without evidence that both facilities’ defect rates will continue to decline. - The conclusion concerns last quarter and this quarter, not what will happen later. - No prediction about future defect rates is needed for the analyst’s inference. It compares defect rates from periods that may differ in length rather than from identical periods. - Both facilities’ rates are reported for last quarter and this quarter, so the stated comparisons use the same periods. - The missing information is output during those periods, not whether the periods are comparable in length. It presumes that a facility with a lower defect rate must use a better inspection process. - Bex’s rates are lower, but the analyst makes no claim about inspection processes. - The conclusion compares changes in the number of defective items, not the reasons for either facility’s defect rate.

  4. 4. Principle: When a publisher discovers that the central factual claim of one of its reports is false, it should promptly publish a correction with prominence comparable to that of the report, unless doing so would disclose protected confidential information. An online journal discovers that the principal accusation in a prominent report about a nonprofit organization was based on misidentified records. Correcting the accusation would disclose no confidential information. Which one of the following actions most closely conforms to the principle?

    • A. Publish a correction promptly and give it prominence comparable to that of the original report.
    • B. Post a correction only if the organization discussed in the report formally requests one.
    • C. Remove the report without explanation and privately apologize to the organization discussed.
    • D. Retain the report unchanged but add a general statement that published reports may contain errors.
    • E. Delay any correction until the journalist who wrote the original report approves its wording.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Publish a correction promptly and give it prominence comparable to that of the original report.

    Publish a correction promptly and give it prominence comparable to that of the original report. - The misidentified records made the report’s principal accusation false, triggering the principle’s duty to correct it. - Because the correction would disclose no confidential information, the journal should publish it promptly with prominence comparable to the original report. Post a correction only if the organization discussed in the report formally requests one. - The principle requires correction when the publisher discovers the central claim is false, not when the affected organization requests one. - Waiting for a request would improperly delay correction of the journal’s prominent report. Remove the report without explanation and privately apologize to the organization discussed. - Removing the report and apologizing privately do not publish a correction of the false accusation. - Readers of the prominent report would not receive a correction with comparable prominence. Retain the report unchanged but add a general statement that published reports may contain errors. - A general disclaimer does not correct the specific false accusation based on misidentified records. - Leaving the report unchanged fails the principle’s requirement of a prompt, comparably prominent correction. Delay any correction until the journalist who wrote the original report approves its wording. - The principle makes no exception for obtaining the journalist’s approval before correcting a false central claim. - Waiting for approval conflicts with its requirement that the journal publish the correction promptly.

  5. 5. Policy analyst: Merchants consistently report that long waits at the licensing office discourage them from renewing permits promptly. In a limited pilot program, applicants with scheduled appointments waited less time than applicants without appointments. Thus, expanding the appointment system would probably shorten applicants' waits. Since shortening waits without relaxing permit requirements would improve the office's service, the office should expand the appointment system. In the argument, the statement that expanding the appointment system would probably shorten applicants' waits plays which one of the following roles?

    • A. It provides evidence that the merchants accurately measured processing times.
    • B. It identifies an objection that the final recommendation is intended to answer.
    • C. It states an intermediate conclusion used to support the final recommendation.
    • D. It supplies a general principle from which the final recommendation is derived.
    • E. It states the argument's main conclusion about what the licensing office should do.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It states an intermediate conclusion used to support the final recommendation.

    It states an intermediate conclusion used to support the final recommendation. - The pilot’s shorter waits for applicants with appointments support the prediction that expansion would probably shorten waits. - That prediction then supports the final recommendation to expand the system, given the claim that shorter waits without relaxed requirements would improve service. It provides evidence that the merchants accurately measured processing times. - The statement predicts the effect of expanding appointments; it says nothing about how merchants measured processing times. - The merchants’ reports establish that long waits discourage prompt renewals, while the pilot compares waits for applicants with and without appointments. It identifies an objection that the final recommendation is intended to answer. - Shorter waits are a reason for, not an objection to, expanding appointments. - The analyst uses the prediction to support the recommendation rather than presenting it as a concern to overcome. It supplies a general principle from which the final recommendation is derived. - The statement is a specific prediction about expanding this office’s appointment system. - The broader principle is that shortening waits without relaxing permit requirements would improve the office’s service. It states the argument's main conclusion about what the licensing office should do. - The main conclusion is that the licensing office should expand the appointment system. - The statement about probable waits explains why that action would help; it does not itself say what the office should do.

  6. 6. Parks director: The city commissioned murals in twelve alleys. During the following six months, reported graffiti in those alleys declined by 35 percent, while reported graffiti in twelve otherwise similar alleys without murals remained unchanged. Thus, installing murals caused the decline in graffiti in the first group of alleys. Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the parks director's argument?

    • A. Graffiti reports in both groups of alleys were submitted through the same reporting system.
    • B. The murals cost less to install than the department had originally projected.
    • C. Brighter lighting was installed in the mural alleys, but not the comparison alleys, during the same week.
    • D. Most residents surveyed after the project said that the murals improved the alleys' appearance.
    • E. Some comparison alleys had more graffiti reports than some mural alleys before the project began.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Brighter lighting was installed in the mural alleys, but not the comparison alleys, during the same week.

    Brighter lighting was installed in the mural alleys, but not the comparison alleys, during the same week. - Brighter lighting is another change that could have reduced graffiti in the mural alleys during the six-month period. - Because the comparison alleys received neither murals nor new lighting, their unchanged reports do not isolate murals as the cause of the 35 percent decline. Graffiti reports in both groups of alleys were submitted through the same reporting system. - A shared reporting system makes differences in how reports were submitted less likely to explain the groups’ different results. - It does not identify another cause of the decline in the twelve mural alleys. The murals cost less to install than the department had originally projected. - Installation cost says nothing about why reported graffiti fell in the mural alleys. - A lower-than-projected cost does not weaken the comparison with the twelve alleys without murals. Most residents surveyed after the project said that the murals improved the alleys' appearance. - Residents’ views about appearance do not establish what caused the decline in reported graffiti. - The survey supplies no competing explanation for why reports fell in the mural alleys but remained unchanged in the comparison alleys. Some comparison alleys had more graffiti reports than some mural alleys before the project began. - Some overlap in initial report counts is compatible with the two groups being otherwise similar. - Those initial counts do not explain why reports later declined by 35 percent in the mural alleys while remaining unchanged in the comparison alleys.

  7. 7. Archivist: Digitizing the archive's fragile letters will not eliminate the need to preserve the originals, since digital formats can become obsolete. Nevertheless, digitization should begin this year. Researchers who cannot travel to the archive would gain access to the letters, and the grant available to pay for digitization expires at the end of the year. In the archivist's argument, the claim that digital formats can become obsolete plays which one of the following roles?

    • A. It supports a subsidiary conclusion that qualifies, but does not conflict with, the recommendation.
    • B. It presents an objection that the archivist ultimately accepts as decisive against digitization.
    • C. It provides the principal evidence that researchers would gain broader access to the letters.
    • D. It states the main conclusion for which the expiring grant is offered as support.
    • E. It identifies a consequence of digitization that directly explains why the grant will expire.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. It supports a subsidiary conclusion that qualifies, but does not conflict with, the recommendation.

    It supports a subsidiary conclusion that qualifies, but does not conflict with, the recommendation. - The possibility that digital formats can become obsolete supports the subsidiary conclusion that digitizing the letters will not eliminate the need to preserve the originals. - That qualification is consistent with the archivist’s main recommendation to begin digitization this year. It presents an objection that the archivist ultimately accepts as decisive against digitization. - The archivist acknowledges possible obsolescence but still recommends digitizing the letters this year. - Obsolescence limits what digitization can replace; it is not treated as a decisive objection to digitization. It provides the principal evidence that researchers would gain broader access to the letters. - Broader access follows from the fact that some researchers cannot travel to the archive. - Possible format obsolescence concerns future access to digital copies, not the stated reason digitization would expand access now. It states the main conclusion for which the expiring grant is offered as support. - The main conclusion is that digitization should begin this year, supported in part by the grant’s expiration at year’s end. - The claim about obsolescence instead supports the separate conclusion that the originals must still be preserved. It identifies a consequence of digitization that directly explains why the grant will expire. - The archivist says the grant expires at the end of the year, not that digitization or digital obsolescence causes its expiration. - The expiration creates a reason to start digitizing this year; it is not explained by the claim about digital formats.

  8. 8. Commentator: Last year, the Northern Agency awarded 500 grants, 40 percent of them for arts projects, while the Southern Agency awarded 300 grants, 50 percent of them for arts projects. This year, Northern awarded 800 grants, 35 percent for arts projects, and Southern awarded 500 grants, 45 percent for arts projects. Since the arts percentage declined at both agencies, the combined number of arts grants must have declined. The reasoning in the commentator's argument is flawed because the argument

    • A. It presumes without justification that every grant not awarded to the arts was awarded to the same alternative purpose.
    • B. It draws a conclusion about all grant-making agencies from information concerning only two such agencies.
    • C. It overlooks that a smaller percentage of a larger total can represent a greater number of grants.
    • D. It treats receiving an arts grant as a necessary condition for producing work of artistic value.
    • E. It assumes without evidence that the same organizations applied for arts grants in both years.
    Show answer

    Answer: C. It overlooks that a smaller percentage of a larger total can represent a greater number of grants.

    It overlooks that a smaller percentage of a larger total can represent a greater number of grants. - Last year, Northern awarded 500 × 40% = 200 arts grants and Southern awarded 300 × 50% = 150, for 350 combined. - This year, Northern awarded 800 × 35% = 280 and Southern awarded 500 × 45% = 225, for 505 combined despite both percentages falling. It presumes without justification that every grant not awarded to the arts was awarded to the same alternative purpose. - The commentator says nothing about the purposes of non-arts grants at either agency. - How those grants were distributed cannot establish whether the number of arts grants declined. It draws a conclusion about all grant-making agencies from information concerning only two such agencies. - The conclusion concerns the combined number of arts grants at Northern and Southern, not at all agencies. - Figures for other agencies are unnecessary to test that conclusion. It treats receiving an arts grant as a necessary condition for producing work of artistic value. - The argument compares arts-grant percentages and totals; it makes no claim about what produces valuable art. - Whether valuable art can be produced without a grant does not affect the grant count. It assumes without evidence that the same organizations applied for arts grants in both years. - The commentator does not identify or compare applicants across the two years. - Applicant identity is irrelevant to calculating 350 arts grants last year and 505 this year.

Flashcards: Attacking the source and the straw man

  1. 1. What is the key difference between an ad hominem fallacy and a genetic fallacy?

    Show answer

    An ad hominem fallacy attacks the person making the claim (e.g., their character, motives), while a genetic fallacy attacks the origin or history of the belief or claim itself, rather than its current merits.

  2. 2. A critic rejects an environmental proposal because its author once worked for an oil company. What is the flaw?

    Show answer

    This is an ad hominem or genetic fallacy: it attacks the proposal’s source instead of evaluating its reasoning.

  3. 3. If an argument for a conclusion contains a logical fallacy, does that automatically mean the conclusion itself is false?

    Show answer

    No. This is the 'fallacy fallacy.' A flawed argument only means the argument fails to establish its conclusion; the conclusion itself might still be true, supported by other reasons, or even accidentally true despite the bad argument.

  4. 4. An argument states: 'Each musician in the Riverton Quartet can play the opening movement flawlessly alone. Therefore, the quartet can play the opening movement flawlessly as a group.' What is the flaw?

    Show answer

    This is an error of composition. Individual ability does not guarantee flawless group performance due to coordination or interaction issues.

  5. 5. What are the three main diagnostic questions to ask when evaluating arguments involving parts/whole, samples, or general rules?

    Show answer

    1. Check the direction (parts to whole, whole to parts). 2. Audit every sample (representativeness, bias, size). 3. Test for exceptional features before applying a general rule.

  6. 6. What are the two main types of causal flaws and the two main types of conditional flaws discussed in this lesson?

    Show answer

    Causal flaws: (1) reversed causation and (2) a third-variable explanation—both forms of correlation–causation confusion. Conditional flaws: (1) mistaken reversal and (2) mistaken negation.

  7. 7. An argument states, 'All employees received the new policy document, but some employees did not receive it.' What is the flaw?

    Show answer

    This is an internal contradiction: the two claims ('All employees received' and 'some employees did not receive') cannot both be true simultaneously.

  8. 8. What is the 'middle ground' fallacy?

    Show answer

    The middle ground fallacy assumes that the truth or best policy must lie between two competing extreme positions, without evaluating the merits of any position.

Everything you need for LSAT prep

Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

GET STARTED FOR FREE
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF