Find the Target: Is the Attack Aimed at the Claim or Its Source?
When an argument attacks a person, publication, motive, or origin, how do you tell whether it has answered the claim?
Run this procedure:
- State the target claim neutrally. Ask what proposition is supposed to be true.
- Locate the support offered against it. Is the support about the claim’s evidence, or about where the claim came from?
- Name the object attacked.
- If the argument attacks the source as a source, it uses a source argument.
- If it attacks the source’s character, motives, intelligence, or status, it is an ad hominem.
- If it attacks the origin or history of the belief, it is a genetic fallacy.
- If it attacks only the quality of an argument and then concludes that the argument’s conclusion is false, it commits the fallacy fallacy.
- Ask whether the source information actually bears on the claim. A source’s reliability can matter when the source is the only basis for the claim. But “this came from a bad person” or “this began in a disreputable place” does not by itself refute the content.
These labels can overlap. A genetic fallacy is often a source attack, and an ad hominem is often a source attack. Use the narrowest label that matches what the argument attacks.
Do not confuse “the source is unreliable” with “the claim is false.” The first may show only that this support is weak.
Separate the Person, the Origin, and the Reason: Three Fast Tests
For a source argument, replace the source temporarily with a neutral description:
“The claim is false because its advocate has a financial interest.”
The argument has not examined the claim. It has tried to disqualify the source. The same structure can be reasonable if the conclusion is specifically about the source-for example, “This witness is unreliable because she could not see the event.” The flaw appears when source information substitutes for evaluating the claim.
For an ad hominem, ask whether the attack would work only by making the audience dislike or distrust the person:
“Do not accept the proposal; its author is arrogant.”
Arrogance does not show that the proposal is mistaken. Motive attacks work the same way: a person may have a bad motive and still make a true statement.
For the genetic fallacy, track the claim’s birthplace rather than the current speaker:
“That medical practice originated in an ancient superstition, so it cannot be effective.”
Its origin may be irrelevant to whether it works now. The claim must be tested on present evidence, not merely on how it began.
For the fallacy fallacy, use a different test:
“That argument relies on an ad hominem, so its conclusion is false.”
The criticism may correctly show that the argument fails to establish its conclusion. It does not show that the conclusion itself is false. A bad argument can accidentally support a true conclusion.
One Source, One Claim: Classify the Attack
A study reports that a particular fertilizer increases crop yields. The study first appeared in a newsletter published by a company that sells that fertilizer. Dana says, “The study’s conclusion is worthless because it came from that newsletter.”
Practice
Which one of the following most accurately describes Dana’s reasoning?
On a question stem, identify the conclusion first, then circle the noun receiving the attack: argument, person, or origin. If the conclusion is rejected merely because the argument was defective, select the fallacy fallacy instead.
High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways
Identify whether the attack targets the claim, its source, a person, or the claim’s origin. An ad hominem attacks the person; a genetic fallacy attacks where the belief came from. A bad argument does not make its conclusion false: that mistake is the fallacy fallacy.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more