Find the Rival Engine: Make the Result Expected Without the Conclusion
When a stimulus says A caused B, how can you weaken it without merely saying, “That does not prove it”?
Supply a different engine for B. Your alternate cause must explain the observed result at least as well as A does, while requiring less reliance on the author’s conclusion.
Run this procedure:
First, isolate the proposed arrow. Write it in ordinary language: expanded patrols → fewer burglaries.
Second, remove the proposed cause mentally. Ask: “What else could have produced the fewer burglaries?”
Third, demand explanatory fit. The alternate cause should connect to the same result, the same people or places, and roughly the same time. A fact that merely coexists with the result is not enough.
Fourth, check the comparison. If the argument compares one group with another, the rival cause should explain why the groups differed. “A citywide event occurred” is weak if both groups experienced it equally.
The strongest alternate-cause answer often describes a second intervention that affected only the allegedly treated group. If the argument credits new tutoring with higher scores, an answer saying that those students also received one-on-one coaching directly competes with tutoring as the explanation.
Do not require the alternate cause to be proven. On a weaken question, it is enough that the answer makes the conclusion less secure by offering a credible explanation the argument has not eliminated.
Reverse the Arrow: Let the Result Select the Supposed Cause
A different attack reverses the proposed direction. Instead of asking what else caused B, ask whether B-or an earlier version of B-caused A.
The procedure is short:
Name the observed relationship. For example: districts with expanded patrols had larger burglary declines.
Reverse the arrow. Consider: an existing burglary decline → officials expanded patrols.
Look for selection or timing evidence. The reversal is especially powerful when the stimulus says the supposed cause was introduced after officials noticed the outcome beginning. That sequence makes the cause-effect claim unstable: the “cause” may have been a response to the result.
The reversed cause does not need to explain every later change. It only needs to show that the observed association could have arisen because decision-makers selected places already improving, or because people adopted A after experiencing B.
Distinguish reversal from an alternate cause. “A private security program also reduced burglaries” supplies a different cause of B. “Officials expanded patrols because burglaries had already begun falling” says the supposed cause followed the result. Both weaken, but they attack different links.
When answers compete, prefer the one that targets the argument’s exact comparison and timing. A general fact that could affect everyone is usually less damaging than a fact explaining why A appeared precisely where B was observed.
One Arrow, Two Attacks: Diagnose the Stronger Answer
In one year, districts receiving expanded police patrols experienced larger declines in burglary than districts that did not receive expanded patrols. The police chief concluded that the expanded patrols caused the declines.
Practice
Which one of the following, if true, most weakens the police chief’s conclusion?
On test day, separate the two questions: “What other event could have produced B?” identifies an alternate cause; “Could B have led to A?” identifies reversed causation. Then choose the answer that best fits the argument’s population, comparison, and timeline.
High-Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways
To supply an alternate cause, explain the result without relying on the proposed cause. To reverse causation, show that the observed result preceded and prompted the supposed cause. Prefer the rival explanation that matches the argument’s comparison and timing.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more