Ethics of Surrogacy and Third-Party Reproduction

Ethics of Surrogacy and Third-Party Reproduction

Ethics of Surrogacy and Third-Party Reproduction

On this page

Definitions & Types - Womb Wonders

  • Surrogacy: An arrangement where a woman (surrogate mother) agrees to carry and deliver a child for another person or couple (intended parents/IPs).
  • Third-Party Reproduction (TPR): Involves individuals other than the IPs to help conceive. Includes gamete donation (sperm, egg), embryo donation, and surrogacy.
  • Types of Surrogacy:
    • Traditional Surrogacy: Surrogate’s egg is fertilized (usually by IP’s sperm). Surrogate is genetically related to the child.
    • Gestational Surrogacy (GS): Embryo (created using IPs' or donor gametes) is implanted in the surrogate. Surrogate has no genetic link to the child.
      • Altruistic Surrogacy: Surrogate receives no financial compensation beyond reimbursement for medical and other reasonable expenses.
      • Commercial Surrogacy: Surrogate is paid a fee for carrying the pregnancy. (Largely restricted/banned in India).

⭐ India's Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021 permits only altruistic gestational surrogacy for eligible Indian couples, with strict criteria for both IPs and surrogate mothers. Commercial surrogacy is prohibited.

Ethical Dilemmas in Surrogacy - Moral Maze

Loading diagram…
  • Autonomy Clash: Surrogate's bodily integrity vs. IPs' procreative rights.
  • Informed Consent: Comprehensive (physical, psychological, social risks) for surrogate.
  • Exploitation: Financial/emotional coercion risk, especially for vulnerable women.
  • Child's Best Interests: Paramount; includes identity, parentage clarity.
  • Commodification: Ethical concerns: child as product, womb as service.
  • Legal Maze: Parentage, rights, responsibilities post-birth.

⭐ India's Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021, permits only altruistic surrogacy, banning commercial surrogacy to prevent exploitation.

  • Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021:
    • Altruistic surrogacy only; commercial banned.
    • Intending Couple: Indian, married ≥5 yrs; F 23-50, M 26-55 yrs; proven infertility.
    • Surrogate: Close relative, married, own child, 25-35 yrs, once; medically/psychologically fit.
    • Parental order by Magistrate Court.
    • Mandatory insurance for surrogate (36 months).
  • Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Act, 2021 (ART Act):
    • Regulates ART clinics/banks; National/State ART & Surrogacy Boards.
    • ART-born child rights protected (deemed biological).
    • Written informed consent; donor anonymity.
    • Sex selection prohibited.

⭐ Commercial surrogacy: punishable up to 10 yrs jail & ₹10 lakhs fine.

Ethics of Gamete/Embryo Donation - Seed & Soil Saga

  • Informed Consent: Essential for donors & recipients; covers procedures, risks, rights.
  • Anonymity vs. Disclosure: Balancing donor privacy with DCI's right to know. Regulated anonymity common.
  • Donor Screening: Mandatory for genetic issues, STIs (HIV, HBV, HCV) for safety.
  • Psychological Counseling: Recommended for all parties; addresses emotional/social aspects.
  • Donation Limits: Caps on offspring per donor (ICMR) to prevent consanguinity.
  • Commercialization: Altruistic donation preferred; sale of gametes/embryos restricted.
  • Embryo Donation: Ethical handling of surplus embryos: donation, research, or discard (consent vital).
  • "Seed & Soil": "Seed" (gamete/embryo) ethics: donor choice, genetic health. "Soil" (recipient) ethics: maternal well-being, psychosocial stability.

⭐ ART (Regulation) Act, 2021, mandates donor screening for communicable diseases and relevant genetic disorders.

High‑Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

  • Surrogacy Regulation Act (India): Permits only altruistic surrogacy for infertile Indian couples (married 5 years).
  • Commercial surrogacy is banned.
  • Intending couple needs Certificate of Essentiality & Eligibility.
  • Surrogate: Close relative, married, own child, 25-35 years, once a lifetime.
  • Child: Legal rights as biological child of intending couple.
  • ART Regulation Act, 2021: Governs ART clinics/banks, promotes ethical practice.
  • Informed consent: Mandatory for all parties (surrogate, couple, donors).

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Ethics of Surrogacy and Third-Party Reproduction

  1. 1. Which of the following is the least invasive assisted reproductive technique?

    • A. ZIFT
    • B. IVF
    • C. IUI
    • D. GIFT
    Show answer

    Answer: C. IUI

    > Key point: IUI is the least invasive technique listed because it places washed sperm in the uterus without oocyte retrieval or laparoscopic transfer. Why IUI is correct - IUI places washed sperm directly into the uterus. - It avoids the oocyte retrieval involved in IVF and the laparoscopic transfer used in ZIFT and GIFT. How they compare | Technique | Main intervention | Relative invasiveness | |---|---|---| | IUI | Sperm placed in uterus | Least invasive | | IVF | Oocyte retrieval; laboratory fertilization and embryo transfer | More invasive than IUI | | ZIFT | Laparoscopic zygote transfer | More invasive than IUI | | GIFT | Laparoscopic gamete transfer | More invasive than IUI | Why the other options are wrong - IVF: Oocyte retrieval makes it more invasive than IUI. - ZIFT: Laparoscopic zygote transfer makes it more invasive than IUI. - GIFT: Laparoscopic gamete transfer makes it more invasive than IUI.

  2. 2. Under the Medical Termination of Pregnancy Act, 1971, as amended in 2021, which statement is incorrect?

    • A. One eligible RMP in life-saving emergencies
    • B. Two RMP opinions mandatory through 20 weeks
    • C. Confidentiality except where disclosure is legally authorized
    • D. No spousal consent for competent adults
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Two RMP opinions mandatory through 20 weeks

    > Key point: Through 20 weeks, the Act requires the opinion of one eligible RMP, not two. Why Two RMP opinions mandatory through 20 weeks is correct - The question asks for the incorrect statement: through 20 weeks, one eligible RMP opinion is required when statutory grounds are met. - The Act does not make two RMP opinions mandatory throughout this period. How they compare | Statement | Status | Why | |---|---|---| | Two RMP opinions mandatory through 20 weeks | Incorrect | One eligible RMP opinion is required. | | One eligible RMP in life-saving emergencies | Correct | This is permitted when termination is immediately necessary to save the woman’s life. | | Confidentiality except where disclosure is legally authorized | Correct | This reflects the Act’s confidentiality provision. | | No spousal consent for competent adults | Correct | A competent adult woman provides her own consent. | Why the other options are wrong - One eligible RMP in life-saving emergencies: This is permitted in the stated emergency; it is not the incorrect statement. - Confidentiality except where disclosure is legally authorized: This reflects the confidentiality provision. - No spousal consent for competent adults: A competent adult woman’s own consent is sufficient.

  3. 3. Professional death in medical profession is -

    • A. Temporary suspension from medical register
    • B. Permanent erasure from medical register
    • C. Restriction of specified clinical privileges
    • D. Formal warning for professional misconduct
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Permanent erasure from medical register

    > Key point: “Professional death” means permanent erasure from the medical register. Why permanent erasure from the medical register is correct - It permanently removes the doctor’s registered professional status. - This is the meaning of “professional death.” Why the other options are wrong - Temporary suspension from the medical register: practice is prohibited only for a limited period; registration is not permanently erased. - Restriction of specified clinical privileges: limits particular activities but does not permanently remove registration. - Formal warning for professional misconduct: does not itself remove the doctor from the register.

  4. 4. A woman at 8 weeks’ gestation has an ultrasound-confirmed viable intrauterine pregnancy with an IUD in situ and visible threads. She wishes to continue the pregnancy. What is the most appropriate management?

    • A. Delayed IUD removal
    • B. Gentle IUD removal
    • C. Hysteroscopic IUD removal
    • D. Continued IUD retention
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Gentle IUD removal

    > Key point: In a continuing pregnancy, gently remove an IUD when its threads are visible. Why Gentle IUD removal is correct - The pregnancy is viable, the patient wishes to continue it, and the threads are visible, allowing gentle removal. - Removing the IUD avoids the increased pregnancy complications associated with retaining it. Decision path mermaid flowchart TD A[" Pregnancy to continue "]:::input --> B[" IUD threads visible "]:::input B --> C[" Remove gently "]:::outcome Why the other options are wrong - Continued IUD retention: leaves the device in place and increases pregnancy complication risks. - Hysteroscopic IUD removal: is unnecessarily invasive when the threads are visible. - Delayed IUD removal: prolongs exposure to the risks of retaining the device.

  5. 5. Under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, as amended before its repeal, and its judicial interpretation, which statement is incorrect?

    • A. Coverage of ESI-funded hospital care
    • B. Recognition of consumer safety rights
    • C. Enactment during the year 1986
    • D. Six-month statutory disposal target
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Six-month statutory disposal target

    > Key point: The Act set three- and five-month disposal targets, not a six-month target. Why Six-month statutory disposal target is correct - The Act called for complaints to be decided within three months when testing was unnecessary and five months when it was required. - Therefore, a six-month statutory disposal target is the incorrect statement. Why the other options are wrong - Coverage of ESI-funded hospital care: This was covered because employee and employer contributions counted as consideration. - Recognition of consumer safety rights: The Act recognised protection against goods and services hazardous to life and property. - Enactment during the year 1986: The specified Act was enacted in 1986.

  6. 6. Which constitutional article does NOT directly address protection from exploitation or the right to education?

    • A. Article 42
    • B. Article 21-A
    • C. Article 23
    • D. Article 24
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Article 42

    > Key point: Articles 23, 24 and 21-A address exploitation or education; Article 42 concerns working conditions and maternity relief. Why Article 42 is correct - Article 42 directs provision of just and humane working conditions and maternity relief. - It does not directly address protection from exploitation or the right to education. How they compare | Article | Main subject | |---|---| | Article 42 | Working conditions and maternity relief | | Article 23 | Trafficking, begar and forced labour | | Article 24 | Child employment in factories, mines or hazardous work | | Article 21-A | Free and compulsory education for children aged 6–14 | Why the other options are wrong - Article 23: Prohibits trafficking, begar and other forced labour, so it addresses protection from exploitation. - Article 21-A: Guarantees free and compulsory education for children aged 6–14. - Article 24: Restricts child employment in factories, mines and hazardous work, so it addresses protection from exploitation.

  7. 7. In June 2024, which IPC section prescribed punishment for causing a woman's death by an act intended to cause miscarriage?

    • A. 314 IPC
    • B. 309 IPC
    • C. 312 IPC
    • D. 316 IPC
    Show answer

    Answer: A. 314 IPC

    > Key point: IPC Section 314 addresses a death caused by an act intended to cause miscarriage. Why 314 IPC is correct - Section 314 applies when an act intended to cause miscarriage results in the woman’s death. How they compare | Section | What it addresses | |---|---| | 314 IPC | Woman’s death from an act intended to cause miscarriage | | 316 IPC | Death of a quick unborn child from an act amounting to culpable homicide | | 309 IPC | Attempt to commit suicide | | 312 IPC | Causing miscarriage generally | Why the other options are wrong - 316 IPC: concerns the death of a quick unborn child, not the woman’s death. - 309 IPC: concerns an attempt to commit suicide. - 312 IPC: concerns causing miscarriage generally, not the resulting death of the woman.

  8. 8. A 14-year-old victim of sexual assault with 22 weeks gestation has been brought for Medical Termination of Pregnancy (MTP). Which of the following statements is true?

    • A. Requires one practitioner's opinion
    • B. Requires life-threatening indications
    • C. Permitted through 24 weeks
    • D. Prohibited after 20 weeks
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Permitted through 24 weeks

    > Key point: Under the stated MTP framework, a minor who is a sexual-assault survivor may be eligible for termination through 24 weeks. Why Permitted through 24 weeks is correct - The patient is 14 and is a sexual-assault survivor, categories eligible for termination up to 24 weeks under the stated framework. - At 22 weeks, the pregnancy is within that limit. How they compare | Statement | Why it fits or fails | |---|---| | Permitted through 24 weeks | Covers this 22-week pregnancy and eligible category. | | Requires life-threatening indications | Life-threatening indications are not the only basis stated. | | Requires one practitioner's opinion | Two practitioners' opinions are required at 22 weeks. | | Prohibited after 20 weeks | The limit for specified categories extends to 24 weeks. | Why the other options are wrong - Requires life-threatening indications: This is not required for an eligible minor and sexual-assault survivor. - Requires one practitioner's opinion: At 22 weeks, two registered medical practitioners' opinions are required. - Prohibited after 20 weeks: The applicable limit for specified categories is 24 weeks.

  9. 9. A 24-year-old woman presents with abnormal vaginal discharge. Wet mount shows motile trichomonads. Her male partner is asymptomatic. Which of the following is the most appropriate management for her partner?

    • A. Treat regardless of symptoms
    • B. No treatment unless symptoms develop
    • C. Test before treating
    • D. Monitor without intervention
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Treat regardless of symptoms

    Treat regardless of symptoms - Trichomoniasis is a sexually transmitted infection, and male partners may carry it asymptomatically while continuing transmission. - Treating the partner regardless of symptoms prevents reinfection and helps eradicate infection in both partners. Test before treating - Testing is possible, but presumptive treatment is recommended for male partners of women diagnosed with trichomoniasis. - Testing in men may have lower sensitivity, so a negative result could miss infection and permit reinfection or further transmission. No treatment unless symptoms develop - Waiting for symptoms is inappropriate because male partners commonly remain asymptomatic despite carrying trichomonads. - Delayed treatment permits persistent infection and increases the risk of reinfection in the treated woman. Monitor without intervention - Monitoring without intervention leaves the partner an infectious source, even if he has no clinical symptoms. - This fails to break the transmission cycle and risks recurrent infection after the woman’s treatment.

Flashcards: Ethics of Surrogacy and Third-Party Reproduction

  1. 1. What are the components of the antenatal combined test (first-trimester screening)?

    Show answer

    PAPPA + hCG + nuchal translucency

  2. 2. Desire for future pregnancy is a(n) contraindication to uterine artery embolisation

    Show answer

    relative

  3. 3. NST has a false positive rate

    Show answer

    high

  4. 4. Infertility is defined as lack of conception despite months of regular unprotected intercourse in women aged < 35 years.

    Show answer

    12

  5. 5. Definitive mx of incomplete abortion before 12 weeks is  followed by curettage

    Show answer

    dilatation and evacuation

  6. 6. scoring system is recognised as the gold standard for bacterial vaginosis

    Show answer

    Nugent

Everything you need for Indian Medical PG prep

Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

GET STARTED FOR FREE
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF