Ethics in Cancer Care

On this page

Ethical Pillars in Oncology - Cancer Care Compass

Core principles guiding complex decisions in cancer care, ensuring patient-centered approaches.

  • Autonomy: Patient's right to self-determination; informed consent is paramount.
  • Beneficence: Duty to act for the patient's welfare, promoting good.
  • Non-maleficence: Obligation to "do no harm"; minimize risks and side effects.
  • Justice: Fair allocation of resources, equitable access to care, no discrimination.

⭐ The principle of double effect can ethically justify palliative treatments that may unintentionally hasten death, if the primary intent is symptom relief.

  • Core: Patient autonomy vs. beneficence in high-stakes cancer choices.
  • Challenges:
    • Patient: Vulnerability, ↓ literacy, emotional distress, fluctuating capacity.
    • Info: Complexity, uncertainty, overload.
    • Family: Pressure vs. support.
    • Clinician: Communication gaps, time, therapeutic misconception.
  • Crossroads:
    • Aggressive vs. Palliative care.
    • Clinical trial enrollment.
    • End-of-life (EoL) planning.

⭐ Therapeutic misconception: Patients may confuse research goals with personal care. Essential to clarify trial purpose.

Truth, Bad News & Privacy - Communication Tightrope

  • Truth-telling (Veracity): Uphold patient's right to know (diagnosis, prognosis).
    • Balance with cultural sensitivity (family involvement).
    • Therapeutic privilege: Rare, if disclosure causes direct, severe harm.
  • Breaking Bad News (BBN):
    • Use structured protocols (e.g., SPIKES).
    • Core: Empathy, clarity, support, check understanding.
  • Privacy & Confidentiality:
    • Strictly maintain per IMC Ethics Regulations.
    • Disclosure exceptions: Legal mandate, imminent harm to self/others.

⭐ Balancing patient's direct right to information with family's role in shared decision-making is a key ethical challenge in Indian cancer care.

Loading diagram…

End-of-Life Ethics - Navigating Final Stages

  • Key Principles: Autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence.
  • Advance Care Planning:
    • Living Will: Specifies treatment preferences.
    • DPOAHC (Durable Power of Attorney for Healthcare): Appoints healthcare agent.
  • Palliative vs. Hospice Care:
    • Palliative: Symptom control, focus on quality of life, any disease stage.
    • Hospice: Prognosis typically < 6 months, comfort-focused, bereavement support.
  • LST (Life-Sustaining Treatment) Decisions: Withholding/withdrawing ethically distinct from euthanasia; respects patient wishes or best interests.
  • DNR/AND Orders: Do Not Resuscitate / Allow Natural Death; must be documented.
Loading diagram…

⭐ The Doctrine of Double Effect ethically permits providing treatments (e.g., opioids for pain) intended to relieve suffering, even if they might unintentionally hasten death, provided the primary intention is palliation, not causing death.

Research & Resource Realities - Fair Share Fight

  • Research Ethics:
    • Mandatory Institutional Ethics Committee (IEC) approval.
    • Robust informed consent, especially for vulnerable populations.
    • Clinical equipoise essential for trial justification.
    • Ethical considerations for post-trial access to beneficial drugs.
  • Resource Allocation:
    • Distributive justice: fair sharing of scarce resources (drugs, technology, personnel).
    • Balance cost-effectiveness with individual patient needs and societal benefit.
    • Address disparities in cancer care access (e.g., urban vs. rural).

⭐ Clinical trials must maintain equipoise, meaning genuine uncertainty exists regarding the comparative therapeutic merits of each arm.

High‑Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

  • Informed consent is vital: ensure full disclosure of risks, benefits, alternatives, and prognosis.
  • Respect patient autonomy: their absolute right to choose or refuse any offered treatment.
  • Maintain strict patient confidentiality unless legally required or with explicit consent.
  • Balance beneficence (acting for patient good) with non-maleficence (preventing harm).
  • Proactively discuss end-of-life care: including palliative options, DNR status, and advance directives.
  • Practice truthful, empathetic communication regarding diagnosis, prognosis, and treatment options.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Ethics in Cancer Care

  1. 1. Which of the following is NOT a principle of primary health care?

    • A. IEC strategy
    • B. Intersectoral coordination
    • C. Equitable distribution
    • D. Appropriate technology
    Show answer

    Answer: A. IEC strategy

    IEC strategy - IEC strategy (Information, Education and Communication) supports health promotion within primary health care but is a strategy or component rather than a core principle established in the Alma-Ata Declaration. - The core principles describe foundational features of health-care delivery; therefore, IEC does not belong to the standard set being tested, despite its importance in practice. Intersectoral coordination - Intersectoral coordination is a core primary health-care principle because health depends on coordinated contributions from agriculture, education, housing, and other sectors. - Collaboration beyond health services addresses the social determinants of health and supports the goal of achieving health for all. Equitable distribution - Equitable distribution is a fundamental principle requiring health services and resources to be accessible to all, regardless of geography, socioeconomic status, or demographic factors. - By promoting reduced disparities in access and outcomes, equitable distribution ensures primary health care benefits the entire population. Appropriate technology - Appropriate technology is a core principle involving scientifically sound and socially acceptable methods that are affordable and culturally relevant to the community. - It prioritizes practical, effective, and accessible tools suited to the local context rather than unnecessarily complex or unaffordable interventions.

  2. 2. In the context of civil negligence against a doctor, who bears the burden of proof?

    • A. Doctor defending the civil claim
    • B. Hospital defending the civil claim
    • C. Insurer contesting the civil claim
    • D. Patient bringing the civil claim
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Patient bringing the civil claim

    Patient bringing the civil claim bears the initial burden of establishing duty, breach, causation, and damage on the balance of probabilities. Doctor defending the civil claim and Hospital defending the civil claim are defendants, not the claimant responsible for initially establishing negligence. Insurer contesting the civil claim does not bear the patient's initial burden merely because it contests liability or coverage. An evidentiary burden may subsequently shift, including where res ipsa loquitur applies.

  3. 3. In 2014, under Section 29(2) of the CrPC, what were the maximum imprisonment and fine that a Judicial Magistrate First Class could impose?

    • A. 3 yr, Rs. 3000
    • B. 5 yr, Rs. 3000
    • C. 5 yr, Rs. 50000
    • D. 3 yr, Rs. 10000
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 3 yr, Rs. 10000

    3 yr, Rs. 10000 These are the historical limits under Section 29(2) of the CrPC as applicable in 2014; the current BNSS Section 23(2) permits imprisonment up to three years, a fine up to Rs. 50,000, both, or community service. - A Class I Judicial Magistrate may award a maximum imprisonment of 3 years under Section 29(2) of the CrPC, 1973. - The corresponding maximum fine is Rs. 10,000, making this the complete and correct punishment limit. 5 yr, Rs. 3000 - A 5-year imprisonment exceeds the Class I Judicial Magistrate’s maximum sentencing power under the stated CrPC provision. - The Rs. 3,000 fine is also below the specified maximum of Rs. 10,000, so both components are incorrect. 5 yr, Rs. 50000 - The stated 5-year imprisonment is incorrect because the maximum for a Class I Judicial Magistrate is 3 years. - Although Rs. 50,000 is a fine amount, it does not match the specified maximum of Rs. 10,000. 3 yr, Rs. 3000 - The 3-year imprisonment correctly identifies the maximum term for a Class I Judicial Magistrate. - However, the Rs. 3,000 fine is incorrect; the stated maximum fine is Rs. 10,000.

  4. 4. Which sentinel-node tracer is detected by unaided vision rather than gamma detection or near-infrared imaging?

    • A. Technetium-99m sulfur colloid
    • B. Isosulfan blue
    • C. Indocyanine green
    • D. Technetium-99m albumin nanocolloid
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Isosulfan blue

    Isosulfan blue stains draining lymphatics and sentinel nodes, permitting identification by unaided vision. Technetium-99m sulfur colloid is a radiotracer detected with a gamma probe. Indocyanine green is detected using near-infrared fluorescence imaging. Technetium-99m albumin nanocolloid is also a radiotracer and requires gamma detection rather than unaided visual identification.

  5. 5. Which statement about the bone tumour shown is NOT correct?

    • A. Eccentric lytic growth
    • B. Epiphyseal–metaphyseal involvement
    • C. Chemotherapy-based treatment
    • D. Well-defined radiographic margins
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Chemotherapy-based treatment

    Chemotherapy-based treatment - Chemotherapy is not the treatment of choice for giant cell tumor; primary management is surgical, commonly curettage with or without bone grafting. - For aggressive or unresectable lesions, en bloc resection or denosumab may be considered, making chemotherapy-based treatment the incorrect statement. Eccentric lytic growth - A giant cell tumor typically appears as an eccentric, expansile lytic lesion in the epiphyseal-to-metaphyseal region of a long bone. - Therefore, an eccentric lesion is characteristic and does not represent the incorrect statement in this question. Well-defined radiographic margins - Giant cell tumors commonly show a well-defined margin, reflecting their relatively slow growth despite locally aggressive behavior. - Thus, a distinct margin is compatible with the described tumor and is not the incorrect statement. Epiphyseal–metaphyseal involvement - The characteristic location of a giant cell tumor is the epiphyseal-to-metaphyseal region, especially in long bones around the knee. - This distribution helps distinguish it from osteosarcoma, which more typically arises in the metaphysis, but the statement remains correct for giant cell tumor.

  6. 6. A surgeon, aware that he is severely intoxicated, insists on operating despite an immediately available sober surgeon. His impaired coordination causes an avoidable arterial injury and haemorrhagic shock. Which is the most serious form of negligence supported by these facts?

    • A. Contributory negligence
    • B. Composite negligence
    • C. Criminal negligence
    • D. Civil negligence
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Criminal negligence

    Criminal negligence is the most serious supported classification because knowingly operating while severely intoxicated despite an available sober surgeon is a gross departure from reasonable care, consistent with Jacob Mathew v State of Punjab (2005). Contributory negligence requires a contribution by the patient, which is not described. Composite negligence requires negligent contributions by multiple tortfeasors, whereas only one negligent actor is described. Civil negligence may also support compensation, but it is not the most serious classification requested.

  7. 7. Prohibition of participation in torture by a doctor comes under:

    • A. Declaration of Helsinki
    • B. Declaration of Oslo
    • C. Declaration of Tokyo
    • D. Declaration of Geneva
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Declaration of Tokyo

    Declaration of Tokyo - The Declaration of Tokyo (1975) specifically prohibits physicians from participating in or facilitating torture and other cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment. - It requires doctors to refuse involvement in torture even under threat or duress, establishing the relevant professional and ethical prohibition. Declaration of Oslo - The Declaration of Oslo (1970) addresses the ethical considerations of therapeutic abortion, including the physician’s role in termination of pregnancy. - It does not specifically establish the prohibition of physician participation in torture, making it an unsuitable choice. Declaration of Helsinki - The Declaration of Helsinki primarily provides ethical principles for medical research involving human subjects, rather than physician conduct during torture. - Its focus includes informed consent, risk–benefit assessment, and protection of vulnerable research participants, so it does not fit this question. Declaration of Geneva - The Declaration of Geneva (1948) is a modern Hippocratic Oath outlining broad ethical duties, including respect for life and professional secrecy. - Although it establishes general physician responsibilities, it does not specifically detail the prohibition against participation in torture.

  8. 8. Which of the following, by itself, excludes medical negligence?

    • A. Exercise of reasonable professional care
    • B. Provision of necessary treatment instructions
    • C. Achievement of the intended treatment outcome
    • D. Adherence to customary institutional practice
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Exercise of reasonable professional care

    Exercise of reasonable professional care meets the standard expected of a reasonably competent practitioner and excludes negligence. Achievement of the intended treatment outcome does not by itself exclude negligence because a successful outcome does not establish that reasonable care was exercised. Adherence to customary institutional practice does not by itself establish that the practice meets the required professional standard. Provision of necessary treatment instructions fulfils one duty but does not establish that reasonable care was exercised in other aspects of treatment.

  9. 9. What term describes an unintended fatal complication of appropriate medical treatment occurring despite reasonable care and skill, without negligence?

    • A. Therapeutic privilege
    • B. Medical misadventure
    • C. Diminished responsibility
    • D. Vicarious liability
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Medical misadventure

    Medical misadventure - Medical misadventure is an unintentional or unexpected complication or death occurring during appropriate medical treatment, despite absence of negligence. - It reflects the inherent risks of medical treatment, where an adverse outcome may occur even when the doctor and staff act reasonably and skillfully. Vicarious liability - Vicarious liability holds a hospital or employer responsible for an employee’s actions performed within the scope of employment. - It describes the allocation of legal responsibility, often for negligence, rather than the unintentional adverse outcome itself. Therapeutic privilege - Therapeutic privilege permits a physician to withhold information when disclosure would likely cause significant harm to the patient. - It concerns non-disclosure of medical information, not an unintentional adverse outcome or death during treatment. Diminished responsibility - Diminished responsibility is a criminal-law concept involving reduced responsibility because of mental impairment. - It does not describe unintentional treatment-related harm or death occurring without negligence.

  10. 10. Failure by hospital administrators to provide adequate facilities is classified as which type of negligence?

    • A. Corporate negligence
    • B. Therapeutic misadventure
    • C. Contributory negligence
    • D. Composite negligence
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Corporate negligence

    Corporate negligence - Corporate negligence makes the hospital itself responsible for duties owed directly to patients, including maintaining adequate facilities and equipment. - Administrators’ failure to provide appropriate facilities is therefore negligence by the healthcare institution rather than merely by an individual employee. Composite negligence - Composite negligence involves negligence by two or more persons whose actions together cause injury to a third party. - This scenario concerns the hospital’s own failure to provide facilities, not multiple negligent parties contributing to one outcome. Therapeutic misadventure - Therapeutic misadventure describes an unintended, undesired outcome occurring during a medical or surgical procedure. - It generally refers to an adverse treatment outcome without negligence, whereas inadequate hospital facilities represent an institutional failure. Contributory negligence - Contributory negligence occurs when the plaintiff’s own negligent conduct contributes to the injury, even if the defendant was also negligent. - The issue here is the hospital’s failure to provide facilities, with no indication that patient conduct contributed to the harm.

Flashcards: Ethics in Cancer Care

  1. 1. Appendiceal carcinoid tumors measuring > cm should be managed with .

    Show answer

    2; right hemicolectomy

  2. 2. Sentinel lymph node biopsy is usually done in patients with clinically node- disease

    Show answer

    negative

  3. 3. Siewert Type I: Tumour center located between _____ and _____ cm proximal to the anatomical cardia

    Show answer

    5 · 1

  4. 4. The minimum number of lymph nodes to be examined for accurate staging of colorectal cancer is _____.

    Show answer

    12 — A minimum of 12 lymph nodes is required for accurate nodal staging of colorectal cancer according to AJCC guidelines.

  5. 5. Bronchoplastic lung resection is the best modality for the mx of subtype of lung tumor

    Show answer

    carcinoid

  6. 6. Treatment of desmoid tumor includes excision with wide margin clearance of cm to avoid recurrence.

    Show answer

    2.5

  7. 7. Pre-op biopsy is for a glomus tumor

    Show answer

    never done (mandatory/never done)

Everything you need for Indian Medical PG prep

Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

GET STARTED FOR FREE
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF