Medical Decision Making

On this page

Diagnostic Tests - Numbers Game

  • Basis: 2x2 table (Disease vs. Test: TP, FP, FN, TN).
  • Sensitivity (Sn): $TP / (TP+FN)$. Detects disease.
    • 📌 SNOUT: Sensitive test, Negative result, rules OUT.
  • Specificity (Sp): $TN / (TN+FP)$. Confirms absence.
    • 📌 SPIN: Specific test, Positive result, rules IN.
  • PPV (Positive Predictive Value): $TP / (TP+FP)$. Prob. disease if test +ve. Varies with prevalence.
  • NPV (Negative Predictive Value): $TN / (TN+FN)$. Prob. no disease if test -ve. Varies with prevalence.
  • Likelihood Ratios (LR): Link pre- to post-test probability.
    • LR+: $Sn / (1-Sp)$. >10 strong for disease.
    • LR-: $(1-Sn) / Sp$. <0.1 strong against disease. 2x2 Contingency Table for Diagnostic Test Evaluation

⭐ Prevalence ↑ → PPV ↑, NPV ↓.

Decision Thresholds - Choice Points

  • Critical probability points guiding decisions: withhold action, test, or treat.
  • Test Threshold ($T_{test}$):
    • If P(Disease) < $T_{test}$: No further testing or treatment. Disease considered ruled out.
  • Treatment Threshold ($T_{treat}$):
    • If P(Disease) > $T_{treat}$: Initiate treatment empirically. Disease considered ruled in.
  • Test-Treat Zone:
    • If $T_{test}$ ≤ P(Disease) ≤ $T_{treat}$: Optimal to perform diagnostic testing.
  • Influencing factors:
    • Disease: Prevalence, severity.
    • Test: Accuracy (Sn, Sp), risks, cost.
    • Treatment: Efficacy, risks, benefits, cost.

⭐ The treatment threshold ($T_{treat}$) is lowered by ↑disease severity, ↑treatment efficacy, or ↓treatment risk.

Decision thresholds: test, uncertain, and treatment

Clinical Scores & EBM - Evidence Edge

  • Clinical Scores: Objectify risk/diagnosis (e.g., Wells' for DVT/PE, CURB-65 for pneumonia severity).
    • Metrics: Sensitivity $TP/(TP+FN)$, Specificity $TN/(TN+FP)$.
    • PPV $TP/(TP+FP)$, NPV $TN/(TN+FN)$.
    • Likelihood Ratios: $LR+ = Sens/(1-Spec)$; $LR- = (1-Sens)/Spec$.
  • EBM: Integrates best evidence, clinical expertise, patient values.
    • PICO: Patient, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome.
    • Hierarchy (Top to Bottom): Meta-analysis/Systematic Review → RCT → Cohort → Case-Control → Case Series → Expert Opinion.
    • Key EBM stat: Number Needed to Treat (NNT) = $1/ARR$.
    • 📌 FINER criteria (Research Q): Feasible, Interesting, Novel, Ethical, Relevant. Hierarchy of Evidence in Evidence-Based Medicine

⭐ Odds Ratio (OR) is used in case-control studies; Relative Risk (RR) in cohort studies. For rare diseases ($prevalence < 10%$), $OR \approx RR$

Cognitive Biases & SDM - Mind Matters

  • Cognitive Biases: Systematic thinking errors impairing clinical judgment.
    • Anchoring: Over-relying on initial info.
    • Availability: Overestimating based on easily recalled examples.
    • Confirmation: Seeking info confirming existing beliefs.
    • Premature Closure: Accepting diagnosis early, missing alternatives.
    • Framing Effect: Decisions influenced by info presentation.
    • Mitigation: Metacognition, checklists, second opinions.
  • Shared Decision Making (SDM): Clinicians and patients collaboratively make healthcare decisions.
    • Involves discussing options, evidence, benefits/risks.
    • Aligns care with patient values and preferences.
    • Improves satisfaction and adherence. 📌 Remember "BRAN": Benefits, Risks, Alternatives, Nothing.

⭐ SDM is not just an option but an ethical imperative in patient-centered care.

High‑Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

  • Bayes' Theorem is crucial for post-test probability calculation using likelihood ratios.
  • Understand Sensitivity (Sn), Specificity (Sp), PPV, and NPV for test interpretation.
  • ROC curves help compare diagnostic tests; Area Under Curve (AUC) quantifies overall accuracy.
  • Decision analysis often employs decision trees to model choices and potential outcomes.
  • The threshold model (test/treat thresholds) guides diagnostic and therapeutic actions.
  • Recognize common cognitive biases (e.g., anchoring, availability) that can affect clinical judgment.
  • Apply Evidence-Based Medicine (EBM) principles, respecting the hierarchy of evidence for decisions.

Practice Questions: Medical Decision Making

Test your understanding with these related questions

Specificity of a diagnostic test is defined as:

1 of 5

Flashcards: Medical Decision Making

1/5

Pellagra (from severe B3 deficiency) may be caused by _____ disease, malignant carcinoid syndrome, and isoniazid therapy

TAP TO REVEAL ANSWER

Pellagra (from severe B3 deficiency) may be caused by _____ disease, malignant carcinoid syndrome, and isoniazid therapy

Hartnup

browseSpaceflip

Enjoying this lesson?

Get full access to all lessons, practice questions, and more.

Start Your Free Trial