Epidemiological Study Designs

On this page

Epidemiological Study Designs - Study Blueprints

  • Foundation: Plans to study disease distribution & determinants.
  • Two Main Types:
    • Observational: Researcher observes existing patterns; no intervention.
      • Descriptive: Who, What, Where, When? (Hypothesis generating)
        • Case Report/Series
        • Ecological (population-level data)
        • Cross-sectional (prevalence at a point in time; snapshot)
      • Analytical: Why? How? (Hypothesis testing)
        • Case-Control (Odds Ratio; retrospective: outcome → exposure)
        • Cohort (Relative Risk, Incidence; prospective/retrospective: exposure → outcome)
    • Experimental (Interventional): Researcher actively manipulates exposure to assess effect.
      • Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT): Gold standard for causality; random allocation.
      • Non-Randomized Trials: Intervention, but no random allocation.
Loading diagram…

⭐ Cohort studies are best for determining incidence and the natural history of a disease.

Epidemiological Study Designs - Snapshot & Rewind

  • Observational Designs:
    • Cross-sectional (Prevalence Study):
      • "Snapshot": Assesses exposure & outcome simultaneously at one point in time.
      • Measures prevalence.
      • Uses: Health surveys, hypothesis generation.
      • Adv: Quick, inexpensive.
      • Disadv: No temporality (cannot infer causation), not for rare diseases.
      • Measure: Prevalence Ratio, Odds Ratio.
    • Case-Control (Retrospective/Trohoc Study):
      • "Rewind": Starts with outcome (Cases with disease vs. Controls without disease).
      • Looks back (retrospective) for past exposure.
      • Uses: Rare diseases, outbreak investigation. 📌 Mnemonic for selection of controls: Population-based, Hospital-based, Special group (PHS).
      • Adv: Quick, inexpensive, good for rare diseases, multiple exposures.
      • Disadv: Recall bias, selection bias, interviewer bias. Cannot calculate incidence/prevalence directly.
      • Measure: Odds Ratio ($OR = (ad) / (bc)$).

      ⭐ Odds Ratio from a case-control study can approximate Relative Risk if the disease is rare (prevalence < 10%).

Epidemiological Study Designs - Forward & Future

  • Cohort Studies (Observational): Follows groups from exposure to outcome.
    • Prospective: Present exposure → Future outcome.
      • Strengths: Establishes temporality, measures incidence, $RR = [a/(a+b)] / [c/(c+d)]$, $AR$. Good for rare exposures.
      • Weaknesses: Costly, long duration, attrition.
    • Retrospective (Historical): Past exposure (records) → Outcome.
      • Strengths: Quicker, cheaper.
      • Weaknesses: Record dependency, bias.
    • 📌 COhort = COming Outcomes.
  • Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) (Experimental): Intervention → Outcome.
    • Gold standard for causality. Investigator assigns exposure.
    • Key Features: Randomization, Blinding, Control.
    • Measures: Efficacy, $RR$, $AR$.
    • Strengths: ↑Internal validity, ↓bias, causal inference.
    • Weaknesses: Costly, ethical limits, ↓external validity.

⭐ RCTs provide the strongest evidence for causal relationships.

oka

Epidemiological Study Designs - Bias & Blunders

  • Bias: Systematic error in design, conduct, or analysis leading to erroneous association.
    • Selection Bias: Non-random subject selection.
      • Berksonian bias: Hospital-based controls differ from general population.
      • Neyman bias (Incidence-Prevalence bias): Selective survival in prevalent cases.
    • Information Bias (Measurement/Misclassification Bias): Errors in data collection/measurement.
      • Recall bias: Cases recall exposure more/less than controls (📌 common in case-control).
      • Interviewer bias: Interviewer influences responses.
  • Confounding: Distortion of exposure-disease relationship by a third variable (confounder).
    • Control: Randomization, Restriction, Matching, Stratification, Multivariate analysis.
  • Effect Modification: True difference in effect across strata of a third variable. Not a bias.

⭐ Randomization is the best method to control for unknown confounders in RCTs.

  • Bradford Hill Criteria: Guidelines for inferring causality (e.g., Strength, Consistency, Temporality, Dose-response).

High‑Yield Points - ⚡ Biggest Takeaways

  • Case-control studies: Retrospective, start with outcome, calculate Odds Ratio (OR); efficient for rare diseases.
  • Cohort studies: Prospective or retrospective, start with exposure, calculate Relative Risk (RR), Incidence; establish temporality.
  • Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs): Gold standard for causality; use randomization, control group, blinding.
  • Cross-sectional studies: Measure prevalence (disease & exposure) at a single point in time; "snapshot".
  • Ecological studies: Use group-level data (not individual); prone to ecological fallacy.
  • Bias control: Randomization & blinding in RCTs; matching in case-control for confounders.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Epidemiological Study Designs

  1. 1. What does the value calculated as (True Positive) / (True Positive + False Positive) x 100 represent in a diagnostic test?

    • A. Negative Predictive Value (NPV)
    • B. Specificity of a diagnostic test
    • C. Sensitivity of a diagnostic test
    • D. Positive Predictive Value (PPV)
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Positive Predictive Value (PPV)

    > Key point: PPV is the proportion of positive test results that are true positives. Why Positive Predictive Value (PPV) is correct - TP / (TP + FP) × 100 divides true positives by all positive test results. - It therefore gives the percentage of positive results that are true positives. How they compare | Measure | Formula | What it measures | |---|---|---| | PPV | TP / (TP + FP) | True positives among positive results | | NPV | TN / (TN + FN) | True negatives among negative results | | Sensitivity | TP / (TP + FN) | True positives among people with disease | | Specificity | TN / (TN + FP) | True negatives among people without disease | Why the other options are wrong - Negative Predictive Value (NPV): uses TN / (TN + FN), not the supplied formula. - Specificity: uses TN / (TN + FP), not TP / (TP + FP). - Sensitivity: uses TP / (TP + FN); its denominator includes false negatives, not false positives.

  2. 2. A researcher follows adults with newly diagnosed diabetes for 10 years to document disease progression and complications. Which study design is used?

    • A. Cohort study
    • B. Case-control study
    • C. Cross-sectional study
    • D. Ecological study
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Cohort study

    > Key point: Following individuals over time to observe disease progression is a cohort study. Why Cohort study is correct - The researcher follows adults with newly diagnosed diabetes for 10 years. - This longitudinal follow-up documents progression and complications in individuals. How they compare | Design | Starting point or approach | Fit here | |---|---|---| | Cohort study | Follow individuals over time | Yes; progression is observed | | Case-control study | Begin with outcome status; compare prior exposures | No individual follow-up | | Cross-sectional study | Measure at one point in time | No progression over time | | Ecological study | Analyze group-level data | Not individual trajectories | Why the other options are wrong - Case-control study: It compares prior exposures by outcome status rather than following people to document progression. - Cross-sectional study: It measures characteristics at one time point, so it cannot show progression over 10 years. - Ecological study: It analyzes groups, not the disease trajectories of individual adults.

  3. 3. A UK study compared annual national asthma mortality rates with annual national sales of anti-asthma drugs. What type of study is this?

    • A. Ecological study
    • B. Experimental study
    • C. Case-control study
    • D. Cohort study
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Ecological study

    > Key point: An ecological study compares exposure and outcome data measured for groups or populations, not linked individuals. Why Ecological study is correct - The study compares annual national asthma mortality rates with national anti-asthma drug sales. - Both measures are aggregate, population-level data, which defines an ecological study. How they compare | Study type | Unit of analysis | Why it fits or does not fit | |---|---|---| | Ecological study | Population or group | Both measures are national aggregates | | Experimental study | Assigned intervention | No researcher-controlled intervention is described | | Case-control study | Individuals selected by disease status | No individual cases and controls are compared | | Cohort study | Followed individuals | No individual exposure-based follow-up is described | Why the other options are wrong - Experimental study: the comparison uses existing data, not an assigned intervention. - Case-control study: it does not compare individual cases with controls. - Cohort study: it does not follow individuals according to exposure.

  4. 4. Adults without coronary artery disease are grouped by smoking status and followed for 10 years to compare the incidence of coronary artery disease. Which study design is described?

    • A. Cross-sectional study
    • B. Randomized controlled trial
    • C. Cohort study
    • D. Case-control study
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Cohort study

    > Key point: Grouping participants by exposure and following them for new outcomes describes a cohort study. Why Cohort study is correct - Participants are grouped by smoking status and followed over time to compare the incidence of coronary artery disease. - This observes exposure without assigning it and preserves the exposure-before-outcome sequence. How they compare | Design | Starting point | What happens | |---|---|---| | Cohort study | Exposure status | Follow over time for outcomes | | Cross-sectional study | Exposure and outcome | Measure at one point in time | | Randomized controlled trial | Assigned intervention | Randomly allocate participants | | Case-control study | Disease status | Compare prior exposures | Why the other options are wrong - Cross-sectional study: measures exposure and outcome at one point, rather than following participants for incidence. - Randomized controlled trial: researchers assign an intervention; here, participants are grouped by observed smoking status. - Case-control study: starts with disease status and looks back at exposure; this study starts with exposure status and follows for disease.

  5. 5. In a normal distribution curve, which values are the same?

    • A. Standard Deviation and Mode
    • B. Standard Deviation and Median
    • C. Mode and Arithmetic Mean
    • D. Standard Deviation and Mean
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Mode and Arithmetic Mean

    > Key point: In a normal distribution, the mean, median, and mode coincide; standard deviation describes spread. Why Mode and Arithmetic Mean is correct - A normal distribution is symmetric, so its central peak (mode) and arithmetic mean occur at the same value. - The median also coincides with them, but standard deviation measures spread rather than central location. How they compare | Pair | What the measures describe | Same in a normal distribution? | |---|---|---| | Mode and Arithmetic Mean | Peak and center | Yes | | Standard Deviation and Mode | Spread and peak | No | | Standard Deviation and Median | Spread and center | No | | Standard Deviation and Mean | Spread and center | No | Why the other options are wrong - Standard Deviation and Mode: standard deviation measures spread; mode is the peak. - Standard Deviation and Median: standard deviation measures spread; median is the center. - Standard Deviation and Mean: standard deviation measures spread; mean is the center.

  6. 6. Which expression gives the false-negative rate of a diagnostic test?

    • A. 1 − specificity
    • B. 1 − sensitivity
    • C. Sensitivity
    • D. Specificity
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 1 − sensitivity

    > Key point: The false-negative rate is the proportion of people with disease who test negative: 1 − sensitivity. Why 1 − sensitivity is correct - Sensitivity is the true-positive rate among people who have the disease. - False negatives and true positives partition this group, so the false-negative rate is 1 − sensitivity. How they compare | Measure | Meaning | |---|---| | 1 − sensitivity | False-negative rate among people with disease | | Sensitivity | True-positive rate among people with disease | | 1 − specificity | False-positive rate among people without disease | | Specificity | True-negative rate among people without disease | Why the other options are wrong - Sensitivity: this is the true-positive rate, not the false-negative rate. - 1 − specificity: this is the false-positive rate among people without disease. - Specificity: this is the true-negative rate among people without disease.

  7. 7. A new test, test B, for Diabetes mellitus is performed in a group containing diabetics and non-diabetics. A standard test A has been used as a reference to classify them as diabetics and non-diabetics. If 120 mg/dl of blood sugar is taken as the cut-off for test B, the area shaded in the graph below represents what?

    • A. False Positives
    • B. False Negatives
    • C. True Positives
    • D. True Negatives
    Show answer

    Answer: B. False Negatives

    > Key point: False negatives are reference-positive individuals whose test B result falls below its positive cutoff. Why False Negatives is correct - Test A identifies the individuals who truly have diabetes. - Diabetic individuals with blood sugar below 120 mg/dL test negative on B, so the shaded area represents false negatives. Why the other options are wrong - False Positives: These are non-diabetic individuals above the cutoff who test positive on B. - True Positives: These are diabetic individuals above the cutoff who test positive on B. - True Negatives: These are non-diabetic individuals below the cutoff who test negative on B.

  8. 8. What is a key benefit of Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs) in clinical research?

    • A. Shorter study duration
    • B. Reduced selection bias
    • C. Efficient rare-disease recruitment
    • D. Lower study costs
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Reduced selection bias

    > Key point: Random allocation helps reduce selection bias by assigning participants to study groups without recruiter choice. Why reduced selection bias is correct - Randomization limits systematic differences in who enters each study group, reducing selection bias. - Allocation concealment helps prevent recruiters from predicting assignments and selectively enrolling participants. Why the other options are wrong - Shorter study duration: RCTs often require substantial planning, recruitment, and follow-up. - Lower study costs: Intervention delivery, monitoring, data collection, and follow-up can make RCTs expensive. - Efficient rare-disease recruitment: Recruiting enough participants with a rare disease is often difficult.

  9. 9. What is the common threshold for statistical significance in hypothesis testing?

    • A. 0.03
    • B. 0.01
    • C. 0.02
    • D. 0.05
    Show answer

    Answer: D. 0.05

    > Key point: The conventional significance threshold in hypothesis testing is 0.05. Why 0.05 is correct - A prespecified significance level of 0.05 is the usual convention in medical hypothesis testing. - For a valid test, this sets the Type I error rate under the null hypothesis at 5%. How they compare | Significance level | Role | |---|---| | 0.05 | Conventional threshold | | 0.01 | More stringent threshold | | 0.02 | Possible stricter threshold, not the usual default | | 0.03 | Possible stricter threshold, not the usual default | Why the other options are wrong - 0.01: It is a commonly used, more stringent level, not the general default. - 0.02: It can be prespecified, but it is not the conventional default. - 0.03: It can be prespecified, but it is not the usual convention.

  10. 10. What is the statistical term for the value that occurs most frequently in a data set?

    • A. Arithmetic mean
    • B. Modal value
    • C. Median value
    • D. Standard deviation
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Modal value

    > Key point: The mode is the value that occurs most frequently in a data set. Why Modal value is correct - The modal value (mode) identifies the observation with the highest frequency. - It answers the question of which value appears most often. How they compare | Measure | What it describes | |---|---| | Modal value | Most frequent value | | Median value | Middle value when ordered | | Arithmetic mean | Average of the observations | | Standard deviation | Spread of the observations | Why the other options are wrong - Standard deviation: measures variation, not a particular value's frequency. - Median value: identifies the middle value, not the most frequent one. - Arithmetic mean: is the average, not the value occurring most often.

Flashcards: Epidemiological Study Designs

  1. 1. _____ studies are useful for measuring _____

    Show answer

    Case-control · odds ratio (OR)

  2. 2. is a method of removing confounding factors by restricting the study sample to only those participants with particular characteristics

    Show answer

    Restriction

  3. 3. Incidence and prevalence rates are included in indicators

    Show answer

    morbidity (mortality/morbidity)

  4. 4. CIR = (_____)/(_____) that gives you a measure of average risk

    Show answer

    of new cases for a specific time period · # of people at risk for same time period

  5. 5. Generalizability bias is a form of _____ that is related to the selective referral of patients to _____

    Show answer

    selection bias · tertiary medical centers

  6. 6. A study to evaluate the effect of water fluoridation on dental health is categorized as a  study.

    Show answer

    community intervention

  7. 7. _____ = _____ / _____ at a point in time

    Show answer

    Prevalence · # of existing cases · total # of people in a population

  8. 8. Excluding skin cancer, which of the listed three demographics count the incidence of the following cancers as their top 3 most common in the United States? _____

    Show answer

    Children

  9. 9. The validity of a screening test is defined by its _____ and _____ .

    Show answer

    sensitivity · specificity

  10. 10. Primary prevention prevents _____

    Show answer

    contraction of disease

Everything you need for Indian Medical PG prep

Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

GET STARTED FOR FREE
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF