Equity awards use grant-date fair value
⭐ EXAM TRAP: A company grants 2,000 equity-classified options with a grant-date fair value of $8 per option and a two-year service period. At the end of the first year, the draft debits compensation expense for $16,000 and credits a liability for $16,000. Which part of the draft belongs in a different account or amount?
The draft mixes the award class with the wrong measurement pattern. The build order separates classification, fair value, service-period allocation, and entry direction.
Classify, measure, allocate and record
Classification determines the account and measurement pattern. Use this fixed sequence for both award types.
- Start with the award classification supplied by the facts: equity or liability.
- Select the measurement basis. For an equity-classified award, use grant-date fair value. For a liability-classified award, use fair value at each reporting date through settlement.
- Identify the requisite service period and allocate the cost over the service received. For a service-only award with one tranche, use straight-line allocation.
- For a liability award, compute cumulative compensation cost at the current reporting date. Subtract the amount recognized previously to find the current-period adjustment. The adjustment may be a debit or a credit to compensation expense.
- Record the entry. Credit APIC-stock compensation for an equity award. Credit or debit the liability for a liability award. When a cash-settled liability award is paid, debit the liability and credit cash.
The inputs come from Grant date, vesting and award valuation, which supplies the grant date, fair value, and service period. Identifying and expensing R&D costs is separate and does not change these award-entry rules.
Equity and liability award schedules
The schedule applies the sequence to one equity award and one liability award. All awards vest when the stated service period is completed. The equity award has only a service condition.
The equity award has 1,000 units, a grant-date fair value of $12 per unit, and a three-year service period. Its total compensation cost is $12,000, allocated at $4,000 per year.
The liability award has 1,000 cash-settled SARs and a three-year service period. Its grant-date fair value is $10 per SAR. Its fair value is $11 at the end of Year 1, $9 at the end of Year 2, and $13 at the end of Year 3.
ASC 718-10-25-2 and ASC 718-10-35-1 require equity awards to use grant-date fair value without later remeasurement. Liability awards are remeasured at each reporting date through settlement.
| Line | Amount | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Source: equity award | - | 1,000 units × $12 grant-date fair value = $12,000 total; allocate over three years. |
| Equity, Year 1: Dr compensation expense | $4,000 | $12,000 ÷ three years. |
| Equity, Year 1: Cr APIC-stock compensation | $4,000 | Equity awards credit APIC as compensation cost is recognized. |
| Equity Year 1 subtotal | $4,000 | Debit equals credit. |
| Equity, Year 2: Dr compensation expense | $4,000 | The grant-date amount is not remeasured; recognize the next straight-line portion. |
| Equity, Year 2: Cr APIC-stock compensation | $4,000 | The equity award's credit account does not change to a liability. |
| Equity Year 2 subtotal | $4,000 | Debit equals credit. |
| Equity, Year 3: Dr compensation expense | $4,000 | Recognize the final straight-line portion. |
| Equity, Year 3: Cr APIC-stock compensation | $4,000 | Total APIC credit after service is complete is $12,000. |
| Equity Year 3 subtotal | $4,000 | Debit equals credit. |
| Source: liability award, Year 1 | - | Current fair value is $11 per SAR; cumulative cost is 1,000 × $11 × 1/3 = $11,000. |
| Liability, Year 1: Dr compensation expense | $11,000 | First cumulative amount recognized for the liability award. |
| Liability, Year 1: Cr share-based payment liability | $11,000 | Record the current fair value for service received. |
| Liability Year 1 subtotal | $11,000 | Debit equals credit. |
| Liability, Year 2: Dr share-based payment liability | $5,000 | Cumulative cost is 1,000 × $9 × 2/3 = $6,000; reduce the prior $11,000 liability by $5,000. |
| Liability, Year 2: Cr compensation expense | $5,000 | The current-period adjustment is a credit because cumulative cost decreased. |
| Liability Year 2 subtotal | $5,000 | Debit equals credit. |
| Liability, Year 3: Dr compensation expense | $7,000 | Cumulative cost is 1,000 × $13 × 3/3 = $13,000; subtract the prior $6,000 cumulative amount. |
| Liability, Year 3: Cr share-based payment liability | $7,000 | Increase the liability to its final fair value. |
| Liability Year 3 subtotal | $7,000 | Debit equals credit. |
| Settlement: Dr share-based payment liability | $13,000 | Remove the liability when the cash-settled SARs are paid. |
| Settlement: Cr cash | $13,000 | Record the cash payment; do not record another compensation expense. |
| Settlement subtotal | $13,000 | Debit equals credit. |
| Tie-out: total debits and total credits | $48,000 = $48,000 | All entries balance. |
The equity credit stays in APIC, while the liability balance changes with reporting-date fair value and is removed at settlement.
Allocating RSU and SAR compensation
The same order applies to different awards. The equity award has 600 RSUs with grant-date fair value of $15 each and a two-year service period. The liability award has 800 cash-settled SARs with a two-year service period.
The liability award's fair value is $6 per SAR at the end of Year 1 and $7 per SAR at the end of Year 2. The Year 2 cumulative cost is 800 × $7 × 2/2 = $5,600, compared with the Year 1 liability.
| Line | Amount | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Equity award: annual entry, Dr compensation expense and Cr APIC | ? | 600 × $15 total grant-date fair value allocated over two years. |
| Liability award, Year 1: Dr compensation expense and Cr liability | ? | 800 × $6 × 1/2. |
| Liability award, Year 2: ending liability | $5,600 | 800 × $7 × 2/2. |
| Liability award, Year 2: current entry, Dr compensation expense and Cr liability | ? | $5,600 cumulative cost less the Year 1 liability. |
| Settlement: Dr liability and Cr cash | ? | Remove the $5,600 liability when cash is paid. |
The figures change, but the equity award still uses grant-date fair value and the liability award still uses the change in cumulative cost.
Practice
The annual entry amount for the 600-unit equity award is ____.
The liability to report at the end of Year 1 is ____.
The Year 2 liability entry's compensation expense debit is ____.
The cash paid at settlement is ____.
Classification, accounts and entry direction
Classification and direction cause the common errors. Each case tests the account, the measurement basis, or the change from the prior liability balance.
Practice
The 1,000-unit equity award in the worked schedule has grant-date fair value of $12 per unit and a three-year service period. What entry recognizes the award's Year 2 compensation cost?
For the worked liability award, cumulative cost is $11,000 at the end of Year 1 and $6,000 at the end of Year 2. What Year 2 entry is required?
At the end of Year 3, the cash-settled SAR liability is $13,000 and the company pays it immediately. Which entry records settlement?
Change one fact in the worked schedule: the 1,000 cash-settled SARs vest over four years rather than three. Fair value is $11 at the end of Year 1 and $9 at the end of Year 2. What Year 2 entry is required?
The correct classification determines the credit account. The change in liability fair value determines the current-period direction.
Equity and liability award entry rules
- Classify the award as equity or liability.
- Use grant-date fair value for equity awards and reporting-date fair value for liability awards.
- Allocate compensation cost over the requisite service period.
- For a liability award, record current cumulative cost less prior cumulative cost.
- Credit APIC for equity compensation; adjust the liability for liability compensation.
- At cash settlement, debit the liability and credit cash.
Tie-out: total debits must equal total credits, and settlement must remove the liability without creating a second compensation expense.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

