Fair value measurements

On this page

Fair value is an orderly exit price

Fair value is the price received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability. The transaction occurs between market participants at the measurement date. This is an exit price, not the entity's purchase price, entity-specific value, replacement cost, or forced-sale amount.

Financial statement preparers use fair value when another GAAP topic requires or permits it. Investors, lenders, and other users compare these market-based amounts.

An online listing shows a higher asking price. No orderly transaction has occurred. A higher asking price does not establish fair value. The listing is only evidence. Fair value requires a market-participant price in an orderly transaction. Market participants are independent, knowledgeable, able to transact, and willing but not forced or compelled.

How the unit leads to value

Read the ladder from left to right. The unit of account and market determine what is priced. Highest and best use determines which evidence matters. Inputs feed the valuation approaches. The most representative indication becomes fair value.

Loading diagram…

Each decision limits the next one. The unit determines what is priced. The market and highest and best use determine which evidence matters. The evidence determines which indication best represents the exit price.

Market, unit and highest use determine value

Exit price and market participants

Fair value uses current market conditions at the measurement date. The transaction is orderly, so it is not a forced liquidation.

Use the principal market. This is the market with the greatest volume and level of activity that the entity can access. If no principal market exists, use the most advantageous market.

Fair value excludes transaction costs. Those costs belong to the transaction, not the asset or liability. Transport costs can affect the price when location is an asset characteristic.

The full framework for these assumptions is in Fair value framework and assumptions.

Unit of account and highest use

The unit of account comes from the GAAP topic requiring or permitting fair value. It is not chosen to produce the best answer. The base unit is one parcel and warehouse.

For a nonfinancial asset, highest and best use must be:

  • Physically possible.
  • Legally permissible.
  • Financially feasible.

The analysis uses the market participant's perspective. Management's intended use does not control the conclusion.

Apartments are physically possible. Zoning permits them. The completed project value is $9,000,000. Development, financing, and required-return costs total $6,800,000. The site residual is $2,200,000, supporting financial feasibility.

The warehouse must be removed because comparable sites are vacant. Demolition costs $120,000. Current use is presumed to be highest and best use until evidence shows another use maximizes value.

The full application of these decisions is in Fair value framework and assumptions.

Market, cost, and income approaches

The market approach uses prices and other information from transactions involving identical or similar assets.

The three vacant-land sales adjust to:

  • $2,100,000.
  • $2,120,000.
  • $2,140,000.

Equal weighting gives a $2,120,000 vacant-land indication. Subtracting $120,000 of demolition cost gives $2,000,000 for the combined unit.

The cost approach starts with a $900,000 land component and $1,600,000 replacement cost new. It subtracts $320,000 of physical deterioration and $100,000 of functional obsolescence. The indication is $2,080,000. The physical deterioration rate is 20%.

The income approach converts future amounts to a current amount. Annual NOI is $180,000. Dividing by an 8% capitalization rate gives $2,250,000.

Use techniques appropriate in the circumstances with sufficient data. Maximize relevant observable inputs. Minimize unobservable inputs. Multiple techniques do not require an automatic average.

The full application of the three approaches is in Cost, income and market approaches.

Inputs and the final selection

Level 1 inputs are quoted prices in active markets for identical assets or liabilities. The entity must be able to access the market at the measurement date.

Level 2 inputs are observable inputs other than Level 1 inputs. Examples include quoted prices for similar assets and prices in inactive markets.

Level 3 inputs are unobservable inputs.

Classify the entire fair value measurement according to the lowest-level input that is significant. ASC 820 supplies no numeric cutoff for significance. The facts supporting significance must be stated.

The base measurement is Level 3. The highest-and-best-use conclusion and the $120,000 demolition adjustment are significant unobservable inputs. The comparable sale prices remain observable.

Select $2,000,000. The adjusted market evidence directly reflects the highest and best use. Do not select the highest indication or average the three approaches.

The final selection and related checks are developed further in Cost, income and market approaches.

Demolition changes the market indication

The key artifact is the adjusted vacant-land indication of $2,120,000. The $120,000 demolition adjustment produces a $2,000,000 indication for the parcel-and-warehouse unit. The warehouse has $0 salvage value.

The $2,080,000 cost indication and $2,250,000 income indication remain parallel evidence. They are not added to or automatically averaged with the market indication. Omitting demolition overstates fair value by $120,000. Using the wrong unit mixes land-only and combined-asset prices. Using the intended warehouse use selects the wrong comparable evidence.

The number that moves forward is not simply the first comparable sale or the highest approach result. The comparison below identifies what each approach measures and why the market indication fits this case.

Market, cost and income indications

Each row produces a fair value indication, not an automatic final answer. The market row reflects highest and best use and the combined unit after demolition. The cost row reflects replacement service capacity and deterioration. The income row depends on NOI and the capitalization rate.

ApproachWhat is receivedWhat is recognizedMain assumptionsMain limit in the case
MarketThree adjusted vacant-land sales: $2,100,000, $2,120,000, and $2,140,000Equal-weight average of $2,120,000 less $120,000 demolition = $2,000,000Comparable sales reflect the apartment-development use and the principal marketRequires reliable comparable sales and supportable adjustments
Cost$900,000 land; $1,600,000 replacement cost new; $320,000 physical deterioration; $100,000 functional obsolescence$900,000 + $1,600,000 - $320,000 - $100,000 = $2,080,000Replacement cost reflects service capacity and depreciationThe existing warehouse is not the highest and best use
Income$180,000 annual NOI and an 8% capitalization rate$180,000 / 8% = $2,250,000Cash flow and the capitalization rate reflect market participant expectationsSensitive to projected cash flows and the selected rate

The market indication is the best fit because its evidence directly reflects the selected use and unit.

Apartment development is highest and best use

At the measurement date, an entity owns one parcel with a warehouse. The reporting unit is the combined parcel and warehouse. Management plans to keep the warehouse. Market participants in the local development-property market would buy the property for apartment development.

Apartments are physically possible. Zoning permits them. The completed-project value is $9,000,000. Development, financing, and required-return costs are $6,800,000. The site residual is $2,200,000.

The comparable sales are vacant apartment-development parcels. Sale A is $2,000,000 and needs a 5% time increase. Sale B is $2,100,000 and needs a 2% time increase. Sale B then needs a negative $22,000 size or location adjustment. Sale C is a current $2,140,000 sale.

The three adjusted sales are equally reliable. Demolition costs $120,000. It has $0 salvage value. The cost and income inputs are those shown in the comparison table.

Determine the fair value, all three indications, the selected amount, and the input level.

The schedule keeps each monetary amount in its own column. It carries the market result beside the parallel cost and income indications.

StepDecisionSite residualSale A adjustedSale B after timeSale B other adjustmentSale B adjustedSale C adjustedDemolitionMarket indicationLand componentReplacement cost newPhysical deterioration ratePhysical deterioration amountFunctional obsolescenceCost indicationAnnual NOICapitalization rateIncome indicationFair valueInput levelChapter
1Use the combined unit and local development-property market. Exclude transaction costs.Fair value framework and assumptions
2Apartments are physically possible, legally permissible, and financially feasible.$2,200,000Fair value framework and assumptions
3Average the adjusted sales and deduct demolition.$2,100,000$2,142,000($22,000)$2,120,000$2,140,000$120,000$2,000,000Fair value framework and assumptions; Cost, income and market approaches
4Apply replacement cost with both depreciation adjustments. Apply NOI and the capitalization rate.$900,000$1,600,00020%$320,000$100,000$2,080,000$180,0008%$2,250,000Cost, income and market approaches
5Select reliable market evidence that directly reflects highest and best use. Do not average approaches.$2,000,000Level 3

Demolition change

Demolition cost changes to $200,000. All other facts remain unchanged.

Determine the new selected fair value.

Answer: $1,920,000. Only the demolition deduction changes.

Apartments are legally prohibited at the measurement date. Current-use comparable sales are $1,900,000, $1,980,000, and $2,060,000. The sales are equally reliable.

Determine the fair value.

Answer: $1,980,000. The warehouse use remains the legally permissible highest and best use. No demolition deduction applies.

Principal market, highest use and methods

These questions change one decision at a time. The decisions concern the principal market, legal highest and best use, cost calculations, and approach selection.

Practice

At the measurement date, Market A is the principal market for an identical asset, with 100 orderly transactions at $950,000. Market B has 10 orderly transactions at $1,000,000. What price is used for fair value before any asset-specific adjustments?

A parcel's current warehouse use has comparable sales of $1,900,000, $1,980,000, and $2,060,000. Apartments would support a $3,000,000 value before demolition, but zoning prohibits apartments at the measurement date. If the current-use sales are equally reliable, what fair value indication follows?

Using the cost approach, a property has a $900,000 land component, $1,600,000 replacement cost new, 20% physical deterioration, and $100,000 functional obsolescence. What is the cost indication?

For a combined parcel-and-warehouse unit, reliable comparable evidence for the apartment-development highest and best use gives a $2,000,000 market indication after demolition. The cost indication is $2,080,000 and the income indication is $2,250,000. Which amount is the best fair value selection?

Fair value requires aligned decisions

  • Exit price: Use an orderly transaction between market participants in the principal market.
  • Unit and highest use: Price the correct reporting unit at the physically possible, legally permissible, and financially feasible use that maximizes value.
  • Approaches: Apply market, cost, and income techniques with appropriate data. Their indications are evidence, not automatic averages.
  • Inputs and selection: Maximize relevant observable inputs, minimize unobservable inputs, and select the point most representative of fair value.
  • Whole topic: Fair value is the market-based exit price that remains after the unit, market, use, evidence, and final selection agree.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Fair value measurements

  1. 1. You are assisting with the December 31, 2025, financial statement close of Vector Appliances, Inc., a U.S. GAAP reporting entity. The financial statements are scheduled to be issued on March 15, 2026. Management has asked you to evaluate information received after year-end, prepare required adjustments, and document the resulting financial statement treatment. All matters described in the exhibits are material.

    • 2. A lessee occupies one floor under a six-year operating lease. Two years after commencement, the parties modify the contract to add a second floor for the remaining four years. The added consideration equals the second floor's stand-alone market rent, adjusted only for costs the lessor avoids by leasing to the existing tenant. How should the lessee account for the modification?

      • A. As a separate contract for the additional right of use
      • B. As a termination of the original lease and creation of one new lease
      • C. As a remeasurement of the original lease using its original discount rate
      • D. As variable lease cost recognized when each additional payment is made
      Show answer

      Answer: A. As a separate contract for the additional right of use

      > Key point: An added right of use is a separate contract when its price reflects its stand-alone price, adjusted for applicable circumstances. Why a separate contract for the additional right of use is correct - The second floor adds a distinct right of use while the lessee keeps the first floor. - The added consideration equals the second floor’s stand-alone market rent, adjusted for costs the lessor avoids, so the modification qualifies as a separate contract. Decision path mermaid flowchart TD A[" Second floor added Four years remain "]:::input --> B[" Separate contract tests met? "]:::decision B -->|Yes| C[" Separate contract "]:::outcome B -->|No| D[" Modify existing lease "]:::risk Why the other options are wrong - Termination of the original lease and creation of one new lease: The lessee retains the first floor; the modification adds a right rather than replacing the existing lease. - Remeasurement of the original lease using its original discount rate: The qualifying addition is accounted for separately, so it does not require remeasurement of the original lease. - Variable lease cost recognized when each additional payment is made: The consideration is agreed for the added floor, not a variable cost recognized only when paid.

    • 3. A lessee has an operating lease for one floor of an office building. Effective July 1, Year 5, the agreement is modified to add a second floor for the remaining three years. The incremental payments are substantially below the second floor's stand-alone rental price, and no market-based or other circumstance explains the discount. How should the lessee account for the modification?

      • A. Remeasure the existing lease liability and adjust the right-of-use asset at the modification date.
      • B. Account for the additional floor as a separate contract without changing the existing lease.
      • C. Recognize the additional fixed payments as lease expense when each payment becomes due.
      • D. Terminate the existing lease and recognize a new lease for both floors at the modification date.
      Show answer

      Answer: A. Remeasure the existing lease liability and adjust the right-of-use asset at the modification date.

      > Key point: A scope increase priced below its stand-alone price without justification is not a separate contract; remeasure the lease and adjust the right-of-use asset. Why remeasure the existing lease liability and adjust the right-of-use asset at the modification date is correct - Adding the second floor increases the lease’s scope, but the unexplained discount means the added right of use is not priced commensurately with its stand-alone price. - The modification therefore is not a separate contract; the lessee remeasures the lease liability and adjusts the right-of-use asset on July 1, Year 5. Decision path mermaid flowchart TD A[" Second floor added Scope increases for three years "]:::input --> B[" Separate-contract pricing? "]:::decision B -->|No| C[" Not separate "]:::risk B -->|Yes| D[" Separate contract "]:::rule C --> E[" Remeasure liability Adjust right-of-use asset "]:::outcome Why the other options are wrong - Account for the additional floor as a separate contract without changing the existing lease: The unexplained below-market price fails the separate-contract pricing condition. - Recognize the additional fixed payments as lease expense when each payment becomes due: The payments are included in the modification-date remeasurement; expense recognition does not replace it. - Terminate the existing lease and recognize a new lease for both floors: The added floor increases scope but does not end the right to use the original floor.

    • 4. On January 1, Year 1, a customer pays $120,000 for one year of service and a nonrefundable $12,000 activation fee. Activation does not transfer a separate good or service. Annual renewals cost $120,000, do not require another activation fee, and are expected to extend the customer relationship through Year 3. How much revenue should be recognized in Year 1?

      • A. $132,000
      • B. $124,000
      • C. $120,000
      • D. $44,000
      Show answer

      Answer: B. $124,000

      > Key point: Recognize the annual service as provided and allocate the activation fee over the expected relationship because it transfers no separate service. Why $124,000 is correct - Year 1 service revenue is $120,000. - Activation revenue for Year 1 is $12,000 ÷ 3 = $4,000. Working | Step | Working | Result | |---|---|---:| | Year 1 service | Annual fee for Year 1 | $120,000 | | Activation fee | $12,000 ÷ 3 years | $4,000 | | Total Year 1 revenue | $120,000 + $4,000 | $124,000 | Answer: $124,000 Why the other options are wrong - $132,000: Recognizes the full activation fee immediately, although it transfers no separate service. - $120,000: Defers the entire activation fee and omits its $4,000 Year 1 portion. - $44,000: Divides all $132,000 by three, incorrectly spreading the annual fee rather than recognizing it for Year 1 service.

    • 5. You are assisting with the December 31, 2025, financial statement close of Lark Manufacturing, Inc., a U.S. GAAP reporting entity. Management expects to issue the financial statements on March 15, 2026. Use the exhibits to determine the required year-end adjustments and disclosures.

      • 6. During Year 2, an entity discovers that merchandise received before December 31, Year 1, was omitted from both inventory and accounts payable at Year 1-end. The Year 1 financial statements were issued, and the error is material. How should the entity report the correction in comparative financial statements issued during Year 2?

        • A. Restate the Year 1 financial statements and adjust the beginning Year 2 retained earnings balance
        • B. Record the correction in Year 2 income without revising the Year 1 financial statements
        • C. Apply the correction prospectively to inventory purchases occurring after discovery
        • D. Report the correction as a Year 2 change in accounting estimate affecting current operations
        Show answer

        Answer: A. Restate the Year 1 financial statements and adjust the beginning Year 2 retained earnings balance

        > Key point: Correct a material prior-period error retrospectively by restating comparative statements and adjusting opening retained earnings for any cumulative income effect. Why restating Year 1 and adjusting beginning Year 2 retained earnings is correct - The merchandise was received before Year 1-end, so inventory and accounts payable were misstated in the issued Year 1 statements; a material error requires restatement. - Adjust beginning Year 2 retained earnings for any cumulative income effect of the correction. Why the other options are wrong - Record the correction in Year 2 income without revising Year 1: This leaves the material Year 1 error uncorrected and misstates Year 2 income. - Apply the correction prospectively to later purchases: Future purchases do not correct the merchandise and payable omitted at Year 1-end. - Treat it as a Year 2 change in accounting estimate: This is an omission of received merchandise and its payable, not a revision of an uncertain estimate.

      • 7. During 2025, Lark Co. discovered that routine repair costs incurred in 2024 had been capitalized as equipment contrary to U.S. GAAP. The equipment account and 2024 income were materially overstated. Lark presents comparative 2024 and 2025 financial statements, and the income tax effects are ignored. How should Lark report the correction?

        • A. Record the remaining carrying amount as repair expense prospectively over the equipment's useful life.
        • B. Restate the 2024 comparative financial statements and disclose the nature of the correction.
        • C. Apply the correction retrospectively as a voluntary change in accounting principle.
        • D. Record the entire remaining carrying amount as repair expense in 2025 without restating 2024.
        Show answer

        Answer: B. Restate the 2024 comparative financial statements and disclose the nature of the correction.

        > Key point: Correct a material prior-period error by restating the affected comparative statements and disclosing the correction. Why restating the 2024 comparative statements is correct - Capitalizing routine repairs contrary to U.S. GAAP materially overstated 2024 equipment and income, so Lark corrects the error in the 2024 statements it presents. - Lark also discloses the nature of the correction. Why the other options are wrong - Record the remaining carrying amount as repair expense prospectively over the equipment's useful life: This continues treating routine repairs as an asset instead of correcting the 2024 error. - Apply the correction retrospectively as a voluntary change in accounting principle: Lark is correcting an error, not choosing between acceptable accounting principles. - Record the entire remaining carrying amount as repair expense in 2025 without restating 2024: This places a 2024 expense in 2025 and leaves the comparative 2024 statements materially misstated.

      • 8. On October 1, Year 1, a service provider received a nonrefundable $12,000 activation fee and agreed to provide monthly monitoring services for 12 months at $2,000 per month. Activation consists only of administrative setup and does not transfer a separate service to the customer. All monthly fees are fixed and collectible. What revenue should be recognized through December 31, Year 1?

        • A. $6,000
        • B. $9,000
        • C. $12,000
        • D. $18,000
        Show answer

        Answer: B. $9,000

        > Key point: Combine the activation fee with the monthly fees and recognize the total evenly over the 12-month monitoring period. Why $9,000 is correct - Administrative setup transfers no separate service, so the $12,000 activation fee is recognized over the monitoring period. - Total fees are $36,000; over 12 months, that is $3,000 per month. October through December covers three months. Working | Step | Working | Result | |---|---|---| | Total fees | $12,000 + (12 × $2,000) | $36,000 | | Monthly revenue | $36,000 ÷ 12 | $3,000 | | Revenue through December 31 | 3 × $3,000 | $9,000 | Answer: $9,000 Why the other options are wrong - $6,000: Counts only three monthly monitoring fees and omits the activation fee’s allocated share. - $12,000: Counts four months at $3,000 rather than October through December’s three months. - $18,000: Recognizes the entire activation fee immediately, although it transfers no separate service.

      Flashcards: Fair value measurements

      1. 1. What approaches can entities use, alone or in combination, to measure the fair value of an asset or a liability?

        Show answer

        The market approach, income approach, cost approach, or a combination of these.

      2. 2. In the definition of fair value, what would be received and what would be paid?

        Show answer

        The price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability.

      3. 3. How is a cash flow hedge accounted for?

        Show answer

        A cash flow hedge protects against variability in future cash flows. When hedge accounting applies, the derivative is measured at fair value; the effective portion of gains and losses is reported initially in OCI and later reclassified into earnings when the hedged item affects earnings. If the hedged forecast transaction results in recognizing a nonfinancial asset or liability, the amount is included in that asset’s or liability’s initial carrying amount. Any ineffective portion is recognized in earnings.

      4. 4. What is fair value in relation to an asset?

        Show answer

        Fair value is the price that would be received to sell an asset in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date. For a nonfinancial asset, the measurement considers its highest and best use.

      5. 5. What characterizes Level 3 inputs in the fair value hierarchy?

        Show answer

        They are unobservable inputs, such as assumptions or forecasts, and have the lowest priority in the fair value hierarchy.

      6. 6. Identify examples of Level 2 valuation inputs.

        Show answer

        Observable inputs other than Level 1 quoted prices, such as market interest rates (including an observable prime rate), yield curves, and credit spreads. The input must be observable and not qualify as a Level 1 input.

      7. 7. What information is generally disclosed about derivative transactions?

        Show answer

        Disclosures generally include the objectives and strategies for using derivatives; notional amounts; fair values; gains and losses and where they appear in the financial statements; hedging designations and related accounting; and relevant credit-risk, collateral, and contingent-feature information.

      8. 8. What constitutes a Level 1 input in the fair value hierarchy?

        Show answer

        A quoted, unadjusted price in an active market for an identical asset or liability that the reporting entity can access at the measurement date.

      9. 9. Where are unrealized gains or losses on trading debt securities reported?

        Show answer

        They are recorded on the income statement.

      10. 10. What assumptions underlie a fair value measurement?

        Show answer

        The buyer and seller are unrelated, both parties are informed and able to transact, and both are willing to engage in the transaction.

      Everything you need for CPA prep

      Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

      GET STARTED FOR FREE
      75% OFFLimited time offer
      GET 75% OFF