An uncorrected material inventory error
Ridgeway asks for a review of its second-quarter interim financial statements prepared under U.S. GAAP.
Management accepts responsibility but refuses to correct an inventory overstatement of $40,000 that is material but not pervasive.
The accountant completes the required review procedures.
Common answer: issue the standard review conclusion because a review is not an audit.
That answer is wrong because an uncorrected material departure requires a modified conclusion.
Review procedures and modified conclusions
A review uses inquiry and analytical work rather than the broader work needed for an audit opinion. The accountant still responds to evidence of a material departure.
- The accountant should perform procedures that provide a reasonable basis for expressing a conclusion on the interim financial information.
- A review consists principally of making inquiries of persons responsible for financial and accounting matters and applying analytical procedures.
- The accountant should obtain knowledge of the entity's business and industry, accounting principles and practices, and internal control. The accountant should read the interim financial information and relevant minutes. The accountant should inquire about subsequent events and other matters that may require adjustment or disclosure. Other procedures are performed when the circumstances require them.
- If the accountant becomes aware that the interim financial information may require material modification, the accountant should perform additional procedures sufficient to provide a reasonable basis for the conclusion.
- The standard conclusion is: “Based on our review, we are not aware of any material modifications that should be made to the accompanying interim financial information for it to be in conformity with [the applicable financial reporting framework].”
- The report states that the review is substantially less in scope than an audit and does not provide a basis for expressing an opinion. It identifies management's responsibility, the accountant's responsibility, the applicable review standards, the interim information reviewed, the conclusion, the accountant's signature, and the report date.
- If an uncorrected departure is material but not pervasive, issue a qualified conclusion. If it is material and pervasive, issue an adverse conclusion. If the accountant cannot complete procedures considered necessary, withdraw when practicable and do not issue a review report. No dollar or percentage threshold decides materiality or pervasiveness. Those judgments depend on the financial information as a whole.
🔑 RULE: Combining rule: establish management responsibility and the framework, perform the review procedures, perform additional procedures when needed, then choose the conclusion based on any remaining material departure and its pervasiveness.
Compliance reporting, Comparative statements and consistency, Other and supplementary information, and Special-purpose framework reports address different reporting questions from interim financial information reviews.
From review procedures to conclusion
The flowchart makes the order visible: do the work, investigate anything unusual, decide whether the work is complete, and classify any remaining departure. A possible material modification triggers additional procedures. An inability to complete necessary procedures ends the reporting path.
Loading diagram…
A corrected departure returns to the standard conclusion because no uncorrected material departure remains.
Ridgeway meets review requirements
Each fact takes a place in the flow. The framework and management responsibility support the engagement, the procedures are complete, and the inventory issue remains uncorrected.
| Fact | Criterion it touches | Met or not met |
|---|---|---|
| Ridgeway requests a review of second-quarter interim financial statements prepared under U.S. GAAP. | Interim information and applicable framework | Met |
| Management accepts responsibility for preparing and presenting the interim financial information. | Management responsibility | Met |
| The accountant obtains knowledge of the business and accounting practices, makes inquiries, applies analytical procedures, reads relevant minutes and the interim statements, and asks about subsequent events. | Required review procedures | Met |
| The accountant completes the procedures and any needed follow-up work. | Reasonable basis for a conclusion | Met |
| The procedures identify a $40,000 inventory overstatement. | Possible material modification | Not met; a departure exists |
| The overstatement is material but not pervasive. | Pervasiveness classification | Met for the qualified-conclusion branch |
| Management refuses to correct the overstatement. | Uncorrected departure | Not met; the departure remains |
| Verdict: issue a qualified review conclusion with a basis for qualified conclusion paragraph. | Material but not pervasive and uncorrected | Qualified conclusion |
The wrong answer came from treating a review's lack of an audit opinion as if it prevented a qualified conclusion.
A corrected departure needs no modification
A material issue found during the work does not automatically force a qualified conclusion. The key question is whether a material departure remains uncorrected when the report is issued.
| Fact | Criterion it touches | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Harbor Co. provides second-quarter interim financial statements prepared under U.S. GAAP. | Applicable framework | ? |
| Management accepts responsibility for the statements. | Management responsibility | ? |
| The accountant completes inquiries, analytical procedures, reading of relevant minutes, and subsequent-event inquiries. | Required review procedures | ? |
| The procedures identify a $25,000 prepaid-expense misclassification that is material but not pervasive. | Possible material modification | ? |
| Management corrects the misclassification before the report, and no other material modifications are identified. | Uncorrected departure | ? |
| Verdict | Final reporting decision | ? |
Practice
Harbor Co. provides second-quarter interim financial statements prepared under U.S. GAAP for review. Management accepts responsibility. The accountant completes the required review procedures and identifies a $25,000 prepaid-expense misclassification that is material but not pervasive. Management corrects it before the report, and no other material modifications are identified. Which conclusion is appropriate?
Qualified, adverse and incomplete procedures
These cases isolate the choices that are easiest to mix up: review procedures, incomplete procedures, and the difference between qualified and adverse conclusions.
Practice
Which procedure set best matches a review of interim financial information under AU-C 930?
An accountant cannot obtain records needed for a procedure considered necessary, and no alternative procedure provides a reasonable basis for a conclusion. What should the accountant do?
Management refuses to correct a departure from U.S. GAAP that is material and pervasive to the interim financial information. Which conclusion is appropriate?
A pervasive departure requires an adverse conclusion
Was: Ridgeway requested a review of second-quarter interim U.S. GAAP financial statements, management accepted responsibility, the accountant completed the required review procedures, those procedures found a $40,000 material but not pervasive inventory overstatement, and management refused to correct it.
Now: The same overstatement affects the financial statements broadly, rather than only the inventory account. Does the verdict change?
Answer: Yes. The pervasiveness criterion moved from material but not pervasive to material and pervasive, so the uncorrected departure requires an adverse conclusion.
Review reporting conclusions and exceptions
The criteria that control the reporting path are:
- Management responsibility and the applicable framework must be established.
- Perform the review's principally inquiry and analytical procedures, plus other procedures needed for the circumstances.
- When something may require material modification, perform additional procedures.
- If no uncorrected material departure remains, use the standard review conclusion.
- If an uncorrected departure is material but not pervasive, use a qualified conclusion.
- If an uncorrected departure is material and pervasive, use an adverse conclusion.
- If necessary procedures cannot be completed, withdraw when practicable and do not issue a review report.
Combining rule: follow the sequence from procedures, to additional work, to the conclusion based on the remaining departure.
Often skipped: ask about subsequent events and consider whether they require adjustment or disclosure.
Interim financial information reviews do not replace Compliance reporting, Comparative statements and consistency, Other and supplementary information, or Special-purpose framework reports; each chapter answers a different reporting question.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

