Four audit types and objectives
Professional skepticism and judgment from Professional skepticism and judgment help the auditor choose and apply the right criteria. The four types below differ by objective, subject matter, criteria, scope, and report. The current comparison also connects to Types and objectives of audit engagements.
| Audit type | Main objective | Subject matter | Criteria | Scope | Report or conclusion | Clue words |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Financial statement audit | Reasonable assurance that financial statements are free from material misstatement due to fraud or error | Financial statements and disclosures | Applicable financial reporting framework, such as GAAP under FASB ASC 105 | Balances, transactions, disclosures, and related audit evidence | Opinion on the financial statements under AU-C 700 | Fairly presented; GAAP; material misstatement; audit opinion; fraud or error |
| Compliance audit | Reasonable assurance that applicable requirements were followed in all material respects | Compliance with laws, regulations, contracts, grants, or other requirements | Specified compliance requirements | Allowable costs, eligibility, reporting, matching, or spending rules | Opinion or conclusion on compliance, with reported findings, under AU-C 935 | Complied; requirements; grant; law; regulation; contract; allowable costs |
| Operational audit | Assess economy, efficiency, and effectiveness of operations or programs | A process, department, program, or service | Goals, policies, performance measures, laws, or accepted practices | Broad scope set by the performance question | Findings, conclusions, and recommendations | Efficient; effective; economical; performance; goals; process; improve |
| Integrated audit | Express an opinion on financial statements and an opinion on ICFR effectiveness | Financial statements plus ICFR | Applicable reporting framework plus a suitable control framework, such as COSO | Financial statements and relevant ICFR design and operating effectiveness | Two opinions: financial statements and ICFR, under AU-C 940 | ICFR; control effectiveness; material weakness; two opinions; integrated |
In a financial statement audit, ordinary internal-control work supports the opinion but does not produce a separate ICFR opinion.
Material has no fixed percentage. A matter is material when it could reasonably influence a reasonable user’s decision.
A grant engagement is not automatically integrated. Grant rules point to compliance, while an ICFR opinion points to integrated auditing.
The next chapter, GAGAS, attestation and SSARS engagements, adds other engagement families. Those families are not substitutes for these four audit objectives.
The key distinction is the conclusion requested, not every procedure performed.
Requested conclusion and criteria decide
The requested conclusion and its criteria provide the single decision axis.
- If the question is whether financial statements are fairly presented, choose a financial statement audit.
- If the question is whether specified requirements were followed, choose a compliance audit.
- If the question is whether operations meet goals economically, efficiently, and effectively, choose an operational audit.
- If the question asks for both financial statement fairness and ICFR effectiveness, choose an integrated audit.
The auditor, client type, use of sampling, and presence of controls do not decide the type. Engagements can include overlapping work, but the requested conclusion controls the classification.
Under Government Auditing Standards, an operational audit is commonly called a performance audit. A performance question remains operational even when laws or policies provide some criteria.
Classifying audits by conclusion and criteria
Each scenario below changes the requested conclusion or criteria. The answer depends on that request rather than one familiar word, such as controls or grant.
Practice
An auditor is engaged to obtain reasonable assurance that a company's annual financial statements are free from material misstatement due to fraud or error and to issue an opinion under GAAP. No separate opinion on ICFR is requested. Which type of audit is this?
A nonprofit receives a government grant. The auditor must determine whether the nonprofit followed the grant's eligibility, allowable-cost, and reporting requirements and report whether it complied in all material respects. Which type of audit is this?
A city asks an auditor to assess whether its emergency-response program meets service goals, uses staff and equipment efficiently, and delivers services economically. The report will contain findings and recommendations. Which type of audit is this?
A nonissuer asks its auditor to express an opinion on whether its financial statements are fairly presented and a separate opinion on whether its ICFR was effective during the period. Which type of audit is this?
Each answer follows the requested conclusion and its criteria. The same words, such as controls or a grant, do not decide the type by themselves.
The requested conclusion controls classification
Was: A city asks an auditor to assess whether its transit operations meet service goals and use fuel, vehicles, and staff efficiently. The report will contain findings and recommendations.
Now: Keep the city and auditor, but change the request: the auditor must determine whether the city’s annual financial statements are fairly presented under GAAP and issue an opinion.
Which one now?
Answer: Financial statement audit.
What changed hands: The subject matter changed from transit performance to financial statements. The criteria changed from service goals and efficiency measures to GAAP. The report changed from findings and recommendations to a financial statement opinion.
The city and auditor did not decide the type. The requested conclusion did. The final lines reduce every comparison to that same axis.
Financial, compliance, operational and integrated audits
Financial statement audit: asks whether financial statements are fairly presented and free from material misstatement.
Compliance audit: asks whether specified laws, regulations, contracts, grants, or other requirements were followed in all material respects.
Operational audit: asks whether operations or programs are economical, efficient, and effective.
Integrated audit: asks for both a financial statement opinion and an ICFR effectiveness opinion.
Axis: classify the engagement by the conclusion requested and the criteria used: financial reporting, compliance, performance, or financial reporting plus ICFR.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

