Types and objectives of audit engagements

Types and objectives of audit engagements

Published September 28, 2026

Types and objectives of audit engagements

On this page

Four audit types and objectives

Professional skepticism and judgment from Professional skepticism and judgment help the auditor choose and apply the right criteria. The four types below differ by objective, subject matter, criteria, scope, and report. The current comparison also connects to Types and objectives of audit engagements.

Audit typeMain objectiveSubject matterCriteriaScopeReport or conclusionClue words
Financial statement auditReasonable assurance that financial statements are free from material misstatement due to fraud or errorFinancial statements and disclosuresApplicable financial reporting framework, such as GAAP under FASB ASC 105Balances, transactions, disclosures, and related audit evidenceOpinion on the financial statements under AU-C 700Fairly presented; GAAP; material misstatement; audit opinion; fraud or error
Compliance auditReasonable assurance that applicable requirements were followed in all material respectsCompliance with laws, regulations, contracts, grants, or other requirementsSpecified compliance requirementsAllowable costs, eligibility, reporting, matching, or spending rulesOpinion or conclusion on compliance, with reported findings, under AU-C 935Complied; requirements; grant; law; regulation; contract; allowable costs
Operational auditAssess economy, efficiency, and effectiveness of operations or programsA process, department, program, or serviceGoals, policies, performance measures, laws, or accepted practicesBroad scope set by the performance questionFindings, conclusions, and recommendationsEfficient; effective; economical; performance; goals; process; improve
Integrated auditExpress an opinion on financial statements and an opinion on ICFR effectivenessFinancial statements plus ICFRApplicable reporting framework plus a suitable control framework, such as COSOFinancial statements and relevant ICFR design and operating effectivenessTwo opinions: financial statements and ICFR, under AU-C 940ICFR; control effectiveness; material weakness; two opinions; integrated

In a financial statement audit, ordinary internal-control work supports the opinion but does not produce a separate ICFR opinion.

Material has no fixed percentage. A matter is material when it could reasonably influence a reasonable user’s decision.

A grant engagement is not automatically integrated. Grant rules point to compliance, while an ICFR opinion points to integrated auditing.

The next chapter, GAGAS, attestation and SSARS engagements, adds other engagement families. Those families are not substitutes for these four audit objectives.

The key distinction is the conclusion requested, not every procedure performed.

Requested conclusion and criteria decide

The requested conclusion and its criteria provide the single decision axis.

  • If the question is whether financial statements are fairly presented, choose a financial statement audit.
  • If the question is whether specified requirements were followed, choose a compliance audit.
  • If the question is whether operations meet goals economically, efficiently, and effectively, choose an operational audit.
  • If the question asks for both financial statement fairness and ICFR effectiveness, choose an integrated audit.

The auditor, client type, use of sampling, and presence of controls do not decide the type. Engagements can include overlapping work, but the requested conclusion controls the classification.

Under Government Auditing Standards, an operational audit is commonly called a performance audit. A performance question remains operational even when laws or policies provide some criteria.

Classifying audits by conclusion and criteria

Each scenario below changes the requested conclusion or criteria. The answer depends on that request rather than one familiar word, such as controls or grant.

Practice

An auditor is engaged to obtain reasonable assurance that a company's annual financial statements are free from material misstatement due to fraud or error and to issue an opinion under GAAP. No separate opinion on ICFR is requested. Which type of audit is this?

A nonprofit receives a government grant. The auditor must determine whether the nonprofit followed the grant's eligibility, allowable-cost, and reporting requirements and report whether it complied in all material respects. Which type of audit is this?

A city asks an auditor to assess whether its emergency-response program meets service goals, uses staff and equipment efficiently, and delivers services economically. The report will contain findings and recommendations. Which type of audit is this?

A nonissuer asks its auditor to express an opinion on whether its financial statements are fairly presented and a separate opinion on whether its ICFR was effective during the period. Which type of audit is this?

Each answer follows the requested conclusion and its criteria. The same words, such as controls or a grant, do not decide the type by themselves.

The requested conclusion controls classification

Was: A city asks an auditor to assess whether its transit operations meet service goals and use fuel, vehicles, and staff efficiently. The report will contain findings and recommendations.

Now: Keep the city and auditor, but change the request: the auditor must determine whether the city’s annual financial statements are fairly presented under GAAP and issue an opinion.

Which one now?

Answer: Financial statement audit.

What changed hands: The subject matter changed from transit performance to financial statements. The criteria changed from service goals and efficiency measures to GAAP. The report changed from findings and recommendations to a financial statement opinion.

The city and auditor did not decide the type. The requested conclusion did. The final lines reduce every comparison to that same axis.

Financial, compliance, operational and integrated audits

Financial statement audit: asks whether financial statements are fairly presented and free from material misstatement.

Compliance audit: asks whether specified laws, regulations, contracts, grants, or other requirements were followed in all material respects.

Operational audit: asks whether operations or programs are economical, efficient, and effective.

Integrated audit: asks for both a financial statement opinion and an ICFR effectiveness opinion.

Axis: classify the engagement by the conclusion requested and the criteria used: financial reporting, compliance, performance, or financial reporting plus ICFR.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Types and objectives of audit engagements

  1. 1. Rowan & Cole, CPAs, is auditing the December 31, 2025 GAAP financial statements of Aspen Medical Devices, Inc., a privately held nonissuer under AICPA auditing standards. On March 10, 2026, shortly before the planned March 15 audit report date, the engagement partner performs a final independence review. Use the exhibits to determine the effect of each relationship or service and the actions required before the firm decides whether it may issue an audit report as independent.

    • 2. A CPA who practices publicly is undergoing a review of their practice as part of an AICPA-authorized peer review program, which requires production of a former nonissuer audit client's workpapers. The former client refuses to authorize disclosure. Under the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct, which action should the CPA take?

      • A. Withhold the workpapers unless the former client provides written consent.
      • B. Provide only information that is already available from public sources.
      • C. Produce the workpapers required for the peer review without obtaining client consent.
      • D. Decline production until the state board of accountancy approves the disclosure.
      Show answer

      Answer: C. Produce the workpapers required for the peer review without obtaining client consent.

      Produce the workpapers required for the peer review without obtaining client consent. - The AICPA Code’s confidentiality rule permits disclosure of client information for an AICPA-authorized peer review of the CPA’s practice. - The CPA may therefore produce the required former nonissuer audit client workpapers despite the client’s refusal to consent. Withhold the workpapers unless the former client provides written consent. - Written client consent is not required when the authorized peer review exception applies. - Withholding the required workpapers would treat the client’s refusal as overriding that exception. Provide only information that is already available from public sources. - The peer review exception permits disclosure of the required workpapers, not just publicly available information. - Limiting production to public information would not meet the stated peer review requirement. Decline production until the state board of accountancy approves the disclosure. - The AICPA Code does not require advance state board approval for disclosure under its authorized peer review exception. - The CPA should produce the required workpapers rather than delay production for an approval the exception does not require.

    • 3. Cedar Laboratories, LLC, a nonissuer, pays First Bank a royalty based on qualifying sales under a financing agreement. Cedar asks Sutton & Co., CPAs, to perform procedures on its 2025 royalty schedule under AICPA attestation standards. Cedar is responsible for the royalty schedule, and both Cedar and First Bank will use the report. The engagement team must determine whether the requested work can be performed, address a proposed additional procedure, evaluate the test results, and prepare appropriate report language.

      • 4. A firm's monitoring process finds that an audit methodology supplied by its network omitted a required procedure for a recurring class of significant risks. Several engagements used the methodology, but no resulting audit failure has yet been identified. Under the AICPA quality management standards, what should the firm do?

        • A. Evaluate the deficiency's severity and pervasiveness, implement remedial action, and assess whether the action is effective.
        • B. Refer the matter to the network and take no firm-level action unless an audit opinion is shown to be incorrect.
        • C. Defer action until the firm's next cyclical inspection determines whether engagement teams compensated for the omission.
        • D. Withdraw every report issued using the methodology because the omission establishes that each engagement failed.
        Show answer

        Answer: A. Evaluate the deficiency's severity and pervasiveness, implement remedial action, and assess whether the action is effective.

        Evaluate the deficiency's severity and pervasiveness, implement remedial action, and assess whether the action is effective. - Omitting a required procedure for a recurring class of significant risks is an identified quality management deficiency that the firm must evaluate and remediate. - The firm should determine which engagements used the methodology, address any resulting engagement-level implications, and assess whether its remedial action is effective. Refer the matter to the network and take no firm-level action unless an audit opinion is shown to be incorrect. - A network-supplied methodology does not transfer responsibility for the firm's system of quality management to the network. - The firm must act on the identified deficiency even though no incorrect audit opinion has been found. Defer action until the firm's next cyclical inspection determines whether engagement teams compensated for the omission. - The monitoring finding calls for timely evaluation and remediation, not a wait for the next inspection cycle. - Whether engagement teams performed other procedures may inform the firm's assessment, but it does not justify deferring action. Withdraw every report issued using the methodology because the omission establishes that each engagement failed. - The methodology defect does not establish that every engagement using it lacked sufficient audit evidence. - The firm must assess affected engagements individually before determining whether any issued report requires action.

      • 5. During an audit of a nonissuer, management selects assumptions for several material estimates near the optimistic ends of acceptable ranges. Each estimate is individually reasonable, but the auditor concludes that the collective pattern may indicate management bias. Management records no adjustments. Which communication to those charged with governance is most appropriate?

        • A. Communicate only the aggregate amount by which the estimates differ from the auditor's point estimates.
        • B. Communicate the matter only if the estimates cause a material financial statement misstatement.
        • C. Report the matter solely as a significant deficiency in internal control over financial reporting.
        • D. Communicate the qualitative aspects of the estimates and the indication of possible management bias.
        Show answer

        Answer: D. Communicate the qualitative aspects of the estimates and the indication of possible management bias.

        Communicate the qualitative aspects of the estimates and the indication of possible management bias. - The estimates are individually reasonable, but management’s repeated selection of assumptions near the optimistic ends of acceptable ranges may indicate bias. - The auditor should communicate that qualitative concern to those charged with governance even though management records no adjustments. Communicate only the aggregate amount by which the estimates differ from the auditor's point estimates. - An aggregate amount would not explain the consistent directional pattern in management’s assumptions. - Because each estimate is individually reasonable, the concern is not resolved by comparing estimates solely with the auditor’s point estimates. Communicate the matter only if the estimates cause a material financial statement misstatement. - Communication of significant qualitative aspects of accounting practices does not require a material misstatement. - The pattern may warrant governance attention despite the auditor’s conclusion that each estimate is reasonable. Report the matter solely as a significant deficiency in internal control over financial reporting. - Possible management bias is not, by itself, a finding that an internal control deficiency exists. - A control deficiency would require separate consideration if identified, but it would not replace communication about the estimates’ qualitative aspects.

      • 6. Before an audit report is dated, an engagement partner and a technical-consultation partner disagree about whether sufficient appropriate audit evidence supports a significant accounting estimate. The firm's quality management policies require consultation on the issue. What should the engagement partner do?

        • A. Resolve and document the difference of opinion before releasing the audit report.
        • B. Release the report and document the disagreement during final file assembly.
        • C. Follow the engagement partner's conclusion because that partner has final responsibility.
        • D. Ask management to select which technical conclusion the firm should apply.
        Show answer

        Answer: A. Resolve and document the difference of opinion before releasing the audit report.

        Resolve and document the difference of opinion before releasing the audit report. - The disagreement concerns whether sufficient appropriate audit evidence supports a significant accounting estimate, so the firm’s required consultation and difference-of-opinion procedures apply. - The engagement partner must resolve the difference and document the conclusion before the audit report is released. Release the report and document the disagreement during final file assembly. - Final file assembly cannot substitute for resolving an unresolved technical disagreement before release. - Documenting the disagreement later would leave the report released without a settled conclusion about the audit evidence. Follow the engagement partner's conclusion because that partner has final responsibility. - The engagement partner’s responsibility does not override the firm’s required consultation and difference-resolution policies. - The partner must resolve and document the disagreement rather than simply disregard the technical-consultation partner’s view. Ask management to select which technical conclusion the firm should apply. - Management is responsible for its accounting estimate, but the auditor determines whether sufficient appropriate audit evidence supports it. - Management cannot settle an internal disagreement between the engagement partner and the technical-consultation partner.

      • 7. A CPA firm audits a nonissuer under AICPA standards. During the audit period, the client asks the firm to prepare a federal refund claim for a fee equal to 15% of any refund received. The claim does not involve a judicial proceeding. Which action complies with the AICPA Code of Professional Conduct?

        • A. Accept the contingent fee because the service is a tax service rather than an attest service.
        • B. Perform the service only under a fee arrangement that is not contingent on the refund.
        • C. Accept the contingent fee after obtaining approval from those charged with governance.
        • D. Accept the contingent fee if the potential fee is immaterial to the firm's annual revenue.
        Show answer

        Answer: B. Perform the service only under a fee arrangement that is not contingent on the refund.

        Perform the service only under a fee arrangement that is not contingent on the refund. - The firm audits the nonissuer during the period at issue, so the AICPA Code prohibits it from charging that client a contingent fee for this service. - Because the federal refund claim does not involve a judicial proceeding, the firm should prepare it only for a fee not tied to the refund. Accept the contingent fee because the service is a tax service rather than an attest service. - The prohibition applies to professional services performed for an audit client, not just the audit. - Calling the refund claim a tax service does not permit a fee equal to 15% of the refund received. Accept the contingent fee after obtaining approval from those charged with governance. - Approval from those charged with governance does not override the AICPA contingent-fee restriction. - The firm must change the fee arrangement rather than seek approval for the proposed 15% fee. Accept the contingent fee if the potential fee is immaterial to the firm's annual revenue. - The restriction does not depend on materiality to the firm’s revenue. - Even a small refund-based fee remains contingent because its amount depends on the client’s refund.

      • 8. A CPA in public practice does not provide the client with an audit, review, compilation, prospective financial information examination, or other attest service. Which fee arrangement is permitted under the AICPA contingent fee rule?

        • A. A fee for preparing an original income tax return equal to 15% of the client's refund.
        • B. A fee contingent on the outcome of representing the client during an IRS examination.
        • C. A fee for a routine amended return contingent on a refund when substantive agency review is not expected.
        • D. A fee for litigation testimony equal to 10% of the damages awarded to the client.
        Show answer

        Answer: B. A fee contingent on the outcome of representing the client during an IRS examination.

        A fee contingent on the outcome of representing the client during an IRS examination. - The AICPA contingent fee rule permits a fee tied to the outcome of representing a client in a tax return examination by a revenue agent. - Because the CPA provides none of the listed attest services, that separate restriction on contingent fees does not prevent this arrangement. A fee for preparing an original income tax return equal to 15% of the client's refund. - The rule prohibits a contingent fee for preparing an original tax return, even when the CPA provides no attest services. - Setting the fee at 15% of the refund makes payment depend on the return’s result, so it is not a permitted preparation fee. A fee for a routine amended return contingent on a refund when substantive agency review is not expected. - A contingent fee for an amended return or refund claim requires a reasonable expectation of substantive consideration by the taxing authority. - The question expressly says substantive review is not expected, so this routine amended return does not qualify. A fee for litigation testimony equal to 10% of the damages awarded to the client. - Making the testimony fee 10% of damages awarded ties the CPA’s compensation to the litigation outcome. - That contingent expert-witness fee is prohibited because it threatens the CPA’s objectivity.

      • 9. A senior assigned to the audit of a nonissuer submits an application for the client's assistant controller position. The senior has not received an offer and intends to remain on the audit while interviewing. Under the AICPA independence rules, which action is required when the senior begins seeking employment?

        • A. Continue audit work but avoid procedures involving payroll and executive compensation
        • B. Continue audit work after disclosing the application to the client's audit committee
        • C. Notify an appropriate person in the firm and cease participating in the engagement
        • D. Remain on the engagement until the client extends a formal employment offer
        Show answer

        Answer: C. Notify an appropriate person in the firm and cease participating in the engagement

        Notify an appropriate person in the firm and cease participating in the engagement - Under the AICPA independence rules, the senior’s application for the client’s assistant controller position means the senior is seeking employment with an attest client. - The senior must notify an appropriate person in the firm and stop participating in the audit engagement when the employment search begins, even though no offer has been made. Continue audit work but avoid procedures involving payroll and executive compensation - Avoiding payroll and executive compensation procedures does not remove the independence threat created by seeking a position with the audit client. - The required response is to cease participating in the engagement, not merely to change assigned audit areas. Continue audit work after disclosing the application to the client's audit committee - Disclosure to the client’s audit committee does not substitute for notifying an appropriate person in the firm. - Disclosure also does not permit the senior to continue audit work while seeking employment with the client. Remain on the engagement until the client extends a formal employment offer - The requirement applies when the senior begins seeking employment, which has already occurred by submitting the application. - Waiting for a formal offer would leave the senior participating in the audit while the employment-related independence threat exists.

      Flashcards: Types and objectives of audit engagements

      1. 1. What inquiries and considerations should an auditor address before accepting an engagement?

        Show answer

        With the prospective client’s permission, inquire of the predecessor auditor about the reason for the change, disagreements, significant communications with management or those charged with governance, and matters affecting management’s integrity. Also assess independence, competence and resources, and whether sufficient appropriate evidence can be obtained. A refusal to permit communication with the predecessor auditor should be considered in the acceptance decision; it does not automatically require rejection.

      2. 2. What should an auditor consider before accepting an audit engagement?

        Show answer

        The auditor should evaluate whether the preconditions for an audit exist, comply with independence and other ethical requirements, assess the prospective client’s integrity and the auditor’s ability to perform the engagement, and obtain management’s agreement to its responsibilities. The auditor should also, with the prospective client’s permission, communicate with the predecessor auditor; a refusal to permit that communication generally supports declining the engagement.

      3. 3. What level of assurance does a compilation engagement offer?

        Show answer

        A compilation engagement provides no assurance.

      4. 4. Why is professional skepticism essential for auditors?

        Show answer

        Professional skepticism—a questioning mind and critical assessment of audit evidence—helps auditors remain alert to possible misstatements, including those caused by fraud, and avoid accepting insufficient or less persuasive evidence.

      5. 5. What are attestation services?

        Show answer

        Attestation services are engagements in which a practitioner reports on subject matter, or an assertion about subject matter, that is the responsibility of another party. The practitioner performs the engagement under applicable professional standards and must be independent. Depending on the engagement, the report may provide an examination opinion, a review conclusion, or agreed-upon-procedures findings.

      6. 6. Which professional standards govern the preparation of compilation reports for non-public companies?

        Show answer

        SSARS (Statements on Standards for Accounting and Review Services) governs these reports.

      7. 7. What does due professional care require of an auditor?

        Show answer

        Due professional care requires the auditor to exercise professional judgment and professional skepticism, comply with applicable professional standards, and plan and perform the audit diligently to obtain reasonable assurance that the financial statements are free of material misstatement.

      8. 8. Which professional standards govern the preparation of financial statements for non-public entities?

        Show answer

        SSARS (Statements on Standards for Accounting and Review Services) govern this process for non-public entity reporting.

      Everything you need for CPA prep

      Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

      GET STARTED FOR FREE
      75% OFFLimited time offer
      GET 75% OFF