A material weakness without misstatement
The controller prepares and posts all manual journal entries without an independent review before close.
Financial statement materiality is $100,000, and an unsupported $180,000 revenue entry is reasonably possible.
No other control would catch it before the statements are issued.
The common answer is that this is only a significant deficiency because no actual misstatement has been found.
That answer is wrong because a material weakness can exist when a material misstatement could escape timely prevention, detection, or correction.
The wrong answer focuses on whether an error was found instead of whether the control system could fail. The rule tests that possibility first, then determines the required communication.
Deficiency, material weakness, significant deficiency
The first three criteria classify the control problem. Identifying and classifying control deficiencies The communication differs from the planning matters in Communicating planned scope and timing.
- A control deficiency exists when the design or operation of a control does not allow management or employees, in the normal course of performing their assigned functions, to prevent, or detect and correct, misstatements on a timely basis.
- A material weakness is a deficiency, or combination of deficiencies, in internal control over financial reporting, such that there is a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement of the entity's financial statements will not be prevented, or detected and corrected, on a timely basis.
- A significant deficiency is a deficiency, or combination of deficiencies, in internal control over financial reporting that is less severe than a material weakness, yet important enough to merit attention by those charged with governance.
- Apply the criteria as a sequence: first identify a control deficiency; then test the material-weakness condition; only if that condition is not met, test for a significant deficiency. A material weakness may result from one deficiency or a combination of deficiencies.
- Communicate significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in writing to those charged with governance on a timely basis.
- Also communicate those significant deficiencies and material weaknesses in writing to management on a timely basis, unless it would be inappropriate to communicate directly to management in the circumstances. Other deficiencies should be communicated in writing to management when they are of sufficient importance to merit management's attention.
- The written communication should describe the deficiencies and explain their potential effects. It should also explain that the audit was performed to express an opinion on the financial statements, not on the effectiveness of internal control, and that the matters reported are limited to deficiencies identified during the audit that merit attention.
A reasonable possibility means the likelihood of occurrence is reasonably possible or probable. The $100,000 amount in the case is the entity's materiality benchmark, not a fixed AU-C 265 threshold.
The first two chapters lead into this test. Planning communication is not the same as reporting a control deficiency. The order is deficiency, material weakness, significant deficiency, then the correct written recipients and timing.
The material weakness decision sequence
The flowchart turns the numbered rule into an order of decisions. A yes answer to the reasonable-possibility question ends the classification as a material weakness. A no answer moves to the significant-deficiency test. Communication follows the classification rather than replacing it.
Loading diagram…
The next case applies the same branches to a different control problem with no actual misstatement found.
Unsupported revenue entry is a material weakness
The table matches each fact to the criterion it affects. The final row gives the classification and the resulting communication.
| Fact | Criterion it touches | Met or not met |
|---|---|---|
| Financial statement materiality for the case is $100,000. | Whether the possible error could be material | Met because the possible $180,000 error exceeds the benchmark. |
| The controller prepares and posts all manual journal entries. | Control design and operation | Not met because the process lacks effective review. |
| No one independently reviews the entries before close. | Timely prevention, detection, or correction | Not met. |
| An unsupported $180,000 revenue entry is reasonably possible. | Reasonable possibility of a material misstatement | Met. |
| No other control would catch the entry before the statements are issued. | Timely prevention, detection, or correction | Not met. |
| Verdict: classify the deficiency as a material weakness. | Material-weakness classification | Met; written, timely communication is required. |
| Communicate to governance and management unless direct management communication is inappropriate. | Communication recipients and timing | Met; the wrong answer required an actual misstatement. |
The $180,000 amount exceeds the case's $100,000 materiality benchmark, but the possible amount alone does not decide the classification.
Fictitious vendor payment risk
The facts below test the same material-weakness branch. The verdict column remains open until the classification is reached.
| Fact | Criterion it touches | Met? | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| The accounts-payable clerk can create vendors and approve payments. | Control deficiency | Yes | |
| No independent person reviews vendor changes or payment support before payment. | Control design and operation | No | |
| Annual cash disbursements are $2,400,000 and materiality is $150,000. | Potential material misstatement | Yes; exposure could exceed materiality | |
| The CFO reviews total cash disbursements monthly but not payees, invoices, or vendor changes. | Compensating control and timely detection | No effective compensating control | |
| A $200,000 fictitious-vendor payment is reasonably possible, although none has been found. | Reasonable possibility of a material misstatement | Yes | |
| Verdict | Material-weakness classification and communication | ? |
The absence of a discovered payment does not end the analysis. The possible amount, ineffective compensating review, and reasonable-possibility finding support the material-weakness branch.
Practice
This is a material weakness that must be communicated in writing and on a timely basis to those charged with governance and management, unless direct management communication is inappropriate.
Material weakness and significant deficiency tests
These questions change one rule condition at a time. The explanations identify the exact condition that controls each answer.
Practice
A payroll clerk can change employee pay rates and approve payroll. No independent review is performed. The auditor assesses that a $180,000 payroll overstatement is reasonably possible, materiality is $100,000, and no other control would prevent, detect, or correct it before the statements are issued. Which classification is appropriate?
A material weakness is identified during an audit. It is not inappropriate to communicate directly with management. Which communication is required?
An account-reconciliation deficiency is not reasonably likely to allow a material misstatement to escape timely prevention, detection, or correction, but it is important enough to merit attention by those charged with governance. How should it be classified?
Effective review prevents material weakness
Was: The entity used $100,000 financial statement materiality; the controller prepared and posted all manual journal entries; no one independently reviewed them before close; an unsupported $180,000 revenue entry was reasonably possible; and no other control would catch it before issuance.
Now: An independent reviewer reviews every manual journal entry before close and would catch an unsupported entry; does the verdict change?
Answer: Yes. The reasonable-possibility condition for a material weakness is no longer met because the effective review would detect and correct the error on a timely basis. The material-weakness communication does not follow.
Only the review control changes. That single fact changes the timely-detection condition, so the amount alone does not determine the classification.
Deficiencies, classification and communication
The criteria and their order preserve the same logic used in the decision path and the cases.
🔑 RULE:
Control deficiency: The control design or operation does not allow prevention, or detection and correction, of misstatements on a timely basis.
Material weakness: A deficiency or combination creates a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement will not be prevented, or detected and corrected, on a timely basis.
Significant deficiency: The deficiency is less severe than a material weakness but important enough to merit attention by those charged with governance.
Communication: Material weaknesses and significant deficiencies are communicated in writing and on a timely basis to governance and management, unless direct management communication is inappropriate.
Combining rule: Identify the deficiency, test material weakness first, test significant deficiency only if material weakness fails, then apply communication.
The criterion people skip: Reasonable possibility. An actual material misstatement does not have to be found for a material weakness to exist.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

