US services, interest and withholding
Northstar Ltd., a German corporation with a US branch, receives $220,000 for services performed entirely by the branch and $40,000 of interest on a note from a US corporation. A first calculation says all $260,000 is subject to 30% withholding, or $78,000. That is wrong because the service receipt is US-source ECI taxed at 21% on $100,000 of net income, while only the $40,000 passive interest is subject to 30% gross withholding.
The corporation's country does not decide the source of every receipt. The schedule separates place of performance, ECI status, net tax, and gross withholding before the figures are calculated. Sourcing income of US corporations abroad uses the same location rules with the corporation's residence reversed.
Source, ECI and withholding order
Use this order for every foreign corporation with US operations. Source each item first, then decide whether the US-source item is effectively connected with a US trade or business. ECI is calculated on a net basis, while non-ECI FDAP is subject to gross withholding.
Deductions cannot change where income was earned. ECI deductions reduce the §882 tax base, but they do not reduce the gross FDAP amount used for withholding.
| Line | How it is found | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Receipt | List each gross receipt and its type | Different types use different source rules |
| Source of services | Determine where the services were performed | Services are sourced by place of performance |
| Source of interest | Determine the residence of the payer | Interest is sourced by the obligor's residence |
| Source of dividends | Determine the residence of the payer corporation | Dividends are sourced by payer residence |
| Source of rents and royalties | Determine the location or use of the property | Property income follows the property |
| Source of purchased inventory | Determine where the inventory was sold | Sales income follows the sale location |
| Mixed services | Allocate the fee between US and foreign work | Only the US-performed part is US-source |
| ECI gross income | Include US-source income effectively connected with the US trade or business | ECI is the net-tax bucket |
| ECI deductions | Subtract deductions allowable and allocable to ECI | The §882 tax uses net taxable income |
| ECI taxable income | Subtract ECI deductions from ECI gross income | This is the corporate tax base |
| §882 tax | Multiply ECI taxable income by the applicable corporate rate | A foreign corporation pays net tax on ECI |
| Non-ECI FDAP | Identify US-source interest, dividends, rents, or royalties that are not ECI | These amounts use gross withholding |
| Federal withholding | Multiply non-ECI FDAP by 30%, unless an exception applies | The payer collects tax on the gross payment |
| Check | Reconcile total US-source gross income to ECI gross income plus non-ECI FDAP | The classification and arithmetic must tie |
🔑 RULE: Under IRC §§1441(a) and 1442(a), US-source FDAP paid to a foreign corporation is generally subject to 30% withholding when it is not effectively connected with a US trade or business. Under IRC §1441(c)(1), ECI is not subject to that withholding when properly documented with Form W-8ECI; the ECI is instead taxed on net taxable income under IRC §882 at the corporate rate, 21% under IRC §11(b).
The schedule keeps source, ECI, net tax, and gross withholding as separate lines.
US services, passive interest and tax
Use the service location and the note payer's residence to source each receipt. Northstar carries on a US trade or business through its branch. The service receipt is active US-source business income and is ECI under IRC §864(c)(3). The note interest is US-source under IRC §861(a)(1), but it is passive and unrelated to the branch, so it is non-ECI FDAP.
The $120,000 expense is tied only to the service activity. The valid Form W-8ECI means the service payer does not withhold under chapter three. The note payer withholds 30% from the interest.
| Line | How it is found | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Service receipt | $220,000; all services were performed in the US | $220,000 |
| Interest receipt | $40,000; the note was issued by a US corporation | $40,000 |
| ECI gross income | Include the US service receipt | $220,000 |
| ECI deductions | Deduct expenses allocable to the service activity | $120,000 |
| ECI taxable income | $220,000 − $120,000 | $100,000 |
| §882 corporate tax | $100,000 × 21% | $21,000 |
| Non-ECI FDAP | Include the passive US-source interest | $40,000 |
| Withholding on service receipt | Form W-8ECI supports a 0% withholding rate | $0 |
| Withholding on interest | $40,000 × 30% | $12,000 |
| Total federal withholding | $0 + $12,000 | $12,000 |
| Check | US-source gross income: $220,000 + $40,000 = $260,000. ECI gross plus non-ECI FDAP: $220,000 + $40,000 = $260,000. | Ties |
The $21,000 §882 tax is separate from the $12,000 federal withholding.
A higher service fee changes ECI tax
Keep every worked-example fact except the service fee. Northstar still performs the services entirely in the US. It still has $120,000 of allocable service expenses. It still receives $40,000 of passive US-source interest. It still provides Form W-8ECI and claims no treaty benefit. The service fee is now $250,000.
The higher service fee changes ECI gross income, ECI taxable income, and the §882 tax. It does not change the source classification or the $12,000 withholding on the separate interest receipt.
| Line | How it is found | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Service receipt | Performed entirely in the US | $250,000 |
| Interest receipt | Paid by a US corporation and passive | $40,000 |
| ECI gross income | US service receipt | $250,000 |
| ECI deductions | Allocable service expenses | $120,000 |
| ECI taxable income | $250,000 − $120,000 | ? |
| §882 corporate tax | ECI taxable income × 21% | ? |
| Withholding on service receipt | Valid Form W-8ECI | ? |
| Withholding on interest | $40,000 × 30% | ? |
| Total federal withholding | Add the two withholding lines | ? |
Practice
The ECI taxable income is ____
The §882 corporate tax is ____
The withholding on the service receipt is ____
The total federal withholding is ____
Source, ECI, tax and withholding
These questions turn on the source line, the ECI classification line, the net ECI tax line, and the gross FDAP withholding line.
The first question combines the complete schedule. The others isolate mixed services, expenses that cannot reduce FDAP withholding, and passive rent from US property.
Practice
Northstar receives $220,000 for services performed in the US and $40,000 of passive interest from a US corporation. It has $120,000 of allocable service expenses and provides Form W-8ECI. With no treaty benefit, which pair correctly states the federal withholding and the §882 corporate tax?
A foreign corporation charges $120,000 for services. Employees work 7 of 12 workdays in the US and 5 of 12 workdays in Spain. If workdays fairly reflect the service, how much is US-source service income?
A foreign corporation receives $40,000 of non-ECI interest from a US payer and has $15,000 of related expenses. With no treaty benefit, what federal withholding applies to the interest?
A foreign corporation receives $90,000 of passive rent from a US warehouse. It has no US rental activity, makes no net-basis election, claims no treaty benefit, and has no stated expenses. What federal withholding applies?
Services performed abroad remove ECI
💎 CHECK:
Was: Northstar is a German foreign corporation with a US branch. It receives $220,000 for services performed entirely in the US, $40,000 of passive interest from a US corporation, and has $120,000 of allocable service expenses. It provides Form W-8ECI and claims no treaty benefit.
Now: The $220,000 service is performed entirely in Germany by German employees; all other facts remain unchanged. Which schedule lines move, and which way?
Answer: The service receipt changes from $220,000 of US-source ECI to $0 of US-source ECI. ECI taxable income and §882 tax move from $100,000 and $21,000 to $0 and $0. The $40,000 interest remains US-source non-ECI FDAP, so the $12,000 withholding and total withholding do not move.
Changing the place of performance changes the source and ECI lines. Changing nothing about the payer or nature of the interest leaves its withholding unchanged. Foreign structures and presence tests explains when a structure or permanent establishment exists, while this case changes only where the services occur.
Separating source, ECI, tax and withholding
- Identify each receipt and its type.
- Determine the source using the location, payer, property, or sale rule for that type.
- Separate US-source income that is ECI from US-source FDAP that is not ECI.
- Subtract only deductions allowable and allocable to ECI.
- Compute ECI taxable income and apply the 21% corporate rate.
- Compute withholding only on non-ECI US-source FDAP.
- Apply the 30% withholding rate to the gross FDAP amount.
- Check that total US-source gross income equals ECI gross income plus non-ECI FDAP.
- Confirm that ECI tax was not confused with federal withholding.
Keeping source, ECI, deductions, tax, and withholding in this order prevents a deduction from changing source or reducing gross FDAP withholding. The final tie-out confirms both the classification and the arithmetic.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

