Secured collateral and unsecured deficiency
A bank has an allowed $100,000 claim secured by equipment that sells for $80,000.
The estate also has $50,000 of unencumbered cash.
Allowed wages of $10,000 earned within 180 days, allowed taxes of $10,000, and an allowed timely trade claim of $20,000 remain; assume no other claims or costs.
Most people pay the bank $100,000 before distributing anything else.
That is wrong because §506 makes only $80,000 secured and puts the $20,000 deficiency in the unsecured pool.
The wrong answer treats the secured debt as one indivisible amount. The rule first separates collateral value from the unsecured deficiency, then sends the deficiency through the bankruptcy distribution order.
Secured claims, priority and filing order
The numbered criteria below classify each claim and place it in the correct payment tier. The criteria operate in sequence.
- Allowed claims and estate property. Use allowed claims under 11 U.S.C. §502 and proof of claim rules under §501.
- Secured amount. Section 506(a)(1) states, “An allowed claim of a creditor secured by a lien on property in which the estate has an interest ... is a secured claim to the extent of the value of such creditor's interest in the estate's interest in such property ... and is an unsecured claim to the extent that the value ... is less than the amount of such allowed claim.”
- Pay the secured portion from collateral value.
- Treat any deficiency as unsecured.
- Priority claims. Section 507(a) states, “The following expenses and claims have priority in the following order.”
- Domestic support obligations come under §507(a)(1).
- Administrative expenses come under §507(a)(2).
- Certain involuntary-case claims come under §507(a)(3).
- Employee wages come under §507(a)(4).
- Employee benefit contributions come under §507(a)(5).
- Grain farmer and fisherman claims come under §507(a)(6).
- Consumer deposits come under §507(a)(7).
- Certain taxes come under §507(a)(8).
- Certain capital-maintenance commitments come under §507(a)(9).
- Death or personal injury claims from intoxicated vehicle or vessel operation come under §507(a)(10).
- Under §507(a)(4), wages include vacation, severance, and sick leave pay earned within 180 days before filing or cessation of business, whichever occurs first.
- The current wage cap is $17,150 per person for cases filed on or after April 1, 2025.
- Chapter 7 order. Section 726(a) pays §507 claims first, then timely filed unsecured claims that are not priority claims, then tardily filed unsecured claims, then certain fines and penalties, then postpetition interest, and finally the debtor.
- The timely tier uses the statutory phrase “proof of which is timely filed under section 501(a).”
- The statute provides that “property of the estate shall be distributed.”
- Sharing. Section 726(b) requires payment “pro rata among claims of such kind” when funds cannot pay a tier in full.
This is a sequence, not an any-one test. Pay secured collateral value, then priority tiers in order, then timely unsecured claims, and move lower only as funds permit.
Rights of debtors, creditors and guarantors supplies the secured-versus-unsecured distinction. Perfecting a security interest supplies lien status. This chapter applies the payout order.
Tracing each dollar through distribution tiers
The flowchart turns the numbered rule into a fixed path. Each dollar can be traced from collateral or estate cash to a claimant.
Loading diagram…
Collateral value, priority and pro rata sharing
The table applies each fact to its criterion in order. The final row combines collateral treatment, priority, timely filing, and pro rata sharing.
| Fact | Criterion it touches | Met or not met |
|---|---|---|
| Equipment sells for $80,000 and secures the bank's allowed $100,000 claim. | §506(a)(1) secured only to collateral value. | Met: bank receives $80,000 secured; $20,000 deficiency becomes unsecured. |
| Estate has $50,000 unencumbered cash. | Estate property available after secured collateral treatment. | Met: $50,000 enters the distribution pool. |
| Employee wages are $10,000 and were earned within 180 days. | §507(a)(4) wage priority; amount is below the $17,150 cap. | Met: pay $10,000. |
| Taxes are $10,000 and are an allowed §507(a)(8) priority claim. | §507(a) priority order. | Met: pay $10,000. |
| Trade claim is an allowed timely $20,000 unsecured claim. | §726(a)(2) timely unsecured tier. | Met: it shares with the $20,000 bank deficiency. |
| Final distribution. | §726(a)(1), §726(a)(2), and §726(b). | Verdict: Pay $80,000 to the bank from equipment; pay $10,000 wages and $10,000 taxes; $30,000 remains for a $40,000 unsecured pool, so the bank receives $15,000 of its deficiency and trade receives $15,000. The bank receives $95,000 total. The wrong answer came from ignoring §506's collateral-value limit. |
The priority claims consume $20,000 of the $50,000 cash, leaving $30,000 for the same timely unsecured tier.
Surplus collateral removes the bank deficiency
The table gives the new facts and leaves each verdict open. Apply §506 first, then the priority and unsecured tiers.
| Fact | Criterion it touches | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| An allowed $100,000 bank claim is secured by equipment that sells for $120,000. | §506(a)(1) secured amount and excess collateral value. | ? |
| The estate also has $50,000 cash. | Estate property after secured payment. | ? |
| Allowed wages are $10,000, allowed taxes are $10,000, and the allowed timely trade claim is $20,000. | §507(a)(4), §507(a)(8), and §726(a)(2). | ? |
| Assume no other claims or costs. | Complete distribution sequence. | ? |
Practice
Which distribution is correct?
The changed collateral value removes the bank deficiency and creates $20,000 of surplus value for the estate.
Filing timing, wage caps and sharing
These cases test filing timing, the wage cap, secured deficiencies, and pro rata sharing. Each answer follows the same sequence.
Practice
After secured claims are paid, $30,000 remains. An allowed $10,000 wage claim is priority. An allowed timely general unsecured claim is $40,000, and an allowed tardily filed general unsecured claim is $20,000. Assuming no other claims, how much does each claimant receive?
An allowed employee wage claim of $20,000 was earned within 180 days before filing. The current §507(a)(4) cap is $17,150. The estate has $20,000 available and an allowed general unsecured claim of $10,000. How much is paid to the wage claimant and the general creditor?
A bank has an allowed $50,000 claim secured by equipment sold for $30,000. The estate has $40,000 cash, an allowed $10,000 priority claim, and an allowed timely $20,000 trade claim. What total distribution is correct?
The first item changes filing timing, the second changes the wage amount against a statutory cap, and the third combines an undersecured claim with pro rata sharing.
Late filing moves trade claim behind
Was: Equipment worth $80,000 secures an allowed $100,000 bank claim; the estate has $50,000 cash; allowed §507(a)(4) wages are $10,000, allowed §507(a)(8) taxes are $10,000, and the bank deficiency and $20,000 trade claim are timely.
Now: The trade creditor files its $20,000 claim after the applicable deadline; does the distribution change?
Answer: Yes. Under §726(a)(3), the trade claim moves from the timely unsecured tier to the tardily filed unsecured tier, so the bank's timely $20,000 deficiency receives the $30,000 left after priority and trade receives nothing.
The asset values and priority claims did not move, so the $30,000 after priority did not move. Only the filing-timing criterion changed, placing the trade claim behind the timely bank deficiency.
The bankruptcy distribution order
Secured amount: Pay an allowed secured claim only to the extent of collateral value; any deficiency is unsecured.
Priority class: Pay an allowed unsecured claim only if it fits a §507(a) category, using the statutory order.
Filing timing: Timely unsecured claims come before tardily filed unsecured claims under §726(a).
Same tier: Share pro rata under §726(b) when available funds are insufficient.
Surplus: Pay later §726 tiers and then the debtor only after earlier tiers are satisfied.
Combining rule: Move through secured collateral, §507 priority, timely unsecured, tardy unsecured, later statutory tiers, and the debtor in sequence. If funds stop, payment stops at that tier.
The criterion people skip is timely proof of claim under §501(a), because an otherwise valid unsecured claim can fall behind every timely unsecured claim.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

