Substantial performance leaves cure costs
Dana agrees in writing on May 1 to replace Lee’s roof for $12,000 by June 30.
Dana installs 98% of the roof, completes flashing and cleanup, and leaves $500 of trim unfinished.
The contract has no express condition, and another roofer would charge $500 to finish the trim.
The common answer is that Lee owes nothing because Dana did not finish every item.
That answer is wrong because Dana substantially performed, so Lee generally owes $11,500 after the reasonable $500 cure cost.
The first issue is not whether every detail is perfect. It is which duty remains and whether the failure is material. Elements of a valid contract covers how the duties arose. Breach and available remedies covers a material failure and its remedies.
Performance, agreement and operation of law
A condition controls when a duty is due. Performance controls whether a due duty has been rendered. Identify the duties first, then classify the claimed discharge route.
- Identify duties and conditions. List every exchanged promise, the time for performance, and any condition precedent. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 224 defines a condition as an event, not certain to occur, that must occur before performance becomes due. An express condition must occur as written unless excused.
- Test performance. Restatement § 235(1) states, “Full performance of a duty under a contract discharges the duty.” Under § 237, each party’s remaining duty is conditioned on no uncured material failure by the other party. Under the substantial-performance rule, a minor failure normally leaves the performer entitled to the contract price less damages. A material failure can suspend the other party’s remaining duty. Use § 241 factors: loss of the expected benefit, adequacy of compensation, forfeiture, likelihood of cure, and good-faith conduct. There is no fixed percentage test.
- Test agreement. Mutual rescission discharges remaining duties by agreement. A release is a contract in which a party relinquishes a right. A novation is a substituted contract that includes a new party and discharges the original duty. The original parties, the new party, and the required release must agree. Under § 281, an accord is an agreement to accept stated performance in satisfaction of an existing duty. Satisfaction is the performance of that accord. An executory accord does not discharge the original duty until satisfaction unless the parties intended a substituted contract.
- Test operation of law. Under § 261, a duty is discharged when performance becomes impracticable without the party’s fault because an event whose nonoccurrence was a basic assumption occurs. This applies unless the contract or circumstances indicate otherwise. Sections 262-264 cover death or incapacity of a necessary person, destruction of a necessary thing, and supervening government regulation. Under § 265, a principal purpose must be substantially frustrated by an event whose nonoccurrence was a basic assumption. Bankruptcy may discharge qualifying debts under 11 U.S.C. § 524, but exceptions apply under § 523. A limitation period may bar enforcement, subject to the governing jurisdiction.
- Apply the goods variant. For a sale of goods, UCC § 2-601 generally permits the buyer to reject if the goods or tender fail in any respect to conform. UCC § 2-508 and other UCC limits may allow cure. This rule belongs with Contract types and sales of goods.
Use this sequence: identify each promise, due date, and condition; classify the claimed discharge route; then apply every condition for that route. One satisfied route is enough to discharge the relevant duty, but all conditions within that route must be met.
An executed contract has completed performance. A contract with remaining duties is executory. An incomplete performance should not be mislabeled as rescission, novation, or impossibility.
Promises, conditions and performance record
The document supplies the promises, timing, conditions, and performance record. It shows why the missing condition matters.
| Margin label | Contract document |
|---|---|
| Title | ROOF AGREEMENT |
| Parties | Dana Roofing and Lee |
| Date | May 1 |
| Work | Replace the roof, install flashing and trim, and clean the site |
| Price | $12,000 |
| Due date | June 30 |
| Payment | Due when the work is completed |
| Special condition | None stated |
| Performance obligation | Dana’s work |
| Exchanged obligation | Lee’s payment |
| Performance record | 98% complete; flashing and cleanup complete; $500 of trim unfinished |
| Reasonable cure cost | $500 |
| Condition note | No express condition requires perfect completion |
The document leads to substantial-performance analysis rather than a perfect-completion condition.
Full, substantial or blocked performance
The document identifies the duties. The table tests whether each duty was fully performed, substantially performed, or blocked by a condition.
| Fact | Criterion it touches | Met or not met |
|---|---|---|
| The written agreement requires Dana to replace the roof and requires Lee to pay $12,000. | Identify the exchanged performance obligations. | Met: both duties are clear. |
| Dana’s work is due by June 30. | Performance is due; no timing condition prevents the analysis. | Met. |
| Dana completed the flashing and cleanup. | Performance of stated duties. | Met for those duties. |
| Dana installed 98% of the roof but left $500 of trim unfinished. | Full performance under § 235(1). | Not met: performance is not complete. |
| The unfinished trim is a minor part of the job, and another roofer can cure it for $500. | Substantial performance and § 241 material-failure factors. | Met: the failure is compensable and not shown to be material. |
| The contract contains no express condition requiring perfect completion before payment. | Condition precedent under § 224. | Met: no unfulfilled express condition blocks payment. |
| Lee refuses to pay anything. | Effect of substantial performance under § 237. | Verdict: Dana substantially performed; Lee owes $12,000 less $500, or $11,500. |
The wrong answer applies the full-performance rule and skips the materiality analysis in § 241. A material failure would move the issue toward Breach and available remedies.
Accord and satisfaction replace performance
The roof case used substantial performance. This case uses an agreement route and asks whether the agreed substitute performance has occurred.
| Fact | Criterion it touches | Verdict |
|---|---|---|
| Lena agrees in writing on April 1 to build Kai a 10-page website for $15,000 by June 1. | Original performance obligations. | ? |
| Before June 1, Lena and Kai sign an agreement accepting an 8-page website and $12,000 as full settlement. | Accord: agreement to accept different performance. | ? |
| Lena delivers the 8-page website on June 1. | Satisfaction: performance of the accord. | ? |
| Kai pays $12,000 and accepts the website. | Completion of the agreed substitute performance. | ? |
Practice
Is the original website contract discharged?
Legal conditions change the discharge result
Each case changes one legal condition. The rationales identify the criterion that controls the result.
Practice
A builder completes almost all work on a renovation. The remaining defect does not defeat the renovation’s main purpose, and the reasonable cost to cure it is $500. Which result is correct?
A debtor owes a creditor $20,000. The creditor agrees in writing to accept a car worth $15,000 in full satisfaction, and the debtor delivers the car. When is the original duty discharged?
A company owes Ari a debt. Ari, the company, and Bo sign an agreement under which Bo becomes the new obligor, Ari releases the company, and Bo accepts the debt. Which discharge route applies?
A seller promises to deliver a unique machine. Before delivery, a fire destroys the machine without the seller’s fault, and no substitute machine exists. Which result is correct?
Express condition controls payment
Was: Dana agreed May 1 to replace Lee’s roof for $12,000 by June 30, completed 98% including flashing and cleanup, left $500 of trim, had no express condition, and Lee refused payment despite a $500 cure cost.
Now: The signed contract says payment is due only after every roof item, including trim, is complete, and the $500 trim remains unfinished.
Answer: Yes. The express condition precedent to payment is unsatisfied. Substantial performance does not make payment presently due.
The performance facts did not move. The condition precedent changed, and that criterion must be tested before substantial performance establishes when Lee’s payment duty is due.
Discharge requires a satisfied legal route
Duties: list each promise, due date, and condition.
Performance: full performance discharges the duty; substantial performance usually leaves a cure-cost adjustment; material failure can suspend the other party’s remaining duty.
Agreement: mutual rescission, a valid release, novation, or an accord followed by satisfaction can discharge duties.
Operation of law: impossibility, impracticability, frustration, death or incapacity, destruction of a necessary thing, illegality, bankruptcy discharge, or a limitation bar may apply when the stated conditions are met.
Combining rule: classify the claimed route, apply every condition within it, and treat one satisfied route as enough for the relevant duty.
The criterion people skip is the express condition precedent.
Formation questions belong to Elements of a valid contract. Goods questions belong to Contract types and sales of goods. A material failure may lead to Breach and available remedies.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

