Ranking investments with payback, IRR and EVA

Ranking investments with payback, IRR and EVA

Published September 28, 2026

Ranking investments with payback, IRR and EVA

On this page

Four measures answer different questions

These methods answer different management questions. Discounting is developed in Discounted cash flow and net present value, while this chapter uses NPV with three other ranking lenses. NOPAT means net operating profit after tax. WACC means weighted-average cost of capital. The required return is the return needed for the project's risk.

AttributePayback periodNet present value (NPV)Internal rate of return (IRR)Economic value added (EVA)
Decision questionHow long until the original outlay is recovered?How many dollars of value remain after discounting future cash flows at the required return?What discount rate makes the project's NPV equal to zero?Did operating profit exceed the dollar charge for capital used during the period?
Core calculationYears before full recovery plus the unrecovered amount divided by the next period's cash flowNPV equals discounted future cash flows less the initial outlayThe rate r that makes the present value of inflows equal the present value of outflowsEVA equals NOPAT less capital employed multiplied by WACC
Time value of moneyNo for simple payback; discounted payback is a separate variantYes; every future cash flow is discounted at the required returnYes; the rate itself is the break-even discount rateThe capital charge uses WACC, but EVA is an accounting-period measure
Decision rulePrefer a shorter payback than management's stated cutoff; the cutoff is not universalAccept positive NPV, reject negative NPV, and treat zero as indifferentAccept when IRR exceeds the required return, reject when below, and treat equality as indifferentPositive EVA means value was created for the period; negative EVA means the capital charge exceeded operating profit
Ranking strengthHighlights early recovery and liquidityMeasures dollar value and handles timing and project scaleGives a percentage return for comparison with a hurdle rateShows annual residual operating performance after capital cost
Main limitationIgnores the time value of money and cash flows after payback; no universal cutoff existsDepends on the required return and cash-flow estimatesCan mis-rank projects because of scale or timing; multiple sign changes can produce multiple or no IRRsUses accounting profit and capital balances, so it is not automatically a project cash-flow ranking
Clue wordsrecover the investment, years to get money back, cutoff, liquidity, break-even timepresent value, dollars added, required return, value created today, discounted cash flowspercentage return, hurdle rate, discount rate that sets NPV to zero, yieldresidual income, capital charge, NOPAT, invested capital, value added after cost of capital
Relationship to the sibling chapterThe sibling chapter's discounting work is not used in simple paybackDiscounted cash flow and net present value develops present-value logic; this chapter uses NPV as one ranking lensUses the same discounted-cash-flow logic as NPV but solves for the rate instead of using a stated rateProvides a separate residual-income view of performance rather than replacing NPV

The key difference is the requested output: time, discounted dollars, a break-even rate, or residual operating dollars.

Time, value, rate and operating profit

The deciding axis is the management question being answered. The four outputs are:

  • Payback measures time until the cash outlay is recovered.
  • NPV measures dollar value after discounting at a required return.
  • IRR measures the percentage rate that makes NPV exactly zero.
  • EVA measures annual operating dollars left after the capital charge.

Payback asks only when cash is recovered. It does not discount simple payback cash flows.

NPV asks how much value the project adds after discounting. For mutually exclusive projects, the highest positive NPV is the value-maximizing ranking when risk and assumptions are comparable.

IRR asks which rate makes the project's value exactly zero. EVA asks whether the period's operating profit covered its capital charge.

A project may have the shortest payback or highest IRR but a lower NPV. Project size or cash-flow timing can cause different rankings. For mutually exclusive projects, use NPV when the goal is total value creation.

Once the output type is clear, clue words usually identify the method without a long calculation. The questions use each output type, including the capital-charge and break-even-rate variants.

Identifying the requested investment measure

Each scenario keeps the investment decision family constant but changes the requested output. The answer choices stay in the same order.

Practice

A company pays $100,000 today and expects $50,000 at the end of each of the first three years. The manager wants the number of years until cumulative undiscounted receipts recover the outlay. Which method supplies that measure?

Project Cedar requires $100,000 today and produces $50,000 at the end of each of the first three years. At a required return of 10%, the decision maker wants the dollar amount by which the present value of the inflows is above or below the outlay. Which method supplies that measure?

Project Lake requires $100,000 now and returns $110,000 at the end of year one. The manager wants the percentage discount rate that makes the present value of the return equal to the outlay. Which method supplies that measure?

Project Cedar reports NOPAT of $18,000, uses $100,000 of capital, and has a WACC of 12%. Management wants operating profit after charging the project for the capital it used during the period. Which method supplies that measure?

Each item changes the requested output, not the underlying investment facts. An accounting capital charge is not the same as a project discount rate.

The requested measure can change

The project facts remain fixed. Only the requested decision measure changes.

💎 CHECK:

Was: Project Pine costs $120,000 and pays $40,000 at the end of each of three years. The manager asks for the time until cumulative cash receipts recover the cost.

Now: Keep all project facts unchanged, but apply a 10% required return and ask whether the discounted inflows exceed the outlay in dollars.

Which one now?

Answer: NPV. What changed hands: the requested output changed from recovery time to discounted dollar value.

The cash flows did not move. The requested question moved from payback to NPV.

Payback, NPV, IRR and EVA definitions

Payback period asks how fast the initial outlay is recovered.

NPV asks how many dollars of value remain after discounting at the required return.

IRR asks what percentage return makes NPV zero.

EVA asks whether NOPAT exceeded the capital charge for the period.

The deciding axis is whether the scenario asks for time, discounted dollars, a break-even percentage, or residual operating dollars.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Ranking investments with payback, IRR and EVA

  1. 1. A newly licensed CPA is assisting the controller of Harbor Components with a customer-profitability review. Management uses activity-based costing for internal decisions and must determine whether to accept an incremental order from Alpha, evaluate claims made by the sales manager, and document a recommendation. All amounts are for the current annual period unless an exhibit states otherwise.

    • 2. A newly licensed CPA is assisting the controller of Cloud Harbor, Inc., a subscription software company, with the 2025 board reporting package and a 2026 pricing proposal. Management uses adjusted EBITDA, annual recurring revenue, and customer churn as internal performance measures. The CPA must apply the company's approved KPI policy consistently, reconcile the measures to supporting data, evaluate the proposed pricing change, and document a financially supportable conclusion.

      • 3. A company must raise $4,000,000. Under the debt plan, it would issue 8% debt and retain 1,000,000 common shares outstanding. Under the equity plan, it would issue 200,000 additional shares at $20 per share. The income tax rate is 25%. At what annual EBIT would earnings per share be equal under the two plans?

        • A. $2,240,000
        • B. $1,600,000
        • C. $2,400,000
        • D. $1,920,000
        Show answer

        Answer: D. $1,920,000

        $1,920,000 - The debt plan incurs $320,000 of annual interest ($4,000,000 × 8%) and has 1,000,000 shares, while the equity plan has 1,200,000 shares and no interest. - Equating EPS and canceling the common 75% after-tax factor gives \((EBIT-\$320,000)/1,000,000=EBIT/1,200,000\), so EBIT = $1,920,000. $2,240,000 - This results from adding the $320,000 interest to the correct $1,920,000 EBIT rather than solving the EPS equation. - The debt plan’s interest must be subtracted from EBIT when calculating its earnings per share. $1,600,000 - Dividing $320,000 of interest by the 20% increase in shares produces $1,600,000. - That calculation omits the 1.2 factor needed when comparing earnings across 1,000,000 versus 1,200,000 shares. $2,400,000 - Using 10% instead of 8% for the debt rate would produce $400,000 of interest and an indifference EBIT of $2,400,000. - The stated 8% rate produces $320,000 of interest, and the 25% tax factor cancels from both plans’ EPS.

      • 4. A company needs $4,000,000 of new financing. It may either issue preferred stock with an 8% dividend rate (nondeductible for tax purposes) or issue 200,000 additional common shares. The company currently has 1,000,000 common shares, no preferred stock outstanding, and a 25% income tax rate. At what annual EBIT would the two alternatives produce equal earnings per share available to common shareholders?

        • A. $320,000
        • B. $1,280,000
        • C. $1,600,000
        • D. $2,560,000
        Show answer

        Answer: D. $2,560,000

        $2,560,000 - The preferred stock requires an annual $320,000 dividend ($4,000,000 × 8%), paid after tax, while issuing common stock raises shares from 1,000,000 to 1,200,000. - Equating EPS gives \((0.75 × EBIT − \$320,000) ÷ 1,000,000 = (0.75 × EBIT) ÷ 1,200,000\), so \(0.15 × EBIT = \$384,000\) and EBIT is $2,560,000. $320,000 - This is the preferred dividend ($4,000,000 × 8%), not the EBIT at which the financing alternatives yield equal EPS. - Using the dividend itself as the answer skips the comparison between preferred dividends and the 200,000 additional common shares. $1,280,000 - This results from dividing the $320,000 preferred dividend by the 25% tax rate. - The dividend is nondeductible, so the tax rate applies to EBIT before the dividend is subtracted; it is not a divisor for finding the indifference point. $1,600,000 - This results from dividing the $320,000 dividend by the 20% increase in common shares (200,000 ÷ 1,000,000). - That shortcut omits the 25% tax on EBIT and does not equate the after-tax earnings per share under the two alternatives.

      • 5. A CPA on the financial planning and analysis team is reviewing the March 2026 production plan for Hartwell Components. Both products use the same machining department, and customer demand cannot be carried into a later month. The CPA must determine the financially preferable product mix, evaluate a temporary capacity expansion, and prepare a documented recommendation for the controller.

        • 6. A company budgeted sales of 10,000 units with a mix of 60% Product P and 40% Product Q. Budgeted contribution margins are $8 for P and $14 for Q. Actual total sales were 12,000 units, consisting of 6,000 units of each product. What is the sales mix variance?

          • A. $7,200 unfavorable
          • B. $7,200 favorable
          • C. $12,000 favorable
          • D. $16,800 favorable
          Show answer

          Answer: B. $7,200 favorable

          $7,200 favorable - At 12,000 actual units, the budgeted 60%–40% mix would be 7,200 P and 4,800 Q, rather than the 6,000 units of each actually sold. - Selling 1,200 fewer P and 1,200 more Q shifts those units to a product with a $6 higher contribution margin, producing 1,200 × $6 = $7,200 favorable. $7,200 unfavorable - The $7,200 magnitude is correct, but the direction is not: the actual mix includes more Q, which earns $14 per unit rather than P’s $8. - The P shortfall is $9,600 unfavorable, while the Q excess is $16,800 favorable, for a $7,200 favorable net variance. $12,000 favorable - This results from applying the $6 contribution-margin difference to the 2,000-unit increase from budgeted to actual total sales: 2,000 × $6 = $12,000. - Sales mix variance instead holds total sales at 12,000 units and measures the 1,200-unit shift from P to Q. $16,800 favorable - This is only Q’s component: its 6,000 actual units exceed the 4,800 units at the budgeted mix by 1,200, worth 1,200 × $14 = $16,800 favorable. - It omits P’s offsetting $9,600 unfavorable component, leaving $7,200 favorable overall.

        • 7. A CPA in the financial planning and analysis group of Harbor Components, Inc. is reviewing the quarter ended March 31, 2026. Management wants a static-to-flexible budget reconciliation and an assessment of compliance with a debt-to-adjusted-EBITDA covenant. The lender requires quarterly adjusted EBITDA to be annualized by multiplying it by four. Use the budget, actual results, and controlling lender definition in the exhibits; amounts classified within an expense line are already included in reported operating income.

          • 8. A subscription company reports that its customer-retention rate increased from 86% in 2024 to 91% in 2025. Beginning in 2025, management excludes customers whose accounts were inactive for more than 60 days from both the beginning-customer denominator and the lost-customer numerator. The 2024 measure was not recast. Which conclusion is most supportable?

            • A. The increase demonstrates improved customer loyalty because both measures are percentages.
            • B. The trend should not be relied upon until 2024 is recast or the effect of the definition change is quantified.
            • C. The 2025 rate should be compared with revenue growth instead of the prior-year retention rate.
            • D. The increase demonstrates improved performance because inactive customers do not generate current revenue.
            Show answer

            Answer: B. The trend should not be relied upon until 2024 is recast or the effect of the definition change is quantified.

            The trend should not be relied upon until 2024 is recast or the effect of the definition change is quantified. - The reported rise from 86% to 91% is not directly comparable because the 2025 calculation excludes accounts inactive for more than 60 days from both the beginning-customer denominator and the lost-customer numerator, while 2024 was not recast. - Recasting 2024 under the new definition or quantifying the change’s effect would help distinguish improved retention from a measurement change. The increase demonstrates improved customer loyalty because both measures are percentages. - Percentages are comparable only when their underlying populations and definitions are consistent; the 2025 exclusions changed both. - Without a recast or quantified effect, the five-percentage-point increase does not establish improved customer loyalty. The 2025 rate should be compared with revenue growth instead of the prior-year retention rate. - Revenue growth measures a different outcome and does not resolve the inconsistent customer-retention definitions. - The relevant comparison is retention across years, using the same definition or an adjustment that quantifies the difference. The increase demonstrates improved performance because inactive customers do not generate current revenue. - Whether inactive customers generate current revenue does not make the unrecast 2024 and revised 2025 retention rates comparable. - Excluding those accounts from both parts of the 2025 calculation could affect the reported rate, so the increase alone does not demonstrate improved performance.

          Flashcards: Ranking investments with payback, IRR and EVA

          1. 1. What valuation methods are commonly used in capital budgeting?

            Show answer

            Capital budgeting commonly uses discounted-cash-flow methods such as net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR). Payback is a nondiscounted screening method. Capital budgeting is not limited to present-value tables, and fair value is not its exclusive valuation method.

          2. 2. What is the future value of $1 invested for n periods at periodic rate r?

            Show answer

            FV = (1 + r)^n. More generally, FV = PV × (1 + r)^n.

          3. 3. What are the advantages of using the net present value method?

            Show answer

            NPV incorporates the time value of money and considers all relevant cash flows. Risk can be incorporated through a risk-adjusted discount rate or risk-adjusted cash flows; NPV does not account for risk automatically.

          4. 4. What is a disadvantage of the net present value method?

            Show answer

            The NPV method is more complex compared to the accounting rate of return.

          5. 5. What is the formula for the Present Value of $1?

            Show answer

            1 / (1 + i)^n, where i = interest rate and n = number of periods.

          6. 6. What is NPV used for when evaluating an investment?

            Show answer

            NPV assesses profitability using the time value of money: PV of future cash flows minus investment.

          7. 7. When is the Present Value of an Annuity Due table used?

            Show answer

            It is used for multiple payments made at the beginning of each period.

          8. 8. What does the discount rate represent in investment evaluation?

            Show answer

            It represents the minimum required rate of return on an investment.

          9. 9. What is the purpose of capital budgeting?

            Show answer

            Capital budgeting is a tool used to assess investment options, support managerial decision-making, and incorporate both accounting and non-accounting data. It is not governed by GAAP.

          10. 10. When is the Present Value of $1 table applicable?

            Show answer

            It is used for a single payment made once.

          Everything you need for CPA prep

          Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

          GET STARTED FOR FREE
          75% OFFLimited time offer
          GET 75% OFF