Capital structure and cost of capital

Capital structure and cost of capital

Capital structure and cost of capital

On this page

Debt, equity and required returns

Capital structure is the mix of debt and equity that a business uses to fund its assets and projects. Debt creates contractual interest and repayment obligations. Equity provides ownership capital and a residual claim on the business.

Management chooses the mix. Lenders, owners and analysts use it to judge financial risk and funding choices. Cost of capital is the return that debt and equity providers require for supplying money.

Weighted average cost of capital, or WACC, combines those required returns using each funding source's market value. It answers this question: what blended return must a comparable-risk project earn to cover current capital providers?

WACC helps management compare financing choices. It does not guarantee that any project will earn that return. Modigliani and Miller discussed a major capital-structure framework in 1958.

From funding weights to financing choice

The ladder begins with market-value debt and equity. Those values create the funding weights. Each source then receives its current required return, with debt adjusted for a usable tax benefit.

The weighted source costs become WACC. A proposed debt or equity change must then be compared using WACC, leverage, cash interest, covenants, liquidity and control. A low WACC is a candidate, not the final answer.

Loading diagram…

Market values, tax and WACC

Market values set the weights

Use current market values of debt and equity, not book balances, to measure the financing mix. Let V equal debt plus equity.

The base facts use debt of $400,000 and equity of $600,000. Total capital is $1,000,000. Debt is 40% of capital, and equity is 60%.

If debt market value changes to $500,000 while equity stays at $600,000, total capital becomes $1,100,000. The weights become 45.45% debt and 54.55% equity. The current debt-to-equity ratio is 0.667x.

The full market-value schedule is in Calculating the cost of capital.

Source costs and weighted contributions make WACC

The pre-tax debt cost is the current required borrowing rate. It is 6% in the base facts. The required return on equity is 10%.

Apply the supplied 25% tax rate to debt cost when the interest deduction creates a usable tax benefit. The after-tax debt cost is $6% \times (1 - 25%) = 4.50%$.

Do not tax-adjust the equity cost. The 25% rate is an example fact, not a claim about a statutory corporate rate.

IRC §163(j) generally limits deductible business interest to business interest income plus 30% of adjusted taxable income plus floor-plan-financing interest, subject to statutory exceptions. If interest is not fully deductible, use only the usable tax benefit.

WACC equals the debt weight multiplied by after-tax debt cost, plus the equity weight multiplied by equity cost. With the base facts, debt contributes $40% \times 4.50% = 1.80%$. Equity contributes $60% \times 10% = 6.00%$. WACC is 7.80%.

The result is the blended required return for a comparable-risk project. The full WACC schedule is in Calculating the cost of capital.

Structure changes create tradeoffs

A structure must be compared using more than WACC.

  • Plan A has $400,000 of debt and $600,000 of equity. Its WACC is 7.80%.
  • Plan B has $600,000 of debt and $400,000 of equity. Its debt weight is 60%, and its equity weight is 40%.
  • Plan B has an after-tax debt cost of 5.25%. Its debt contribution is 3.15%, and its equity contribution is 4.40%.
  • Plan B has a WACC of 7.55% and a debt-to-equity ratio of 1.50x.
  • Plan C has $800,000 of debt and $200,000 of equity. Its debt weight is 80%, and its equity weight is 20%.
  • Plan C has an after-tax debt cost of 6.75%. Its debt contribution is 5.40%, and its equity contribution is 2.80%.
  • Plan C has a WACC of 8.20% and interest coverage of 1.67x.

With $120,000 of EBIT and $42,000 of annual interest, Plan B has EBIT interest coverage of 2.86x. That is below the stated 3.00x covenant.

Plan B has 60% debt, while the stated debt-to-capital limit is 60.00%. Plan C breaches both the 60.00% debt-to-capital limit and the 3.00x coverage limit.

A structure with the lowest WACC is not automatically feasible.

Separate the source of each change.

  • Issuing $200,000 of debt to buy a new asset creates $600,000 of debt and $600,000 of equity.
  • Issuing $200,000 of shares for a new asset creates $400,000 of debt and $800,000 of equity.
  • Borrowing $200,000 to repurchase shares creates $600,000 of debt and $400,000 of equity.
  • After that repurchase, debt-to-capital is 60%, and debt-to-equity is 1.50x.
  • Issuing $200,000 of shares to repay debt creates $200,000 of debt and $800,000 of equity.
  • After that repayment, debt-to-capital is 20%, and debt-to-equity is 0.25x.

More debt generally increases fixed cash claims and leverage. It can preserve existing owners' control. More equity generally reduces mandatory interest and leverage. It can dilute existing owners.

The financing comparison is covered in Financing strategies and capital structure changes.

The financing schedule carries forward

The handoff from one idea to the next is a financing schedule. It includes the source, market value, total capital, weight, pre-tax cost, tax-adjusted cost and weighted contribution.

The schedule carries debt and equity values into the weights. It carries the tax rate into debt cost. It carries the contributions into WACC.

If total capital is wrong, both weights can be wrong. If the tax adjustment is wrong, the debt contribution and WACC are wrong. If the proposed debt or equity value is wrong, later leverage, interest, coverage and liquidity conclusions can also be wrong.

The schedule is the numerical handoff between calculation and decision. The same debt and equity values must be reused when testing the proposed structure.

Weights, source costs and structure comparison

The rows move from the funding mix to source costs, then to WACC and finally to feasibility. Each row receives the prior row's values and passes a result forward.

IdeaTriggerInputs receivedWorkOutput passed forward
Market-value weightsA current or proposed funding mix is givenMarket-value debt and equityAdd debt and equity, then divide each by total capitalWeights for each source cost
After-tax source costsDebt and equity required returns are givenPre-tax debt cost, equity cost and usable tax rateMultiply debt cost by one minus the tax rate; leave equity cost unadjustedSource costs for contribution lines
Weighted contributions and WACCSource costs and weights are readyEach source weight and adjusted costMultiply each pair and add the contributionsBlended required return
Structure comparisonDebt or equity is issued, repaid or repurchasedNew debt, equity, interest, EBIT and contract termsRecompute WACC, leverage, cash interest and coverageFeasible financing choice considering cost, covenant, liquidity and control

The proposed structure must pass both the cost calculation and the financial constraint review.

Borrowing or issuing shares

Pine Co. currently has market-value debt of $400,000 and equity of $600,000. Its pre-tax debt cost is 6%. Its equity cost is 10%. Its applicable tax rate is 25%.

Pine expects EBIT of $120,000. It needs $200,000 for a new asset.

If Pine borrows the amount, post-financing debt is $600,000 and equity is $600,000. Debt cost is 7%. Equity cost is 11%. Annual cash interest is $42,000.

If Pine issues shares instead, post-financing debt is $400,000 and equity is $800,000. Debt cost is 6%. Equity cost is 9%. Annual cash interest is $24,000.

The loan agreement sets a maximum debt-to-capital ratio of 60.00%. It also sets a minimum EBIT-to-cash-interest coverage ratio of 3.00x.

Required outputs:

  • Calculate current WACC.
  • Calculate WACC under both financing choices.
  • Calculate debt-to-capital and debt-to-equity under both choices.
  • Calculate annual cash interest and interest coverage.
  • Select the better choice under the stated cost, liquidity and covenant facts.

The schedule keeps each value, cost and test visible as the financing choice changes.

LineChapterDebtEquityTotal capitalDebt weightEquity weightPre-tax debt costEquity costAfter-tax debt costDebt contributionEquity contributionWACCDebt-to-capitalDebt-to-equityInterestCoverageDecision meaning
1Calculating the cost of capital$400,000$600,000$1,000,00040%60%N/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/A0.667xN/AN/AThe market-value mix supplies the weights.
2Calculating the cost of capital$400,000$600,000$1,000,00040%60%6%10%4.50%1.80%6.00%7.80%N/AN/AN/AN/AThe blended current required return is 7.80%.
3Calculating the cost of capital$600,000$600,000$1,200,00050%50%7%11%5.25%2.625%5.50%8.125%N/AN/AN/AN/ANew debt raises the blended cost under the supplied post-financing costs.
4Financing strategies and capital structure changes$600,000$600,000$1,200,00050%50%7%11%5.25%2.625%5.50%8.125%50%1.00x$42,0002.86xDebt is below the ratio limit but breaches the coverage covenant.
5Calculating the cost of capital; Financing strategies and capital structure changes$400,000$800,000$1,200,00033.33%66.67%6%9%4.50%1.50%6.00%7.50%33.33%0.50x$24,0005.00xEquity has lower WACC, interest and leverage, but dilutes control.
6Financing strategies and capital structure changesN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AN/AChoose equity under the stated priorities, while noting the control tradeoff.

The equity-funded option has the lower WACC, lower cash interest and stronger covenant capacity.

Hook facts

Debt market value changes from $400,000 to $500,000. Equity remains $600,000. Source costs remain 6% and 10%. The tax rate remains 25%.

Hook answer

Total capital is $1,100,000. Debt weight is 45.45%. Equity weight is 54.55%. Debt contribution is 2.045%. Equity contribution is 5.455%. The new WACC is 7.50%.

Your-turn facts

The tax rate changes from 25% to 30%. Debt remains $400,000. Equity remains $600,000. Source costs remain 6% and 10%.

Your-turn answer

After-tax debt cost is 4.20%. Debt contribution is 1.68%. WACC is 7.68%.

Change-one-thing facts

The minimum coverage covenant changes from 3.00x to 2.50x. The debt-financing facts remain unchanged. The debt option has coverage of 2.86x.

Change-one-thing answer

The debt option passes the changed 2.50x covenant at 2.86x. Equity still has the lower WACC, 7.50% versus 8.125%, and lower cash interest.

WACC, tax, structure and equity

These items move from the base WACC calculation to a tax change, a structure comparison and an equity issuance. Each rationale identifies the relevant chapter.

Practice

Pine Co. has market-value debt of $400,000 and equity of $600,000. Its pre-tax cost of debt is 6%, cost of equity is 10% and tax rate is 25%. What is Pine's WACC?

If only Pine's tax rate changes from 25% to 30%, while debt remains $400,000, equity remains $600,000 and the source costs remain 6% and 10%, what is the new WACC?

Three proposed structures have these inputs, all with a 25% tax rate: Plan A has $400,000 debt, $600,000 equity, a 6% debt cost and a 10% equity cost; Plan B has $600,000 debt, $400,000 equity, a 7% debt cost and an 11% equity cost; Plan C has $800,000 debt, $200,000 equity, a 9% debt cost and a 14% equity cost. Which plan has the lowest calculated WACC before covenant review?

Starting with $400,000 of debt and $600,000 of equity, Pine issues $200,000 of shares to fund a new asset. Which statement is correct?

WACC and financing tradeoffs

Use market values of debt and equity to set the weights.

Use each source's current required return. Apply the tax shield only to usable debt interest.

Multiply each weight by its adjusted source cost. Add the contributions to get WACC.

Treat the lowest-WACC structure as a candidate. Then check covenants, liquidity, leverage and control.

For the topic as a whole, carry the same values and costs from the WACC schedule into the financing tradeoff.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Capital structure and cost of capital

  1. 1. A company currently sells 100,000 units annually at $50 per unit. For next year, management forecasts a 3% decline in unit demand, general inflation of 4%, and a 2% increase in the product's real selling price in addition to inflation. What nominal sales revenue should the company forecast for next year?

    • A. $5,144,880
    • B. $5,044,000
    • C. $4,947,000
    • D. $5,304,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. $5,144,880

    $5,144,880 - Current revenue is 100,000 units × $50 = $5,000,000. - Forecast nominal revenue by multiplying for the 3% demand decline, 4% inflation, and additional 2% real price increase: $5,000,000 × 0.97 × 1.04 × 1.02 = $5,144,880. $5,044,000 - $5,000,000 × 0.97 × 1.04 = $5,044,000. - This calculation omits the 2% real price increase in addition to inflation. $4,947,000 - $5,000,000 × 0.97 × 1.02 = $4,947,000. - This calculation omits 4% inflation from the nominal selling price. $5,304,000 - $5,000,000 × 1.04 × 1.02 = $5,304,000. - This calculation omits the 3% decline in unit demand, leaving volume at 100,000 units.

  2. 2. A manufacturer has 13,000 machine-hours available. Product A provides a $36 unit contribution margin, requires three machine-hours per unit, and has demand limited to 4,000 units. Product B provides a $30 unit contribution margin, requires two machine-hours per unit, and has demand limited to 5,000 units. What maximum total contribution margin can the manufacturer earn?

    • A. $156,000
    • B. $180,000
    • C. $186,000
    • D. $195,000
    Show answer

    Answer: C. $186,000

    $186,000 - Product B earns $15 per machine-hour ($30 ÷ 2), more than Product A’s $12 ($36 ÷ 3), so produce B first. - Making 5,000 units of B uses 10,000 hours and earns $150,000; the remaining 3,000 hours make 1,000 units of A and earn $36,000, for $186,000 total. $156,000 - This results from valuing all 13,000 hours at Product A’s $12 per hour: 13,000 × $12 = $156,000. - That allocation overlooks B’s higher contribution per hour and would also require more than A’s 4,000-unit demand limit. $180,000 - This results from correctly earning $150,000 on B but mistakenly valuing the remaining 1,000 units of A at $30 each: $150,000 + $30,000 = $180,000. - Product A’s stated unit contribution margin is $36, so those units contribute $36,000 instead. $195,000 - This results from applying B’s $15 contribution per hour to all 13,000 hours: 13,000 × $15 = $195,000. - That would require 6,500 units of B, exceeding its 5,000-unit demand limit.

  3. 3. A company currently retains an 8% annual risk of a supply disruption that would cause a $1,500,000 loss. Dual sourcing would cost $70,000 annually and reduce the disruption probability to 2% and the loss to $900,000. Insurance would cost $95,000 annually and leave a $250,000 deductible for each disruption. Which alternative has the lowest expected annual cost?

    • A. Dual sourcing, with an expected annual cost of $88,000
    • B. Insurance, with an expected annual cost of $95,000
    • C. Insurance, with an expected annual cost of $115,000
    • D. Risk retention, with an expected annual cost of $120,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Dual sourcing, with an expected annual cost of $88,000

    Dual sourcing, with an expected annual cost of $88,000 - Dual sourcing costs $70,000 + (2% × $900,000) = $88,000 annually in expected terms. - That is less than insurance’s $115,000 and risk retention’s $120,000. Insurance, with an expected annual cost of $95,000 - $95,000 is only the annual premium; it omits the expected deductible of 8% × $250,000 = $20,000. - Including that exposure makes insurance’s expected annual cost $115,000, above dual sourcing’s $88,000. Insurance, with an expected annual cost of $115,000 - $115,000 correctly adds the $95,000 premium and the $20,000 expected deductible. - The mistake is selecting insurance despite its expected annual cost exceeding dual sourcing’s $88,000. Risk retention, with an expected annual cost of $120,000 - $120,000 correctly reflects an 8% chance of a $1,500,000 loss. - The mistake is selecting retention despite its expected annual cost exceeding dual sourcing’s $88,000.

  4. 4. A customer generated revenue of $500,000 and product costs of $300,000 during the year. The customer placed 40 orders, required 12 deliveries, and returned 200 units. Activity-based rates are $120 per order, $250 per delivery, and $15 per returned unit. What is the customer's profit?

    • A. $189,200
    • B. $192,200
    • C. $195,200
    • D. $200,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. $189,200

    $189,200 - Revenue less product costs gives a $200,000 product margin. - Deducting order costs of $4,800 (40 × $120), delivery costs of $3,000 (12 × $250), and return costs of $3,000 (200 × $15) leaves $189,200. $192,200 - This results from deducting $4,800 in order costs and only one of the two $3,000 activity costs from the $200,000 product margin. - Both delivery and return costs apply, so omitting either overstates profit by $3,000. $195,200 - This deducts only the $4,800 order cost from the $200,000 product margin. - It omits both $3,000 in delivery costs and $3,000 in return costs. $200,000 - This is the product margin: $500,000 of revenue less $300,000 of product costs. - Customer profit also deducts $10,800 in order, delivery, and return costs.

  5. 5. A risk-neutral company expects no insurable loss with 70% probability, a $100,000 loss with 25% probability, and a $500,000 loss with 5% probability. It may retain the risk, buy a $32,000 policy with a $50,000 deductible per loss, buy a $43,000 policy with no deductible, or spend $20,000 on controls that change the loss probabilities to 15% and 2%, respectively. Which alternative has the lowest expected annual cost?

    • A. Buy the no-deductible policy, with an expected cost of $43,000.
    • B. Install the controls and retain the risk, with an expected cost of $45,000.
    • C. Buy the deductible policy, with an expected cost of $47,000.
    • D. Retain the existing risk, with an expected cost of $50,000.
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Buy the no-deductible policy, with an expected cost of $43,000.

    Buy the no-deductible policy, with an expected cost of $43,000. - With no deductible, the company pays the $43,000 premium and bears none of the stated losses. - Its expected annual cost is $43,000, the lowest of the four alternatives. Install the controls and retain the risk, with an expected cost of $45,000. - The controls cost $20,000 and leave expected losses of (15% × $100,000) + (2% × $500,000) = $25,000. - The total $45,000 expected cost is $2,000 more than the no-deductible premium. Buy the deductible policy, with an expected cost of $47,000. - The $50,000 deductible applies to either loss, so its expected cost is $32,000 + [(25% + 5%) × $50,000] = $47,000. - That is $4,000 more than the no-deductible policy. Retain the existing risk, with an expected cost of $50,000. - Expected losses without insurance or controls are (25% × $100,000) + (5% × $500,000) = $50,000. - Retention therefore costs $7,000 more in expectation than the no-deductible policy.

  6. 6. A company expects the nominal cost of a fixed quantity of raw materials to increase from $1,000,000 to $1,070,000 next year. General inflation is forecast at 3%. Using the exact multiplicative relationship between nominal and real values, what is the projected increase in the real cost of the materials?

    • A. $38,835
    • B. $40,000
    • C. $70,000
    • D. $100,000
    Show answer

    Answer: A. $38,835

    $38,835 - The exact multiplicative relationship gives next year’s real cost as $1,070,000 ÷ 1.03 = $1,038,834.95. - Subtracting the current $1,000,000 cost gives a projected real increase of $38,834.95, or $38,835 rounded to the nearest dollar. $40,000 - Subtracting the 3% inflation rate from the 7% nominal increase gives an approximate 4% real increase. - Applying that approximation to $1,000,000 produces $40,000, but the question requires division by 1.03. $70,000 - Subtracting $1,000,000 from $1,070,000 gives the nominal increase of $70,000. - That calculation does not remove the effect of the forecast 3% general inflation. $100,000 - Adding the $70,000 nominal increase to 3% of $1,000,000 produces $100,000. - Inflation must instead be removed by dividing next year’s nominal cost by 1.03.

Flashcards: Capital structure and cost of capital

  1. 1. What is factoring of accounts receivable?

    Show answer

    The transfer of accounts receivable to a factor, typically for cash less a fee or discount. Depending on the terms and applicable GAAP criteria, the transfer may be accounted for as a sale or as a secured borrowing.

  2. 2. How is a bond’s current yield calculated?

    Show answer

    Current yield = annual coupon interest payment ÷ current market price of the bond.

  3. 3. What are common advantages and disadvantages of commercial paper as short-term financing?

    Show answer

    Advantages: For a creditworthy issuer, commercial paper may have a lower financing cost than bank borrowing and generally does not require collateral; it may also avoid compensating-balance requirements. Disadvantages: It is generally available only to creditworthy issuers, is unsecured, and creates rollover and liquidity risk because the issuer must continually refinance maturing notes. Market disruptions can make refinancing difficult or expensive.

  4. 4. What is WACC, and how is it calculated?

    Show answer

    WACC assesses the overall cost of capital. For example, with debt at 5% representing 40% of capital and equity at 12% representing 60%: (5% × 40%) + (12% × 60%) = 9.2%.

  5. 5. What are debenture bonds?

    Show answer

    Bonds issued without collateral backing.

  6. 6. What characterizes a junk bond?

    Show answer

    It generally carries an elevated interest rate and significant default risk.

  7. 7. What are subordinated debentures?

    Show answer

    Debentures with repayment rights subordinate to other debts upon liquidation.

Everything you need for CPA prep

Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

GET STARTED FOR FREE
75% OFFLimited time offer
GET 75% OFF