Overall strategy and the audit plan

On this page

Overall strategy before detailed procedures

A first-time team has a draft that lists tests of revenue before it states the reporting framework, scope, timing, or direction. The partner asks whether that draft can guide the audit and show what the team will do when facts change.

A list of procedures is not yet a complete plan because it does not show the engagement’s scope, timing, or direction. The finished schedule must move from the broad strategy to the detailed procedures and then show who will perform and review the work.

From preliminary work to audit procedures

Preliminary activities and entity knowledge supply the facts for the overall strategy. The strategy then sets the frame for the audit plan, which supplies procedures, staffing, and documentation.

  1. Complete preliminary engagement activities. Consider acceptance or continuance, independence, other ethical requirements, and engagement terms under AU-C 210, AU-C 220, and AU-C 300.
  2. Gather facts about the entity, reporting framework, reporting date, locations, prior knowledge, and resources. Industry and external factors supplies outside conditions. The entity, its strategy and governance supplies entity and governance facts.
  3. Set the overall strategy for scope, timing, direction, communications, supervision, and resources.
  4. Convert the strategy into an audit plan with the nature, timing, and extent of risk assessment procedures under AU-C 315.
  5. Add further procedures at the assertion level under AU-C 330 and other procedures required for compliance with GAAS.
  6. Assign staff, hours, supervision, and review.
  7. Document the strategy, plan, significant changes, and reasons for the changes. Update them as needed.

The facts about outside conditions, the entity, and governance support the broad strategy before detailed procedures are selected.

Scope, timing, direction and detailed work

The broad rows establish what the engagement is, when it will happen, and how it will be directed. The detailed rows then connect each major area to planned work, staffing, and completion.

Cedar Trail Tools is a repeat nonissuer client. Its financial statements use GAAP for the year ended December 31, 20X5. The report is due March 15, 20X6. There are no group components.

LineAmountWhy
Engagement basis and scopeFull-scope GAAP financial statement audit for a nonissuer; no group componentsDefines the reporting objective and engagement scope after preliminary procedures.
Overall timingInterim: November 30, 20X5; final: January 20-February 28, 20X6; report due March 15, 20X6Sets when risk assessment, year-end work, completion, communications, and reporting occur.
Direction, supervision, and reviewPartner 4 hours; manager 10 hours; senior 22 hours; staff 24 hoursSets responsibility and review levels and totals 60 assigned hours.
Planned risk assessment procedures8 hoursUses inquiries, analytical procedures, and observation or inspection under AU-C 315.
Further procedures: revenue and accounts receivable14 hoursTests revenue cutoff, recorded sales, receivables, and subsequent receipts.
Further procedures: inventory18 hoursCovers the physical count, test counts, condition, costing, and cutoff.
Further procedures: debt and operating costs8 hoursCovers debt agreements, debt confirmations, disbursements, and expense records.
Other required procedures and completion12 hoursCovers final analytics, misstatements, subsequent events, communications, and reporting.
Planned procedures subtotal60 hoursRisk assessment, further procedures, and completion work total 60 hours.
Role allocation subtotal4 + 10 + 22 + 24 = 60 hoursPartner, manager, senior, and staff assignments total the planned procedures.
Tie-out60 planned hours = 60 assigned hoursNo planned work or assigned time is missing.

The strategy rows come first, followed by the plan rows. AU-C 300.07 states, “The overall audit strategy sets the scope, timing, and direction of the audit and guides the development of the more detailed audit plan.” AU-C 300.09 requires the plan to describe the nature, timing, and extent of planned risk assessment procedures, further procedures, and other procedures.

The $12,000,000 revenue, $2,400,000 inventory, $1,800,000 receivables, and $3,000,000 debt balances drive the detailed focus, while both subtotals tie to 60 hours.

Planning scope, timing and attention areas

Fill the broad scope and timing before the detailed work because the plan must follow the strategy. Payroll receives more planned time than fixed assets because payroll is an identified attention area.

Harbor Light Services is a repeat nonissuer client with GAAP financial statements for the year ended June 30, 20X6. It has 3 branches and decentralized payroll. Identified attention areas include payroll, cash, and receivables. There are no group components. The report is due September 15, 20X6. Interim work is July 31, 20X6. Final work is August 1-September 10, 20X6.

LineAmountWhy
Reporting framework and scope?Repeat nonissuer client; GAAP financial statements; no group components.
Report date?The report is due September 15, 20X6.
Overall timing?Interim work is July 31, 20X6; final work is August 1-September 10, 20X6.
Risk assessment procedures6 hoursUnderstand the entity and assess risks under AU-C 315.
Further procedures: cash and receivables10 hoursRespond to the identified cash and receivables attention areas.
Further procedures: payroll12 hoursRespond to the identified payroll attention area.
Further procedures: fixed assets?Routine fixed assets still require planned procedures.
Completion and reporting?Complete final analytics, subsequent events, evaluation, communications, and reporting.
Planned procedures subtotal?Add all planned procedure hours.
Role allocation subtotalPartner 3; manager 8; senior 17; staff 20Add the assigned hours.
Tie-out?Planned hours must equal assigned hours.

The missing entries separate strategy choices from detailed procedures and test whether planned hours equal assigned hours.

Practice

The reporting framework and scope are a ____.

The fixed-assets procedures receive ____.

The planned procedures subtotal and tie-out are ____.

The completed schedule has 48 planned hours and 48 assigned hours, with the broad strategy placed before detailed procedures.

Strategy, procedures and planning updates

The second schedule requires the same distinction tested here: strategy states the broad frame, while the plan states procedures, timing, and extent. New facts can require updates to both.

Practice

Which item belongs in the overall engagement strategy rather than only in the detailed audit plan?

Which item is required in the audit plan under AU-C 300.09?

During the audit, the team finds a large amount of obsolete inventory. What should the auditor do?

The correct direction is broad strategy first, detailed procedures second, and documented updates whenever new evidence changes risk.

Source facts for strategy and planning

The exhibits provide source facts, but each fact must be placed in the strategy or plan. The bankruptcy update tests whether the documented plan changes when new evidence changes risk.

Exhibits

ExhibitSource facts
Exhibit 1: engagement letterLumen Medical Supplies is a nonissuer.
Exhibit 1: engagement letterThe financial statements use GAAP.
Exhibit 1: engagement letterThe year ended December 31, 20X6.
Exhibit 1: engagement letterThe report is due March 1, 20X7.
Exhibit 1: engagement letterThe audit covers 2 locations.
Exhibit 1: engagement letterThe physical inventory count is December 31, 20X6.
Exhibit 2: staffing schedulePartner 4 hours; manager 8 hours; senior 20 hours; staff 20 hours.
Exhibit 3: planning notesRisk assessment 7 hours; revenue and receivables 13 hours; inventory 16 hours; accounts payable and payroll 6 hours; completion 10 hours.

Task grid

CellRequestStatusSource or response
AOverall strategy: scope, reporting framework, and report dateFill
BLocationsProvided2 locations.
CPlanned inventory proceduresFill
DPlanned procedures totalFill
EStaffing totalProvided52 hours.
Change one factA customer with a $360,000 receivable files for bankruptcy after interim work. State the required update.Fill

The blank cells require the schedule entries, while the provided cells supply direct exhibit facts.

Cell A: Full-scope GAAP financial statement audit for a nonissuer; report due March 1, 20X7.

Cell C: Attend the December 31 physical count, perform test counts, inspect condition, and test costing and cutoff.

Cell D: 52 hours.

Change one fact: Update the overall strategy and audit plan. Add collectibility and subsequent-receipt or subsequent-event procedures. Document the fact and reason for the change.

The 52 planned hours tie to the 52 staffing hours, and the bankruptcy fact requires a documented update.

Audit planning steps and hour tie-out

  • Complete preliminary acceptance, independence, ethical, and engagement-term work.
  • Gather entity, reporting, timing, prior-knowledge, and resource facts.
  • Set the overall strategy for scope, timing, direction, communications, supervision, and resources.
  • Plan AU-C 315 risk assessment procedures.
  • Plan AU-C 330 further procedures and other required procedures.
  • Assign staff, hours, supervision, and review.
  • Document the strategy, plan, significant changes, and reasons, and update them as necessary.
  • Final tie-out: planned procedure hours must equal assigned hours.

The order prevents detailed tests from appearing before the engagement’s purpose and direction are clear. The tie-out and documented updates keep the schedule complete and usable.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Overall strategy and the audit plan

  1. 1. You are the group audit senior planning the audit of Atlas Products, Inc., a nonissuer that prepares consolidated financial statements under U.S. GAAP for the year ending December 31, 20X6. Atlas operates through two components and a corporate headquarters. The group engagement team expects to use another CPA firm to perform work at North Division. Review the exhibits and determine how the identified component and consolidation risks should affect the group audit plan.

    • 2. A nonissuer converted its general ledger to a new ERP system three months before year end. Opening balances were migrated automatically, and the auditor finds that several emergency program changes lacked approval or complete change logs. The audit plan had assumed reliance on automated posting controls. Which response is most appropriate?

      • A. Rely on control tests performed before conversion and reconcile only the final trial balance.
      • B. Inspect approval for one documented program change and retain the original reliance strategy.
      • C. Test one transaction processed by each automated control and rely on the controls for the period.
      • D. Test migration completeness and accuracy, investigate program changes, and increase substantive procedures.
      Show answer

      Answer: D. Test migration completeness and accuracy, investigate program changes, and increase substantive procedures.

      Test migration completeness and accuracy, investigate program changes, and increase substantive procedures. - Automatically migrated opening balances require testing for completeness and accuracy in the new ERP system, not just agreement of the final trial balance. - Missing approvals and incomplete logs for several emergency changes undermine the planned reliance on automated posting controls, so the auditor should investigate the changes and increase substantive procedures. Rely on control tests performed before conversion and reconcile only the final trial balance. - Preconversion tests do not show whether controls operated effectively in the new ERP system during the final three months. - A final trial-balance reconciliation alone does not establish that individual opening balances migrated completely and accurately. Inspect approval for one documented program change and retain the original reliance strategy. - Approval for one documented change does not address the several emergency changes lacking approval or complete logs. - Retaining the original reliance strategy without investigating those changes leaves uncertainty about the automated posting controls. Test one transaction processed by each automated control and rely on the controls for the period. - One transaction per control does not establish that the controls remained unchanged and effective throughout the period after conversion. - Transaction testing alone also does not establish the completeness and accuracy of the automatically migrated opening balances.

    • 3. During planning for an audit of a nonissuer, the engagement partner conducts a discussion among key engagement team members about how the entity's financial statements might be materially misstated. Which of the following is the primary purpose of this discussion?

      • A. To exchange insights about susceptibility to misstatement and determine how those insights affect audit procedures
      • B. To assign final responsibility for each significant account balance to an individual engagement team member
      • C. To establish that assessed control risk may be reduced without testing the operating effectiveness of controls
      • D. To identify every account in which the auditor must perform substantive procedures at an interim date
      Show answer

      Answer: A. To exchange insights about susceptibility to misstatement and determine how those insights affect audit procedures

      To exchange insights about susceptibility to misstatement and determine how those insights affect audit procedures - The discussion lets key engagement team members share what they know about where the nonissuer’s financial statements may be susceptible to material misstatement. - The team then considers how those insights affect the nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures. To assign final responsibility for each significant account balance to an individual engagement team member - Assigning account balances is an administrative planning task, not the primary purpose of discussing possible misstatements. - The discussion focuses on risks and their implications for audit procedures rather than finalizing individual assignments. To establish that assessed control risk may be reduced without testing the operating effectiveness of controls - A discussion cannot establish that controls operated effectively. - If the auditor plans to rely on controls to reduce assessed control risk, the auditor must test their operating effectiveness. To identify every account in which the auditor must perform substantive procedures at an interim date - The risk discussion does not require substantive procedures for every account to occur at an interim date. - The timing of substantive procedures depends on assessed risks and other audit-planning considerations, not the discussion alone.

    • 4. An auditor engages a valuation specialist employed by the audit firm to assist in auditing a complex derivative. Which of the following correctly describes the auditor's responsibility when using the specialist's work?

      • A. Evaluate the specialist's competence, capabilities, and objectivity and assess whether the specialist's work supports the audit conclusion.
      • B. Refer to the specialist in the auditor's report because responsibility for the valuation conclusion is shared with the specialist.
      • C. Accept the specialist's valuation when the specialist holds a relevant professional credential and used a recognized valuation model.
      • D. Limit involvement to determining whether management accepted the specialist's valuation adjustment in the financial statements.
      Show answer

      Answer: A. Evaluate the specialist's competence, capabilities, and objectivity and assess whether the specialist's work supports the audit conclusion.

      Evaluate the specialist's competence, capabilities, and objectivity and assess whether the specialist's work supports the audit conclusion. - Because the valuation specialist is employed by the audit firm, the auditor must evaluate the specialist’s competence, capabilities, and objectivity and agree on the nature and scope of the work. - The auditor must assess whether the specialist’s methods, assumptions, data, and findings provide adequate audit evidence for the conclusion about the complex derivative. Refer to the specialist in the auditor's report because responsibility for the valuation conclusion is shared with the specialist. - Using a valuation specialist does not divide responsibility for the audit opinion between the auditor and the specialist. - The auditor ordinarily does not refer to the specialist in an unmodified auditor’s report. Accept the specialist's valuation when the specialist holds a relevant professional credential and used a recognized valuation model. - A professional credential helps establish competence, but it does not establish that the derivative’s valuation is appropriate. - A recognized model still requires the auditor to assess the assumptions, methods, data, and findings used in this valuation. Limit involvement to determining whether management accepted the specialist's valuation adjustment in the financial statements. - Management’s acceptance of an adjustment does not establish that the specialist’s valuation is adequate audit evidence. - The auditor must evaluate the specialist’s work even if management records the proposed adjustment to the derivative.

    • 5. A nonissuer's chief executive officer frequently overrides established controls, and the controller has posted several unsupported entries at the CEO's direction. The auditor concludes that this condition creates a pervasive risk affecting multiple accounts. Which overall audit response is most appropriate?

      • A. Assign more experienced personnel, increase supervision, and incorporate unpredictability into audit procedures
      • B. Reduce substantive testing after documenting the design of the entity's established approval controls
      • C. Restrict additional procedures to confirming accounts receivable balances at year-end
      • D. Rely on management representations concerning the business purposes of the unsupported entries
      Show answer

      Answer: A. Assign more experienced personnel, increase supervision, and incorporate unpredictability into audit procedures

      Assign more experienced personnel, increase supervision, and incorporate unpredictability into audit procedures - The CEO’s repeated control overrides and the controller’s unsupported entries create a pervasive financial-statement-level risk affecting multiple accounts. - More experienced personnel, closer supervision, and unpredictable procedures are appropriate overall audit responses to that risk. Reduce substantive testing after documenting the design of the entity's established approval controls - Documenting control design does not establish that the controls operated effectively. - The CEO’s overrides and the controller’s unsupported entries make reducing substantive testing on that basis inappropriate. Restrict additional procedures to confirming accounts receivable balances at year-end - Receivables confirmations address a specific balance, while the identified risk affects multiple accounts. - Restricting procedures to year-end receivables would not address the unsupported entries posted at the CEO’s direction. Rely on management representations concerning the business purposes of the unsupported entries - Management representations alone are insufficient audit evidence for the business purposes of unsupported entries. - Reliance is especially inappropriate when the CEO directed those entries and frequently overrides established controls.

    • 6. An auditor initially determined overall materiality as 5% of forecast pretax income of $10 million and set performance materiality at 75% of overall materiality. During the audit, forecast pretax income declined to $6 million because of ordinary operating results. If the same percentages remain appropriate, what should revised performance materiality be?

      • A. $500,000
      • B. $375,000
      • C. $300,000
      • D. $225,000
      Show answer

      Answer: D. $225,000

      $225,000 - Revised overall materiality is $300,000: $6 million of forecast pretax income × 5%. - Revised performance materiality is $225,000: $300,000 × 75%, using the unchanged percentage. $500,000 - This is original overall materiality: $10 million × 5%. - It uses the initial forecast and does not apply the 75% performance-materiality percentage. $375,000 - This is original performance materiality: $10 million × 5% × 75%. - It fails to reflect the decline in forecast pretax income to $6 million. $300,000 - This is revised overall materiality: $6 million × 5%. - It omits the final 75% step needed to determine revised performance materiality.

    • 7. While planning a nonissuer audit, the auditor learns that the chief financial officer has repeatedly restricted employee access to the audit committee, two experienced controllers resigned after disputes with the chief financial officer, and management has delayed providing requested records. Which planned response most directly addresses the resulting risk?

      • A. Lower the threshold for confirming individual accounts receivable balances while leaving the remainder of the audit plan unchanged
      • B. Assign more experienced personnel, increase supervision, and incorporate additional unpredictability throughout the audit
      • C. Increase reliance on routine payroll controls after testing a sample of employee time records at an interim date
      • D. Perform additional inventory pricing tests before year end while reducing procedures over journal entries and estimates
      Show answer

      Answer: B. Assign more experienced personnel, increase supervision, and incorporate additional unpredictability throughout the audit

      Assign more experienced personnel, increase supervision, and incorporate additional unpredictability throughout the audit - The CFO’s restrictions on audit committee access, the controllers’ resignations, and delayed records raise concerns about management integrity and the control environment. - Because those concerns may affect the financial statements broadly, experienced staff, closer supervision, and unpredictable procedures are appropriate overall audit responses. Lower the threshold for confirming individual accounts receivable balances while leaving the remainder of the audit plan unchanged - Confirming more receivable balances addresses an account-specific risk, not the broader concerns raised by management’s conduct. - Leaving the rest of the plan unchanged fails to respond to the potential effects of those concerns throughout the audit. Increase reliance on routine payroll controls after testing a sample of employee time records at an interim date - An interim test of time records does not establish that the broader control environment supports increased reliance on controls. - Greater reliance on routine payroll controls does not directly address the CFO’s restrictions on audit committee access or management’s delayed records. Perform additional inventory pricing tests before year end while reducing procedures over journal entries and estimates - Inventory pricing tests address a specific area rather than the pervasive risk indicated by the CFO’s conduct. - Reducing work on journal entries and estimates would weaken the response to potential management override.

    • 8. A retailer's application developers can move changes to the production pricing system without independent authorization. The auditor assesses a risk that unauthorized program changes could alter sales prices and recorded revenue. Which procedure would most directly address this risk?

      • A. Inspect periodic recertifications of sales clerks' application access
      • B. Reconcile daily sales batch totals to the general ledger interface
      • C. Inspect evidence that backup files were restored during recovery testing
      • D. Compare production migrations with approved change tickets and independent approvals
      Show answer

      Answer: D. Compare production migrations with approved change tickets and independent approvals

      Compare production migrations with approved change tickets and independent approvals - Comparing production migrations with change tickets tests whether changes to the pricing system were authorized before reaching production. - Checking independent approvals directly addresses the risk created by developers being able to move their own changes. Inspect periodic recertifications of sales clerks' application access - Recertification tests whether sales clerks retain appropriate application access, not whether developers' program changes were authorized. - A clerk's access review would not show whether a pricing-system migration had independent approval. Reconcile daily sales batch totals to the general ledger interface - This reconciliation tests whether recorded sales totals agree with amounts passed to the general ledger interface. - Matching totals would not establish that the pricing logic used to generate those sales was authorized. Inspect evidence that backup files were restored during recovery testing - Restoring backup files tests recovery capability, rather than authorization of production changes. - A successful restoration would not reveal whether developers moved unapproved pricing changes into production.

    • 9. An audit team plans to use an auditor-engaged environmental specialist to assist in auditing a material remediation liability. The audit team lacks the expertise needed to independently develop the engineering estimate. Which approach is appropriate?

      • A. Accept the specialist's conclusion if the specialist holds a relevant professional license
      • B. Refer to the specialist in the auditor's report to divide responsibility for the estimate
      • C. Allow the specialist to determine the audit objective and issue the conclusion on the liability
      • D. Evaluate the specialist's competence, capabilities, and objectivity; agree on the work's scope; and assess the findings
      Show answer

      Answer: D. Evaluate the specialist's competence, capabilities, and objectivity; agree on the work's scope; and assess the findings

      Evaluate the specialist's competence, capabilities, and objectivity; agree on the work's scope; and assess the findings - Because the team cannot independently develop the engineering estimate, it may use an environmental specialist but must evaluate the specialist’s competence, capabilities, and objectivity. - The auditor must agree on the work’s scope and assess whether the specialist’s findings provide sufficient appropriate evidence for the material remediation liability. Accept the specialist's conclusion if the specialist holds a relevant professional license - A professional license alone does not establish the specialist’s objectivity or capability to address this particular remediation estimate. - The auditor must assess the specialist’s work and findings rather than accept the conclusion without evaluation. Refer to the specialist in the auditor's report to divide responsibility for the estimate - Using an auditor-engaged specialist does not divide responsibility for the audit opinion. - The auditor ordinarily does not refer to the specialist in an unmodified report and must still evaluate the evidence supporting the liability. Allow the specialist to determine the audit objective and issue the conclusion on the liability - The auditor, not the environmental specialist, determines the audit objective for the remediation liability. - The specialist may provide engineering expertise, but the auditor assesses the findings and remains responsible for the audit conclusion.

    Flashcards: Overall strategy and the audit plan

    1. 1. Why is it advantageous to engage the auditor early in relation to the balance-sheet date?

      Show answer

      Engaging the auditor earlier is advantageous for efficient audit planning.

    2. 2. When may an auditor accept an audit engagement after year-end?

      Show answer

      The auditor may accept it if the auditor can obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence despite the timing-related limitations, including by performing appropriate alternative procedures when necessary.

    3. 3. What does formulating an audit strategy involve?

      Show answer

      Establishing the audit’s overall scope, timing, and direction, including its reporting objectives and required resources. The strategy guides development of the detailed audit plan.

    4. 4. How can auditors use analytical procedures during audit planning?

      Show answer

      Auditors can perform analytical procedures by comparing actual figures with forecasted figures.

    5. 5. What is management responsible for regarding the financial statements?

      Show answer

      Management is responsible for preparing and fairly presenting the financial statements in accordance with the applicable financial reporting framework.

    Everything you need for CPA prep

    Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

    GET STARTED FOR FREE
    75% OFFLimited time offer
    GET 75% OFF