Learning Outcome Statement
Describe historical simulation and explain how it can be used in investment applications.
On the exam: You may receive a current portfolio value, observed periodic returns, a tail convention, and sometimes a changed input. You may need to describe the replay, compute or identify the empirical-tail loss, and explain how the result informs investment use. The format is usually an MCQ, a fill-in answer, or an ordered sequence.
Historical simulation takes actual observed returns and replays them on today’s portfolio. You keep today’s portfolio fixed, then ask what each old market move would have done to it. Each observed move becomes one scenario, with no parametric return distribution imposed. Sort the scenario outcomes and read the selected empirical loss tail.
Start with today’s portfolio value, $V_0$, measured in USD. Take one observed periodic return, $r_t$, written as a decimal, where $t$ identifies the period. The replayed scenario profit or loss is $P/L_t$, also measured in USD.
| Feature | Treatment |
|---|---|
| Return input | Observed periodic returns |
| Distribution | No parametric distribution imposed |
| Scenario set | Empirical population |
| Portfolio value | Current value held constant |
| Investor sign | Positive gain, negative loss |
| Tail reading | Selected empirical loss tail |
Match the return period to the requested horizon before you replay it. Treat the observed history as the empirical population of scenarios, so the selected tail comes directly from sorted outcomes. Use the following equation to turn each observed return into its dollar scenario outcome.
$$ P/L_t = V_0 \times r_t $$
The multiplication replays the old return on today’s portfolio. A larger $V_0$ increases every scenario’s dollar gain or loss, while a negative $r_t$ gives the investor a loss and a positive return gives a gain. The result keeps the return’s period, and you sort every $P/L_t$ from worst loss to best gain before reading the selected empirical tail. Historical VaR is that tail loss reported as a positive amount, not a forecast guarantee.
The replay follows a fixed path.
Loading diagram…
You can compare that loss with the portfolio’s risk limit and judge whether current exposure fits the investment mandate. The method puts an observed market move behind your decision, but the tail remains a historical estimate. Read the figure as a chain: today's value stays in place while each observed return is replayed, producing dollar outcomes that can be ranked. The ranking, rather than the size of the portfolio alone, identifies which scenario supplies the selected loss tail.
Worked example
You are handed a current portfolio worth USD 1,000,000 and 10 observed daily returns. You need the one-day historical loss at confidence level 0.9, using the stated convention that the single worst observation supplies the selected tail. Use the investor perspective, so a negative scenario profit or loss is a loss. First pin down the inputs that govern the replay: the portfolio value is fixed, the daily frequency matches the one-day horizon, and the convention selects one observation from the empirical set. These details tell you what the return chart and dollar outcomes must show.
| Given | Value |
|---|---|
| Portfolio value | USD 1,000,000 |
| Return input | Daily decimal |
| Horizon | One day |
| Confidence level | 0.9 |
| Observations | 10 |
| Portfolio during replay | Held constant |
| Additional cash flows | None |
| Tail convention | Single worst observation |
The bar chart orders the most negative observed daily returns. The outcome table keeps the full empirical set for the tail decision. Read the bars as return inputs, not dollar losses: each value still has to be multiplied by USD 1,000,000. Keeping the full set matters because the selected tail is determined by ranking every replayed scenario, even though the stated convention ultimately selects just one observation.
Loading diagram…
The table is sorted from worst to best, and the observation number stays visible so you can trace the tail back to $r_8$. Compare the signed dollar outcomes down the column: negative values are investor losses, while positive values are gains. The observation label links each result to its original return, so you can verify both the arithmetic and the ordering. Since the rule selects the single worst observation, the first row supplies the tail input for the calculation that follows.
| Observation | Daily return | Scenario profit or loss (USD) |
|---|---|---|
| 8 | -0.04 | -40,000 |
| 1 | -0.03 | -30,000 |
| 2 | -0.02 | -20,000 |
| 4 | -0.015 | -15,000 |
| 6 | -0.01 | -10,000 |
| 10 | -0.005 | -5,000 |
| 7 | 0.005 | 5,000 |
| 3 | 0.01 | 10,000 |
| 9 | 0.015 | 15,000 |
| 5 | 0.025 | 25,000 |
-
Keep the units aligned. The daily return frequency matches the one-day horizon, so the replay creates 10 empirical one-day outcomes.
-
Replay observation 8 first. It is the worst return in the sorted table, so apply $r_8=-0.04$ to the current USD 1,000,000 value. The substitution $P/L_8 = 1,000,000 \times (-0.04) = -40,000$ produces a scenario profit or loss of USD -40,000.
-
Read the selected tail. With confidence level $0.9$ and 10 observations, the stated convention chooses the single worst outcome. Reverse its sign with $-(-40,000) = 40,000$, producing a historical loss of USD 40,000.
-
Interpret the result for the investor. It is a one-day historical VaR of USD 40,000 under this replay, not a promise about the next one-day loss.
That measure lets the investor compare current exposure with a risk limit or investment mandate.
Changed condition
The current portfolio and replay convention stay fixed. Only the return in observation 8 changes.
| Item | Before | After |
|---|---|---|
| Observation 8 return | -0.04 | -0.06 |
| Worst scenario profit or loss (USD) | -40,000 | -60,000 |
| Historical VaR (USD) | 40,000 | 60,000 |
Before looking at the changed arithmetic, predict a larger loss. The more negative return makes the scenario profit or loss more negative when it is multiplied by the same positive portfolio value, so the selected loss rises from 40,000 to 60,000. Before reading on, replay observation 8 and identify the selected loss yourself.
Common error
A candidate annualizes the daily historical returns before replaying them because VaR sounds like an annual risk measure. The shortcut feels right because annual risk figures are common in portfolio discussions. The one-day horizon paired with an annual return input exposes a unit mismatch, so use the stated daily return without annualization.
Calculator
Enter the current value and the worst return before computing the scenario. The last keystroke changes the negative scenario result into the positive loss amount.
| Keys | Display |
|---|---|
| 1000000 ENTER | 1,000,000 |
| 0.04 +/- ENTER | -0.04 |
| × | -40,000 |
| +/- | 40,000 |
Check yourself
Practice
Which sequence describes the worked historical simulation?
Which investment use matches the historical loss produced here?
Put the historical simulation steps in order.
- Collect observed periodic returns
- Replay each return on current value
- Calculate each scenario profit or loss
- Sort the empirical outcomes
- Read the selected loss tail
- Compare the result with the investment mandate
Revision snapshot
Historical simulation replays observed periodic returns without imposing a parametric return distribution. Use $P/L_t = V_0 \times r_t$ for each observed period, where $V_0$ is the portfolio value at the starting point and $r_t$ is the observed return. Sort the empirical scenario outcomes before reading the selected loss tail. Keep the return frequency equal to the horizon. Do not annualize daily returns for a one-day question. Historical VaR is the loss at the selected empirical tail. It is not a forecast guarantee. On the exam, identify the replay order, compute or recognize the tail loss, and explain how an investor can compare it with a risk limit or mandate.
Unlock the full lesson and continue reading
Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more