Returns and their interpretation

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Describe, compare, and interpret returns.

On the exam: You receive beginning and ending asset values, periodic income, and a holding period in a compact data table. You then calculate the requested return measures and explain or compare what they say.

Your return shows how your wealth changed compared with the value you committed at the start. A price move creates capital-gain return, while cash income gives you another source of wealth. Before you compare answers, keep the period, reinvestment assumption, and investor perspective aligned.

Return measureInputs and pattern
PeriodicPeriod return $R_t$, one stated frequency
Holding-period$R_{\mathrm{HPR}}$, $V_0$, $V_1$, $I$, full period
Capital-gain returnStart and end values, price change
Income returnIncome and start value, income only
Total returnCapital gain plus income
CumulativeGrowth factor $G$, geometric linking
Arithmetic meanPeriodic returns $R_t$, period count $n$
AnnualizedGrowth factor $G$, years held $Y$
Time-weighted returnSubperiod returns, remove cash-flow timing
Money-weighted returnInvestor cash flows, reflect timing

With a periodic return, you reset the denominator at the beginning of each period. A cumulative return carries the ending wealth into the next period. On the exam, match the return frequency and reinvestment assumption before you compare results. A time-weighted return removes the effect of external cash-flow timing, while a money-weighted return reflects when the investor's cash flows occur.

Read every return here as a decimal rate for its stated period. For a single holding period, you begin with asset value $V_0$, finish with asset value $V_1$, and receive income $I$ during the period. The measure that combines those changes is the holding-period return $R_{\mathrm{HPR}}$.

When you link periods, $R_t$ records the return in period $t$. The product of the period growth factors gives you $G$ after $n$ periods, and $Y$ records the holding period in years. The formulas below show how these measures connect.

$$ \begin{aligned} R_{\mathrm{HPR}} &= \frac{V_1 - V_0 + I}{V_0} \ G &= \prod_{t=1}^{n}(1+R_t) \ \text{cumulative return} &= G-1 \ \text{arithmetic mean} &= \frac{\sum_{t=1}^{n}R_t}{n} \ \text{annualized return} &= G^{1/Y}-1 \end{aligned} $$

The holding-period formula adds the change in asset value to the income you received, so total return combines capital-gain return and income return. For the same gain, a larger ending value or more income raises the rate, while a larger beginning value lowers it. When you link periods, multiply each $1+R_t$ because the next period starts with the wealth left by the prior period, then subtract $1$ to convert the growth factor into cumulative return. The arithmetic mean gives each periodic return equal weight without compounding, while the $1/Y$ exponent takes the holding-period root before subtracting $1$.

Worked example

You are handed an equity's beginning price, each period's ending price, and income per share. You need to calculate the periodic holding-period returns, then the arithmetic-average, cumulative, and annualized returns. Each period is annual, income arrives at period end and is reinvested at receipt. Use the investor perspective, decimal return units, and no fees, taxes, or additional external cash flows.

InputValue
Beginning priceUSD 100 per share
Period 1 ending priceUSD 110 per share
Period 1 incomeUSD 3 per share
Period 2 ending priceUSD 121 per share
Period 2 incomeUSD 4 per share
Period count2 annual periods
Years held2 years
Initial wealthUSD 100

The line tracks wealth after each period when income is reinvested. Each period begins with the wealth carried forward, then adds that period’s total return through its growth factor. Notice that the second period compounds on USD 113.00, rather than on the original USD 100.00. This distinction explains why linked wealth reaches USD 128.41 and why cumulative return differs from simply adding the two periodic rates.

Loading diagram…

Read the chart as a sequence of account values, not as a return scale: it starts at USD 100.00, rises to USD 113.00, and ends at USD 128.41. The step from period 1 to period 2 is larger in dollars because the second return applies to a larger starting balance. The table below records the same checkpoints precisely, making it easy to compare each period’s ending wealth with its beginning wealth.

PeriodWealth (USD)
0USD 100.00
1USD 113.00
2USD 128.41
  1. Find period 1's price change before adding income. The change is $110-100=10.00$ USD per share, and adding $3$ produces $10.00+3=13.00$ USD per share.

  2. Separate the return sources if the question asks for them. The capital-gain return is $10.00/100=0.1000$, and the income return is $3/100=0.0300$. Their sum gives the period 1 total return, $0.1000+0.0300=0.1300$.

  3. Reset the denominator to period 2's beginning price. The price change is $121-110=11.00$, and adding $4$ produces $11.00+4=15.00$ USD per share. Dividing by that starting value gives $15.00/110=0.1364$.

  4. Average the periodic results equally when the question asks for an arithmetic mean. The result is $(0.1300+0.1364)/2=0.1332$.

  5. Link growth factors when the question asks for cumulative wealth. The multiplier is $(1+0.1300)\times(1+0.1364)=1.2841$, so cumulative return is $1.2841-1=0.2841$.

  6. Annualize the multiplier across the holding period, rather than averaging the cumulative result. The annualized return is $1.2841^{1/2}-1=0.1332$.

The linked return grows initial wealth from USD 100.00 to USD 128.41, so 0.2841 describes the full holding period and 0.1332 supports a per-year comparison.

Changed condition

Keep all assumptions and replace the period 2 ending price with USD 115.

MeasureOriginalWeaker terminal price
Period 2 return0.13640.0818
Cumulative return0.28410.2225
Annualized return0.13320.1056

Only the period 2 ending price changes, from USD 121 to USD 115. Before looking at the changed column, predict a smaller period 2 capital gain and smaller linked returns because the lower ending price reduces the period 2 growth factor. The table confirms that direction in the periodic, cumulative, and annualized measures. Calculate the changed period 2 return yourself before reading on.

Common error

You may annualize the cumulative return by dividing $0.2841$ by $2$ years because a total spread across time can feel like a quick yearly average. That shortcut treats the cumulative result as a simple amount, even though the investment grew through compounding. You need to annualize the cumulative growth factor across $2$ periods by taking the $2$-year root of $1.2841$ and then subtracting $1$.

Calculator

Use the calculator to multiply the initial wealth by the linked growth factor.

KeysDisplay
2ND CLR TVM0.00
100 ×100.00
1.28411.2841
=128.41

Check yourself

Practice

Which comparison is correct?

Put the return analysis steps in order.

  • Identify beginning value, ending value, income, and holding period
  • Calculate each periodic total return
  • Compound the periodic growth factors
  • Take the holding-period root and subtract one

Revision snapshot

Use the holding-period formula $R_{\mathrm{HPR}}=\frac{V_1-V_0+I}{V_0}$. Total return combines capital-gain return and income return. The arithmetic mean averages periodic returns. Geometric linking compounds periodic growth factors. Annualized return is the cumulative growth factor raised to the reciprocal of the holding period, minus one.

Match return frequency, periodicity, reinvestment assumption, and investor perspective before comparing returns. A time-weighted return removes the effect of external cash-flow timing, whereas a money-weighted return reflects the investor's cash-flow timing. On the exam, read the beginning value, ending value, income, frequency, reinvestment assumption, and holding period before selecting the measure. The trap is dividing a cumulative return by years instead of rooting its growth factor and subtracting one.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Returns and their interpretation

  1. 1. Elena Ruiz, a performance analyst at Meridian Asset Management, is reviewing a global equity fund. The fund accepts subscriptions and redemptions at the end of each trading day, and portfolio management does not control the size or timing of those external cash flows. Ruiz therefore reports time-weighted return when evaluating the manager's investment performance. Returns are reported net of transaction costs but before management fees unless a question states otherwise. Ruiz first reviews four quarterly gross returns for the fund and its benchmark. She notes that adding periodic returns may provide an arithmetic summary but does not measure the compounded growth of one unit of currency invested throughout the year. No external cash flow occurred within any of the four quarters shown in Exhibit 1. She next evaluates a separate account for which the investor, rather than the manager, determined the timing and amount of contributions. The account's cash flows occur at the dates stated in Exhibit 1: the initial investment occurs at the beginning of Year 1, the additional contribution occurs immediately after the Year 1 valuation, and the terminal value is measured at the end of Year 2. The annual money-weighted return is the internal rate of return that equates the present value of contributions with the present value of the ending account value. For risk reporting, Ruiz has a four-observation sample of monthly security returns. She is instructed to estimate volatility from the sample rather than treat the observations as the entire population. All return observations are equally weighted. Finally, Ruiz reviews an account that earned an 8.00% annual nominal return during a period in which the general price level increased by 3.00%. She uses the exact multiplicative relationship between nominal and real returns rather than the additive approximation. All calculations should retain full precision until the final answer.

    • 2. Meridian Asset Management evaluates the performance of its Balanced Fund. The fund accepts external contributions at quarter-end after its portfolio has been valued. Because management does not control the timing or amount of client contributions, the performance team uses a time-weighted return when assessing the manager's investment decisions. Exhibit 1 presents the fund values surrounding a contribution received immediately after the 31 March valuation. No other external cash flows occurred during the six-month measurement period. The fund is evaluated against a strategic benchmark representing its long-term asset allocation. To prepare a performance report, analyst Lena Ortiz reviews the benchmark's calendar-year returns in Exhibit 2. She considers both the arithmetic mean, which estimates a single-period expected return, and the geometric mean, which measures the compound rate linking beginning wealth to ending wealth. The report must identify the annualized historical growth rate over the three years rather than an expected return for an individual future year. Ortiz also evaluates the purchasing-power growth of the fund. For a separate annual period, the fund earned a nominal return of 7.50%, and the relevant inflation rate was 2.50%. The firm's methodology requires the exact multiplicative relation between nominal and real returns, rather than the nominal return minus inflation approximation. Finally, the performance report distinguishes gross and net returns. During the most recent year, the fund earned a gross return of 9.20%. The reported gross return is measured after trading and transaction costs but before the annual investment-management fee. The only additional investor-borne charge is a 0.70% management fee, assessed for the year. For this calculation, Ortiz is instructed to ignore compounding or intra-year fee timing and deduct the fee directly from the reported gross return. All returns in the report are expressed in percentage terms and are not annualized unless the question expressly requests an annualized measure.

      • 3. Northbridge Advisory evaluates several portfolios for institutional clients. An analyst is asked to calculate returns using the convention appropriate to each investment and to assess the benchmark assigned to an externally managed equity fund. The first investment is a publicly traded share purchased and sold during the same measurement period. The investor received one cash dividend before selling the share. There were no taxes, transaction costs, stock splits, or other distributions. The relevant prices and dividend are reported in Exhibit 1. The analyst also reviews a balanced portfolio that received a client-directed contribution during the measurement period. The portfolio value was recorded immediately before the contribution, and no other external cash flows occurred. The contribution was invested immediately and remained in the portfolio through the end of the period. Northbridge wants a return measure that removes the effect of the amount and timing of this external contribution when assessing the portfolio manager. The required valuations are also shown in Exhibit 1. Finally, Northbridge reviews a global equity fund with a three-year performance history. The analyst notes that the annual returns vary substantially and states that an arithmetic average would not represent the constant annual compound growth rate earned over the full period. Exhibit 2 provides the fund returns and summarizes its mandate. The equity fund's manager may invest throughout developed and emerging markets but is restricted to securities classified as small capitalization under the fund's published rules. The manager may hold both growth and value securities and does not target a persistent factor tilt. The fund does not hedge currency exposure, and both portfolio and benchmark returns are to be measured in USD on a total-return basis. Northbridge requires the selected benchmark to be unambiguous, measurable, investable, appropriate to the manager's opportunity set, reflective of current investment opinions, specified in advance, and accountable.

        • 4. A performance analyst at Meridian Asset Consulting is reviewing the Meridian Balanced Fund. The fund began Year 1 with USD 100 million. At the end of Year 1, but before an external contribution, the portfolio was valued at USD 110 million. The sponsor then contributed USD 50 million, which was invested immediately. No other external cash flows occurred, and the portfolio was worth USD 176 million at the end of Year 2. The analyst must report a return that measures the manager's investment performance without allowing the sponsor's contribution decision to distort the result. The analyst also evaluates Strategy R, a separate systematic strategy with the annual returns shown in Exhibit 2. She notes that the arithmetic mean is useful for estimating a single-period expected return, whereas the geometric mean measures the constant compound rate that links beginning wealth to ending wealth over multiple periods. All reported annual returns are total returns, including income and price appreciation, and no fees or taxes need to be deducted. For a third analysis, the analyst examines 36 independent monthly active returns for the fund. She tests the null hypothesis that the population mean monthly active return equals zero against the two-sided alternative that it differs from zero. The population variance is unknown, and she therefore uses the sample standard deviation and a t-test with 35 degrees of freedom. The applicable 5% critical values are supplied in Exhibit 2. The analyst is instructed to base her conclusion only on statistical significance and not on whether the estimated active return is economically meaningful. Finally, the risk committee models continuously compounded returns over a fixed horizon as normally distributed. A committee member claims that this assumption means terminal asset prices are also normally distributed and can take negative values. The analyst must assess the claim by distinguishing the distribution of continuously compounded returns from the distribution of the price obtained by exponentiating those returns.

          • 5. Meridian Asset Management evaluates a US equity fund with a mandate to invest in small-cap value securities. The performance analyst must report a return that measures the manager's investment decisions without allowing the timing or magnitude of client-directed external cash flows to distort the result. The fund receives a substantial contribution immediately after the end of the first quarter. The subperiod returns shown in Exhibit 1 have already been calculated using valuations immediately before the contribution, and there are no other external cash flows during the evaluation period. The investment committee currently compares the fund with a broad US equity index. The analyst observes that this index contains large-cap, mid-cap, and small-cap securities across growth and value styles. Before recommending a replacement index, she reviews the generally accepted criteria used to judge whether any candidate benchmark is suitable for the fund's mandate. The fund does not use leverage, derivatives, or securities outside the United States. The committee also asks whether historical performance provides evidence that the fund's population mean annualized active return differs from its required target of 6.0%. The analyst uses the 36 independent monthly observations summarized in Exhibit 2. She assumes the observations are drawn from a normally distributed population with unknown variance and conducts a two-tailed test at the 5% significance level. The sample standard deviation shown is appropriate for calculating the standard error of the sample mean, and the critical value is supplied so that no external table is required. Finally, Meridian is considering combining the fund's strategy with a US investment-grade bond allocation. Exhibit 3 reports the proposed weights and return standard deviations. The investment committee recognizes that portfolio variance depends on component variances and covariance rather than on a simple weighted average of standard deviations. All weights sum to one, returns are measured in the same currency, and the stated correlation is assumed to be stable over the decision horizon. Each requested calculation can be completed directly from its relevant exhibit and does not depend on the answer to another question.

            • 6. A portfolio analyst at Meridian Asset Management estimates a market model for the monthly excess return on a publicly traded industrial company. The dependent variable is the company's monthly return in excess of the one-month risk-free rate, and the independent variable is the broad equity market's monthly excess return. The sample contains 36 consecutive observations. The analyst confirms that all observations were available at the dates represented and that the same return convention was used for both series. The estimated intercept is 0.30% per month with a standard error of 0.25%. The estimated market slope is 0.82 with a standard error of 0.20. For a two-sided test with 34 degrees of freedom at the 5% significance level, the relevant critical t-value is 2.034. The regression has an R-squared of 0.58 and a standard error of regression of 3.10% per month. The Durbin–Watson statistic is 1.05. The analyst is particularly interested in whether the company's market sensitivity differs from one. She therefore specifies H0: β1 = 1 against H1: β1 ≠ 1. She also cautions the portfolio manager that statistical significance would not, by itself, establish that an estimated relationship is economically significant or causal. As part of her diagnostic review, the analyst produces Figure 1, which plots residuals against fitted monthly returns. The residuals are centered approximately around zero, but their vertical dispersion is visibly narrow at low fitted returns and progressively wider at high fitted returns. She notes that ordinary least squares coefficient estimates can remain unbiased under exogeneity when error variance is nonconstant, although conventional standard errors and hypothesis tests may then be unreliable. She separately reviews the chronological residual sequence because a residual-versus-fitted plot does not directly establish whether successive errors are correlated.

              • 7. An investment committee evaluates the Meridian Balanced Fund, a USD-denominated institutional portfolio. The committee wants to assess both the return earned on the portfolio's investments and the return experienced on capital after considering the timing of contributions. All values in Exhibit 1 are measured after management fees. The contribution on 31 December Year 1 occurred after that year's investment return had been earned and was invested throughout Year 2. A performance analyst explains that the time-weighted return should remove the effect of external cash flows because the portfolio manager does not control the contribution. For money-weighted performance, the committee uses annual periods and treats the initial value and subsequent contribution as cash outflows from the investor, with the ending value as the terminal inflow. There were no distributions, withdrawals, taxes, or other external cash flows during the measurement period. The fund's strategic policy, currency treatment, and rebalancing rules appear in Exhibit 2. The committee is considering three benchmark alternatives: an unhedged global equity index, a policy-matched composite using investable total-return indices, and the median return of a commercially maintained global balanced-fund peer group. The proposed policy composite would use 60% of a broad unhedged global equity index and 40% of a global investment-grade bond index hedged to USD, rebalanced monthly without retrospective constituent changes. The analyst also evaluates whether the current manager has generated positive active return. Using a sufficiently large sample of monthly observations, she estimates an annualized active return of 0.40% and conducts a two-sided test with the null hypothesis that expected active return equals zero. The estimated annual implementation cost includes trading costs and additional monitoring expenses attributable to retaining the active mandate. The committee requires both credible statistical evidence and positive expected value after implementation costs before concluding that an active strategy is economically worthwhile.

                • 8. Meridian Capital Advisors evaluates the reported performance and risk of several investment strategies. Senior analyst Lena Kwan begins by reviewing an equity investment in Vega Industries. The position was purchased at the beginning of the measurement period, received one cash dividend during the period, and was sold at the end of the period. There were no taxes, transaction costs, stock splits, or additional purchases. Kwan intends to report the investor's total holding-period return, including both price appreciation and investment income. Kwan then reviews a discretionary balanced portfolio for which the client made a substantial external contribution during the year. The portfolio was valued immediately before the contribution, and the contribution was invested without delay. No other external cash flows occurred. Because the portfolio manager did not control the amount or timing of the contribution, Kwan concludes that manager performance should be measured using a time-weighted return. She divides the year into two subperiods at the contribution date and plans to geometrically link the two subperiod returns. A third strategy invests in securities with limited ordinary gains but occasional large positive outcomes. Its empirical return distribution is unimodal and positively skewed. Kwan notes that the sample is sufficiently large for the observed shape to be meaningful and that no observations were removed as outliers. She considers how the extreme positive observations affect the relative locations of the arithmetic mean, median, and mode. Finally, Meridian is designing a two-asset portfolio containing Asset L and Asset S. The weights, individual standard deviations, and return correlation are shown in Exhibit 1. The weights sum to 100%, and the reported correlation is based on returns measured at the same frequency as the standard deviations. Kwan reminds the investment committee that portfolio variance must include the covariance term. She also notes that a negative correlation should cause portfolio risk to be lower than the value obtained by ignoring covariance and lower than the weighted average of the component standard deviations. All returns and standard deviations in the exhibit are stated on a consistent annual basis.

                  Flashcards: Returns and their interpretation

                  1. 1. What is the difference between a price index and a total return index?

                    Show answer

                    A price index uses only prices; a total return index includes prices and income (e.g., dividends).

                  2. 2. Price weighted return for all the different weighted types of security indexs

                    Show answer

                    return = total beginning price / total end price (adjusted for how its weighted - i.e price\shares for market-capitalization-weighted index)

                  3. 3. What formula do you use to annualize a Holding Period Return (HPR) realized over a specific number of days?

                    Show answer

                    \[\text{Annualized Return} = (1 + HPR)^{\frac{365}{\text{days}}} - 1\]

                  4. 4. What formula do you use to calculate the Holding Period Return (HPR)?

                    Show answer

                    \[HPR = \frac{P1 - P0 + Div1}{P0}\] where \(P1\) is ending price, \(P0\) is beginning price, and \(Div1\) is the dividend.

                  5. 5. What is the formula linking Quoted Add-on Yield and Holding Period Yield (HPY) for money market instruments?

                    Show answer

                    \[\text{Quoted Add-on Yield} = HPY \times \left( \frac{365}{\text{days to maturity}} \right)\] (or 360 depending on convention).

                  6. 6. What is the formula linking Quoted Discount Yield and the actual unannualized discount for money market instruments?

                    Show answer

                    \[\text{Quoted Discount Yield} = \text{Actual Discount \%} \times \left( \frac{360}{\text{days to maturity}} \right)\]

                  7. 7. What formula calculates the rate of return on a price index?

                    Show answer

                    \[RI = \frac{V1 - V0}{V0}\]

                  8. 8. In the price index return formula \(RI = \frac{V1 - V0}{V0}\), what does \(V1\) represent?

                    Show answer

                    The value of the index at the end of the period.

                  Everything you need for CFA prep

                  Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

                  GET STARTED FOR FREE
                  75% OFFLimited time offer
                  GET 75% OFF