Due diligence and the business plan

On this page

Learning Outcome Statement

Discuss the role of conducting due diligence and establishing a business plan in the private investment process.

On the exam: You receive a GP's proposed investment, selected diligence findings, and management-plan assumptions. You discuss the role of diligence and judge whether the resulting business plan addresses material risks and value drivers.

A management forecast is a claim, not evidence. The GP uses due diligence to test customers, operations, finances, legal matters, financing terms, and management capacity against the investment thesis. The business plan links verified findings to actions, owners, milestones, resources, and value-creation objectives. It becomes the GP's value-creation and risk-management roadmap, so you care when a polished forecast hides an unpriced risk.

Thesis claimIndependent testBusiness-plan response
Revenue growthCustomer contracts and interviewsRevise forecast and sales milestones
Margin expansionPricing and process reviewAssign owner and operating actions
Financing capacityDebt terms and liquidity reviewFund reserve or reprice entry
Management executionReferences and capability reviewAdd support or control rights

Due diligence converts management claims and investment assumptions into independently supported evidence. Use the following decision rule to connect that evidence to revised assumptions, downside mitigants, control rights, and business-plan actions.

$$ \text{Proceed} = \text{verified thesis} + \text{material risks understood, mitigated, or priced} + \text{executable business plan} $$

Read the plus signs as conditions, not arithmetic. A verified thesis supports the upside claim. Understanding, mitigating, or pricing a material risk keeps the downside from being hidden in the base case. An executable plan turns the response into assigned work with resources and monitoring. If a term is missing, the GP should renegotiate, reprice entry, add control rights, or decline.

Due diligence is a GP responsibility, but the LP needs a clear account of what was tested and what the mandate now requires.

Financing diligence needs a capital-stack view. The senior claim is paid before lower claims, so covenant, liquidity, and control-rights findings can change the resources available to the plan. Read the stack from top to bottom: each lower layer depends on cash remaining after claims above it are met. Debt terms can restrict cash or actions, requiring a larger reserve, a different entry price, or revised milestones. Check that the plan can meet those terms before accepting its assumptions.

Loading diagram…

A plan that assumes debt capacity without testing these terms is not executable. Tie financing conditions to the approval mandate.

Worked example

You are handed a proposed investment in a specialty distributor. The GP's thesis is that pricing discipline and inventory controls will lift margins. You need to decide whether diligence supports that thesis and whether the plan can manage the downside. The file contains these facts.

Case factFinding
Investment thesisPricing discipline and inventory controls lift margins
Customer evidenceRenewal risk among largest accounts
Operations evidenceInventory controls are untested
Management assumptionNo extra capital or implementation lead needed
Plan detailNo owner or milestone for operational change

The case facts separate an attractive margin idea from evidence that the idea can be delivered. Customer renewals test the revenue base, while untested inventory controls leave the operating improvement uncertain. The missing owner and milestone make the plan difficult to monitor, and the assumption of no extra capital may understate what execution requires. Use those gaps to shape a conditional recommendation, with each condition tied to an observable action or resource.

Loading diagram…
  1. Compare the thesis with the customer and inventory evidence because independent findings determine whether the upside claim survives. This produces a conditional margin thesis.
  2. Convert each finding into a business-plan action because each risk needs a response the GP can monitor. This produces a resourced action plan with a commercial owner, an inventory-control milestone, and a working-capital resource.
  3. Set approval conditions before the mandate is signed because the LP's mandate must match the remaining risk. This produces a conditional proceed mandate, or a reprice if the GP cannot obtain the required terms.

The investment is not an unconditional approval. The GP can invest only if the mandate reflects the revised assumptions, named actions, resources, and monitoring rights.

Changed condition

Keep every fact unchanged except the operating evidence.

ItemBeforeAfter
Operating evidenceInventory controls are untestedInventory controls independently tested
Plan responseAdd controls and ownerMonitor controls with named owner
RecommendationProceed after remediationProceed with monitoring

Predict the direction before reading the last row. Independent testing removes the operating uncertainty, so the recommendation should move toward proceeding and the plan should move from remediation to monitoring. Customer renewal risk still weakens the revenue case, so the changed finding does not justify unconditional approval. Before reading on, write the remaining condition you would place in the mandate.

Common error

You treat due diligence as a checklist that validates management's forecast because the diligence folder is complete. That feels right because a complete file looks like evidence that every risk has been tested. The missing link is an approval recommendation that does not connect independent findings to revised assumptions, downside mitigants, control rights, or specific business-plan actions.

Go deeper

When you write the GP's recommendation, state the finding's consequence rather than repeating its label. Translate the consequence into the action the GP should take, such as lowering forecast confidence, budgeting remediation, changing financing terms, or adding oversight.

Diligence areaRed flagValuation implication
CustomersRenewal risk lacks supportReduce forecast confidence
OperationsControls lack an ownerAdd remediation cost
FinancingCovenant headroom is thinReprice or reduce debt
ManagementRequired skill is absentAdd support or control

A red flag is not an automatic rejection. It becomes a mandate issue when the GP cannot show who fixes it, when the work happens, what resources it needs, or how residual risk is reflected in price. If the consequence is already captured in the forecast, budget, financing terms, or governance plan, do not count it twice. Test whether the stated owner, timing, resources, and residual-risk adjustment are credible.

Check yourself

Practice

Which response best converts an independently identified operating risk into a business plan?

Revision snapshot

Proceed only when material risks are understood, mitigated or priced, and reflected in the business plan. Due diligence converts management claims and investment assumptions into independently supported evidence. A business plan links verified findings to actions, owners, milestones, resources, and value-creation objectives. A complete file is not proof that management's forecast is valid. On the exam, connect each finding to revised assumptions, downside mitigants, control rights, and specific business-plan actions.

Unlock the full lesson and continue reading

Signup to continue reading this lesson and unlimited access questions, flashcards, AI notes, and more

Scan to download app

Scan to download
UNLOCK FREE ACCESS

Practice Questions: Due diligence and the business plan

  1. 1. Northbridge Capital is the general partner of Northbridge Fund III, a closed-end private equity limited partnership. Its ten-year term includes a five-year investment period. During the investment period, management fees are charged on committed capital; afterward, fees are charged on invested capital at cost. The fund uses a European waterfall, under which the GP receives carried interest only after LPs have received aggregate distributions equal to all contributed capital. No preferred return, catch-up, or clawback adjustment is relevant to the questions. Exhibit 1 presents the applicable terms and Year 4 amounts. The GP has agreed to sell one portfolio company for USD 120 million. Before this exit, Fund III had made cumulative distributions of USD 150 million. The portfolio assets remaining after the sale have a reported NAV of USD 90 million. The current exit is being completed after the investment period, and the invested-capital-at-cost figure in Exhibit 1 already excludes investments previously realized. All amounts are measured immediately before or after the current exit as indicated in each question. Northbridge also proposes moving the fund's highest-performing remaining company into a continuation vehicle managed by Northbridge. The existing fund would sell the company to the new vehicle. Existing LPs could receive cash or roll their interests, although the GP initially proposes relying solely on its internal valuation. The GP would earn management fees and carried interest from the continuation vehicle and would continue controlling the company. The LP advisory committee notes that Northbridge would effectively participate on both sides of the transaction and asks what process would best protect existing investors without preventing a potentially value-enhancing extension of the holding period. One committee member argues that internal valuation is sufficient because the GP has superior information about the company. Another proposes requiring every existing LP to roll into the continuation vehicle to keep investors economically aligned. A third proposes independent pricing support, full disclosure of the GP's economics, adequate time for each LP to elect cash or rollover treatment, and independent LPAC approval of final terms. The committee must distinguish protections that directly address conflicts from measures that merely preserve the transaction.

    • 2. Meridian Capital is evaluating the leveraged acquisition of Delta Components, a manufacturer with recurring aftermarket revenue. Meridian plans to acquire the company at the enterprise value implied by the entry assumptions in Exhibit 1. Senior and subordinated acquisition debt will fund USD 300 million of the purchase price. Management will invest USD 40 million alongside Meridian and will own 20% of the ordinary equity; Meridian will own the remaining 80%. Both investor groups participate pro rata in exit proceeds, and no preferred securities, transaction fees, taxes, interim dividends, or equity dilution are assumed. Meridian's base case assumes EBITDA rises through pricing initiatives, procurement savings, and expansion of the aftermarket business. The exit multiple is expected to contract by 1.0x relative to entry, while free cash flow reduces debt to the amount shown in Exhibit 1. The investment committee evaluates value creation from three sources: EBITDA growth measured at the entry multiple, change in the valuation multiple, and debt repayment. The committee also reviews a sensitivity chart prepared using Year 4 debt of USD 240 million rather than the base-case debt balance. For every cell, enterprise value equals the stated EBITDA multiplied by the stated exit multiple. Equity value equals enterprise value less USD 240 million, Meridian receives 80% of that equity value, and sponsor MOIC equals Meridian's proceeds divided by its USD 160 million initial contribution. The chart is intended to assess downside outcomes independently of the base case.

      • 3. Meridian Real Assets is evaluating a stabilized office property and three infrastructure opportunities for an institutional investor. The investor seeks current income, some inflation sensitivity, and diversified exposure to long-duration real assets. The investment policy permits both real estate and infrastructure but requires each asset to be underwritten using cash flows appropriate to its asset class. Harbor Center is a stabilized office property. Exhibit 1 provides the analyst's first-year underwriting assumptions. Vacancy and collection loss applies only to potential gross rental income. Under the direct capitalization method, net operating income equals effective gross property income less property operating expenses. Financing costs, depreciation, and capital expenditures are excluded from NOI. The capitalization rate is applied to stabilized forward NOI without a separate growth adjustment. The proposed mortgage would be funded at acquisition, but property value must be estimated independently of the financing structure. The investment committee also reviews the infrastructure projects in Exhibit 2. The toll road is a greenfield project for which construction has not started. Its future revenue depends on actual traffic volume, and neither minimum-revenue support nor an availability-payment arrangement is available. The project therefore retains construction, completion, ramp-up, and long-term demand risk. The solar facility is a brownfield operating asset with three years of operating history. Its take-or-pay contract obligates the investment-grade purchaser to make contracted payments for available output, subject to specified performance standards. This arrangement reduces volume and market-price exposure but does not eliminate operating, counterparty, or refinancing risk. The district heating network is also an operating brownfield asset. Its regulated tariff resets annually using a published inflation index, although regulators may disallow inefficient costs. The inflation linkage provides a closer contractual connection between revenue and inflation than a traffic-dependent toll that can be constrained by customer demand. For infrastructure credit analysis, Meridian defines debt-service coverage ratio as cash flow available for debt service divided by scheduled interest and principal payments for the same period. Values above 1.0x indicate that modeled CFADS exceeds scheduled debt service, although lenders generally require an additional cushion. The CFADS and debt-service figures in Exhibit 2 already reflect each project's operating costs, taxes, and maintenance expenditure and require no further adjustment. The analyst is instructed not to compare infrastructure CFADS directly with real estate NOI because the metrics are constructed for different underwriting purposes. Each question instead applies the metric specified for the relevant asset.

        • 4. An investor subscribes to a fund with no fixed maturity date, contributes capital upfront, and can request redemptions during periodic windows subject to liquidity gates. The structure is most likely:

          • A. An open-end core property fund
          • B. A closed-end buyout fund
          • C. A separately managed liquid-credit account
          Show answer

          Answer: A. An open-end core property fund

          > Key point: No fixed maturity and gated redemption windows point to an open-end core property fund. Why An open-end core property fund is correct - The fund has no fixed maturity date, consistent with an open-end structure. - Periodic redemptions subject to liquidity gates fit a property fund, whose assets may not be quickly sold to meet requests. How they compare | Structure | Maturity / access | Fit with the stem | |---|---|---| | Open-end core property fund | No fixed maturity; gated redemption windows | Matches both features | | Closed-end buyout fund | Generally fixed term; capital calls and distributions | Does not fit the stated redemption access | | Separately managed liquid-credit account | Account for one investor, not a pooled fund | Does not fit fund redemption windows | Why the other options are wrong - A closed-end buyout fund: generally has a fixed term and typically does not offer periodic investor-requested redemptions. - A separately managed liquid-credit account: is an account for one investor rather than a pooled fund with redemption windows and gates.

        • 5. An investor purchases an LP interest for USD 72 million when reported NAV is USD 90 million. One year later, it receives USD 20 million and holds residual NAV of USD 79 million. The calculated one-year MOIC is closest to:

          • A. 1.10×
          • B. 1.38×
          • C. 1.53×
          Show answer

          Answer: B. 1.38×

          > Key point: MOIC equals total value received or remaining at the end of the period divided by the investor’s purchase price. Why 1.38× is correct - Total ending value is USD 20 million received plus USD 79 million residual NAV, or USD 99 million. - Divide by the USD 72 million purchase price: USD 99 million ÷ USD 72 million = 1.375×, approximately 1.38×. Working | Step | Working | Result | |---|---|---:| | Ending value | USD 20 million + USD 79 million | USD 99 million | | MOIC | USD 99 million ÷ USD 72 million | 1.375× | Answer: 1.38× Why the other options are wrong - 1.10×: Uses reported NAV as the denominator: USD 99 million ÷ USD 90 million = 1.10×; the investor paid USD 72 million. - 1.53×: Substitutes initial NAV for residual NAV: (USD 20 million + USD 90 million) ÷ USD 72 million = 1.5278×; ending residual NAV is USD 79 million.

        • 6. A mezzanine lender invests USD 20 million, receives USD 4 million annually for three years, and receives USD 20 million principal plus USD 7 million warrant proceeds at year 3. The MOIC is closest to:

          • A. 1.60×
          • B. 1.75×
          • C. 1.95×
          Show answer

          Answer: C. 1.95×

          > Key point: MOIC equals total proceeds received divided by the amount invested. Why 1.95× is correct - The three annual payments total USD 12 million; adding USD 20 million of principal and USD 7 million of warrant proceeds gives USD 39 million. - USD 39 million ÷ USD 20 million invested = 1.95×. Working | Step | Working | Result | |---|---|---:| | Annual payments | USD 4 million × 3 | USD 12 million | | Total proceeds | USD 12 million + USD 20 million + USD 7 million | USD 39 million | | MOIC | USD 39 million ÷ USD 20 million | 1.95× | Answer: 1.95× Why the other options are wrong - 1.60×: Omitting warrant proceeds gives USD 32 million ÷ USD 20 million = 1.60×; warrant proceeds are part of total proceeds. - 1.75×: Omitting one annual payment gives USD 35 million ÷ USD 20 million = 1.75×; all three payments count.

        • 7. An LP replaces part of a diversified commingled-fund commitment with a no-fee, no-carry single-company co-investment. The change most likely results in:

          • A. Lower fund-level fee drag and higher asset concentration
          • B. Higher fund-level fee drag and lower asset concentration
          • C. Unchanged fund-level fee drag and higher asset concentration
          Show answer

          Answer: A. Lower fund-level fee drag and higher asset concentration

          > Key point: Replacing part of a fee-bearing diversified fund commitment with a no-fee, no-carry single-company investment lowers fee drag and raises concentration. Why lower fund-level fee drag and higher asset concentration is correct - The co-investment has no fees or carry, so replacing part of the commingled-fund commitment lowers overall fee drag. - The investment is in one company rather than a diversified fund, increasing asset concentration. How they compare | Effect | Correct change | Why | |---|---|---| | Fee drag | Lower | The co-investment has no fees or carry | | Asset concentration | Higher | Exposure shifts to one company | Why the other options are wrong - Higher fund-level fee drag and lower asset concentration: The no-fee, no-carry investment does not raise fee drag, and single-company exposure is more concentrated. - Unchanged fund-level fee drag and higher asset concentration: Concentration rises, but replacing part of the fee-bearing commitment lowers fee drag.

        Flashcards: Due diligence and the business plan

        1. 1. Due Diligence\ Alternative Investments

          Show answer

          1. Market opportunity 2. Investment process 3. Organization 4. People 5. Terms & structure 6. Service providers 7. Documents 8. Write-up

        Everything you need for CFA prep

        Get full Oncourse access with lessons, practice questions, flashcards and AI study tools.

        GET STARTED FOR FREE
        75% OFFLimited time offer
        GET 75% OFF